Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

Best Hotels with a Swimming Pool in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

Searching hundreds of travel sites to find you the best price

Sort by:

Best Value
Properties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveller ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
Traveller Ranked
Highest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveller reviews.
Distance to city centre
See properties located closest to the centre first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners

This is one of the highest rated properties in Sanibel Island

1. Tortuga Beach Club Resort

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

582 reviews

#1 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Debbie B

"This was my second stay at Tortuga Beach..."

Visit hotel website

2. Sanibel Siesta on the Beach

Enter dates to see prices

462 reviews

#2 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Elisa C

"Pool very quiet and clean, Did not use the laundry room very is very clean and convenient there is one in every building, We had beach umbrellas, chairs and, beach games We will certainly will stay again."

3. Ocean's Reach Condominiums

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

681 reviews

#3 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Denise T

"Every condo here is beautifully..."

Our heated swimming pool with views of the Gulf.

4. Sandalfoot Condominium

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

483 reviews

#4 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Julie G

"Our condo (3C3) was newly updated and..."

5. Sanibel Moorings

Enter dates to see prices

Resort

1,138 reviews

#5 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By prh107

"We liked our location away from the beach as the swimming pool was hardly used by anyone else."

Visit hotel website

6. Sanibel Arms West Condominium

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

431 reviews

#6 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Angie G

"We stayed in B1 and were very happy with..."

Breakfast included

7. Song of the Sea

Enter dates to see prices

1,021 reviews

#7 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By purpleij

"They have a larger sister property right next door you could use which looked newer but was busier and noisier with a larger pool and bar so depending on what you like you could choose either."

Breakfast included

8. Seaside Inn

Enter dates to see prices

1,006 reviews

#8 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By magd2579

"i'm not saying that we 100% got this from the hotel pool, but it is by far the warmest pool i have ever been in and the chlorine content did not seem particularly strong."

Temporarily closed

9. Sanibel Inn

Enter dates to see prices

Resort

1,857 reviews

#9 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Colin E

"And while there are some facilities - the pool is not massive - some basics were just missing."

10. Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

Enter dates to see prices

3,817 reviews

#10 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By jmaggio949

"I recommend they offer shuttles also they told us main pool was closing while we were there only a few days before our trip and I’m Sure it was scheduled way in advance and no monetary compensation was offered"

Temporarily closed

11. Waterside Inn on the Beach

Enter dates to see prices

Resort

762 reviews

#11 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Samantha Taylor

"The location is great, the staff is super friendly, everything is clean, the beach is very close, and the pool is lovely."

12. Kona Kai Motel

Enter dates to see prices

Speciality Hotel

465 reviews

#12 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Lynn E

"You can also hop on the bike, which is..."

13. Casa Ybel Resort

Enter dates to see prices

Resort

850 reviews

#13 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Florida_Fam_NFL

"Our room was also nice to have our own..."

Breakfast included

14. Sunset Beach Inn

Enter dates to see prices

Resort

975 reviews

#14 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By TVCYouthGuy

"The pool was nice and we were just steps from the gulf waters and a wonderful experience finding shells for my wife, who makes gifts out of them."

Temporarily closed

15. Shalimar Cottages and Motel

Enter dates to see prices

Motel

418 reviews

#15 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Trent W

"This was our fifth stay at Shalimar. We..."

16. Pointe Santo de Sanibel

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

414 reviews

#16 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By pqueneau

"Especially with children, consider the first floor, with its direct access to the lawn, paths, pool, and jacuzzi."

17. Shell Island Beach Club

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

99 reviews

#17 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Wander57320

"Shell Island was a beautiful location..."

18. Sanibel Arms Condominiums

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

242 reviews

#18 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Amy R

"Sanibel Arms is the best condo vacation..."

19. Tropical Winds Motel & Cottages

Enter dates to see prices

Cottage

303 reviews

#19 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By lhesenius

"For years we have raved about Tropical..."

20. Colony Inn

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

229 reviews

#20 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Scott H

"The beach was a short three-minute walk..."

21. Pelicans Roost

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

110 reviews

#21 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Christa H

"Every unit comes with a screened in lanai..."

22. Loggerhead Cay

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

193 reviews

#22 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Scenic35704418898

"Grounds are nice, grills are available, shuffle board,a large heated pool and tennis/ pickleball courts and the beach was just steps from our condo."

This is one of the most booked hotels in Sanibel Island over the last 60 days.

23. Sanibel Island Beach Resort

Enter dates to see prices

Resort

16 reviews

#23 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Dan H

"The pool has nice bar with complete drink menu limited menu of sandwiches and salads. Pool completely redone with new lounge chairs and a convenient bathroom."

Visit hotel website

24. Blind Pass Condominiums

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

197 reviews

#24 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Holly A

"If there is no other reason to request..."

25. Sunshine Island Inn

Enter dates to see prices

Motel

145 reviews

#25 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Jerry M

"Everything is brand new and impeccably clean and tidy, including the pool area and grounds."

26. Sanibel Beach Club

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

49 reviews

#26 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By hunter2b2016

"Second floor units have wonderful views..."

27. Caribe Beach Resort

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

110 reviews

#27 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By marywF3111RQ

"Nice pool with grills available."

28. Anchor Inn & Cottages

Enter dates to see prices

278 reviews

#28 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Kay C

"The Anchor Inn offers everything needed..."

29. Sea Shells of Sanibel

Enter dates to see prices

Apartment

142 reviews

#29 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Crystal W

"We cannot wait to return to Sea Shells at..."

30. Seahorse Cottages

Enter dates to see prices

1 review

#30 Best Value of 45 Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

By Kathi S

"The cottages were 200 yards from the bay..."

Showing results 1-30 of 47

Sanibel Island Hotels Information

Hotels in Sanibel Island	45
Hotels Prices From	C$309
Hotels Reviews	18,010
Hotels Photos	14,479

Frequently Asked Questions about Sanibel Island hotels

: Some of the more popular hotels with a pool near Sanibel Skin Spa include:
Waterside Inn on the Beach - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Shalimar Cottages and Motel - Traveller rating: 4/5
: Some of the best hotels with a pool in Sanibel Island are:
Sanibel Siesta on the Beach - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Moorings - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
: A private balcony can be enjoyed by guests at the following hotels with a pool in Sanibel Island:
Sanibel Siesta on the Beach - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Moorings - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
: These hotels with a pool in Sanibel Island have great views and are well-liked by travellers:
Sanibel Siesta on the Beach - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Moorings - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
: These hotels with a pool in Sanibel Island have been described as romantic by other travellers:
Sanibel Moorings - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Seaside Inn - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
: Families travelling in Sanibel Island enjoyed their stay at the following hotels with a pool:
Sanibel Siesta on the Beach - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Moorings - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
: Free breakfast can be enjoyed at the following hotels with a pool in Sanibel Island:
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Seaside Inn - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sunset Beach Inn - Traveller rating: 4/5
: These hotels with a pool in Sanibel Island have free parking:
Sanibel Siesta on the Beach - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Moorings - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
: These 3 star hotels received great reviews from other travellers:
Song of the Sea - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Seaside Inn - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Inn - Traveller rating: 4/5
: These hotels with a pool in Sanibel Island have a tennis court:
Sanibel Siesta on the Beach - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Moorings - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
Sanibel Inn - Traveller rating: 4/5

Scroll Back to Top Hotels

Best Hotels with a Swimming Pool in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool

Popular

AwardsTravellers’ Choice Awards winners (including the “Best of the Best” title) are among the top 10% of listings on Tripadvisor, according to the reviews and opinions of travellers across the globe.

Property types

Amenities

Distance from

Traveller rating

Hotel class

Style

Brands

Sanibel Island Hotels Information

Hotels in Sanibel Island

Hotels Prices From

Hotels Reviews

Hotels Photos

Awards
Travellers’ Choice Awards winners (including the “Best of the Best” title) are among the top 10% of listings on Tripadvisor, according to the reviews and opinions of travellers across the globe.