Gubernatorial elections, 2018

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
StateExecLogo.png
State Executive Officials

State executive elections by position and year:

In 2018, elections for governor were held in 36 states.

Republicans won 20 of the 36 seats up for election, and Democrats won 16. Democrats gained seven seats that were held by Republicans heading into the election, unseating incumbents in Illinois and Wisconsin and picking up open seats in Kansas, Maine, Michigan, Nevada, and New Mexico. Republicans picked up the open gubernatorial seat in Alaska, which had previously been held by independent Bill Walker. Following the election, Republicans held 27 gubernatorial seats to Democrats' 23.

Heading into the 2018 elections, the majority of governorships were held by Republicans, with 33 governorships to Democrats' 16, and one independent seat in Alaska. Of the 33 Republican-held seats, 26 were up for election, of which 13 were open. Of the 16 Democratic-held seats, nine were up for election, of which four were open.

Gubernatorial offices that changed party control

This table lists gubernatorial offices where party control changed as a result of the November 6, 2018, elections.

Gubernatorial offices that changed party hands, 2018 elections
State Pre-election control Post-election control
Alaska Bill Walker Grey.png Mike Dunleavy Republican Party
Illinois Bruce Rauner Republican Party J.B. Pritzker Democratic Party
Kansas Jeff Colyer Republican Party Laura Kelly Democratic Party
Maine Paul LePage Republican Party Janet Mills Democratic Party
Michigan Rick Snyder Republican Party Gretchen Whitmer Democratic Party
Nevada Brian Sandoval Republican Party Steve Sisolak Democratic Party
New Mexico Susana Martinez Republican Party Michelle Lujan Grisham Democratic Party
Wisconsin Scott Walker Republican Party Tony Evers Democratic Party


This page includes the following components about 2018's gubernatorial elections:

Ballotpedia provided in-depth coverage of gubernatorial primary elections. Click the links below for more information:

2018 election analysis and context

Heading into the election, 33 of the 50 governorships were held by Republicans and 16 by Democrats, plus Alaska’s independent. The 2018 results increased the total number of Democratic governors to 23 and reduced the GOP total to 27.

The new gubernatorial count most closely resembles the landscape after the 2010 election. The last time the Democratic Party had more than 20 governorships was in 2010, when they held 26 heading into that cycle. Republicans entered 2010 with 23 governorships and emerged with 29 following that midterm election.

Incumbents were seeking re-election in 10 of the 36 races contested in 2018, six of them Republicans and four Democrats.

All four Democratic incumbents won their races: New York (Andrew Cuomo), Oregon (Kate Brown), Pennsylvania (Tom Wolf), and Rhode Island (Gina Raimondo).

Republican incumbents won in Arizona (Doug Ducey), Iowa (Kim Reynolds), Nebraska (Pete Ricketts), and New Hampshire (Chris Sununu).

Two Republican incumbents lost:

In five other races without incumbents running, seats held by Republicans were taken by Democrats:

In the Alaska governor’s race, former state Sen. Mike Dunleavy (R) defeated former U.S. Sen. Mark Begich (D). Incumbent Gov. Bill Walker (I) suspended his re-election campaign on October 19, 2018, saying in a statement, "In the time remaining, I believe we cannot win a three-way race,” leaving the seat open for the two major-party candidates.

The first of the maps below shows the results of the 2018 gubernatorial elections. The second shows the total gubernatorial partisan affiliations following the 2018 elections.

State government trifectas

Democrats emerged from the 2018 elections with a net gain in state government trifectas—where one political party holds the governorship, a majority in the state senate, and a majority in the state house in a state's government. Republicans retain a net advantage of eight trifectas over Democrats. The new trifecta count stands at 14 Democratic, 22 Republican, and 14 divided.

Entering the 2018 midterm election, Republicans had a +14 state trifecta lead: of 34 states with trifectas, 26 were Republican and eight were Democratic. But after the votes were counted, Democrats increased their trifecta total with a net gain of six, and Republicans declined to 22 trifectas (a net loss of four). States with divided government (i.e., no trifecta for either major party) declined to 14.

This outcome is similar to the trifecta balance following the 2014 midterm election, which left Republicans with 24 trifectas, Democrats with 13, and 13 states with no trifecta advantage for either major party. After the 2010 midterms, 25 states had no trifectas, Republicans had nine, and Democrats had 16.

In two cases where Democrats gained trifectas, and in one case where Republicans lost a trifecta, Democrats won open gubernatorial races that had been vacated by Republican incumbents who could not seek re-election due to term limits.

The total number of trifectas—36—is almost in line with the 37 trifectas in 2013 and 2014, the most trifectas in recent history.

Change in state government trifectas, 2018 elections
Trifecta status Before After Net
Democratic trifectas Democratic Party 8 14 +6
Republican trifectas Republican Party 26 22 -4
Divided government 16 14 -2


The six Democratic flips from divided government to trifecta control in 2018 were in:

In each of the four states where Republicans lost trifectas the balance of power became divided:

Overall, 10 total states saw a trifecta status change in some way.

  • Colorado: divided government to Democratic trifecta
  • Illinois: divided government to Democratic trifecta
  • Kansas: Republican trifecta to divided government
  • Maine: divided government to Democratic trifecta
  • Michigan: Republican trifecta to divided government
  • Nevada: divided government to Democratic trifecta
  • New Hampshire: Republican trifecta to divided government
  • New Mexico: divided government to Democratic trifecta
  • New York: divided government to Democratic trifecta
  • Wisconsin: Republican trifecta to divided government

The maps and charts below show the pre- and post-2018 election state government trifectas and the percentage of the population living under trifecta control.

Percent of the U.S. population living under trifectas as of Election Day 2018
Total Democratic trifectas Republican trifectas Divided governments
Population 325,025,206[1] 67,128,116 156,080,642 101,816,448
Proportion (%) 100% 20.7% 48.0% 31.3%
Source: U.S. Census Bureau

Percent of the U.S. population living under trifectas following the 2018 elections
Total Democratic trifectas Republican trifectas Divided governments
Population 325,025,206[2] 111,808,708 136,066,930 77,149,568
Proportion (%) 100% 34.4% 41.9% 23.7%
Source: U.S. Census Bureau


List of gubernatorial elections

The table below lists the states with gubernatorial elections in 2018, whether or not those states had a state government trifecta or triplex prior to the 2018 election, the incumbent and the incumbent's party prior to the election, and whether or not the incumbent ran for re-election.

A state government trifecta is a term to describe single party government, when one political party holds the governorship, a majority in the state senate, and a majority in the state house in a state's government. State government triplexes describe when one political party holds the following three positions in a state's government: governor, attorney general, and secretary of state.

Most states impose some form of term limits on governors; of those that do, all but Virginia limit a governor to two four-year terms or to eight years in office. Although most states' term limit laws allow a governor who has served two terms to be elected once again after time has elapsed, some states impose a lifetime term limit like that on the presidency.

State Incumbent Democratic candidate (winners bolded) Republican candidate (winners bolded) Previous ten election results Changed party control? Margin of victory Margin of victory in last gubernatorial election[3] Margin of victory in 2016 presidential election
Alabama Kay Ivey 2013.jpg
Republican Party Kay Ivey
Democratic Party Walt Maddox Republican Party Kay Ivey Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+19.1 R+27.4 R+27.7
Alaska BillWalker2015.jpg
Independent Bill Walker[4]
Democratic Party Mark Begich Republican Party Mike Dunleavy Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Republican Party Four Republican victories
Independent Two independent victories
Approveda R+7.0 I+2.2 R+14.7
Arizona DougDucey2015.jpg
Republican Party Doug Ducey
Democratic Party David Garcia Republican Party Doug Ducey Republican Party Six Republican victories
Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+14.2 R+11.8 R+3.5
Arkansas AsaHutchinson2015.jpg
Republican Party Asa Hutchinson
Democratic Party Jared Henderson Republican Party Asa Hutchinson Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+33.5 R+13.9 R+26.9
California Jerry Brown 1.jpg
Democratic Party Jerry Brown
Democratic Party Gavin Newsom Republican Party John Cox Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Five Republican victories
Defeatedd D+23.8 D+20.0 D+30.1
Colorado John-Hickenlooper.jpg
Democratic Party John Hickenlooper
Democratic Party Jared Polis Republican Party Walker Stapleton Democratic Party Eight Democratic victories
Republican Party Two Republican victories
Defeatedd D+10.6 D+3.3 D+4.9
Connecticut Dan Malloy.jpg
Democratic Party Dan Malloy
Democratic Party Ned Lamont Republican Party Bob Stefanowski Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Four Republican victories
Grey.png One independent victory
Defeatedd D+3.2 D+2.5 D+13.6
Florida Rick Scott.jpg
Republican Party Rick Scott
Democratic Party Andrew Gillum Republican Party Ron DeSantis Republican Party Six Republican victories
Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+0.4 R+1.0 R+1.2
Georgia Nathan Deal 2013.jpg
Republican Party Nathan Deal
Democratic Party Stacey Abrams Republican Party Brian Kemp Democratic Party Six Democratic victories
Republican Party Four Republican victories
Defeatedd R+1.4 R+7.8 R+5.2
Hawaii DavidIge2015.jpg
Democratic Party David Ige
Democratic Party David Ige Republican Party Andria P. Tupola Democratic Party Eight Democratic victories
Republican Party Two Republican victories
Defeatedd D+29.0 D+12.4 D+32.2
Idaho Butch Otter 2013.jpg
Republican Party Butch Otter
Democratic Party Paulette Jordan Republican Party Brad Little Republican Party Six Republican victories
Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+21.6 R+14.9 R+31.8
Illinois BruceRauner2015a.jpg
Republican Party Bruce Rauner
Democratic Party J.B. Pritzker Republican Party Bruce Rauner Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Approveda D+15.7 R+4.0 D+17.1
Iowa Kim Reynolds 2013.jpg
Republican Party Kim Reynolds
Democratic Party Fred Hubbell Republican Party Kim Reynolds Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+2.8 R+21.7 R+9.4
Kansas Jeff Colyer.png
Republican Party Jeff Colyer[5]
Democratic Party Laura Kelly Republican Party Kris Kobach Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Five Republican victories
Approveda D+5.0 R+3.7 R+20.6
Maine Paul LePage.jpg
Republican Party Paul LePage
Democratic Party Janet Mills Republican Party Shawn Moody Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Republican Party Four Republican victories
Grey.png Two independent victories
Approveda D+7.7 R+4.8 D+3.0
Maryland LarryHogan2015.jpg
Republican Party Larry Hogan
Democratic Party Ben Jealous Republican Party Larry Hogan Democratic Party Eight Democratic victories
Republican Party Two Republican victories
Defeatedd R+11.9 R+3.8 D+26.4
Massachusetts CharlesBaker2015.jpg
Republican Party Charles D. Baker
Democratic Party Jay Gonzalez Republican Party Charles D. Baker Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Five Republican victories
Defeatedd R+32.5 R+1.9 D+27.2
Michigan RickSnyder2015.jpg
Republican Party Rick Snyder
Democratic Party Gretchen Whitmer Republican Party Bill Schuette Republican Party Six Republican victories
Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Approveda D+9.6 R+4.0 R+0.2
Minnesota Mark Dayton 2013.jpg
Democratic Party Mark Dayton
Democratic Party Tim Walz Republican Party Jeff Johnson Republican Party Five Republican victories
Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Grey.png One independent victory
Defeatedd D+11.4 D+5.6 D+1.5
Nebraska PeteRicketts2015.jpg
Republican Party Pete Ricketts
Democratic Party Bob Krist Republican Party Pete Ricketts Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+18.0 R+17.9 R+25.5
Nevada Brian Sandoval.jpg
Republican Party Brian Sandoval
Democratic Party Steve Sisolak Republican Party Adam Laxalt Republican Party Six Republican victories
Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Approveda D+4.1 R+46.7 D+2.4
New Hampshire Chris Sununu.jpg
Republican Party Chris Sununu
Democratic Party Molly Kelly Republican Party Chris Sununu Democratic Party Eight Democratic victories
Republican Party Two Republican victories
Defeatedd R+7.0 R+2.3 D+0.4
New Mexico Susana Martinez headshot.jpg
Republican Party Susana Martinez
Democratic Party Michelle Lujan Grisham Republican Party Steve Pearce Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Five Republican victories
Approveda D+14.4 R+14.4 D+8.2
New York AndrewCuomo2015.png
Democratic Party Andrew Cuomo
Democratic Party Andrew Cuomo Republican Party Marcus Molinaro Democratic Party Seven Democratic victories
Republican Party Three Republican victories
Defeatedd D+23.4 D+14.0 D+22.5
Ohio John R Kasich.jpg
Republican Party John Kasich
Democratic Party Richard Cordray Republican Party Mike DeWine Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+3.7 R+30.6 R+8.1
Oklahoma Fallin.jpg
Republican Party Mary Fallin
Democratic Party Drew Edmondson Republican Party Kevin Stitt Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Five Republican victories
Defeatedd R+12.1 R+14.8 R+36.4
Oregon KateBrown2015.jpg
Democratic Party Kate Brown
Democratic Party Kate Brown Republican Party Knute Buehler Democratic Party Eight Democratic victories
Republican Party Two Republican victories
Defeatedd D+6.4 D+7.2 D+11.0
Pennsylvania TomWolf.jpg
Democratic Party Tom Wolf
Democratic Party Tom Wolf Republican Party Scott Wagner Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Five Republican victories
Defeatedd D+17.1 D+9.8 R+0.7
Rhode Island GinaRaimondo2015.jpg
Democratic Party Gina Raimondo
Democratic Party Gina Raimondo Republican Party Allan Fung Republican Party Six Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Independent One independent victory
Defeatedd D+15.4 D+4.5 D+15.5
South Carolina Mcmaster.jpg
Republican Party Henry McMaster
Democratic Party James Smith, Jr. Republican Party Henry McMaster Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+8.1 R+14.5 R+14.3
South Dakota Daugaard.jpg
Republican Party Dennis Daugaard
Democratic Party Billie Sutton Republican Party Kristi Noem Republican Party Ten Republican victories Defeatedd R+3.4 R+45.1 R+29.8
Tennessee BillHaslam2015.jpg
Republican Party Bill Haslam
Democratic Party Karl Dean Republican Party Bill Lee Republican Party Six Republican victories
Democratic Party Four Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+21.0 R+47.5 R+26.0
Texas GregAbbott2015.jpg
Republican Party Greg Abbott
Democratic Party Lupe Valdez Republican Party Greg Abbott Republican Party Eight Republican victories
Democratic Party Two Democratic victories
Defeatedd R+13.3 R+20.4 R+9.0
Vermont Scott.jpg
Republican Party Phil Scott
Democratic Party Christine Hallquist Republican Party Phil Scott Democratic Party Five Democratic victories
Republican Party Five Republican victories
Defeatedd R+14.9 R+8.8 D+26.4
Wisconsin Scott Walker 2.jpg
Republican Party Scott Walker
Democratic Party Tony Evers Republican Party Scott Walker Republican Party Seven Republican victories
Democratic Party Three Democratic victories
Approveda D+1.1 R+5.7 R+0.8
Wyoming MattMead2015.jpg
Republican Party Matt Mead
Democratic Party Mary Throne Republican Party Mark Gordon Democratic Party Six Democratic victories
Republican Party Four Republican victories
Defeatedd R+39.6 R+32.1 R+46.3

Battleground elections

Ballotpedia identified 25 gubernatorial elections as battleground races. Of the 26 Republican-held seats up for election, 16 were battlegrounds, including 10 of the 13 open seats. Of the nine Democratic-held seats up for election, eight—all except Hawaii—were battlegrounds. Alaska's independent-held seat was also a battleground.

Among the battleground races in 2018 was the Illinois gubernatorial election, in which Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner was defeated by Democrat J.B. Pritzker. Both candidates contributed over $50 million to their own campaigns. Between Election Day 2014 and Election Day 2018, Pritzker contributed $171.5 million to his own campaign while Rauner contributed $67.8 million to his run.[6][7] The overall fundraising in the election—$285.0 million—was higher than any other gubernatorial election in U.S. history, surpassing the 2010 California gubernatorial election's $251.9 million fundraising total.[8]

In the Georgia race, former state House Minority Leader Stacey Abrams (D) vied to become the first black woman to win a governor's race in U.S. history. She was defeated by Secretary of State Brian Kemp (R), who beat four Republican rivals in the primaries and secured an endorsement from President Donald Trump.[9]

The nation's only independent governor, Bill Walker of Alaska, suspended his re-election bid on October 19, 2018, after the resignation of his lieutenant governor and running mate Byron Mallott (D). Walker's withdrawal set the stage for a contest between former Sen. Mark Begich (D) and former state Sen. Mike Dunleavy (R), leading to the Republican Party's only gubernatorial pickup in 2018.[10]
The following map displays which gubernatorial seats were up for election in 2018 and identifies those races that were considered battleground elections. Mouse over a state for more detailed information.

2018 Gubernatorial Battleground Races
State Current Incumbent Open Seat (Y/N) Winning candidate Change in partisan control?
Alaska Grey.png Bill Walker Yes Republican Party Mike Dunleavy Approveda
Arizona Republican Party Doug Ducey No Republican Party Doug Ducey Defeatedd
California Democratic Party Jerry Brown Yes Democratic Party Gavin Newsom Defeatedd
Colorado Democratic Party John Hickenlooper Yes Democratic Party Jared Polis Defeatedd
Connecticut Democratic Party Dan Malloy Yes Democratic Party Ned Lamont Defeatedd
Florida Republican Party Rick Scott Yes Republican Party Ron DeSantis Defeatedd
Georgia Republican Party Nathan Deal Yes Republican Party Brian Kemp Defeatedd
Illinois Republican Party Bruce Rauner No Democratic Party J.B. Pritzker Approveda
Iowa Republican Party Kim Reynolds No Republican Party Kim Reynolds Defeatedd
Kansas Republican Party Jeff Colyer Yes Democratic Party Laura Kelly Approveda
Maine Republican Party Paul LePage Yes Democratic Party Janet Mills Approveda
Michigan Republican Party Rick Snyder Yes Democratic Party Gretchen Whitmer Approveda
Minnesota Democratic Party Mark Dayton Yes Democratic Party Tim Walz Defeatedd
Nebraska Republican Party Pete Ricketts No Republican Party Pete Ricketts Defeatedd
Nevada Republican Party Brian Sandoval Yes Democratic Party Steve Sisolak Approveda
New Hampshire Republican Party Chris Sununu No Republican Party Chris Sununu Defeatedd
New Mexico Republican Party Susana Martinez Yes Democratic Party Michelle Lujan Grisham Approveda
New York Democratic Party Andrew Cuomo No Democratic Party Andrew Cuomo Defeatedd
Ohio Republican Party John Kasich Yes Republican Party Mike DeWine Defeatedd
Oklahoma Republican Party Mary Fallin Yes Republican Party Kevin Stitt Defeatedd
Oregon Democratic Party Kate Brown No Democratic Party Kate Brown Defeatedd
Pennsylvania Democratic Party Tom Wolf No Democratic Party Tom Wolf Defeatedd
Rhode Island Democratic Party Gina Raimondo No Democratic Party Gina Raimondo Defeatedd
South Dakota Republican Party Dennis Daugaard Yes Republican Party Kristi Noem Defeatedd
Wisconsin Republican Party Scott Walker No Democratic Party Tony Evers Approveda


Outside race ratings

The following table compared gubernatorial race ratings from The Cook Political Report, Sabato's Crystal Ball, and Inside Elections prior to the November 2018 election.


About the office

See also: Governor (state executive office)

In the United States, the title governor refers to the chief executive of each state. The governor is not directly subordinate to the federal authorities but is the political and ceremonial head of the state. The governor may also assume additional roles, such as the commander-in-chief of the National Guard when the role is not federalized. The governor may also have the ability to commute or pardon a criminal sentence.

In all states, the governor is directly elected and, in most cases, has considerable practical powers. Notable exceptions with weak governorships include the office of the governor in Texas, though this may be moderated by the state legislature and, in some cases, by other elected executive officials. Governors can veto state bills. The specific duties and powers vary widely between states.

Compensation


According to compensation figures for 2022 compiled by the Council of State Governments in the Book of the States, the highest salary for a governor was $250,000 in New York while the lowest is $70,000 in Maine. To view the compensation of a particular governor, hover your mouse over the state.[11]

Staff size


According to figures for 2022 compiled by the Council of State Governments in the Book of the States, gubernatorial offices range in size from 9 staffers in Nebraska to 277 staffers in Texas.[11]

Involvement in budget proposals


Although all governors have some involvement in the process of developing a state budget, the specific level of involvement differs from state to state. According to information published in the 2022 Book of the States, 24 governors share responsibility for developing a budget proposal, while 11 governors have full responsibility for developing an initial budget proposal and the remaining 15 have full responsibility for developing a budget.[12]

Term limits

See also: States with gubernatorial term limits


Most states impose some form of term limits on governors; of those that do, all but Virginia limit a governor to two four-year terms or to eight years in office. Although most states' term limit laws allow a governor who has served two terms to be elected once again after time has elapsed, some states impose a lifetime term limit like that on the presidency. Although Vermont and New Hampshire do not have term limit laws, they are the only states whose governors serve two-year terms rather than four-year terms.

Line-item veto powers


The term line-item veto refers to the ability of a governor or other chief executive to veto specific parts of a bill while signing the rest of the bill into law. Currently, 44 states grant their governors line-item veto powers.[12]

Fundraising

Both Democrats and Republicans have organizations which have been formed to support and help elect governors of their respective parties. The Democratic Governors Association and Republican Governors Association are IRS-designated 527 political organizations that serve as resources for each party's gubernatorial candidates and elected governors.

The following is a breakdown of the DGA's and RGA’s receipts for 2017, as reported by each organization.

DGA's and RGA's reported contributions
Year Democratic Governor’s Association Republican Governor’s Association
2017 [13][14] $41,000,000 $63,200,000

Media coverage and analysis of the 2018 elections

This section provides an overview of media coverage of gubernatorial elections across the country.[15] Selected articles are presented as a jumping-off point for deeper exploration of media coverage and as an overview of narratives that have emerged surrounding the elections.

  • Perry Bacon Jr., FiveThirtyEight (November 7, 2018):
"There are six states Obama won in 2012 that flipped to Trump in 2016 — Florida, Iowa, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Our model suggested Democrats had a great chance to win all six, which would have been a huge coup for the party. Instead, Republicans won in Florida, Iowa and Ohio, while Democrats won Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin.
Republicans entered this election with control of both the state legislature and the governor’s office in all of these states but Pennsylvania. They will remain totally in charge in Florida, Iowa and Ohio. That gives them virtually unfettered power not only on policy but also in drawing district lines for state and federal legislative races. But it’s big for Democrats to have won in Michigan and Wisconsin and broken up so-called trifectas in those states."[16]
  • Margaret Newkirk, Bloomberg (November 7, 2018):
"Democrats lost their bid for history in Florida, with a star-power candidate failing to become the state’s first black governor. But the party won a split decision on governors’ seats in the Midwestern states that sent Donald Trump to the White House. And one of the most high-profile races, in Georgia, was possibly headed to a recount.
In all, Democrats picked up at least seven of 26 GOP-held gubernatorial seats, a shift that could complicate Trump’s re-election hopes and alter the nation’s political landscape for the next decade. GOP hopes for a rare pickup evaporated Wednesday when Connecticut Republican Bob Stefanowski, after leading for much of election night, conceded to Democrat Ned Lamont.
The victories tamed a long, Tea Party-fueled winning streak that had given Republicans control of 33 governor’s mansions, the most since 1928. That success became the party’s biggest vulnerability, with Republicans defending nearly three times as many governor’s mansions this year as Democrats."[17]
  • Dan McLaughlin, National Review (October 19, 2018):
"The most optimistic trends for the GOP are in Arizona, Oklahoma, Nevada, and Georgia, three of which seem to be moving in the direction of the state’s recent partisan lean. The mirror image is happening in Rhode Island, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, and Oregon, and the trendline in Ohio is not encouraging.
If I had to project today, I’d see Republicans picking up Alaska and taking a net loss of about five or six governorships, bringing them down to 27 or 28 of the 50 states. But there are still a lot of races that are either in play, or still have too little reliable polling to call. There were more Election Day surprises in 2014 in the governors’ races than the Senate races, and we should not be surprised to be surprised again."[18]
  • Sally Persons, RealClearPolitics (October 17, 2018):
"While the nation’s midterm focus has primarily been on Republican efforts to maintain control of the House and Senate, the GOP is also playing defense with a number of key gubernatorial seats. Many of them are tossups in the final weeks before Election Day -- and are taking place in states that also have a Senate race. Both major political parties are banking their hopes on ticket-splitting voters.
Ohio, no stranger to national politics, is a case in point. Incumbent Sen. Sherrod Brown has a hefty lead over his Republican opponent, Rep. Jim Renacci, but the state also has a competitive gubernatorial race. RealClearPolitics shows Brown up by 16 points in the latest poll average, while Democratic gubernatorial candidate Richard Cordray has a mere 2.7 point lead against Republican Mike DeWine. Ohio Democrats are hoping that Brown’s coattails will help Cordray -- the former head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau -- while Republicans are banking on continued visits from President Trump to help them energize their base."[19]
  • Amber Phillips, The Washington Post (October 10, 2018):
"Nine of the 10 races most likely to flip parties are held by Republicans, spanning the country from Iowa to New Mexico. And while none makes our top 10, open seats in traditionally conservative states, such as Georgia, Kansas, South Dakota and Oklahoma, are all competitive.
The catch is that however many governor’s races the Democrats win, they will be only chipping away at Republicans' historic level of success. Republicans control 33 governor’s mansions, a near record, and those include blue and swing states. And it’s not impossible that Republicans might also pick up control of a state like Connecticut, though that one has fallen off our top-10 list."[20]
  • Alan Greenblatt, Governing (October 3, 2018)
"In the blue states of Connecticut and Oregon, Republicans have fighting chances at winning governors' offices currently held by Democrats.
In Connecticut, outgoing Democrat Dannel Malloy is one of the least popular governors in the country, with an approval rating of around 20 percent. He's raised taxes substantially, yet the state faces a budget shortfall in the neighborhood of $2 billion. Connecticut remains wealthy, but it's been shedding jobs and population as job creation has lagged well behind the nation as a whole....
The contours of the race in Oregon are different. There, GOP state Rep. Knute Buehler is running against Democratic incumbent Gov. Kate Brown by presenting himself as a moderate. Most prognosticators give Brown the edge, but Real Clear Politics changed its rating of the race last week to tossup."[21]
  • W. James Antle III, The Washington Examiner (September 18, 2018):
"New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s crushing victory over actress and activist Cynthia Nixon brought down the curtain on a long primary season last Thursday. Now the candidates are in place for the midterm elections as his fellow Democrats try to rebuke President Trump, recapture Congress and chip away at the Republicans’ stranglehold on the nation’s governorships.
As is often the case with politics in the Trump era, however, nothing is ever easy. Democrats are defending 26 Senate seats to the Republicans’ nine, including 10 in states Trump won in 2016. In about half of these states, the president is still popular, creating the possibility that the GOP will actually expand its narrow 51-49 majority in the upper chamber. Some of the most popular governors in the country are Republicans, including incumbents running for reelection this year in Massachusetts and Maryland, the bluest of states."[22]

Comparison to all-time best state party performances

See also: All-time best performance in gubernatorial elections

In 2018, a Smart Politics analysis found that four winning candidates for governor received the greatest percentage of votes of any gubernatorial candidate from their party in state history—Democrats Gavin Newsom (Calif.) and David Ige (Hawaii) and Republicans Asa Hutchinson (Ark.) and Mark Gordon (Wyo.).[23] The following chart compares each winning candidate's performance with the state party recordholder.

Winning gubernatorial candidates compared to state party all-time records, 2018
State Winning candidate Winning candidate votes State party all-time winner[24] State party all-time winner votes
Alabama Republican Party Kay Ivey 59.5 percent Republican Party Robert Bentley (2014) 63.6 percent
Alaska Republican Party Mike Dunleavy 51.4 percent Republican Party Sean Parnell (2010) 59.1 percent
Arizona Republican Party Doug Ducey 56.0 percent Republican Party Jane Dee Hull (1998) 61.0 percent
Arkansas Republican Party Asa Hutchinson 65.3 percent Republican Party Asa Hutchinson (2018) 65.3 percent
California Democratic Party Gavin Newsom 62.0 percent Democratic Party Gavin Newsom (2018) 62.0 percent
Colorado Democratic Party Jared Polis 53.4 percent Democratic Party Billy Adams (1928) 67.1 percent
Connecticut Democratic Party Ned Lamont 49.4 percent Democratic Party Abraham Ribicoff (1958) 62.3 percent
Florida Republican Party Ron DeSantis 49.6 percent Republican Party Harrison Reed (1868) 59.1 percent
Georgia Republican Party Brian Kemp 50.2 percent Republican Party Sonny Perdue (2006) 57.9 percent
Hawaii Democratic Party David Ige 62.7 percent Democratic Party David Ige (2018) 62.7 percent
Idaho Republican Party Brad Little 59.8 percent Republican Party Dirk Kempthorne (1998) 67.7 percent
Illinois Democratic Party J.B. Pritzker 54.5 percent Democratic Party Augustus French (1848) 86.8 percent
Iowa Republican Party Kim Reynolds 50.3 percent Republican Party John Hammill (1924) 72.7 percent
Kansas Democratic Party Laura Kelly 48.0 percent Democratic Party Robert Docking (1972) 62.0 percent
Maine Democratic Party Janet Mills 50.9 percent Democratic Party Robert Dunlap (1835) 61.4 percent
Maryland Republican Party Larry Hogan 55.4 percent Republican Party Theodore McKeldin (1950) 57.3 percent
Massachusetts Republican Party Charlie Baker 66.6 percent Republican Party Alexander Bullock (1866) 77.5 percent
Michigan Democratic Party Gretchen Whitmer 53.3 percent Democratic Party Stevens T. Mason (1835) 91.2 percent
Minnesota Democratic Party Tim Walz 53.8 percent Democratic Party Wendell Anderson (1974) 62.8 percent
Nebraska Republican Party Pete Ricketts 59.0 percent Republican Party Dwight Griswold (1944) 76.1 percent
Nevada Democratic Party Steve Sisolak 49.4 percent Democratic Party Richard Bryan (1986) 71.9 percent
New Hampshire Republican Party Chris Sununu 52.8 percent Republican Party Steve Merrill (1994) 69.9 percent
New Mexico Democratic Party Michelle Lujan Grisham 57.2 percent Democratic Party Bill Richardson (2006) 68.8 percent
New York Democratic Party Andrew Cuomo 59.6 percent Democratic Party Eliot Spitzer (2006) 69.6 percent
Ohio Republican Party Mike DeWine 50.4 percent Republican Party George Voinovich (1994) 71.8 percent
Oklahoma Republican Party Kevin Stitt 54.3 percent Republican Party Mary Fallin (2010) 60.5 percent
Oregon Democratic Party Kate Brown 50.1 percent Democratic Party John Kitzhaber (1998) 64.4 percent
Pennsylvania Democratic Party Tom Wolf 57.8 percent Democratic Party Bob Casey Sr. (1990) 67.7 percent
Rhode Island Democratic Party Gina Raimondo 52.6 percent Democratic Party Philip Noel (1974) 78.5 percent
South Carolina Republican Party Henry McMaster 54.0 percent Republican Party Robert Kingston Scott (1870) 62.3 percent
South Dakota Republican Party Kristi Noem 51.0 percent Republican Party Bill Janklow (1982) 70.9 percent
Tennessee Republican Party Bill Lee 59.6 percent Republican Party William Brownlow (1867) 76.9 percent
Texas Republican Party Greg Abbott 55.8 percent Republican Party George W. Bush (1998) 68.2 percent
Vermont Republican Party Phil Scott 55.2 percent Republican Party Frederick Holbrook (1862) 88.5 percent
Wisconsin Democratic Party Tony Evers 49.5 percent Democratic Party Tony Earl (1982) 56.8 percent
Wyoming Republican Party Mark Gordon 67.1 percent Republican Party Mark Gordon (2018) 67.1 percent

Winning streaks

See also: Gubernatorial winning streaks

An analysis in Smart Politics found that as a result of the 2018 gubernatorial elections, 13 states gained or extended record-long winning streaks for single-party control of the governorship.[25][26] Six winning streaks were broken while another seven were started. The following chart details whether a winning streak was broken or started in each of 2018's gubernatorial elections as well as details on each state's longest gubernatorial winning streaks from each major party. A winning streak in bold was extended as a result of the 2018 elections.

Gubernatorial elections and same-party winning streaks, 2018
State Winning party Winning streak continued or broken? Longest Democratic winning streak Longest Republican winning streak
Alabama Ends.png Republican Four-election Republican streak continued 35[27] Five[28]
Alaska Ends.png Republican No winning streak Two[29] Three[30]
Arizona Ends.png Republican Two-election Republican streak continued 10[31] Four[32]
Arkansas Ends.png Republican Republican streak started 47[33] Two[34]
California Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Democratic streak continued Three[35] Five[36]
Colorado Electiondot.png Democratic Three-election Democratic streak continued Six[37] Four[38]
Connecticut Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Democratic streak continued Five[39] 10[40]
Florida Ends.png Republican Five-election Republican streak continued 13[41] Six[42]
Georgia Ends.png Republican Four-election Republican streak continued 52[43] Five[44]
Hawaii Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Democratic streak continued 10[45] Two[46]
Idaho Ends.png Republican Six-election Republican streak continued Six[47] Seven[48]
Illinois Electiondot.png Democratic No winning streak Six[49] Nine[50]
Iowa Ends.png Republican Two-election Republican streak continued Three[51] 19[52]
Kansas Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Republican streak broken Four[53] 11[54]
Maine Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Republican streak broken Six[55] 22[56]
Maryland Ends.png Republican Republican streak started Eight[57] Two[58]
Massachusetts Ends.png Republican Republican streak started Five[59] 18[60]
Michigan Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Republican streak broken Seven[61] 14[62]
Minnesota Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Democratic streak continued Three[63] 19[64]
Nebraska Ends.png Republican Five-election Republican streak continued Five[65] 12[66]
Nevada Electiondot.png Democratic Five-election Republican streak broken Four[67] Five[68]
New Hampshire Ends.png Republican Republican streak started 14[69] 21[70]
New Mexico Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Republican streak broken 10[71] Two[72]
New York Electiondot.png Democratic Three-election Democratic streak continued Nine[73] Eight[74]
Ohio Ends.png Republican Two-election Republican streak continued Four[75] Seven[76]
Oklahoma Ends.png Republican Two-election Republican streak continued 14[77] Three[78]
Oregon Electiondot.png Democratic Nine-election Democratic streak continued Ten[79] Six[80]
Pennsylvania Electiondot.png Democratic Democratic streak started Four[81] 10[82]
Rhode Island Electiondot.png Democratic Democratic streak started Nine[83] 24[84]
South Carolina Ends.png Republican Four-election Republican streak continued 37[85] Five[86]
South Dakota Ends.png Republican Ten-election Republican streak continued Three[87] 13[88]
Tennessee Ends.png Republican Two-election Republican streak continued 20[89] Three[90]
Texas Ends.png Republican Six-election Republican streak continued 51[91] Seven[92]
Vermont Ends.png Republican Republican streak started Five[93] 49[94]
Wisconsin Electiondot.png Democratic Two-election Republican streak broken Three[95] 19[96]
Wyoming Ends.png Republican Two-election Republican streak continued Five[97] Five[98]

Historical control

In 1977, the Democratic Party held a total of 37 governorships to the Republican Party's 12. Following the elections of 1980, the Democratic lead in governorships narrowed to 27 to the Republican Party's 23. The 1986 midterm elections also saw an increase in Republican governorships, bringing the party to 24 governorships compared to the Democrats' 26. The Republican Party would take the national lead in governorships following the midterm elections of 1994; in 1995, there were 30 Republican governors to 19 Democratic governors.

The Republican lead in governorships would be maintained for just over a decade until the midterm elections of 2006; in 2007, there were 28 Democratic governors to the Republicans' 22. However, the Republican Party would regain its national majority in the 2010 midterm elections. Between 2010 and 2017, the number of Republican governors continued to increase, reaching a high point of 34 following West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice's switch to the Republican Party in August 2017.[99]

Wave election analysis

See also: Wave elections (1918-2016)

The term wave election is frequently used to describe an election cycle in which one party makes significant electoral gains. How many seats would Republicans have had to lose for the 2018 midterm election to be considered a wave election?

Ballotpedia examined the results of the 50 election cycles that occurred between 1918 and 2016—spanning from President Woodrow Wilson's (D) second midterm in 1918 to Donald Trump's (R) first presidential election in 2016. We define wave elections as the 20 percent of elections in that period resulting in the greatest seat swings against the president's party.

Applying this definition to gubernatorial elections, we found that Republicans needed to lose seven seats for 2018 to qualify as a wave election.

The chart below shows the number of seats the president's party lost in the 11 gubernatorial waves from 1918 to 2016. Click here to read the full report.

Gubernatorial wave elections
Year President Party Election type Gubernatorial seats change Elections analyzed[100]
1970 Nixon R First midterm -12 35
1922 Harding R First midterm -11 33
1932 Hoover R Presidential -10 35
1920 Wilson D Presidential -10 36
1994 Clinton D First midterm -10 36
1930 Hoover R First midterm -9 33
1938 Roosevelt D Second midterm -9 33
1966 Johnson D First midterm[101] -9 35
1954 Eisenhower R First midterm -8 33
1982 Reagan R First midterm -7 36
2010 Obama D First midterm -7 33

See also


Footnotes

  1. Excludes the 693,972 inhabitants of Washington, D.C.
  2. Excludes the 693,972 inhabitants of Washington, D.C.
  3. 2016 for New Hampshire, Oregon, and Vermont. 2014 for all other states.
  4. Walker ran for re-election but suspended his campaign on October 19, 2018.
  5. Colyer ran for election to a full term in 2018 but was defeated in the Republican primary.
  6. Illinois State Board of Elections, "Contributions Search - By Candidates," accessed August 27, 2018
  7. CBS Chicago, "Primary Sets Up Expensive Showdown Between Billionaires Rauner And Pritzker," March 21, 2018
  8. Follow the Money, "An Overview of Campaign Finances, 2009-2010 Elections," April 12, 2012
  9. New York Times, "Brian Kemp Wins Georgia G.O.P. Runoff for Governor to Face Stacey Abrams," July 24, 2018
  10. Valdez Star, "Gov. Bill Walker suspended campaign for re-election," October 24, 2018
  11. 11.0 11.1 Council of State Governments' Book of the States 2022 Table 4.3: The Governors: Compensation, Staff, Travel and Residence provided to Ballotpedia by CSG personnel
  12. 12.0 12.1 Council of State Governments' Book of the States 2022 Table 4.4: The Governors: Powers provided to Ballotpedia by CSG personnel
  13. DGA, "With Boost from New Donors, DGA Raises Record $41 Million in 2017," January 31, 2018
  14. RGA, "RGA Breaks Fundraising Records, Brings In $63 Million in 2017," January 31, 2018
  15. In selecting articles for inclusion in this section, Ballotpedia has drawn from a variety of sources and viewpoints to identify articles that are representative of broader trends in media coverage.
  16. FiveThirtyEight, "Democrats Had A Big Night In Governors Races, But It Could Have Been Bigger," November 7, 2018
  17. Bloomberg, "Parties Split Governors’ Seats in States That Sent Trump to the White House," November 7, 2018
  18. National Review, "How Will the Governors’ Races Break?" October 19, 2018
  19. RealClearPolitics, "In Tight Governor Races, Ticket-Splitting May Be Key," October 17, 2018
  20. The Washington Post, "The 10 governor’s seats most likely to flip parties in November," October 10, 2018
  21. Governing, "Republicans Could Take Control of These 2 Coastal Blue States," October 3, 2018
  22. The Washington Examiner, "The primaries are over, now it's on to the fall classic," September 18, 2018
  23. Smart Politics, "4 Gubernatorial Nominees Set State Party Records in 2018," December 13, 2018
  24. Excluding unopposed candidates
  25. A winning streak can be defined as two or more consecutive general or special elections in which one party's gubernatorial candidate wins.
  26. Smart Politics, "Partisan Gubernatorial Election Records Abound in 2018 Cycle," December 7, 2018
  27. (1874-1982)
  28. (2002-2018)
  29. (1958-1962, 1982-1986, and 1994-1998)
  30. (2002-2010)
  31. (1930-1948)
  32. (1986-1998)
  33. (1874-1964)
  34. (1966-1968, 1998-2002, and 2014-2018)
  35. (2010-2018)
  36. (1918-1934)
  37. (1926-1936 and 1974-1994)
  38. (1938-1944)
  39. (1873-1876)
  40. (1857-1866)
  41. (1920-1964)
  42. (1998-2018)
  43. (1871-1998)
  44. (2002-2018)
  45. (1962-1998)
  46. (2002-2006)
  47. (1970-1990)
  48. (1994-2018)
  49. (1834-1852)
  50. (1856-1888)
  51. (1932-1936, 1962-1966, and 1998-2006)
  52. (1893-1930)
  53. (1966-1972)
  54. (1859-1880)
  55. (1845-1850)
  56. (1856-1877)
  57. (1970-1998)
  58. (1950-1954 and 2014-2018)
  59. (1910-1914)
  60. (1856-1873)
  61. (1841-1852, 1948-1960)
  62. (1854-1880)
  63. (1904-1908, 1954-1958, 2010-2018)
  64. (1859-1896)
  65. (1930-1938)
  66. (1866-1888)
  67. (1934-1946 and 1982-1994)
  68. (1998-2014)
  69. (1832-1845)
  70. (1924-1960)
  71. (1930-1948)
  72. (1918-1920, 1926-1928, 1950-1952, 1966-1968, 1994-1998, and 2010-2014)
  73. (1922-1938)
  74. (1894-1908)
  75. (1905-1912, 1930-1936, and 1948-1954)
  76. (1891-1903)
  77. (1907-1958)
  78. (2010-2018)
  79. (1986-2018)
  80. (1938-1954)
  81. (1838-1847)
  82. (1894-1930)
  83. (1940-1956)
  84. (1863-1886)
  85. (1876-1970)
  86. (2002-2018)
  87. (1970-1974)
  88. (1900-1924)
  89. (1922-1966)
  90. (2010-2018)
  91. (1873-1974)
  92. (1994-2018)
  93. (1992-2000)
  94. (1867-1960)
  95. (1958-1962)
  96. (1894-1930)
  97. (1974-1990)
  98. (1894-1906)
  99. Because Justice switched his registration more than halfway through the year, he was counted as a Democrat in 2017 for the purposes of the chart.
  100. The number of gubernatorial seats up for election varies, with as many as 36 seats and as few as 12 seats being up in a single even-numbered year.
  101. Lyndon Johnson's (D) first term began in November 1963 after the death of President John F. Kennedy (D), who was first elected in 1960. Before Johnson had his first midterm in 1966, he was re-elected president in 1964.