With its storied combination of coconut, pineapple, and (two types of) rum, this frozen piña colada recipe turns out a tropical cocktail that’s creamy, just sweet enough, and utterly refreshing. The original version of this Caribbean drink is credited to bartender Ramon “Monchito” Marrero of the Caribe Hotel in San Juan, Puerto Rico. According to the hotel, his 1954 recipe combined rum and pineapple juice (not fresh pineapple!) with both heavy cream and coconut cream. Today, most recipes—including this one—instead call for cream of coconut, such as Coco Lopez, which is thicker than coconut milk, thinner than coconut cream, and sweetened.
For the best piña colada (which is totally subjective) you should use whatever type of rum you like. Using white rum will make a breezier drink, while turning to dark rum or a funkier option will result in something richer, but no less refreshing. Here, a combination of aged and coconut rums add layers of flavor. Spiced rum? Go ahead, you do you. Blend whatever you choose with ice until smooth, garnish with a slice of pineapple—and an optional maraschino cherry—and sit back with the ultimate summer cocktail (no matter what time of year it actually is).
Get more frozen cocktail recipes →
Editor’s note: This recipe was originally published in ‘101 Tropical Drinks’ by Kim Haasarud. It first appeared on Epicurious in May 2015.
Recipe information
Yield
Makes 1 cocktail
Ingredients
Preparation
Combine all the ingredients in a blender cup. Add 1 cup of ice. Blend on High until smooth. Pour into a hurricane glass, goblet, or tall glass. Garnish with the pineapple wedge.
Leave a Review
Reviews (3)
Back to TopCoco Lopez is actually ‘cream of coconut’ vs coconut cream. These are 2 often mixed up, but very different products.
StephL
Woodbury, MN
6/12/2019
Use canned pineapple chunks instead of pineapple juide. It's thicker and more flavorful.
duany
Burlington, VT
6/25/2014
Inimitably delicious and caloric! To improve the nearly unimprovable, add a splash of Creme de Maraschin...
Purpleapron
Northern MA
7/15/2013
See Related Recipes and Cooking Tips
53 Fourth of July Recipes for a Fun-Filled Independence Day
We’ve got your July Fourth spread covered with festive recipes for ribs, grilled chicken, and sides.29 Frozen Drinks That Are Worth the Brain Freeze
These slushy frozen cocktails are all about fresh fruit and big flavors, not bottled mixes.47 Summer Cocktails to Put You in a Sunny Mood
Chill out with these easy-drinking summer favorites.23 Rum Drinks to Get You in a Summer Mood
These recipes will help your favorite bottle shine.37 Craveable Coconut Desserts
From creamy coconut pie to a moist and fluffy coconut-carrot cake, these are desserts you'll never flake out on.How to Make Frozen Cocktails and Stay Chill All Summer
This make-ahead method is the best way to make frozen cocktails at home.41 Best Pineapple Recipes: Tacos, Cocktails, Desserts, and More
Yes, you can add it to fruit salad. But there’s more to pineapple than that.77 Ways to Use a Can of Coconut Milk
Rich, versatile canned coconut milk plays a central role in many curries—but that's just the beginning of what this pantry superstar can do.Our Best Pineapple Recipes
Whether it's served for dinner, drinks, breakfast, or dessert, pineapple will brighten any meal.
