Skip to main content

Eggs in Purgatory

4.8

(42)

This image may contain Dish Food Meal Pizza and Plant
Photo by Alex Lau, Styling by Sue Li

Any type of tomatoes will work, though cherry tomatoes hold their shape well. If what you’ve got is a couple of ripe beefsteaks or Romas, cut them into 1" pieces and carry on.

Recipe information

  • Yield

    4 servings

Ingredients

¼

cup olive oil, plus more for drizzling

5

garlic cloves, smashed

Kosher salt, freshly ground pepper

½

teaspoon crushed red pepper flakes

20

ounces cherry tomatoes

1

bunch Swiss chard, preferably rainbow

6

large eggs

4

thin slices country-style bread

1

lemon

Flaky sea salt or kosher salt

Handful of basil leaves

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Heat ¼ cup oil in a medium skillet over medium-high. When it just starts to shimmer, add garlic and season generously with kosher salt and black pepper. Cook, stirring constantly, until garlic is just turning golden around the edges, about 2 minutes. Stir in red pepper flakes, then add tomatoes and cook, tossing occasionally, until tomatoes look plumped and some of the skins start to split, about 2 minutes.

    Step 2

    Reduce heat to medium. Cover pan and cook, stirring tomatoes every couple of minutes and lightly smashing them with a wooden spoon to encourage them to release some juices, until mixture is saucy and tomatoes are slightly deflated but still hold some shape, 5–7 minutes.

    Step 3

    Meanwhile, strip leaves off Swiss chard stems and tear into bite-sized pieces (or bigger, your call). Reserve stems for your next sauté. Transfer leaves to a medium bowl.

    Step 4

    Reduce heat under tomatoes to medium-low (sauce should be bubbling gently). Carefully crack eggs into a large measuring glass, then slip one at a time into tomato mixture, spacing them evenly apart around perimeter of pan. Season eggs with salt and pepper, cover pan, and cook until whites are set but yolks are still runny, 4–6 minutes.

    Step 5

    While eggs are cooking, toast bread until crisp. Drizzle with oil, then firmly rub outside of lemon onto toasts to release aromatic oils from peel (you’ll smell it!). Sprinkle toasts with sea salt.

    Step 6

    Squeeze about 2 Tbsp. lemon juice over greens, then toss in basil. Drizzle some oil over and season with kosher salt and black pepper. Toss again to combine.

    Step 7

    Scoop an egg out of pan, spooning it up from underneath to keep the yolk intact, and transfer to a small shallow bowl. Spoon extra sauce around egg and sprinkle with sea salt. Repeat with remaining eggs. Serve with salad and toasts alongside.

    Step 8

    Do Ahead: Tomato mixture can be made 1 day ahead. Let cool; cover and chill. Reheat over medium until simmering before adding eggs.

Sign In or Subscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Eggs in Purgatory?

Leave a Review

Reviews (42)

Back to Top
  • I added two chopped & rinsed leeks - sautéed them first with garlic then added tomatoes - the sweetness of the leeks and the freshness of the tomatoes made this dish for me. I did use 30oz of cherry tomatoes as I didn;t feel that 20 were enough even with the leek addition.

    • ATL Kate

    • Atlanta

    • 6/21/2024

  • This is an excellent dish, & well prepared. Bits of it are subjective... Toast too toasted, etc. However, not reading the Bible results in people going to Hell because they fall for crap like the mythical place Pergatory & paying for sins, then going to Heaven. Jesus is the only Way to Heaven, not one of a few. Carla cooks, but sadly has believed lies without consulting the Author of the Bible.

    • Ronald

    • Here & There

    • 6/27/2022

  • My family says best breakfast ever. This will be a new Christmas tradition!! The tomatoes and garlic with eggs nestled in. The lemony toast. Amazing!!

    • Susan Pohl

    • Houston

    • 12/25/2021

  • This is my "welcome to summer" recipe! As soon as June hits I start dreaming about Eggs in Purgatory. Now that July is here and the cherry tomatoes are back at the market, this is a weekly staple. I also add in some chopped sweet onion at the start, it adds an extra layer of flavor that sends this over the moon. It's true, don't use too large a pan if cutting the recipe in half. In order to get the sauce just right, you need to have a pan that just holds all of the tomatoes when raw. Thank you Bon Appetit for yet another winner!

    • Anonymous

    • San Francisco, CA

    • 7/24/2021

  • Love love love this! When you want a savory brunch meal and hsve garden tomatoed this is the best!

    • Lori Bee

    • Norman, Oklahoma

    • 7/18/2021

  • Is this dish supposed to be really sour or are my tomatoes just off? I can’t tell because I think I’ve only ever had sour tomatoes. Otherwise I really loved the texture of the eggs and will be shakshuka-ing my eggs more often thanks to this recipe

    • Anonymous

    • Tennessee

    • 3/17/2021

  • So yummy!

    • Anonymous

    • 2/16/2021