Scratchy Husband Pasta

Total Time
20 to 30 minutes, including boiling water
Rating
4(940)
Notes
Read community notes

In spite of the very few and very commonplace ingredients in this dish, there is an alchemy of sorts that takes place, transforming them from humble to holy-smokes-delicious in a way you will crave for the rest of your days. Be generous with your pinches, your grinds of the pepper mill, your scatter of cheese, your slivers of garlic and your final portions. It makes the difference. 

Featured in: The Pasta Cure for the Hungry and the Stressed-Out

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement


Ingredients

Yield:2 quite large portions or 4 small portions
  • ¾cups extra-virgin olive oil
  • ¼pound unsalted butter
  • 1whole head of garlic, or at least 10 cloves, peeled, sliced thin across the grain
  • Good quality salt
  • 1pound dried spaghetti
  • 4teaspoons of chile flakes
  • A generous ½ cup of grated pecorino or Parmigiano-Reggiano
  • Many, many cranks of the pepper mill
Ingredient Substitution Guide
Nutritional analysis per serving (2 servings)

2034 calories; 135 grams fat; 43 grams saturated fat; 0 grams trans fat; 74 grams monounsaturated fat; 12 grams polyunsaturated fat; 173 grams carbohydrates; 9 grams dietary fiber; 6 grams sugars; 36 grams protein; 892 milligrams sodium

Note: The information shown is Edamam’s estimate based on available ingredients and preparation. It should not be considered a substitute for a professional nutritionist’s advice.

Powered by

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Bring large pot of water to a boil. When water simmers and is about to break to a roiling boil, place a 10-inch deep-sided sauté pan on low heat.

  2. Step 2

    Add the olive oil and butter and sliced garlic to the pan and let the butter melt, as the garlic begins to warm through. When the pasta water gets roiling, add salt to taste. (As always, like seawater.) Add the dry spaghetti. Add chile flakes to the warming garlic-oil mixture and swirl the pan a bit.

  3. Step 3

    Stir the spaghetti and make sure it is cooking evenly and the strands are separated. Swirl the garlic-chile-oil pan smoothly and frequently, and let the garlic soften and start to turn golden as the butter starts to foam and the chile blooms its heat and color into the oil. (On my stove, the burners run quite hot, so I keep it on low the whole time, but if your home burner is weak and you are not getting any foaming or toasting of the garlic by now, tap the heat up a half-step.) At 8 minutes, pull the pasta from the boiling water with tongs, let it briefly drip its excess water above the pasta pot, but then place it right into the garlic-chile-oil pan, letting the last drips of water go right into the sauce.

  4. Step 4

    Turn up the heat under the pasta now and stir vigorously, also tossing the pasta with short sturdy flicks of your wrist, for just about a minute, listening to the water hiss a little as it evaporates in the oil.

  5. Step 5

    Turn off the heat, add cheese and a lot of black pepper. Toss and distribute all the garlic and the cheese and the chile flakes using two forks like you are tossing a salad, making sure every bit is coated and luscious and on the edge even of greasy. (The amount of salt that I put in the pasta water, combined with the salt of the cheese, is enough for us. If you feel it needs it, season with a little more salt, according to your tastes.) Serve immediately.

Ratings

4 out of 5
940 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

This is what pasta is all about. Pasta is a “carrier” food, like eggs . . . Add, mix, anything and it can carry it off. If you’re Italian, you cook with anything you have and this is the epitome of that. And... this is the best part (sorry, she/he capped it). ... Makes this perfect! “toasted bread crumbs with minced anchovy and grated lemon zest and chopped parsley” Be still my heart.

I make this all the time but tweak the amounts. A couple of tablespoons of high quality olive oil, a couple of tablespoons of butter, a healthy pinch of pepper flakes, and a couple of sliced garlic cloves. Some freshly grated parmesan, plus serve extra at the table. I make this with a pound of spaghetti which generously serves 3 plus leftovers for lunch. In other words, less is more.

I liked the flavors but a stick of butter and 3/4 cup of olive oil made it too greasy for only a pound of pasta, even with water from the pasta and cheese. I’m not sure you need the butter but you can half both quantities (or less) and still get a flavorful sauce without it being greasy and overly rich. Next time, I’ll use a 1/3 or 1/2 a cup of olive oil and 2 TBS of butter.

Sounds pretty much like spaghetti alla mezze notte (minus the butter) - a very common dish prepared by mothers throughout Rome when their children came home in the middle of the night from partying.

Such a warming narrative. Grateful.

Add toasted bread crumbs, minced anchovy, grated lemon zest and chopped parsley

I’m not sure if I know or care, if it’s this recipe or the vibrant and edgy story that accompanied it in The New York Times magazine on August 19, but this dish made us forget about everything that happened today. A full on deep dive. A relic to relish. Can’t wait for reruns.

No husband. No wife. But this pasta is still amazing for one!! Thank you !

Hold on. The two of yuz eat a pound of spaghetts and 3/4 cup of olive oil for your night snack. You planning to refit the place with sliding garage doors. What's wrong with spaghetti con Aglio, Olio,e Peperoncini-so beautiful. Likely no parsley around, right. On top of everything else, putting out an article about eating pasta ticks off 80% of the elite, all of whom are on self-imposed gluten-free diets. Yak for hours bout not eating wheat.

This is a perfect recipe. If you make it for purposes other than the one for which it is intended, it can serve six people; with a sharply flavored salad, you're set. If you make it for the purpose for which it's intended, i.e., to satisfy a deep longing for either pasta or peace of mind, the serving suggestions are correct. As for the calories: I cooked this after a week of no carbs and low fat and loved it. I will not want carbs or fat for a while. Mission accomplished. It is what it is.

i've been making this since i was 22 without a recipe. i'm now 72. I believe along with girls still doing most of the chores, more women are also cooking dinner after work. Do ya' think a man could make this all by himself? "scratchy husband" wha'???? i thought this was a thing of the past. Let them make this incredibly simple dish for the scratchy wife.

I have been making this exact dish for dinner for over 30 years now. I had not previously attributed my robust mental health to it, though. Of course I’ve usually washed it down with wine so that might be a factor as well.

LOVE THIS! Added the breadcrumbs, lemon, parsley and anchovy. Very similar to a dish my great grandmother made. Simple and delicious! A favorite by my favorite Gabrielle Hamilton.

My olive oil was rancid so I used avocado oil, otherwise followed the recipie exactly. Wonderful! I dont understand why some people are jittery about the ingredients and their proportions- this recipie is not meant to be a regular part of anyone´s diet, just an occasional treat. And what a treat this was! Thank you Gabrielle Hamilton.

I think this recipe is a fine combination of aglio e olio and cacio e pepe. I don’t understand the all’arrabbiara. Aren’t tomatoes required to take on this “triple crown”?

Feb24: used 2 T red pepper and good heat. Didn’t double batch. Use a bit more butter and lessen oil.

So simple, so delicious. Follow the recipe as written. This qualifies as soul food.

I like to add a whole lot of parsley and top it with fresh cherry tomatoes cut in half

Cut pepper flakes back to 1.5tsp, add lemon juice zest, parsley

We accidentally reached for chili powder instead of chili flakes and dumped a couple tablespoons into the oil before we realized. People, it was delicious. Try it!

GF pasta didn't work here for me. Say what you want, I'm sensitive to gluten and what it does to me sucks. Problem is, GF pasta doesn't work well in these kind of dishes and it didn't here. Gloopy mess. Had 12oz of pasta so went w/ 1/2c oil (rosemary oil, leftover from "Creamy Cauliflower Soup") and 4T butter. Used the whole head of garlic, but only 2t chili flakes because I have a heat-averse family. Even with half the chili flakes, it was still too spicy. No alchemy tonight, sadly.

This has become a favorite; I slightly reduce the evoo & butter, and favor capellini noodles over spaghetti. More than anything, I love the greasy pool of leftovers this leaves for the next day: for lunch I make a nest of the remaining pasta in a hot cast iron, then pour in two eggs. The fat from the pasta is enough to fry up the eggs nicely, and the noodles crisp underneath.

We make this in giant batches so that there are leftovers. The leftovers are fabulous, maybe even better than the freshly made pasta, which is saying something. This is a great vehicle for bits of leftover ham (sautéed in butter before tossing with the pasta), and we love the buttered bread crumbs variation. Did we tweak the recipe? Of course - this is a recipe ready for tweaking. But keep the main flavors & techniques & it's always a winner.

Scratchy husband made this dish. He’s a total rule follower so he made it exactly per the recipe. I added parsley and lemon to mine. Quite spicy! I’d probably cut down on the amount of butter bc it is pooling at the bottom of pan.

I don’t know if it’s because I reduced the amount of olive oil and butter (by a lot) but I put in only 3 tsp of pepper flakes and this was bordering on too spicy to be enjoyable. Maybe the flakes have to reduce with the fats, something to keep in mind

This is soooooo good! Absolutely use a whole head of garlic. Less olive oil is okay. It is magically better than the sum of it's parts!

This will surely become a regular. My pepper flakes were hot, so I used less. Added some salt to the sauce. Made it easier by cooking the pasta first, reserving half a cup of cooking liquid, and stopping the pasta from cooking by adding cold water to the pot. Once the garlic was nice and soft, added the cooking water to the sauce, then drained and added the pasta, and gradually mixed in the cheese. It all came together really well. Yum!

We're making this 2-3 x week now, so I try small variations to change it up; some work, some not so much. Always less fat than this recipe, taggiasca EVOO to cover the pan, teaspoon of flakes, lots of garlic, never tried butter but I will give it a go. My options started with minced anchovy of course, also might add some marinara, 1/2 cup for acid, color and umami. Occasionally go for a mazeman ramen effect and stir white miso into the oil/garlic & pepper when its done plus braised rapini.

Added Giuanciale in thin strips and some capers at the end, also parsley. It was really great, even though I should have left out the butter - the giunciale gives off a lot of fat. Made it in a dutch oven and forgot to turn off the stove, so I was rewarded with a crunchy pasta layer at the bottom. Couldnt believe my luck!

Add a bit of rice vinegar, and some lemon zest. Delish

Private notes are only visible to you.

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.