End-to-End Encryption vs. Protecting Children: Can We Have Both? A recent proposal by the European Union has ignited a fierce debate: should tech companies be mandated to scan private messages for child sexual abuse material (CSAM)? Protecting children is imperative, but this proposal raises grave concerns about the integrity of end-to-end encryption. Encryption is the cornerstone of our online privacy. It ensures that only the sender and recipient can access a message's contents. Undermining encryption would have profound consequences, leaving our communications vulnerable to malicious actors. How can we trust the government to safeguard our privacy when vulnerabilities exist in platforms like Signal, a widely trusted encrypted messaging service? Consider the following CVEs: Signal Desktop: CVE-2023-36665, CVE-2022-37601, CVE-2021-23440, CVE-2019-10747 Signal Server: CVE-2022-1471, CVE-2022-42889, CVE-2022-0839 libsignal: CVE-2023-42282 These vulnerabilities highlight the ongoing challenges in maintaining secure communication channels, making it even more critical to question any measures that could further weaken encryption. Advocates of the EU's plan assert that it's necessary to combat the proliferation of CSAM. However, critics argue that scanning private messages sets a dangerous precedent, paving the way for mass surveillance and infringing on our right to privacy. Moreover, such measures might prove futile, as criminals could simply migrate to more secure platforms. The critical question is whether we can protect children without compromising our privacy. This issue demands careful deliberation. We must devise solutions that tackle CSAM effectively without dismantling encryption's security advantages. Consider these questions: 1. Are there alternative methods to detect and prevent CSAM that do not involve scanning private messages? 2. Can education and awareness programs be enhanced to empower people to identify and report CSAM? 3. What role can tech companies play in creating solutions that protect children while upholding privacy? I would like you to please engage in this conversation and share your perspectives on this vital issue. Together, we can find a solution that protects our children and our privacy. #Signal #cybersecurity #privacy #encryption #childsafety #EU #technology What do you think? Can we strike a balance between protecting children and safeguarding privacy? Websites reviewed https://lnkd.in/e_CHeGfU
Thomas Ryan’s Post
More Relevant Posts
-
In the ever-evolving cybersecurity landscape, staying ahead of threats is not just an advantage—it's a necessity. On July 10, 2024, The Cyber Breakfast Club - NYC invites you to an unparalleled event that promises to redefine your approach to ransomware and breaches. Topic: From Panic to Precision: Coordinated Responses to Ransomware and Breaches Our panel is a powerhouse of expertise and experience: 👉 Rick Doten - CISO, Centene Corporation. 👉 Michelle Schaap - Partner, Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, Privacy & Data Security Practice. 👉 Alex W. - DFIR Executive. 👉 Christopher Stangl - Managing Director - Cybersecurity/Investigations (Retd. FBI Senior Executive). Join us to gain insights from the best in the business. Discover how to transform moments of panic into precision-driven responses that safeguard your organization. This isn't just another event—it's your chance to stay ahead of the curve and network with top-tier professionals shaping cybersecurity's future. Spaces are limited, and the buzz is already building. Don't miss out on this opportunity to be at the forefront of cybersecurity innovation. Secure your spot now and prepare to elevate your game! #Cybersecurity #Ransomware #CyberBreakfastClub #Leadership #Innovation #Networking
☕ Join the NYC - Cyber Breakfast Club. Our next virtual breakfast meeting is Wednesday July 10th, 2024, from 7:45 AM - 9:00 AM EST. New members welcome! Register here: https://lnkd.in/g3MJ2yA Thomas Ryan Rick Doten Michelle Schaap Alex W. Christopher Stangl Adrianna Iadarola
This content isn’t available here
Access this content and more in the LinkedIn app
-
I want to thank the Special Operations Association of America (SOAA) and the Irregular Warfare Initiative (IWI) for the incredible opportunity to be part of such a distinguished panel. It is an honor to stand alongside such esteemed colleagues and contribute to discussions shaping the future of cybersecurity and irregular warfare. Additionally, to my friends and colleagues in the Metro DC and NoVa area, I would love to connect with you during this event. Let's seize this chance to exchange insights, share experiences, and strengthen our professional networks. Please feel free to contact me, and let's make the most of this extraordinary gathering. #cybersecurity #nationalsecurity #irregularwarfare #osint #conference
SOAA-IWI Conference 2024: Intelligence and the Changing Landscape of Irregular Warfare Warriors, leaders, and cybersecurity enthusiasts, Next week, the battlefield of knowledge will ignite at the SOAA-IWI Conference 2024 in Falls Church, Virginia. On July 17th and 18th, the Special Operations Association of America (SOAA) joined forces with the Irregular Warfare Initiative (IWI) to host a conference that promises to reshape the future of irregular warfare. This is your call to action for those with a fervent passion for cybersecurity. 🔥 Jax S., SOAA Board Member and VP of Cybersecurity at Pearson, will lead an esteemed panel featuring legends who have forged the path in our domain: 👉 Candice Frost - Director at Nightwing and Adjunct at Georgetown University 👉 Cait Conley - Sr. Advisor to CISA Director 👉 Thomas Ryan - Founder of Asymmetric Response Prepare to immerse yourself in discussions that will cover: 🔥 Uncrewed Systems 🔥 Cybersecurity 🔥 Counterintelligence & OSINT 🔥 Defense Industrial Base This is more than a conference; it's a crucible where innovation meets strategy, and where you'll gain insights from the vanguards of our field. The knowledge shared here will be the edge you need to stay ahead of the curve in a world where cyber and physical domains converge. Don’t miss this chance to be part of something extraordinary. With limited seats available, registration closes on July 9th, 2024, or when tickets sell out—whichever comes first. Act now to secure your place among the elite. Don't wait, take the first step towards enhancing your cybersecurity knowledge. Register now for the SOAA-IWI Conference 2024: https://lnkd.in/ga7zUCtC #specialoperations #cybersecurity #osint #Counterintelligence #nationalsecurity #conference #
-
-
🔥 Must-Watch Episode Alert! 🔥 I’m always on the lookout for compelling content that goes beyond the surface. That’s why Episode 116 of The Shawn Ryan Show, featuring Sarah Adams, aka SuperBad, is one of my top recommendations outside of cybersecurity. Why this episode is a game-changer: 🎙 Host with Firsthand Experience: Shawn Ryan, a former CIA contractor, brings unparalleled insights into intelligence gathering, operations, and analysis. His experience ensures that the show is grounded in real-world expertise. 💡 Incredible Guest Expertise: Sarah Adams, a former CIA Targeting Officer, shares her unique journey in tracking down the #1 enemy of the Benghazi attacks. Her expertise in identifying and assessing threats and her global perspective offer invaluable lessons for anyone in the intelligence field. 📚 Real Stories, Unfiltered: This episode delves into the gritty realities of intelligence work. Sarah’s operational knowledge and firsthand experiences go beyond theoretical discussions, deepening the challenges of targeting and threat assessment. 🌍 Broad Understanding of International Security: Sarah’s work across Europe, the Middle East, North Africa, and South Asia equips her with a nuanced understanding of global security issues, making her insights particularly relevant in today’s complex geopolitical landscape. 📈 Post-CIA Insights: From her book "Benghazi: Know Thy Enemy" to her non-profit work with the Ukraine NGO Coordination Network, Sarah continues to shape the conversation around security and intelligence, offering fresh perspectives on past and current threats. Whether you’re in the intelligence community or have a keen interest in global security, Episode 116 of The Shawn Ryan Show is a must-watch. Don’t miss out on this chance to gain a deeper understanding from one of the most knowledgeable figures in the field. 🔗 Watch Episode 116 Now https://lnkd.in/emvCiZ7q #Intelligence #Security #TheShawnRyanShow #Benghazi #CIA #PodcastRecommendation #SarahAdams #SuperBad #MustWatch #ISIS
Superbad - CIA Targeter Tracks Down #1 Enemy of Benghazi Attacks | SRS #116
https://www.youtube.com/
-
Since I began working with Adrianna Iadarola, Mike Charobee, Dan Haney & Michael Walsh at The Cyber Breakfast Club, people have asked: what is it? How do I join? How do I sponsor an event? So here is a Brief Introduction:
Elevate Your Cybersecurity Network with The Cyber Breakfast Club®
Thomas Ryan on LinkedIn
-
Join us for an electrifying session at the NYC Cyber Breakfast Club Meeting on June 12th, 2024, at 7:45 AM EST! This gathering will explore "The Evolution and Future of Zero Trust Security Models," hosted by Thomas Ryan, CEO and Founder of Asymmetric Response. Prepare to be captivated by our stellar panelists: Don O'Neil frameworks. Don’s vast expertise, including his foundational role at PwC's Zero Trust practice, promises unparalleled insights into secure access and infrastructure security solutions. Greg Fitzgerald, Founder and President of Sevco Security, Inc., and Chairman of Cyberforce Security LLC. With a rich history as a founding CMO at Cylance and strategic leadership roles at Fortinet, Sourcefire, and JASK Labs, Greg’s perspective on market trends and cybersecurity innovation is bound to inspire. Richard Thompson, VP of Field Engineering at Sevco Security, has a 30-year security practice and pre-sales engineering background. Rich’s leadership and technical prowess, honed at Guidance Software and Big Lots, will provide a compelling view of the practical challenges and advancements in zero trust security. Don’t miss out on this exceptional opportunity to network, learn, and stay ahead in the ever-evolving field of cybersecurity. Spaces are limited, so ensure you secure your spot today! https://lnkd.in/eNrNd2ia
☕ Join the NYC - Cyber Breakfast Club. Our next virtual breakfast meeting is Wednesday June 12th, 2024, from 7:45 AM - 9:00 AM EST. New members welcome! Register here: https://lnkd.in/g3MJ2yA Don O'Neil Richard Thompson Greg Fitzgerald Thomas Ryan
This content isn’t available here
Access this content and more in the LinkedIn app
Practice Manager - Security Engineering at Stratascale
2wYou are definitely asking the important questions today Thomas. As a father of 5 boys, I can understand the importance of doing everything in our power to prevent CSAM. As such, the ONLY compromise I would be willing to make and I'm still on the fence about even this, is if possible make it so ONLY images are unencrypted. Now is this still a stretch and a lack of privacy yes. However, in order to maintain the encryption and the privacy of the messaging which was why Signal came about I would be willing to at least debate the ethics of images being decrypted and scanned and would it still secure the text that we send.