Alejandro's Reviews > Harry Potter Series Box Set

Harry Potter Series Box Set by J.K. Rowling
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
665584
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: novel, magic, romance, time-travel, politics, paranormal, military, horror, favorites

Aparecium!

How to choose a single book in the Harry Potter saga? How to choose a part of something that needs each part to generate the expected impact? I was precisely trying to choose one book to use as example in my "favorites" virtual shelf but I realize that not matter which book would I chose, it would feel "incomplete". So I think that the better way is to add this complete edition including the seven novels to use it in my "favorites" virtual shelf.

The rating to the collection is basically the average result combining the seven ratings.

There will be books written about Harry. Every child in the world will know his name.

The Harry Potter novels are truly special to me, since it was "return" to reading for me. I've been a reader all my life, but there were like a "hole" for a couple of years when I wasn't reading anything and certainly it wasn't something good since reading is really important to me and an essential part of myself.

I had already watched four films of Harry Potter when finally I decided to read the novels. I have to thank a friend that he insisted in lending me the first book. Odd enough, he had it on English language while he didn't read English (at least at that time), so he told me that he was glad that somebody was actually reading the book. (He already had read the first 4 books but in Spanish language). I am not a fan of borrowing books and also I don't like that people lend me books, basically for not being in situation where I may feel obliged to borrow some of my books returning the favor. However, since he insisted so much and I knew that he won't ask me for any of my books, finally I accepted.

SOMETHING REALLY MAGICAL STARTS THEN!!!

Wow! I enjoyed a lot the first book, so after that, I started to buy by my own, the following books, even when I already read the seven books, finally I bought my own copy of the first novel to complete the collection. As far as I remember I was able of not having to wait any novel until the final seventh book (such a long wait for that final novel!!!). I ran to the book store to buy it on the very day that it was out and I read it in like 3 days to avoid that somebody would spoil me something crutial or some news on papers and/or internet would spoil a key detail. A reading odyssey of like two years for me.

The Philosopher's Stone (5 stars rating)

It takes a great deal of bravery to stand up to our enemies, but just as much to stand up to our friends.

Truly magical experience where J.K. Rowling, the author, was able to merge such fantastic world with wizards, witches and other paranormal beings with the real experience of parents and kids when they are going to school, needing to get school supplies, books, equipment, etc... Along with all these, the forging a honest and strong friendship between three great characters. And a good thing is that I didn't need to wait years to know how to pronounce the name of Hermione! :D Hermione rules!!!

The Chamber of Secrets (4 stars rating)

It is our choices… that show what we truly are, far more than our abilities.

Maybe I am not fair with my rating on the second book, since the story is quite awesome indeed. I have to admit that my main reason of taking away a star is something involved with Ron Weasley, I can't detail to avoid a spoiler, but I can say that well, I am not much fan of Ron, sorry, what can I say? So, since he got a prominent role at some point here, well, I miss the one that isn't there at that moment.

The Prisoner of Azkaban (5 stars rating)

Happiness can be found, even in the darkest of times, if one only remembers to turn on the light.

Easily the strongest book of the whole bunch. Not only it has a truly well crafted mystery but also, you will amaze to realize how a lot of elements presented in the previous books are explained the reason of existing here in this novel and all is turning around of a character.

The Goblet of Fire (5 stars rating)

If you want to know what a man’s like, take a good look at how he treats his inferiors, not his equals.

Awesome book where the magical world just got bigger and better. You get to know that not only at UK there are wizards and witches but also in other countries. Also, you realize that while the characters have faced dangerous situations before, well, they will have to realize that things are not a game anymore and there will be consequences and dealing with events that they can't be undone.

The Order of the Phoenix (4 stars rating)

Things we lose have a way of coming back to us in the end, if not always in the way we expect.

Maybe another unfair rating. I felt the need of taking away a star just because to reflect the high levels of stress that I suffered while reading this book. Honestly, I really felt "trapped" by it. Hogwarts becomes an awful place to live. There are several really cool scenes. There are moments of wonderful amazement. And of course, you get new wonderful characters too. Luna and Tonks rule! However things became so dark and awful at Hogwarts that I really got stressed each time that I was returning to the book.

The Half-Blood Prince (5 stars rating)

People find it far easier to forgive others for being wrong than being right.

I don't know, but I think that I was so stressed on the fifth book that that reading the sixth book was a truly joyful experience. Really, I think that it can be the book in the saga that I enjoyed the most to read. Love is in the air on the book. Wasted characters so far, they are able to shine in their own way each. You get to know the tragic but truly interesting past of Lord Voldemort that certainly it didn't justify his actions but indeed they give a lot of depth to the character.

The Deathly Hallows (3 stars rating)

Do not pity the dead, Harry. Pity the living, and, above all those who live without love.

I don't know if there was the "pressure" of reading the book as quickly as possible to avoid any spoiler (since it was worldwide news the final book of the saga) or that the development of the story was tedious at some points, or the many stuff that J.K Rowling left unexplained on the saga, but at the end, this book is without a doubt the novel that I enjoy the least in the whole saga. I suppose that endings are a sad moment, you have enoying so much reading the saga that knowing that finally you get to the closing of it, you didn't want to end.

I AM TRULY GLAD OF HAVING READ THIS MAGICAL SAGA AND I RECOMMEND IT TO ANYONE!!!
87 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Harry Potter Series Box Set.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 15, 2005 – Started Reading
July 9, 2007 – Finished Reading
May 5, 2014 – Shelved
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: novel
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: magic
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: romance
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: time-travel
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: politics
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: paranormal
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: military
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: horror
May 5, 2014 – Shelved as: favorites

Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Zoeytron (new)

Zoeytron A most enjoyable review, Alejandro! The Prisoner of Azkaban is my favorite of the bunch, as well.


Alejandro Zoeytron wrote: "A most enjoyable review, Alejandro! The Prisoner of Azkaban is my favorite of the bunch, as well."

Thank you, Zoeytron! :) Great to know that your favorite is Prisoner of Azkaban too :)


message 3: by Carol (new)

Carol Enjoyed your review! Have The Chamber of Secrets ready to go.


message 4: by Nicole~ (new)

Nicole~ A Collector's treasure! Lovely review putting it all together, Alejandro!


message 5: by Lynda (last edited May 05, 2014 11:58PM) (new)

Lynda Wonderfully set out Alejandro. Can you believe I still haven't read these yet? Will have to do something about that. Seen the movies but books are typically better.


message 6: by Anne (new)

Anne Very good review of all the books!


message 7: by Tammie (new)

Tammie Harry Potter marked a return to reading for me too. After having my last two children I had not read much over a period of a few years.


Alejandro Louisa wrote: "Awesome review! Harry Potter brought me much joy and like what you said, it was magical."

Wicked! ;) Thanks for your comments, Louisa :D


Alejandro Carol wrote: "Enjoyed your review! Have The Chamber of Secrets ready to go."

Excellent news! I hope you will enjoy it a lot! :D


Alejandro Nicole~ wrote: "A Collector's treasure! Lovely review putting it all together, Alejandro!"

Thank you, Nicole! :)


Alejandro Lynda wrote: "Wonderfully set out Alejandro. Can you believe I still haven't read these yet? Will have to do something about that. Seen the movies but books are typically better."

Hi, Lynda! I love the movies. Actually I have them on the Ultimate Edition DVDs :P After got them before on Special Editions :P My brother was the one who got benefit of me buying two times the same movies :P

But definitely I highly recommend to read the books, they will give a lot of perspective and deeper knowledge about the saga.


Alejandro Anne wrote: "Very good review of all the books!"

Thanks, Anne! :D


Alejandro Tammie wrote: "Harry Potter marked a return to reading for me too. After having my last two children I had not read much over a period of a few years."

Truly great to know, Tammie! Definitely I think that Harry Potter books not only marked the return to reading of many of us, but also they encouraged a lot of people of all ages to read.


message 14: by Ivonne (new)

Ivonne Rovira Like you, I love The Prisoner of Azkaban -- all the books, really. But my favorite is The Goblet of Fire; my least favorite was The Order of the Phoenix because Harry was so whiny, self-pitying and mean in that one!

I'm sorry you didn't like the final volume, which I loved. Perhaps you need to re-read it slowly so as to savor it? I really took my time on it, as I knew there wouldn't be any more.


Alejandro Ivonne wrote: "Like you, I love The Prisoner of Azkaban -- all the books, really. But my favorite is The Goblet of Fire; my least favorite was The Order of the Phoenix because Harry was so whiny, self-pitying and..."

Hi, Ivonne! Definitely Goblet of Fire is a great book. And I agree about how is Harry on The Order of the Phoenix ;) Yes, maybe a slower reading may help my impression about the final book. ;)


message 16: by Deb (new)

Deb Good job compartmentalizing it all. Very organized. Gotta commend you on that! Another good review my friend. Good stuff! ;o)


Alejandro Debbie wrote: "Good job compartmentalizing it all. Very organized. Gotta commend you on that! Another good review my friend. Good stuff! ;o)"

Thank you so much, Debbie! :D I appreciate a lot your comments!


message 18: by Jan (new)

Jan Rice What a marathon read, plus what a disciplined job of reviewing all, Alejandro. When I was reading them I noticed I would forget what happened in each book as I completed it and went on to the next, but you captured each one in succession!


Alejandro Jan wrote: "What a marathon read, plus what a disciplined job of reviewing all, Alejandro. When I was reading them I noticed I would forget what happened in each book as I completed it and went on to the next..."

Hi Jan, well I read them on the lenght of like two years or so. And even I had to wait to be able to read the final book until publication :P

Yes, I thought that the only fair way to explain my reading experience on Harry Potter and including it on my "favorites" virtual shelf was doing a review about the whole series. ;)


message 20: by Cindy (new)

Cindy I see your dilemma :) I still need to read these....I know, I know.....:D


message 21: by Jan (new)

Jan Rice Alejandro wrote: "Jan wrote: "What a marathon read, plus what a disciplined job of reviewing all, Alejandro. When I was reading them I noticed I would forget what happened in each book as I completed it and went on..."

Speaking of marathons, the other day on my email notification, I saw that you had added 211 books, Alejandro. I almost fell off my chair!


Aditi Wow, Alejandra, a complete justice to Rowling's remarkable work!! I totally agree with your review :)


message 23: by Tania (new)

Tania Loved, loved, loved this whole series. Can't wait for my kids to be old enough so I can introduce them to this wonderful world. Fun review.


message 24: by Brandi (new)

Brandi Great job, Alejandro!


Alejandro Jan wrote: "Alejandro wrote: "Jan wrote: "What a marathon read, plus what a disciplined job of reviewing all, Alejandro. When I was reading them I noticed I would forget what happened in each book as I comple..."

Oh, they technically were already there, but without a date of when I read it, so I went back to check them and set when I read them in the past. :)


Alejandro Killer Rabbit wrote: "Rowling definitely deserves your boxed set tribute review, Alejandro. Would you believe that she was the first author that I stayed up all night to finish their book?"

Thank you, Killer Rabbit :)

Yes, I thought that it was best to do an overall review about the whole saga.

Oh, yes, I believe it since I do almost the same when I was reading thr seventh book ;)


Alejandro Aditi wrote: "Wow, Alejandra, a complete justice to Rowling's remarkable work!! I totally agree with your review :)"

Thank you, Aditi :D


Alejandro Brandi wrote: "Great job, Alejandro!"

Thank you so much, Brandi! I appreciate a lot your kind appraisal!


Alejandro Cindy wrote: "I see your dilemma :) I still need to read these....I know, I know.....:D"

Don't worry Cindy :) Whenever you feel that you're ready for them... the magic will embrace you ;)


Alejandro Tania wrote: "Loved, loved, loved this whole series. Can't wait for my kids to be old enough so I can introduce them to this wonderful world. Fun review."

Awesome, Tania! :D It will be just great that the two generations of your family will love a same book series :D


message 31: by Kaya (new)

Kaya The Order of the Phoenix is my favorite in the series. It's so poignant and yeah, I'm a masochist.

I agree for The Deathly Hallows. The book is a bit static and slow, but the twist in the end made up for it.

Ugh, I definitely need a re-read! :D


Alejandro Kaya wrote: "The Order of the Phoenix is my favorite in the series. It's so poignant and yeah, I'm a masochist.

I agree for The Deathly Hallows. The book is a bit static and slow, but the twist in the end mad..."


Oh, definitely I agree that The Order of the Phoenix is a powerful book, taking aside the stress factor, after all, any book that can provoke such strong emotions should be a good written book.

Thank you, Kaya, for your input :)


message 33: by Arah-Lynda (new)

Arah-Lynda Well done Alejandro.


message 34: by Lono (new) - added it

Lono Looks like I will have to give these books a shot.


message 35: by [deleted user] (new)

I missed this magical series. Hope I have enough time to read it some day. How lucky are the kids who got to read this while still young readers. Great review as always, Alejandro.


message 36: by Florencia (new)

Florencia Wow, speechless. The entire saga described by one fantastic review. Amazing job, Alejandro!


Alejandro Arah-Lynda wrote: "Well done Alejandro."

Thank you, Arah-Lynda! :)


Alejandro Lono wrote: "Looks like I will have to give these books a shot."

Whenever you feel that you are ready for them, Lono ;)

That's the good thing about books, they will wait for you all the time you need to get to them :D


message 39: by Alejandro (last edited Aug 27, 2014 02:13PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Alejandro sckenda wrote: "I missed this magical series. Hope I have enough time to read it some day. How lucky are the kids who got to read this while still young readers. Great review as always, Alejandro."

Well, you never are too old to enjoy a series like this, in fact, some of the books are so dark in some scenes that definitely I wouldn't recommend them to real young kids, at least not all at once, but maybe reading them in the same way as Harry is getting older in the books.

Besides, like C.S. Lewis said: "A children's book that it's not interesting enough for an adult, it's a bad children's book." Or something like that.

I haven't read many books which are "targeted" for kids but that it won't stop me to read them as soon as I'd able.

Books shouldn't be for a certain sex genre or age, they should be enjoy by whoever want to read them in any time of their lives.

You never "miss" it anything in life, you definitely you have all the right of choosing not to read it and that it will be totally fine ;) Life goes on. :)

And don't worry, my friend ;) I understood what you meant ;) I just wanted to comment about the subject in a general way. :D


Alejandro Florencia wrote: "Wow, speechless. The entire saga described by one fantastic review. Amazing job, Alejandro!"

Thank you so much, Florencia! :) I am truly thankful for your kind appraisals.


message 41: by Riley (new)

Riley Vermilya WOW...AMAZING review/tribute to the woman who inspired children AND the world to read again. LOVE this, LOVE J.K. Rowling, AND of course LOVE Harry Potter.


back to top