annie 🇵🇸's Reviews > Once Upon a Broken Heart

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
89964678
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: best-reads, enemies-to-lovers, fantasy-books, it-was-hot

4 stars

This is one of the most interesting worlds I've encountered in fantasy books. Everything was so dreamy, and I might've enjoyed reading about cards if I'd read Caraval. The first book is interesting enough to finish this series quickly. I wanna read it slowly & enjoy it while wanting to finish it quickly because it's so GOOD.

❝For anyone who has ever made a bad decision because of a broken heart.❞


This dedication is enough to make you want to read this book! I LOVE IT AND NEXT BIO IS GONNA BE THIS ONE! 🙌🏻😭


• Evangeline went to the Prince of Heart's church thinking that her prayer might be answered by Fate – prince of Hearts – and the wedding of her lover would be stopped. Desperate and heartbroken enough, she made a deal with fate to stop her lover's wedding in exchange for three kisses with people he choose.

The Prince of Hearts has such a certain vibe! His kiss is deadly, his heart doesn't beat, and the most important – he's heartbroken and is cursed to never find love, which gives Eva hopes that he might help her. Their first interaction was so funny, and I was getting second-hand embarrassments from her behalf! I didn't expect Jacks to be such a meanie! 😭

❝People who don’t like me call me Jacks.❞


Jacks – he's the cursed prince of hearts who's a manipulator, a toxic person who'll do anything to gain what he wants, and cocky. BUT WHY DOES HE HAVE TO BE SO HOT AND PERFECT? It'll always be the villain and never the hero besides.... the hero never gets a happy ending! 🤭 The hype for him is real, and I see myself falling in love with him, just like I did with Aaron Warner 😮‍💨

I'm literally a simp for him atp! Him doing mundane things like tossing the apple, slicing the apple, BITING THE APPLE had me swooning! ANDDDD HE HADDDD NOOO RIGHT TO BE SOOOO HOT IN THIS SCENEEE!!!!! 👇🏻

❝What am I supposed to do with this [dagger]?❞
❝You might want to use it, Little Fox.❞ The corner of his mouth twitched as he slowly slid his pale hands through the bars of the gate and broke the lock in half. It could have been a twig, a piece of paper, or her.



Evangeline Fox — she's just a naive girl with a hopeless romantic personality, and well, she's quite delusional but would call herself hopeful! She has been surrounded by so many fairy tales that she just wants her life to be like it. She's smack-dabbed in the face with the realities, but she'd rather create alternatives to not tarnish the image of people she cares about. I actually liked her selflessness and her acceptance of her BAD DECISION. But there's nothing much interesting to her character besides this. Not a huntress or amazing at fighting too lmao. So far, she's a hopeless romantic who's kind of attracted to Jacks because he's a baddie but doesn't want to die either by kissing him.

Enemies to lovers — their dynamic is so good? Evangeline has hot and cold feelings for him. She's torn between wanting to kiss him or hate him. Jacks being absolutely mean with her one moment and saying things HE SHOULDN'T the next moment were too much to handle and him calling her LITTLE FOX 💞🤭

❝Do you want to be a vampire?❞
❝No,❞ Jacks spat. ❝I don’t want to be a vampire, but I do want to bite you.❞

SIR????? 😮‍💨🧎‍♀️🥵😭

❝You might not like me, but I bet you’d like it if I kissed you.❞





Jacks... wdym IT WAS ENTERTAINING TO SEE HER KISS APOLLO AND THAT OLD LADY FORTUNA ??? 😭 That was really unnecessary, but he just wanted to toy with Eva by making her kiss them! He outright accepted that he manipulated her. He's actually evil in this book regardless of his past, and he threatened her subtly that she'd die if she didn't agree with her part of the bargain. I'm all but patient for his character development and just to see his softie side, after all, a glimpse of it when he carried her through the cold just to take her to get a cure for the poison she got and let her sleep in his arms the whole night , was just 😭💞

❝You could have unlocked me as well❞ — I was wondering if Jacks had indulged her and struck a deal with her in the first place because she opened the church's door. It's known she can open Valory Arch, but maybe that was the time when Jacks realized that she's the rose-gold haired girl who's the one who can open the arch. and he didn't know her before.

Apollo being in love was so funny! I only liked that scene where they were talking and he was being nice, but otherwise, he was really quick to dismiss Eva in the first place, and Marisol is just a bitch! I just knew something was sus about her since the start because no one is too kind, and she's after all her mother's child, and yep she definitely stole Luc. I knew Jacks is evil! I do love him, but he's so manipulative, and the ending actually shocked me! I still hate Marisol because she's a bitch, but damn the way Jacks went through so much just to frame her and wrongly accused Eva just to get the prophecy right 😮‍💨🤚🏻 and yeahhh 4 stars just because, it had wayy too much info dumps! I actually enjoyed most of the book but there were sometimes long ass paragraphs just about NORTH. and Ummmm CHAOS SHOULD GET HIS OWN BOOK PLS + with Lala would be great!


The Ballad Of Never After – 3.75 stars
A Curse For True Love – 3 stars
648 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Once Upon a Broken Heart.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 30, 2022 – Shelved
December 30, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
January 13, 2024 – Started Reading
January 13, 2024 –
page 16
3.92% ""Now, that was a pathetic speech.” Two slow claps followed the indolent voice.

CRYING 😭😭😭"
January 13, 2024 –
page 100
24.51% "Jacks is actually evil 😭"
January 13, 2024 –
page 125
30.64% "Marisol is sus and Apollo's love for Eva is so funny ✋🏻"
January 14, 2024 –
page 258
63.24% ""After I got mauled by the wolf, my scars weren’t sexy scars—”
“He just said sexy scars,” Jacks drawled. “Are you really listening to this?”


Hahahahjaa 😭😭"
January 14, 2024 –
81.0% ""You might not like me, but I bet you’d like it if I kissed you.”

"
January 14, 2024 –
85.0% "“What am I supposed to do with this?”
“You might want to use it, Little Fox.” The corner of his mouth twitched as he slowly slid his pale hands through the bars of the gate and broke the lock in half. It could have been a twig, a piece of paper, or her.


THIS WAS SO HOTTTTTT!!!!!!!! 😮‍💨😭😮‍💨"
January 14, 2024 – Shelved as: best-reads
January 14, 2024 – Shelved as: it-was-hot
January 14, 2024 – Shelved as: fantasy-books
January 14, 2024 – Shelved as: enemies-to-lovers
January 14, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 191 (191 new)


vania ౨ৎ I’m pretty sure you don’t have to read Caraval to read this especially when the characters are different and new ;)


tasnia 🍉 I wish the book was as good as the fanarts 🫣🫣 but you don’t have to read Caraval first if u don’t want to


♥︎ Heather ⚔ You don't have to but the emotional impact hits different when you do. You get much more context on Jacks's character from Caraval series. <3


message 4: by ava !! (new) - added it

ava !! these are my exact thoughts 😭
I wanna read ouabh so bad and most people say you don’t have to read the caraval triology, but it gives more insight for ouabh… ugh but still 😫


jennie ౨ৎ OMG NUMY UR READING IT FINALLY


jennie ౨ৎ I TOLD U THIS IS THE BEST AND I HOPE U LOVE IT GIMME UPDATES


jennie ౨ৎ i didn't read caraval before this but it has the mention of tella and scarlett like just brief


jennie ౨ৎ all u need to know is jacks was one of tella's love interest and she chose some other guy over him


message 9: by selin (new) - added it

selin ahh bb caraval is actually pretty good read too! but i don’t think you need to (even though i haven’t read ouabh) there wasn’t so much of a bg of jacks if i’m not mistaken 🫶🏻


Ziesha Fernandez I'm reading it too and am in love with it!


dee (hiatus) no, you don't really have to. you can jump on the evajacks train straight. you won't be missing out much


message 12: by emilie (new) - added it

emilie you should read caraval before reading ouabh


message 13: by emilie (new) - added it

emilie idk why people are reading it before


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Vania — oooh but I guess the world is same and Jacks have appearances in caraval too!


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Tasnia — so it's not? 😭 well ok that's fine because I don't wanna read caraval!


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Heather — yeah that's what I was thinking actually! 😭😭


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Ava — I KNOWWW RIGHTTTT! LIKE PLS I DON'T WANNA MISS OUT ANYTHING 😭 I want the best experience and all but damn 6 books ???


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Jennie — ahshhaha omg don't get too excited! I'm just thinking about reading this rn 😭😭 OOOH WELL JACKS HAVE MENTION IN CARAVAL SERIES TOO


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Jennie — jacks is hot wtf


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Selin — I don't have anything against caraval lol, I mean I have to read 3 books from that world so it'll take me a long time to reach ouabh so I was wondering If I could skip that series altogether!


autumn ʕ•ᴥ•ʔ you don't need to!! i've read it before caraval as well and you won't have any problems with understanding. i then wanted to read caraval tho and i loved it sm which was such a surprise hahaha


suman!! I did not read caraval before starting this and it was completely fine so I'll say go for it <3!


 。⁠.゚✯Naya ✯。⁠.゚ You don't, jacks is with whole another girl in it and this is the after and it's what I'm gonna do once ik they're endgame


kendyl ʚ♡⃛ɞ (mini vacay) omg my fomo is so bad


Morsalও (semi-hiatus) I recommend you to read Caraval first because it's so much better to understand everything especially Jacks story.


Sabrina Imo you don’t have to! I didn’t and read the ouabh series just fine. I hope you love it!! 🫶🏼


solyaa&#x1f342; I’m reading Caraval right at this moment and it’s sooooo good i think you should read it because i just love it and i’m on page 358 right now i think i will finish it today 🫶🫶


Jenna ꕤ*.゚ Kinda adding to what most people said, these books can be read alone but if you want that extra experience defo read caraval since jacks plays quite a big part, also hopefully you will enjoy that triology as I went in wanting to read OUABH but ended up preferring caraval!! Enjoy either way lovely 💞


message 29: by Sarah (new) - added it

Sarah Just do it. Ima read the caraval series while I wat for acftl


lexie 100% recommend reading the caraval trilogy beforehand because his entire plot point and development is *THAT* much better, and there’s a huge spoiler in ouabh that’s his basic motive


message 31: by (new) - rated it 4 stars

₊ the author says that u don't have to read caraval first. so if u don't want to, then u don't have to. besides u can always pick up the caraval series after ouabh


ellie જ⁀➴ (semi ia) u dont have to read caraval first!! and from what i heard, ouabh trilogy is way better! soo! i cant wait to see when u read this and hear ur thoughts <33


message 33: by Hoda (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hoda You don’t have to read caravel first. But i think u will enjoy them though because Julian is just so 😮‍💨💘


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Ziesha — caraval or this one??


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Dee — thankgod! I'll do that fr soon! 💖


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Emilie — 😭😭😭😭😭 nooo lol Idk why but caraval seems long and some of my friends said that it's boring!


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; Autumn — ooooh that is great! Like, maybe I would want to read Caraval if I like this series lol! I'm waiting for the 3rd book though!


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Suman — ooo thankss for that! I didn't want to read Caraval, that's why 😭


siff ♡ babes read this book ! and you better love it 😭


message 40: by Ri ♡ (new) - added it

Ri ♡ You dont need to but i think it gives you better understanding of their world and it was enjoyable


mitra. JUST START IT BB PLS PLS 😭


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Nada — well I truly think they're gonna be endgame like obv but let's see! Also, I know that about Eva, but I was curious about the world!


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Kendyl — pls NAH I'M MISSING OUT THIS WHOLE SERIES AND THAT DIVINE RIVALS ONE


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Morsal — you too 🥲🥲🥲 ughhshshs I am conflicted here now! I guess I have to read it, Zainab said that Caraval was so slow in the start 🥹


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Sabrina — oooh! Well that's great though! Now everything is 50-50 🤡 I'm confused Af


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Solyaa — Ooohhh happy reading! Hope you'll like it though! 💕 I'll try to see what I'll do!


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Jenna — Some people said that Jacks didn't has a big character and all and yk that's what I'm confused about... the world building! It's true that there are chances that I might prefer Caraval over this one but who knows ahhaha


annie &#x1f1f5;&#x1f1f8; @Sarah — acftl is just coming so so soon!


message 49: by elin ୨୧ (new) - added it

elin ୨୧ GIRL YOU BETTER READ CARAVAL FIRST


The Gist I loved the caraval series!


« previous 1 3 4
back to top