Linda's Reviews > Prophet Song

Prophet Song by Paul    Lynch
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
35179119
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: booker, fiction, irish

Winner Booker Prize 2023

" History is a silent record of people who didn't know when to leave."

Prophet Song kept me up reading late into the night. It is an emotionally draining novel with Orwellian themes and scenes that propel the reader forward with the intensity of a Hitchcock film.

In a dystopian future, Ireland's far-right National Alliance Party (NAP) comes to power. To maintain order, they create a secret police with supplemental powers that strip citizens of their fundamental rights. The story centers on the impact of the new order on a middle-class Dublin family, the Stacks; Eilish, a microbiologist; Larry, an official in the Teacher's Union of Ireland, their four children; and Eilish's aging father, who is struggling with dementia.

The nightmare begins when secret police attack a peaceful teacher's rally for higher wages. Larry and other union officials are arrested and disappear. Legal due process starts to erode, and the NAP replaces people in jobs nationwide with party hacks, causing Eilish to lose her job. Lynch chronicles Eilish's struggles to keep her children and aging father safe as the nation descends into a violent civil war, and they become refugees.

At first, I found Lynch's writing style difficult to follow. There are no paragraphs, and he doesn't use conventional indicators for dialogue. Scenes proceed without interruption until a gap appears, indicating a new section's start. However, once I grew accustomed to his style, I found his writing had almost a cinematic flow that drew me deeper and deeper into the nightmare.

Prophet Song is a powerful novel as it crystalizes the trauma that so many people worldwide are experiencing. In an interview, Lynch stated that two competing sentiments motivated him to write this novel. First, he is troubled by the lack of empathy for refugees, which he feels is prevalent in the West. Lynch also wanted to explore how much agency individuals possess in times of societal collapse. He succeeds on both fronts. Prophet Song is a mesmerizing, provocative read. I highly recommend it.
125 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Prophet Song.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 28, 2023 – Shelved
August 28, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
September 6, 2023 – Started Reading
September 14, 2023 – Finished Reading
September 15, 2023 – Shelved as: booker
September 15, 2023 – Shelved as: fiction
September 15, 2023 – Shelved as: irish

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dmitri (new)

Dmitri Thanks Linda for your review and reference to the Booker long list. Many of the earlier Booker novels I’ve read were excellent.


Linda Dmitri wrote: "Thanks Linda for your review and reference to the Booker long list. Many of the earlier Booker novels I’ve read were excellent."

Thanks, Dmitri. This book stood out for me. I think you would like it.


message 3: by Nika (new)

Nika Sounds like this book tackles some important and sensitive topics. Thank you for putting it on my radar. Five stars from you speak for themselves.
Terrific review, Linda.


message 4: by Vesna (new)

Vesna Great review, Linda. I am not into dystopian novels but this one sound very compelling.


Linda Nika wrote: "Sounds like this book tackles some important and sensitive topics. Thank you for putting it on my radar. Five stars from you speak for themselves.
Terrific review, Linda."

Thanks, Nika. I feel that the book is very timely and addresses some important issues very well.


Linda Vesna wrote: "Great review, Linda. I am not into dystopian novels but this one sound very compelling."

Thanks Vesna. It really is compelling. i hope it makes the Booker shortlist.


John Banks Great review Linda, I'm reading this at the moment (about 2/3 done) and it is a truly powerful and unsettling work. Thoughtfully structured and written but so timely. One of those rare combinations of literary quality with socio-political relevance. At the moment at the very top of my Booker list for the year.


Linda John wrote: "Great review Linda, I'm reading this at the moment (about 2/3 done) and it is a truly powerful and unsettling work. Thoughtfully structured and written but so timely. One of those rare combinations..."

I agree. I have been telling everyone I know to read it.


message 9: by Mark (new) - added it

Mark Porton Great review Linda, I always have trouble with the lack of paragraphs (or chapters) and also no indications of dialogue. Having said that, this does sound good!


Linda Mark wrote: "Great review Linda, I always have trouble with the lack of paragraphs (or chapters) and also no indications of dialogue. Having said that, this does sound good!"

Thanks, Mark


Neale Wonderful review Linda. I was the same with the writing style and found it quite jarring at first, especially with dialogue, but you get used to it quite quickly. I must admit that I am still a bit "old school" when it comes to punctuation though. :-)


message 12: by Linda (last edited Sep 16, 2023 08:55PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Linda Thanks, Neale. I am rooting for this for the shortlist.


message 13: by Barbara (new)

Barbara I think I would have some issues with the lack of punctuation or dialogue indicators for dialogue. I love the subject he's tackling. I agree, the USA has no empathy for immigrants.


Linda Thanks for your comments.


message 15: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Linda wrote: "Thanks for your comments."

Of course! Great review!


Daniel Shindler I have this one on my shelf.Your review increases my anticipation.


Linda I think you will really like it. I am hoping it makes the shortlist so it will get the readership it deserves.


message 18: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Well done on betting this book would make the shortlist, Linda!
I picked it up from a pile of the long-listed books recently, thinking I'd read at least one before the short list came out, but I left it down again in favour of another Irish one, How to Build a Boat. But I bet on the wrong one—couldn't get past the first few pages:-(


Linda Once you get used to his writing style, it really flows.


message 20: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa So happy your review came up. I thought I had this on my to be read list, and I did not. I'll come back and read your review after I get to it. Your five stars, in the meantime, speak volumes.


Linda Lisa, I strongly recommend this for you. I look forward to your thoughts.


Alan (Stratford Festival hiatus) Teder You called it on this one Linda! Prophet Song wins the 2023 Booker Prize!


Linda Alan wrote: "You called it on this one Linda! Prophet Song wins the 2023 Booker Prize!"

I am excited it won!


message 24: by Xavier (new) - added it

Xavier Patiño Excellent review!

Having never read anything from Lynch, would this be a good place to begin? There was a New York Times article I read that piqued my interest for this work.


Linda Xavier wrote: "Excellent review!

Having never read anything from Lynch, would this be a good place to begin? There was a New York Times article I read that piqued my interest for this work."


Xavier, Thanks. it is the only book by Lynch that I have read. I really liked it. I am thinking of reading Grace which also won an award.


message 26: by Gaurav (new)

Gaurav Great review, Linda. I reccently read By the Sea and thoroughly enjoyed it, would be looking to read this one sometime later :)


Linda Thanks Gaurav. I look forward to you thoughts.


message 28: by Chris (new)

Chris Wonderful review.


Linda Chris wrote: "Wonderful review."

Thanks, Chris.


back to top