Ken's Reviews > Breath: The New Science of a Lost Art

Breath by James Nestor
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
730754
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: finished-in-2021, health, nonfiction

If you've got serious health issues, breathing exercises may help in a small way, but they're not about to cure you. But what if you have nagging health issues, the kind allopathic medicine can't really cure and really doesn't have time to dig into? In that case, breathing exercises might offer surprising relief.

Credit India, China, and Nepal of long ago. Hindus and Buddhists, chiefly. You know. The guys who practically stop their lungs from breathing or their hearts from beating or their skin from freezing even though they're "OM-ing" in the great outdoors, mid-winter.

But what about your lay-breather? You, me, the mail carrier? In that case, maybe slowing, speeding, holding (to the point of discomfort), or expanding your lung capacity might bring results. All it takes is... practice.

James Nestor has done a lot of practicing. For this book, he offered himself up for most every modern-day doctor, guru, and holy man alive -- all folks building on ancient knowledge and, in many cases, finding modern clues as to why the breathing techniques work. This, then, is the story of his journey.

Could it be your journey? And which breathing technique suits your problem best? I wasn't always clear on that, and descriptions of breathing techniques are no replacement for videos (better) and actual coaching with an expert (best).

Safe to say, though, that we all generally suck (see what I did there?) at the autonomic process of breathing. We should shut our mouths for starters. Always. Even exercising. And, if we don't have sleep apnea but do snore (check with your loved one or your dog), you might keep your unconscious self honest by trying "sleep tape" (it's on Amazon) over your mouth each night.

You see, the evolution of our heads has worked for us and against us. On the plus side, our skulls have made more room for our brains, even though you wouldn't know it reading exploits of your fellow men in the newspaper (many in positions of power). It's also evolved to make more room for the tongue and talking eloquently.

Big tongues don't help your breathing though. Nor does the continually shrinking mouth space overall. We overbreathe like we overeat. Sucking wind on the rapid, shallow breaths we've gotten used to. Often, unbeknownst to ourselves, sporadically holding our breaths.

Ideally, you see, your inhales should be 5.5 seconds followed by exhales of 5.5 seconds (5 or 6 are both acceptable). Try it, though, and you may find yourself breathless in quick order, like you need to "catch up" on your oxygen (pant, pant, shirt, shirt).

Speaking of big-letter O, did you know that CO2 is equally important to your well-being? (So if you feel like a plant sometimes, there's a scientific reason.) Sucking oxygen on the sidelines isn't really doing much for athletes, but hey, if THEY think so, let 'em mask up and gulp their wonder drug....

Ultimately, if you're too busy to think about your breathing, don't bother reading this. But if you're not too busy to think about it for, say, 10-20 minutes a day (practice!), give it a gander.

Or, as a shortcut because you care not about the details, you can take a tour of some of the breathing videos and excellent Q&A video interviews with pulmonary experts on Nestor's website by simply going to

https://www.mrjamesnestor.com/breath

Who nose? It might do you some good.
43 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Breath.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 21, 2021 – Started Reading
November 21, 2021 – Shelved
November 22, 2021 –
page 165
58.93% "Buddhists are the headliners here, but a whole list of breathing techniques. For starters, don't breath through your mouth. Ever."
November 23, 2021 – Shelved as: finished-in-2021
November 23, 2021 – Shelved as: health
November 23, 2021 – Shelved as: nonfiction
November 23, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura Rogers I was going to review Nestor's book but, "Damn!", what could I possibly add? Great review, good book. Thanks as always.


message 2: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Often holding our breaths unbeknownst to ourselves.

Characters in books are always doing that!
Joking aside, Ken, good reminder here to shut my mouth;-)


message 3: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Laura wrote: "I was going to review Nestor's book but, "Damn!", what could I possibly add? Great review, good book. Thanks as always."

Thanks, Laura. Glad you liked the book too!


message 4: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Fionnuala wrote: "Often holding our breaths unbeknownst to ourselves.

Characters in books are always doing that!
Joking aside, Ken, good reminder here to shut my mouth;-)"


As a kid, my mother frequently reminded me. Later it was my brother. Later still, my wife took up the task. So many helpful people!


message 5: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Thanks, Ken. I think I need to practice some sound breathing exercises. I clicked on the Nestor link and it said 'private site.' Aaaargh.


message 6: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Laysee wrote: "Thanks, Ken. I think I need to practice some sound breathing exercises. I clicked on the Nestor link and it said 'private site.' Aaaargh."

Hmn. That's mysterious. I clicked it and was there. Maybe if you SEARCH his name and the word Breath it will get you there by another rabbit hole. The Internet is a mysterious place!


message 7: by Alarie (new)

Alarie As always, a great review. Thanks for sharing the video link. My husband does slow breathing exercising each evening that have lowered his blood pressure and greatly reduced both the pressure and the medications he used to require. I did them when taking a stress-reduction workshop years ago with good results, but am not good at sticking with a program.


message 8: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Alarie wrote: "As always, a great review. Thanks for sharing the video link. My husband does slow breathing exercising each evening that have lowered his blood pressure and greatly reduced both the pressure and t..."

I used to always get the whitecoat high blood pressure at the doctor's office. Now I do breathing exercises as I wait and while it's being taken. High BP is gone.

And we're all horrible at sticking with a program, unless it's a program of eating comfort food.


message 9: by Alarie (new)

Alarie Ken wrote: "Alarie wrote: "As always, a great review. Thanks for sharing the video link. My husband does slow breathing exercising each evening that have lowered his blood pressure and greatly reduced both the..."

My conscience thinks I'm the only lazy lout and constantly prods me, but it's just background noise.


message 10: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken When my conscience barks, I put on the white noise machine to respect its privacy.


message 11: by Jay (new)

Jay Great review, Ken! Is it worth investigating if you have low blood pressure and hear rate?


message 12: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Hi, Jay. Yes. Breathing exercises, if habitual, take down stress and with it, HBP.


Adina (way behind) I bought this Today to my aunt. Good to read a positive review.


message 14: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Let me know how she likes it!


back to top