Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > A Promised Land

A Promised Land by Barack Obama
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3427339
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: nonfiction, presidents-staff, politics, african-american

”’Whatever you do won’t be enough,’ I heard their voices say.
‘Try anyway.’”


Obama had just been drubbed in an election against a popular candidate when he made the absolutely crazy decision to run for the US Senate. Michelle thought he was out of his mind. He was talking about “magic beans” and shit, but he assured her that this was it. If he lost, he was done with politics. Their credit cards were maxed out, and their overall financial picture was dire...let’s just say, the Star Trek klaxon bells were sounding, and Scotty was screaming at Kirk that he couldn’t hold it together much longer.

Would he really have done with politics if he’d lost? Hell no. I don’t believe it, and as reassuring as the words probably sounded to Michelle, I seriously doubt she believed it either. He had a fire in his belly, and that candle was burning hot. He had a dream, and he wasn’t going to hide it under a bushel. Unh uh!

So in March of 2004, he won the senate election, and in July he was tapped by John Kerry to give the keynote address at the Democratic National Convention. I can remember looking over at my wife and going...who is this guy? I’m a pretty savvy political person. I can remember watching LBJ’s funeral when I was six. I was nine and can remember feeling sorry for President Gerald Ford, even though I had supported President Jimmy Carter in the 1976 Presidential election. Let’s just say that I tuned into United States politics...early on. So I was thinking...this guy...for the keynote?

A guy named Barack Hussein Obama?

I love this conversation he had in the White House with his team, but it sort of sums up the dream-like quality of his rise to the presidency. Spoiler alert...he wins the presidency in 2008.

”’I guess the question for you, Mr. President, is, Do you feel lucky?’*

I looked at him and smiled. ‘Where are we, Phil?’

Phil hesitated, wondering if it was a trick question. ‘The Oval Office?’

‘And what’s my name?’

‘Barack Obama.’

I smiled. ‘Barack Hussein Obama. And I’m here with you in the Oval office. Brother, I always feel lucky.’”


*Phil Schiliro may have watched too many Dirty Harry movies.

I admit, when the Kansas caucus came around, I was sitting in a small room of people supporting Hillary Clinton. I thought Obama was running a cycle early. It was time to elect our first female president, and who knew how long it would be before another woman with the name recognition of Clinton would emerge from the process? I was flabbergasted at the number of people, mostly younger people! who caucused in the gym for Barack Obama. I kept thinking to myself, If these people would actually vote, we could turn Ford County blue. To give you an idea of how red the county is that I live in, 41% of Kansans voted for Joseph R. Biden, but Ford County came in at 33%. In Phillips County, where I grew up, only 11% voted for Biden. Needless to say, my extended family are not only Republicans but are unabashed Trumpsters. I am the black sheep of the family, or should I say the blue sheep of the family.

Obama ran a terrific, revolutionary, grass roots campaign and, against all odds, won the primary and electrified a nation in the process.

So this book primarily covers the election campaign and his first term in office. The second book will cover his second presidential campaign and term in office. Normally, I wouldn’t read this book this soon. I ordinarily like history to get smaller in my rearview mirror before I read any books about it, but after a bruising four years of Trump and an election campaign that slenderized my Facebook friends, mostly family, list, I decided that I needed some time with a voice of reason. I needed to experience our future by reading about the past because I do feel that Obama was the future, even when he was our president of the present.

I like the way he was self-deprecating about his mistakes. Even Obama made some gaffes while speaking...remember “cling to guns or religion?” Stating the stark truth isn’t always the best strategy. I love this little scene with David Axelrod while prepping for a debate.

”’Your problem,’ he said, ‘is you keep trying to answer the question.’

‘Isn’t that the point?’ I said.

‘No, Barack,’ Axe said, ‘that is not the point. The point is to get your message across. What are your values? What are your priorities? That’s what people care about. Look, half the time the moderator is just using the question to try to tip you up. Your job is to avoid the trap they’ve set. Take whatever question they give you, give ‘em a quick line to make it seem like you answered it...and then talk about what you want to talk about.’

‘That’s bullshit,’ I said.

‘Exactly,’ he said.”


Okay, we were all distracted by the fly that flew into Vice-President Mike Pence’s hair and died from toxic embalming fluid during the debate with Vice-President Kamala Harris...I can say that now! Yeah!...but I have never seen a politician during a debate completely ignore any of the questions he was asked like he did. It was hilarious.

If you have been pining for the days when Obama was your president, you will absolutely love reliving those sometimes rocky roads as Obama tried to change our world for the better, despite the best efforts of the Republicans to block anything he tried to do. The Republicans made it very clear from the beginning that they were going to put the party first over the country. The Obama years, despite the obstructions, were certainly halcyon days compared to the last four years. The behind-the-scenes stuff that he shares made me respect and like him even more. He is genuine and cares about the same things that all of us care about, our family, our friends, our dogs, and our need for a sustainable future. He has some of the same fallacies and self-doubts that the rest of us have, but he was determined to become someone who could make a difference.

And he did.

Let’s hope President Joseph Biden and Vice-President Kamala Harris, after getting the White House fumigated and clearing away all the McDonald’s hamburger wrappers, can start driving the car in the right direction.

I’m ridin’ with Biden.

President Obama also answered my question on GR. Check it out at this link: https://www.goodreads.com/questions/1...

If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit http://www.jeffreykeeten.com I also have a Facebook blogger page at:https://www.facebook.com/JeffreyKeeten and an Instagram account https://www.instagram.com/jeffreykeeten/
288 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Promised Land.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 17, 2020 – Shelved
November 17, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
November 17, 2020 – Shelved as: nonfiction
November 17, 2020 – Shelved as: presidents-staff
November 17, 2020 – Shelved as: politics
November 27, 2020 – Started Reading
November 27, 2020 – Shelved as: african-american
December 11, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Hadil (new) - added it

Hadil AL-Sawaiee Great review. I am on my way to read this book.


Jeffrey Keeten Hadil wrote: "Great review. I am on my way to read this book."

Awesome! Thanks Hadil! Enjoy!


message 3: by Bharathi (new) - added it

Bharathi Rastoropnova Thorough and detailed review, thank you. Definitely a must read for me in 2021


Jeffrey Keeten Bharathi, you are welcome. I could have written much more. Obama is a large subject but I didn’t want to exceed the patience of the few readers who will actually read this review.


David Buccola Funny answer Obama gives to your question considering he orchestrated a federal crackdown on the very people he claims to support that were behind Occupy Wall Street. In fact he never even mentions the movement nor the brutal violence that was used to repress it under darkness and no-fly zones. I guess that makes for a better story when it’s happening in Egypt.


Jeffrey Keeten David wrote: "Funny answer Obama gives to your question considering he orchestrated a federal crackdown on the very people he claims to support that were behind Occupy Wall Street. In fact he never even mentions..."

I understand your frustration. I get so tired of my republican acquaintances pointing to a robust stock market to indicate how well the economy is doing, but to use an old phrase Wall Street has nothing to do with Main Street. The belief that people have in capitalism is that there is a free market economy, but anyone who has ever tried to go out there and compete against the corporate structure soon learns there is no free market economy. I'm afraid that capitalism is going to have to break on the wheel of greed. Maybe after THEY have taken everything from the 99% of us then maybe they will fully turn on each other because there is no satiating their greed. There is never enough. Corporations don't seem to understand that if we don't have good jobs and aren't presented with at least the hope of opportunity we won't be able to buy the very shit they are selling. Captialism will destroy itself. We are on the verge of returning to a feudal system of a few lords and a gazillion peasants.

I wish I could speak with more knowledge of the Occupy Wall Street movement. I read a few things about it, but I never could grasp exactly what leverage they could use to achieve their aims. Obama certainly could have done more and offered more support. Is there a good book or an encompassing article that I should read David?


message 7: by Chris (new) - added it

Chris Terrific review!! And I have been following him on GR and have been very impressed with the time he takes to answer people's questions. A class act to be sure.


message 8: by Anne (new)

Anne Fantastic review, Jeffrey, as usual. I plan to listen to this soonish.


Dirk Great review, Jeffrey. I like the way you have weaved in your own experiences with political events!

I am not even halfway into the audiobook, but Obama has already won me over with his honesty and passion. Indeed electrifying.

I love the way he describes his most loyal staff members with deep appreciation and saying “they did not do it for the money or the power.” You can sense that Obama was cut from the same cloth. I share his disgust and utter shock that his successor in the White House is the total opposite of this attitude and has wrecked the country and undermined democratic values. Indeed, Joe Biden was and is a decent man, the type of person worthy of the honor of being president.

By the way, have you read / listened to Dan Rather’s recent “Stories of a lifetime”? He describes the same shock, from the perspective of a seasoned journalist who loves facts, values and character.


Jeffrey Keeten Chris wrote: "Terrific review!! And I have been following him on GR and have been very impressed with the time he takes to answer people's questions. A class act to be sure."

Indeed he is! Maybe class can now return to the WH. Thanks Chris!


Jeffrey Keeten Anne wrote: "Fantastic review, Jeffrey, as usual. I plan to listen to this soonish."

Thanks Anne! I get too impatient to listen to books. My mother read too slow and for not long enough periods of time to my satisfaction so I learned to read. I was highly motivated! haha! When I used to travel a lot I would have probably listened to more books, but I have such a relationship with reading words that I retain what I read much better than what I hear.


Jeffrey Keeten Dirk wrote: "Great review, Jeffrey. I like the way you have weaved in your own experiences with political events!

I am not even halfway into the audiobook, but Obama has already won me over with his honesty an..."


I have not read Dan Rather's book, but I've heard good things about it. As I was explaining to Anne above I retain much more from reading than listening and given the fact that I review the books I read I really want and need that relationship with books. Reading the words and having it echo in my mind leads to better retention for me. It seems to me these days that more people listen to books than read books. I'm not sure what that means long term but it could change the way that writers have to write books.

Obama did have a great relationship with the people he worked with. Unlike the revolving door of people in the T____ WH. Real leadership is making people want to work for you and certainly we've seen the results the past four years of what poor leadership looks like.


message 13: by Vandana (new)

Vandana Sinha That is a great review Jeffrey. With Obama, it is understood that his book will be immensely readable since he speaks so well, he is bound to write well. And your review confirms that.


message 14: by Anne (new)

Anne I hear you, Jeffrey. No pun intended. My father would fall asleep while reading to me (and my twin). Can't resist Obama narrating his own book.


Jeffrey Keeten Vandana wrote: "That is a great review Jeffrey. With Obama, it is understood that his book will be immensely readable since he speaks so well, he is bound to write well. And your review confirms that."

He is a good writer and who he is comes through in his writing. I hope you enjoy the book as much as I did Vandana!


message 16: by Jeffrey (last edited Dec 25, 2020 08:49AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jeffrey Keeten Anne wrote: "I hear you, Jeffrey. No pun intended. My father would fall asleep while reading to me (and my twin). Can't resist Obama narrating his own book."

Aye, that is certainly a bonus hearing The Obama's voice reading his own words.


message 17: by Anne (new)

Anne Jeffrey wrote: "Anne wrote: "I hear you, Jeffrey. No pun intended. My father would fall asleep while reading to me (and my twin). Can't resist Obama narrating his own book."

Aye, that is certainly a bonus hearing..."


Aye. :))


Jeffrey Keeten Elyse wrote: "As they say---- "The mark of a great man is one who knows when to set aside the important things in order to accomplish the vital ones".......... (ha....like Trump golfing today)....
Ho Ho Ho!
***..."


Thanks Elyse! Have a Happy Holiday season! Obama had a lot of vital things on his list and he didn't have time to work on them one at a time. His eight years went by way too fast. May we all have a wonderful 2021 and may 2020 dim in our memories. May we please have two years at least of respite from the 2024 election cycle. May we find some civility in our discourse.


message 19: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Fantastic review, Jeffrey! 'Happy holidays' ;)


Jeffrey Keeten Thanks Diane! The same to you!


message 21: by Zade (new) - added it

Zade Thank you for this review. I've been resisting reading this book, even though I know I'll probably enjoy it. Political burnout, I think.

Although I live in the unicorn county (68% Biden), I too am the odd man out of a heavily red family. That, combined with the unrelenting toxicity of the recent election campaign has turned me into a keen devourer of all things fictional. When zombie novels seem preferable to well-written nonfiction, you know things are bad!

I think you've convinced me to end my exile in fictionland. Obama's book may be just the thing I need to ease back into a more varied diet. Thanks for the great Christmas present!


message 22: by BETTY (new)

BETTY Wow


Jeffrey Keeten Zade wrote: "Thank you for this review. I've been resisting reading this book, even though I know I'll probably enjoy it. Political burnout, I think.

Although I live in the unicorn county (68% Biden), I too a..."


I understand the zombie escapism. I find reading apocalyptic novels of all times strangely comforting. I think it has to do with comparing the lives of the characters to my own life reminds me that my life despite the worries and concerns is still great in comparison. You are most welcome Zade. It was nice to remember a time not that long ago when someone with class occupied the WH.


Jeffrey Keeten BETTY wrote: "Wow"

Thanks Betty!


message 25: by ElementalDragon (new)

ElementalDragon Excellent.


Jeffrey Keeten Thank you Wenxin Liu!


message 27: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey To give you an idea of how red the county is that I live in, 41% of Kansans voted for Joseph R. Biden, but Ford County came in at 33%

What does “red country” mean in this case?

Jeffrey, you’ll be surprised, but I didn’t find out about this book from your review, not even from GR. :) As a matter of fact, I came across it in a completely unamerican way. :D It was serendipity that brought me to it. There is this German TV that I regularly watch to develop my German and as I came to the culture/political section of it, I stumbled upon this gem. :) I saw that they had recorded an interview with Barack Obama. I decided to watch it and I was fascinated. I totally grew to admire him during and after the interview. The questions that the reporter was asking were translated in German, but they had subtitled Obama. :D It was the first time it was happening. They never subtitle anyone there. :) Imagine the veneration they had for him. They wanted people to listen to him speaking with his own voice, to get to know him as much as possible, with all the nuances and to make the experience all the more personal. At least this is my interpretation of their choice. :)

Unfortunately, I don’t remember everything. I remember him, just like you, talking about his concerns in regards to women and their position in society. During the election people had to choose between the first female president and the first president from another race. It was quite a choice. I was happy to see how much the world had changed. The fact that there were such candidates and that one of them was chosen, this fact alone proves the veracity of Obama’s words in his answer to you about the new generation being more open-minded. In my line of work I speak with foreigners all the time. Mostly from Germany. On average I have 55 conversations per day. And I have noticed that the majority of those who mistreat me on the grounds of my foreign origins are of the older generation, people born in the 30s, 40s, 50s. There are exceptions of course, I have been discriminated against by younger people as well, but they are exceptions. The nationalists seem to be a dying breed in Germany. I assume this open-mindedness spreads to other matters as well. I am happy to know that this more gentle and more open mindset of the younger generation does not end with Germany or Bulgaria, where it is usually older people who hate animals, rather that it can be seen in your country as well. In another continent. :D

I also remember Obama speaking about trying to be a gracious winner. He said that he and George Bush were very different, but that by his win Bush invited him to celebrate together, after all and that he tried to show Trump the same courtesy, but he the latter refused. It says a lot about a man's character how he treats his opponents and those he disagrees with.

By the end of the interview I was sure that I wanted to read his autobiography and I was surprised to see that a lot of my GR had already listed it and you were even starting it. Admittedly, I am not very well versed in politics and I always feel rather incompetent when the topic comes up. :D Our mutual friend Willie often talks to me about the political affairs in the States and most of the time I don’t know what to say. :D But this case shows that if you come across the right person, even someone very non-political like me could be motivated and influenced positively.

Thank you for this quite excellent review, Jeffrey. I can imagine how proud you felt on receiving the response from Barack Obama.


Jeffrey Keeten Vessey wrote: " To give you an idea of how red the county is that I live in, 41% of Kansans voted for Joseph R. Biden, but Ford County came in at 33%

What does “red country” mean in this case?

Jeffrey, you’ll..."


The color red is associated with Republicans and the color blue with Democrats so when people say it is a red county or a blue county they are referring to the predominate political party of association of the citizens of that county.

I've heard from many of my friends from around the world who saw Obama as not only their inspiration, but also their president. The mishap of Trump has now been corrected and with Biden we have a chance to put the car back on the road. I have to admit I had tears in my eyes when I heard that Paris rang their bells with Biden's win. I'm sure many bells were ringing all across Europe. I always want people, no matter where they live to be tuned into politics. Not the hate speech, but the real issues so they can vote for the candidate who will help them the most. Biden and Trump both in this election received more votes than any presidential candidate in our history. Both eclipsed even the Obama numbers. Maybe one good thing can come from the Trump era, that more people will be involved in politics going forward.


Karen Fantastic, Jeffrey!


Jeffrey Keeten Thanks Karen!


samantharalphs Is it a good read


Betty My thoughts exactly. Great review. It seems I enjoy reading your reviews as much the books!


Jeffrey Keeten Betty wrote: "My thoughts exactly. Great review. It seems I enjoy reading your reviews as much the books!"

Thanks Betty! I'm so glad you enjoy my reviews! I hope they are helpful.


message 34: by SRS (new)

SRS Karen wrote : Fantastic , Jeffrey


Jeffrey Keeten SRS wrote: "Karen wrote : Fantastic , Jeffrey"

Thank you!


message 36: by Deborah (new)

Deborah Absolutely terrific review! Look forward to reading the book as I was thrilled to receive it as a Christmas gift.


Jeffrey Keeten Deborah wrote: "Absolutely terrific review! Look forward to reading the book as I was thrilled to receive it as a Christmas gift."

Thanks Deborah! Reading this was a breath of fresh air.


message 38: by Jim (new)

Jim The girlfriend got two copies of the President's memoir - I gave mine to the ex, and will get it back at some point.

Do you remember, in 2009, when he was the darling of American Conservatives - for about one week?

(think about it, while I share yet a related snippet from my own memoir)

At dinner, late 2007, we were discussing what our 12-yr-old daugther should do to fullfil her "public service" obligation at school. The missus came up with a fine idea, and we ALL ran with it. We determined she should volunteer to help out at the local gathering for the Democratic Caucus. I thought I should show up myself, as a virgin in such things.

I was then the roadie for my Toastmasters Club - aka Sgt at Arms. Duties typically are set up, lead the Pledge, introduce the Toastmaster, hand out the ribbons at the end, and break it all down. Our club was cooler than that - between the Pledge and the Introduction, the Sgt had two minutes, more or less, for "remarks". A fun stopgap is to do "this day in History" - but other topics were fun as well. Several times in the run-up to the Caucus in January, I riffed on my plan to "speak my voice" - adding that I'd never done it, and that at minimum, it would be a "personal bit of Anthropology" because:

I want to see what a thousand Democrats, all in the same place at the same time, looks like

(later, after the Caucus, I said, "of course, they look like Alaskans")

I got to Begich Middle School well ahead of the procedings - backed into a good parking spot to facilitate a rapid escape - and walked in to the lobby.

The registration table wasn't quite ready, so I hung out and watched. Candidate Obama was well-represented by volunteers, so much so, that I estimate they outnumbered Clinton's by 3:1.

Eventually I registered "D" and watched the crowd come in - and come in - and come in.

One of the faithful - another early attender - soon commented that it was already considerably more crowded than in 2004, when 250 showed up (this would have amounted to fewer than ten/precinct in Anchorage).

The lobby soon was full, so they opened the doors to the adjacent assembly room - which only nomimally relieved the crush. I felt sorry for the seniors, some with walkers, who battled to register in a too-narrow hall connecting to the lobby. The regulars were stunned at the turnout - they'd never seen anything like it.

This being Alaska, a "red state", who always goes "R" (except Johnson over Goldwater), and with the minimum three electors, no actual candidates showed up.

(was it Tim Russert who coined that term circa 2000 - painting the GOP with Soviet and Chinese colors? He seems smart, and old enough to remember Mao, Brehznev, and their criminal associates, so this was a sly bit of misdirection which happened to "stick")

Instead, the candidates sent DVD's. Alas, athough images appeared on the big screen, there was NO AUDIO!

(by this time, I was scheming, thinking I would offer to manage the 2012 local caucus for a nominal fee)

Eventually the wife and I, newly minted "blues", went to the room designated for our neighborhood. While waiting for our throng (which topped out at over 100) I chatted with some twenty somethings who had beer and were willing to share! When time came to "vote", I walked to the "non-aligned" group. After the first vote, Edwards supporters and we "uncertain ones" were below 15% of the total, so had to make another choice. The beer guys were with Obama - that was good enough for me, so I joined THEM.

In the end Obama buried Clinton in our precinct - by several multiples. The overall count for Anchorage totalled about 3850. Other cities had similar extreme turnouts - ratios of 8:1,10:1 (2008:2004) were typical. Reports were that a traffic jam developed around the school - thus discouraging many who hoped "to caucus".

And now, who remembers what garned the temporary right-wing ardor for our president? It was his address to the Nobel Committee.

I remember being impressed with the transcript in 2009, though surely I skimmed it. I looked for such in his memoir while I still had it - to no avail - BUT.....

YOUTUBE TO THE RESCUE!

Within a mere minute I was watching, transfixed, to his 35-minute address. I have RARELY witnessed such an eloquent, nuanced, and well-reseached "apology" for the proper and necessary use of force by America - fully admitting (but not belaboring) that we often do not fully live up to our ideals. It took a long view, only obilquely addressing 2009 foreign and military policy. Surely it sent "the right message" to allies and enemies alike.

Maybe, we can hire him to be our Chief Diplomat?


Jeffrey Keeten Jim wrote: "The girlfriend got two copies of the President's memoir - I gave mine to the ex, and will get it back at some point.

Do you remember, in 2009, when he was the darling of American Conservatives - ..."


Great stuff Jim! Thanks for sharing.


Erika Thank you Jeffrey for a great review. The book is waiting on my shelf, will be read next.


Jeffrey Keeten You are welcome Erika! Relish the book.


message 42: by Lorraine (new)

Lorraine Awesome review Jeffrey 👍


Jeffrey Keeten Lorraine wrote: "Awesome review Jeffrey 👍"

Thanks Lorraine!


back to top