Morgan Blackledge's Reviews > The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma

The Body Keeps the Score by Bessel van der Kolk
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3897817
's review

it was amazing

The Body Keeps Score is my jam. It's better than that. It's like my slammajam. This is my fave book of the year so far, by a bunch.

It's a rich treasure trove of information from the frontiers of trauma research, etiology, diagnosis and treatment. It's changing the way I do therapy and it's changing the way a interpret human behavior.

And to think. I almost didn't read it.

When I entered the mental health field I had intended to specialize in Somatic Experiencing (SE) trauma therapy. But I quickly rejected the model when I realized it was way outside the mainstream and lacked randomized control trials (RCT) that demonstrated its effectiveness compared to other "first line" treatments such as Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Prolonged Exposure Therapy (PE).

I saw the author Dr. Bessel Van Der Kolk lecture at the Evolution of Psychotherapy conference in 2013. He was awesome, and he really reinvigorated my interest in doing somatically oriented trauma work. But something about the experience as a whole left me feeling woozy.

Perhaps my experience was negativity impacted by the mass, prolonged exposure to the unwashed throngs of other psychotherapists (never a good thing), some of whom were from the San Francisco Bay Area (a deadly combination).

Don't get me wrong. There are lots of mental health professionals (even ones from the Bay Area) that are highly functional, sober, top notch folks.

But there are also a bunch of kooky, crazy as fuck people in the field (Particularly in the Bay Area), and there were a bunch in the crowd, and I think I was feeling a bit (or perhaps a lot) of shame for my profession. A pathological shame that was clearly a sequallia of my own dark hippy shadow.

I myself lived in the Bay Area for around a decade. I came to therapy from an unconventional "hippyish" background. I went to art school as an undergraduate. I have practiced yoga and meditation for over 30 years. Plus I have a couple of crappy tattoos. When I entered the field I was dreadfully afraid no one would take me seriously.

So I somewhat consciously but mostly unconsciously tried to distance myself from my own freaky roots.

I was probably still up in my head about all that when I was listening to Dr. Van Der Kolk. I was loving what he was saying, the parts I could understand any way (he speaks in a thick Dutch accent), but I also remember looking around the room and thinking "I have to distinguish myself from these nutty hippies".

Perhaps it was at that point I unconsciously gripped up and rejected somatic trauma work (again) in favor of the more "masculine" "serious" "evidence based", behaviorally oriented, here and now stuff that I currently practice.

Which, by the way, is Acceptance Comment Therapy (ACT). A mindfulness based variant of CBT which is incidentally a "hippy as fuck" therapeutic modality by many standards.

Anyway.

When I first saw that the book was released, I was like "hey, that looks pretty good" but then I had a flash back from the psychotherapy conference.

It was an intrusive mental image of a patchouli smelling, chubby middle aged hippy chick in a mauve knit poncho sweater and dream catcher earrings saying "your fifth level is emitting too much teal energy" and I reflexively withdrew my enthusiasm for the whole somatically oriented trauma treatment program.

Anyway. I did eventually get over myself (and my hippy phobia) and got the book and man is it good. It's extremely, extremely triple extremely good. It's like, organically, cosmically, spin your chakras at a dead show good.

And despite Dr. Van Der Kolk's activist agenda, he's actually a pretty reputable (Harvard affiliated) scientist and clinician and widely regarded as one the the worlds foremost authorities on trauma and trauma sequelae (yes I used the term seguelae twice in the same review, actually three times if you count the time I just used sequallia in this parentheses, oops, better make that four).

And, yes, Dr. Van Der Kolk also apparently does yoga and meditation and has probably smoked tons of weed and hung out at Eslen. But I am willing to forgive the man for that because I too have been guilty of similar behavior in my woolly headed, not so distant past.

Before I became a therapist, I was on my own journey to recovery from addiction, trauma, depression, anxiety etc.

BTW: when I hear other therapist start talking about their recovery, I cringe. Please forgive me if you're feeling cringy. But sometimes we all have to go there in order to communicate certain important points.

Anyway.

The foundation of my recovery was self-care. For me, self-care was (and still is) founded on basics such as: healthy sleep, exercise and nutrition. It also included good therapy and a little 12-step. But the rocket fuel of my recovery was yoga, loving kindness meditation and mindfulness meditation.

Now, one of my primary intentions as a therapist is to assist my clients in developing self compassion and embodied mindfulness skills for utilization in their recovery.

While the secular mindfulness revolution thing that has been happening over the past two decades has normalized mindfulness and provided ample scientific evidence for the clinical use value of mindfulness training e.g. Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR).

And mindfulness-based psychotherapeutic modalities such as Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT) and Acceptance Commitment Therapy (ACT) have provided evidence-based mindfulness integrated psychotherapeutic frameworks.

The evidence for somatically oriented (embodied) therapeutic modalities has lagged. Dr. Van Der Kolk's work is providing this evidence and is blazing the trail for mainstream acceptance of somatically oriented practices.

Dr. Van Der Kolk's work is also foundational for changing the way the field conceptualizes and diagnoses trauma.

Additionally Dr. Van Der Kolk is lending legitimacy to some cutting-edge and very exciting trauma treatments such as Neural Feedback and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR).

I, like millions of other people, have suffered from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) symptoms. In early recovery I received lots of good therapy for trauma and I'm happy to report that I am no longer impaired by PTSD symptoms.

Out of all of the therapy I received, anecdotally speaking, I have to say, some of the most effective was EMDR. I had phenomenal results from an equally phenomenally brief treatment time (two, one hour sessions).

This is standard EMDR testimonial. People very commonly report that it works and it works fast.

Again, as a nascent therapist in training, I had intended to train in EMDR. But EMDR is like the dirty redheaded stepchild of psychotherapy. Despite ample evidence of its efficacy, nobody can figure out why it works, so the model has been widely rejected by the mainstream mental health community.

I sort of drank the Kool-Aid and jumped on the anti EMDR bandwagon. But after reading this book, I'm feeling very enthusiastic about treating trauma with EMDR.

I could go on and on, but I'd rather just urge you to do yourself a big favor and read this book.
1339 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Body Keeps the Score.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 25, 2015 – Started Reading
April 25, 2015 – Shelved
May 9, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 167 (167 new)


message 1: by Mani (new) - added it

Mani Excellent summary and great story, Morgan!


Morgan Blackledge Thanks Mani


message 3: by Christine (new)

Christine Rose Elle Incredible review. Your knowledge of the material really helped me. Amazing.


message 4: by Christine (new)

Christine Rose Elle Incredible review. Your knowledge of the material really helped me. Amazing.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review. Just heard an interview with this doctor on NPR. Can't wait to read this.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review. Just heard an interview with this doctor on NPR. Can't wait to read this.


Morgan Blackledge @ Juli. Let me know what you think about the book.


message 8: by John (new) - added it

John Willams Great review


message 9: by John (new) - added it

John Willams Great review


Morgan Blackledge Thanks John


message 11: by Heather (new)

Heather OMG that was the best review. EVER. I laughed, I cried (okay, I didn't cry) but you have thoroughly convinced me to buy the book. I'm drinking your cool-aid!!


Morgan Blackledge WOW Heather. Let me know how you like it. And thanks for the props :-)


Travel Writing Drop the mic. This will be the pinnacle of GoodReads reviews for time immemorial for me. I was thinking WTF can I say about this book- it blew my mind. So much fell into place and made sense. So many moments of, 'ohshit, yeah that is so dead on!" and 'Why have I never heard of this before? This should be taught in 5th grade. Ok, 11th grade."
I feel like the ONE time I dropped acid and it was so perfect, so life changing and how I never really talk about it because I sound like a douche-canoe, that is what anything I have to say about this book will sound like. Then you nailed it. Thanks, buddy. I am off the hook!


message 14: by Justin (new) - added it

Justin Doud Fantastic, hilarious, and relatable review. I empathize so much with what you're saying


message 15: by Nick (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nick Just finished the book. Slamjam is right!! Can't wait to check your favorites.


message 16: by Jillian (new) - added it

Jillian Hoover EMDR has done wonders for me and 'recovering' from my PTSD. Appreciate you bringing it up-and all the (sad/upsetting) 'truth' that currently surrounds it. We (especially the scientific community) always tend to dismiss what we can't immediately understand, and to the detriment of so much/many.


Joshua I have seen profound change in my life due to EMDR. I am excited to read this.


Alcina This is an excellent and hilarious review. I just finished this book, and your comments sum it up for me.

I would add that one very appealing aspect for me is his lack of salacious stories - he manages to share trauma issues with without glamorizing or doing the 'war stories' thing. There are a few deeply disturbing details, but later and not many and I think this is refreshing.

Also, I agree that he has a unique voice in that he is so credentialed, and validates alternative treatments with serious scientific studies. I don't need this type of validation to know they work (read this: https://www.theguardian.com/global-de...), but I can now defend things like EMDR and 'Communal Rhythms and Theatre' (right?!) to western academic folks who are dismissive.

Great review.


Morgan Blackledge Thanks Alcina.


Valerie Gangas This review just made me laugh out loud. "The Body Keeps Score is my jam. It's better than that. It's like my slammajam." I felt the same way!!


message 21: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Morgan, I love your review. . . Very honest and heartfelt. Thank you :-)


message 22: by Mir (last edited Jul 04, 2017 05:18PM) (new)

Mir patchouli smelling, chubby middle aged hippy chick in a mauve knit poncho sweater and dream catcher earrings saying "your fifth level is emitting too much teal energy"

Bwahaha! I'm from the Bay Area and although I've never had any mental health, er, oops, I mean contact with mental health practitioners, I have totally met the sisters of that women. I assumed they owned incense shops or made crystal healing pendants or something.


Julian Great review. Interesting to read about the intentions you had at one point to specialise in Somatic Experiencing trauma therapy but that you rejected it due to the lack of trails compared with CBT and Prolonged Exposure Therapy. I did a conference with Bessel Van der Kolk last year and he is very critical of both these therapies - critical of CBT because trauma is not cognitive but rather a physiological condition and PE because it simply pushes people into dissociation to cope with the stimulation. I ended up learning SE which proved very effective for my own trauma. Would still like to learn EMDR at some point as the more tools the better. Glad to hear your own trauma is resolved.


message 24: by Steve (new) - added it

Steve Turtell I just put this on hold at the library, but after your review am considering buying it, even though I'm trying to cut down on book purchasing. Great review!


Morgan Blackledge @ Steve. Thanks for the kind words. I buy too many book too. So I feel your pain. If you want to listen to an audio version of the book for free. It's on you tube. Just sayin' :-)


message 26: by Paloma (new) - added it

Paloma Meir We should get married... not really, I just really like your review and EMDR.


Morgan Blackledge Thanks Paloma.

That's a rad really rad idea.

But all joking aside. I think the order of that sequence should be flipped for everyone considering getting married.

First therapy, than marriage.

As opposed to the other way around, which is how almost every one does it.


message 28: by Justin (new) - added it

Justin If people actually did therapy after marriage that'd be a good start


Morgan Blackledge Justin: True!

Usually we wait till the divorce part.

I guess better late than never.


message 30: by Justin (new) - added it

Justin It seems like most of my friends are very bitter with their spouses. A good deal of my friends seem depressed. I wish I could convince people to see a therapist. Therapy needs to get with Yoga's PR guy.


Morgan Blackledge True that. Therapy used to have AMAZING PR. But the field has declined tremendously over the past 30 years.

Why (precisely) is hard to say. It would be a great research subject.

I talk to people all the time who have had REALLY bad therapy. That's got to be a big part of the equation.

Anyway. You're right. Therapy works. It saves lives. It's got a horrible reputation in the eyes of the public. And that is really too bad.


message 32: by Patty (new) - added it

Patty Perrone Gosh, you're swell! I cannot wait to read this especially after your sparkling review.


Morgan Blackledge Jeez! Thanks Patricia :-)


Tiffany  Martin Mylett Loved this review and felt normalized by it after my nerdy excitement throughout reading it. EMDR therapist here and still constantly amazed by its superpowers and how the body speaks. Ironically, I was a little overwhelmed by the hippyish EMDR International Convention, but yet here I am witnessing the benefits of all the preaching of mindfulness, body work, and healing past traumas.


Morgan Blackledge @ Tiffany: I know right? True that!


Morgan Blackledge Linda. OMG you’re amazing. It’s so very life affirming to know people such as yourself are out there, immersed in the literature, training like a beast, and trying it all for themselves first. This is absolutely restoring my faith and pride in our field. GO GET IT GURL.

Please stay in touch.


Zooey Hi Morgan! I loved your funny and honest review! Maybe I like it so much too because I can relate to what you went through! Just like you did, I am dealing with all that mental personal stuff now and majoring in psychology and have attented art academy before :) Very nice to read you worked through the PTSD and all and are doing your own things and writing fabulous reviews now! Wish you all the best!


Morgan Blackledge Thanks Zooey. Keep on rockin’!!!!


message 39: by [deleted user] (new)

Loved your review. I was living in S.F. in the 70's and had a great Jungian, existential therapist.


Morgan Blackledge @ Joel. Was it Irvin Yallom?

He’s still seeing clients (I think)


message 41: by [deleted user] (new)

No, it was Nancy Trahms.


Mrs. ❥Kandake Thank you for your review.


message 43: by Daphne (new) - added it

Daphne What an awesome review! Wish you were practising in London!


message 44: by Joanne (new) - added it

Joanne McPhee Thankyou for sharing you personal and professional experience. You have a way with words. I adore your humour and honesty. Perhaps just removing the reference to the ‘dirty redhead’ would make it perfect. Another to add to my growing list! I’m with you Paloma!
Bluey, Australia


message 45: by Abu (new) - rated it 4 stars

Abu Shaikh i loved your review, it took this serious subject and made it sound like a cupcake! peace and love!


Morgan Blackledge Thanks Adu, Peace and love 2U2 :-)


Anders Demitz-Helin Great review. I'm in love with PE and do get my best results with this technique. I have colleagues educated in and using EMDR, and they show such disappointment with it that I backed off. But I do lack the great experience of having a tool for the more severe "nonverbal" traumas, other than long therapies with focus on building selfcare and love.


Morgan Blackledge Thanks Ig!

I’m a big believer in exposure techniques too.

I think exposure is the important
mechanism underlying therapeutic efficacy across models.

I have some experience with PE proper.

I took a DBT training that integrated PE.

I was really impressed with the way the DBT people were working with PE.

Supper skillful.


Bonnie Great review!


Morgan Blackledge Thanks Bonn!


« previous 1 3 4
back to top