Horror Experts Recommend Terrifying Tales

Posted by Cybil on September 29, 2023


If you want to find a quality scary story, it’s always a good idea to go to the experts. Since the Crypt Keeper is currently in retirement—reposing and decomposing—we’ve found the next best thing: the editors of this year’s biggest horror anthologies!  
 
The publishing professionals below have generously given their time to recommend their favorite horror novels and short fiction for the Halloween season, both old classics and new (burnt) offerings. That’s six separate batches of recommendations in total, with some interesting sub-categories regarding haunted houses, witches, cults, and fireside short stories.
 
It's a great idea, if we do say so ourselves. The contributors below are among the planet’s most qualified experts when it comes to horror story recommendations. We’re very grateful for their expertise. Be sure to check out their new anthologies, too.
 
You can click on the links to get to each individual recommended title, and we’ve collected the book covers at the end of each section. Click on those for more details, and add any good leads to your Want to Read shelf.
 


"A massive shout-out to Goodreads for letting Ted and me play guide on this frightful literary journey this October. Dive headfirst into the unsettling family saga in Ania Ahlborn’s Seed. Next, Christopher Buehlman’s Those Across the River—it’s a historical fright-fest that’ll make you jump at every bump in the night. Do you want to be broken? Tananarive Due’s Ghost Summer has you covered as it elevates the genre. Rachel Harrison’s Such Sharp Teeth blends horror and humor, making you laugh one minute and scream the next. Dare to step into Scott Hawkins’ The Library at Mount Char—it’s a chilling maze of mysteries waiting to be unraveled. Then buckle up for C.B. Jones’ The Rules of the Road, a petrifying road trip you won't soon forget. Stephen Graham Jones’ The Least of My Scars will make you question how dark humanity can get, and Carmen Maria Machado’s Her Body and Other Parties plunges into the scary-beautiful world of womanhood. My eight spine-tingling picks are guaranteed to keep you up at night, frantically checking under the bed and wishing your light switch were closer. Turn the pages if you dare, but remember: The shadows are watching," says Hawk.

"October! The year’s greatest month. Of course, every month is wonderful for reading horror, but it lands a little different here. When asked to come up with titles I thought our readers would like, the books and stories rushed up and in from all around. We get eight apiece, so I had to work a little, and be sad a little by having to leave a few out (I will attempt to sneakily drop a few favorite classics here like The Lottery by Shirley Jackson, The Monkey’s Paw by W.W. Jacobs, and The Devil and Daniel Webster by Stephen Vincent Benét). Shane and I both had Stephen Graham Jones’ The Least of My Scars, but I guess it can only appear once. My list includes ones that both scared the crap out of me and inspired like hell. I really hope you dig them. Oh, and another sneaky moment to hopefully add the Jaunt, the Road Virus Heads North, and The Sun Dog from Stephen King. Here's the list, in alphabetical order; fright-level listings your own. Happy reading, and Happy Halloween!" says Van Alst.


Shane Hawk's Recommendations:

 

 
Ted Van Alst's Recommendations:

   

 
"All These Sunken Souls features new Black horror stories by acclaimed bestsellers and hot new talents. What I enjoy about this collection is how each story explores, through a blend of genres, what it means to be haunted. Whether it be in a hungry Victorian mansion, a zombie apocalypse, or a strange multiverse, they ask: What do we run from? But also: What do we run to? What is it that we desire as well as fear? This list includes a few of my favorite books that have answers of their own for those questions," says Moskowitz.


Circe Moskowitz's Recommendations:

       
 
"Let’s celebrate brand-new horror fiction books with your favorite themes and tropes this spooky season! Haunted houses. Demons, witches, monsters, and cults! Short stories to tell around the firepit. If now is not the time to grow your personal horror library, don’t forget that your local public library is ready to support you in your thirst for scary books. If the book is new, and the library doesn’t have it in the system or on the shelf, stop by the information desk and ask if you could put in a request. If it is an older title, you can borrow it through the interlibrary loan program. Don’t forget you have access to all the free books, movies, and audio your library provides with library apps! All you need is a library card. Hoopla, OverDrive, Libby, Kanopy, and LibraryThing. I highly recommend Libby for audio and e-books, and Kanopy for spooky-season movies. Indulging in quality, newly released horror books doesn’t have to break the bank," says Hartmann.


 

Sadie Hartmann's Haunted Houses:

 

 Sadie Hartmann's Demons, Witches, Monsters & Cults:

   

  Sadie Hartmann's Short Stories to Tell Around the Firepit:

 
 
"Horror is one of my favorite genres. It gives us a way to explore fear in both a concrete and metaphorical way. Whether it’s running from the scary monster of your nightmares, confronting the monster society makes of us, or becoming a monster yourself, horror is a genre where anything is possible. I read it across age categories and subgenres all year-round because who doesn’t want a little spookiness in their life? My favorite books are those featuring a diverse cast of characters from varying ethnic backgrounds, genders, and sexualities. The following recommendations give depth to horror in a unique and exciting way!" says Page.

"Horror is such a fantastic way of realizing that you’re not the only one who thinks something isn’t right. We can take real things that we experience in our daily lives and turn it into something that might be a little easier to understand if it’s given a different form. It’s that feeling you get when something’s lurking in the corner of your eye—when a shadow darts across the room and you turn to a friend and ask, 'Did you see that, too?' Good horror books will smile and say, 'Yes, I did.' The best horror will reply, slyly, 'But did it see you?' " says Brown.


 

Shelly Page's Recommendations:

   

  Alex Brown's Recommendations:

   
Have a great horror recommendation? Share it with us in the comments below!
 

 

Check out more horror coverage here:




Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Randy (new)

Randy Money I'd add to the above a recently reissued novel, Finishing Touches Finishing Touches by Thomas Tessier by Thomas Tessier. There's a restraint to Tessier's writing that makes it all the more unsettling as the implications pile up.


Marc *Dark Reader with a Thousand Young! Iä!* Randy wrote: "I'd add to the above a recently reissued novel, Finishing Touches Finishing Touches by Thomas Tessier by Thomas Tessier. There's a restraint to Tessier's writin..."

I was immediately excited to see it's a Vallancourt Press reissue. Those have been reliably good.


message 3: by Shane (new)

Shane Hawk So many great recommendations and ones I really look forward to buying/checking out from my library. Big thank-you to Goodreads managing editor, Cybil Wallace, for featuring all of our books/anthologies, alongside our favorite spooky season reads. Honored.


message 4: by Kathleen (new)

Kathleen Bring on ALL of the spooky books!!! 🥰🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤


message 5: by Sophie (new)

Sophie Egaña I would add Coraline by Neil Gaiman


message 6: by Laceygoodbooks (new)

Laceygoodbooks Are these smoke sounds really interesting how y’all have fun reading them


message 7: by Amanda (new)

Amanda I just got Coraline at Thriftbooks for, like, $6. Big decision bc it’s going to scare me bigtime…I don’t like clowns, dolls, puppets, mannequins- any of that shit that Hollywood loves to have come to life and eat me…


message 8: by Beth (new)

Beth Neil Gaiman should be on this list.


message 9: by Heather (new)

Heather Crutcher The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman is better, but Coraline is cute. It was my first Neil Gaiman book. Still Stardust is my favorite, but it’s a fantasy book. I love Yvaine.


message 10: by Artur (new)

Artur Freire Finally some Clive Barker love. The Books of Blood are bangers.


message 11: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Kangas October Screams: A Halloween Anthology

Might I humbly suggest this anthology--lot of great stories in it, and it just came out.


message 12: by Lorette (new)

Lorette Lamoureux Looks great! Thanks!

Kevin wrote: "October Screams: A Halloween Anthology

Might I humbly suggest this anthology--lot of great stories in it, and it just came out."



message 13: by Law (new)

Law Silver Nitrate and Annihilation look intriguing, my library has the latter one.


message 14: by Marty (new)

Marty https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/1...

This is another great list of horror titles for the season, except it features exclusively indie authors (at the moment). If you like supporting the little guys and finding some really creative new writers...


message 15: by Jessica (new)

Jessica And exactly how does one become a horror Expert?? 🤔


message 16: by Scott (new)

Scott Jessica wrote: "And exactly how does one become a horror Expert?? 🤔"

Get paid.


message 17: by Editingle (new)

Editingle Indie Please check out Broken Night


message 18: by Editingle (new)

Editingle Indie This halloween anthology please check Whispers of the Hallow Night


message 19: by Anne (new)

Anne Simonot Amanda wrote: "I just got Coraline at Thriftbooks for, like, $6. Big decision bc it’s going to scare me bigtime…I don’t like clowns, dolls, puppets, mannequins- any of that shit that Hollywood loves to have come ..."

Then don't read How to Sell a Haunted House -- puppets and dolls in multitudes.


message 20: by Mathisse (new)

Mathisse Janart Sophie wrote: "I would add Coraline by Neil Gaiman"

Yess!!! I just bought it!


message 21: by Nikki (new)

Nikki I wish more horror was available on KU!


message 22: by Rocío (new)

Rocío Landa this list is missing Our Share of Night !


message 23: by Matthew (new)

Matthew Blum Five new obscenely good reads: (in no particular order)

~Peach Pit: Sixteen Stories Of Unsavory Women

~Whalefall Daniel Kraus

~The Petting Zoos K.S Covert

~The Shards Bret Easton Ellis

~The Passenger Cormac McCarthy

Carpe Diem!


back to top