United States | Budget-modelling wars

Fiscal nerds determine the fate of legislation in America

A battle under way to remake budget scoring

Illustration of a fight between people over stocks and shares.
Illustration: Vincent Kilbride
|Washington, DC

James Carville’s oft-quoted line needs updating. Bill Clinton’s political adviser once quipped that he would like to be reincarnated as the bond market so that he could “intimidate everybody”. It is now a group of fiscal nerds—called budget scorekeepers—who have more clout in determining the fate of American legislation. This has set the stage for a battle about how best to calculate the costs and benefits of tax and spending proposals.

Explore more

This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline “A settling of scores”

Meet America’s most dynamic political movement

From the June 1st 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from United States

How to decode Kamala Harris’s foreign policy

Expect tougher words on Israel, and continuity on Russia and China

Kamala Harris carries the torch, and the burden, of Bidenomics

She aims to build on the president’s social-care agenda while escaping blame for inflation


Republicans adjust their attacks for their new foe, Kamala Harris

Ms Harris inherits some of Joe Biden’s vulnerabilities—and brings a few of her own


More from United States

How to decode Kamala Harris’s foreign policy

Expect tougher words on Israel, and continuity on Russia and China

Kamala Harris carries the torch, and the burden, of Bidenomics

She aims to build on the president’s social-care agenda while escaping blame for inflation


Republicans adjust their attacks for their new foe, Kamala Harris

Ms Harris inherits some of Joe Biden’s vulnerabilities—and brings a few of her own


Can Kamala Harris beat Donald Trump? Here’s what the polls say

How the Democrats’ likely candidate changes the race

Kamala Harris lacks charisma and time

But, if nominated, that does not rule out her defeating Donald Trump

Joe Biden quits the race, at last. What’s next?

The embattled president has endorsed Kamala Harris, his vice-president, as his successor