Teachers arrested for having sex with male students were 'boy-crazy flirts' who cozied up to teenagers and their fathers, claim parents as they reveal new details of their 'shameless' behavior

Two former Georgia high school teachers who were arrested for allegedly having sex with their male students were apparently 'boy-crazy flirts' who cozied up to the teenagers and their fathers.

Railey Greeson and Brooklyn Shuler, 23, were indicted earlier this month on three counts of sexual contact by an employee or agent in the 1st degree, with prosecutors claiming Greeson had sex with two different male students while employed by the Calhoun City School District and Shuler had sex with one.

But parents at the school did not seem shocked by the allegations.

'I'm not trying to stereotype, but you could look at them and tell they were trouble,' Audrey Decker, whose stepdaughter attends the high school, told the New York Post.

'They just seemed boy-crazy. And everyone in the school knew it and joked about it.'

Former Georgia teachers Brooklyn Shuler and Railey Greeson were apparently 'boy-crazy flirts' who cozied up to the teenagers and their fathers

Former Georgia teachers Brooklyn Shuler and Railey Greeson were apparently 'boy-crazy flirts' who cozied up to the teenagers and their fathers

Railey Greeson
Brooklyn Shuler

Parents have described how Greeson, left, and Shuler, right, would cozy up to teenagers and their fathers

A mother of a sophomore at the school, who asked not to be named, also described the two former teachers as 'flirts.'

'You should have seen them with any attractive parents who came to the school,' she said. 'They would flirt with any of the dads. You know: laughing too loud, getting too close, that type of thing.' 

The mother went on to say they were 'flirting' and 'trying to be cute.'

'They were shameless,' the mother claimed.

Prosecutors now say Greeson and Shuler had sex with the three students at some point between October 29, 2021, and January 3, 2022.

Railey Greeson is pictured in a mugshot
Brooklyn Shuler is pictured in a mugshot

Greeson, left, and Shuler, right, were indicted earlier this month on three counts of sexual contact by an employee or agent in the 1st degree

They would later go on to get married, with Shuler tying the knot in Tunnel Hill, Georgia on November 12, 2022, according to her wedding registry website.

Greeson was wed in Tennessee roughly a year later on October 7, 2023.

Shuler named Greeson as her maid of honor, describing her as her 'best friend' and her 'ride or die'.

Shuler didn't get the honor of being Greeson's matron of honor at her wedding but was a bridesmaid.

Shuler was married in Tunnel Hill, Georgia on November 12, 2022

Shuler was married in Tunnel Hill, Georgia on November 12, 2022

Greeson was wed in Tennessee roughly a year later on October 7, 2023

Greeson was wed in Tennessee roughly a year later on October 7, 2023

It remains unclear which school these two lifelong friends were working for at the time of the alleged crimes.

It also remains unclear how the two friends met. 

Greeson was a member of Calhoun High School's class of 2019, according to an Instagram post displaying professional photo taken of her in anticipation of her senior year.

This puts her around the age of 23. 

Greeson was also mildly active on X, posting over two years ago about how she'd approach 'communicating feedback' to her students.

'Communicating feedback in the forms of grades and averages can really stress students out and cause them to struggle,' Greeson wrote.

Her X profile reveals she attended Kennesaw State with her graduation date in 2023.

Shuler's connection to the Calhoun City School District, meanwhile, is unclear.

Shuler's connection to the Calhoun City School District remains unclear

Shuler's connection to the Calhoun City School District remains unclear

However, it seems she is no longer with the man she married in November 2022, since he has a child with a new wife, according to his Facebook profile.

Greeson is still featured on her husband's profile picture on his social media accounts.

The two women were finally arrested and booked at the Gordon County Jail earlier this month, but were released on bond, the Gordon Gazette reports. 

If convicted, Greeson and Shuler could face one to 25 years in prison or a fine of up to $100,000.

If sodomy was involved in the alleged sex acts with the boys, the women could face up to 50 years behind bars.