How much is your luxury bag really worth? As Milan police bust Dior's supplier which was making brand's £2,500 It tote for just £44, we reveal the real value of your designer arm candy

By Bridie Pearson-jones For Mailonline

Published: | Updated:

Designer bags celebrities splash out thousands of pounds on could be made for as little as £50.

Factories that supply Dior and Armani in Milan, one of the fashion capitals of the world, were subject to a police raid this week, with Italian authorities alleging that the luxury fashion houses pay migrant workers as little as $2 (£1.56) an hour.

Prosecutors also allege that Dior paid one supplier just $57  (£44) to produce the famous Dior tote, that retails at $2,780 (£2164).

Meanwhile Armani, are alleged to pay $100 (£78) for bags that sell for $1,950 (£1520).

So do you know how much your luxury bag is really worth?

DIOR BOOK TOTE

ALLEGED COST TO MAKE: £44

RETAIL PRICE:  £2500

Sofía Vergara is a fan of the much loved Dior tote bag

Sofía Vergara is a fan of the much loved Dior tote bag  

The bag, a mix of embroidery and calfskin is less than £50 to make, according to Italian authorities

The bag, a mix of embroidery and calfskin is less than £50 to make, according to Italian authorities

 Dubbed an 'It' bag by dozens of fashion magazines and blogs, the Dior tote bag sells for £2,500 for the small version.

The bag, a mix of embroidery and calfskin is less than £50 to make, according to Italian authorities.

Despite the massive mark up - at 5581 per cent - it's become a favourite of dozen of celebrities, including Sofia Vergara, Kylie Jenner and Priyanka Chopra.

LVMH, Dior's parent compnay, has not replied to request for comment.  

ARMANI LA PRIMA TOTE

ALLEGED COST TO MAKE £78

RETAIL PRICE £2780 

Alessandra Ambrosio (pictured), Lily James, Anne Hathaway, and Kim Kardashian are among the stars to sport Armani bags

Alessandra Ambrosio (pictured), Lily James, Anne Hathaway, and Kim Kardashian are among the stars to sport Armani bags

Italian investigators  said sub-contractors paid people 2-3 euros an hour for 10 hours a day to make bags that got sold to Armani suppliers for 93 euros, re-sold to Armani for 250 euros, and cost about 1,800 euros in shops, according to Reuters news agency.

While the exact bag wasn't named - Medium la Prima Soft baguette bag in nappa leather and the Large La Prima tote bag in palmellato leather from the brand both cost around this amount.

Alessandra Ambrosio, Lily James, Anne Hathaway, and Kim Kardashian are among the stars to sport Armani bags.

BOTTEGA VENETA ARCO MINI TOTE 

COSTS £195

PRICE  £2420

In a TikTok video, Volkan Yilmaz said he believes the Bottega Veneta Arco Mini Tote

In a TikTok video, Volkan Yilmaz said he believes the Bottega Veneta Arco Mini Tote

Since Italian authorities have moved in on Prada and Armani, other luxury brands have also come under the radar.

One person who is an expert on the cost of making bags is  Volkan Yilmaz - a leather craftsman who has some extreme methods to test the durabiltity of a bag.

The US-based leather worker, who has 1.1M followers on TikTok, takes pricey designer handbags, pouring harsh chemical acetone on the expensive leather and then setting the remains alight. 

'The first thing I do when I assess a leather bag is just feel it. Does it feel plasticky or can I feel the natural form of the leather?’ he previously told the Daily Mail.

Often, he says, luxury brands ‘standardise’ leather, applying an acrylic layer to cover up any marks or flaws.

‘I tell people to think of it like make-up. Leather has imperfections because it comes from an animal: there’s scars, bite marks and so on.

‘About 90 per cent of hide requires some form of touch-up.’ A pattern or texture can be stamped on top of this plasticky finish to give a distinctive look — like Prada’s brushed ‘Saffiano’ leather — but it can also be used to disguise low-quality materials.

‘Next, I look at the craftsmanship — are the stitches perfectly in line? How complex is the overall design? What is the inner lining made of?'.

‘Then I cut into it. I pour acetone on the bag to dissolve the finish, so I can assess the leather underneath. Burning the material helps me work out what tanning technique was used — some are much more expensive than others.’ 

One bag is the Bottega Veneta Arco Mini Tote. 

“It has an insane amount of leather, quadruple of a [normal] bag this size,' he explained in an Instagram video.

 “I estimate 18 square feet of lambskin. I total it up to $130 for the leather, probably another $120 for labour and the accessories. Shouldn’t be more than $250 (£195)  to make a bag like this. I paid $2,500 (£1950)  for this bag.”

PRADA SAFFIANO BAG 

Another It bag, loved by the likes of Kendall Jenner and Bella Hadid is the Prada Saffiano bag

Another It bag, loved by the likes of Kendall Jenner and Bella Hadid is the Prada Saffiano bag

COST: £100

PRICE TAG: £1800 

Another It bag, loved by the likes of Kendall Jenner and Bella Hadid.

But Prada's Saffiano bags have a huge mark-up. 

But Volkan says: 'Prada uses a lot of Saffiano leather, which is coated in a plasticky layer and then stamped with a cross-hatched pattern.

'This look is fashionable, but it hides the true quality of the leather used. On the plus side, the heavy finish makes the bag water and scratch-resistant.

'When I remove the finish, the leather that’s been used underneath is good quality, which is reassuring. 

'Still, £42 should be enough to cover the leather used here, and as the design isn’t very complex, I’d estimate about £58 for labour and accessories, like the coveted Prada badge.

Choose a handbag that will last a lifetime 

If you’re just browsing for a new bag — and not carrying acetone or a box of matches - how can you make sure you’re looking at good quality leather and a bag that won’t fall apart after you’ve carried it a few times?

Volkan says . . .

1. Look for imperfections in the leather — these are a good sign. If it looks too polished and perfect, then it’s either been coated in a heavy plastic finish, or it could be made with fake leather.

2. Feel it — and smell it. Good quality leather is textured, not plasticky and smooth. And it will probably smell (pleasantly) like real leather.

If a bag doesn’t have a smell at all, that’s not always a problem — some tanneries deliberately get rid of this natural scent. However, if you detect a chemical or petroleum-like odour, that’s a bad sign.

3. Read the label. It sounds obvious, but many people don’t think to check whether they’re buying polyurethane or real leather.

And beware vague terms such as ‘genuine leather’ or just ‘leather’. Legally, manufacturers have to declare what a bag is made of. But a description like this tells you there’s not much to say.

Brands that create artisan high-quality leathers can’t stop talking about them, and will give added detail such as what the finish or tanning style is.

Don’t assume that because the exterior is leather the interior is, too.

4. Check the weight and finish of hardware (all the metal bits of the bag). Hardware can be tricky to judge — some may look good initially but show defects later on.

But a good first step is to check how much these components weigh. Generally, the heavier they are, the higher the quality. And then inspect the finish for scratches, flaws and dullness. A nice plated or polished finish is a good sign.

5. Look for a branded zip. There’s nothing more infuriating than a zip that breaks or sticks.Luckily, there’s an easy way to check: look for the brand name, which is usually found on the zipper pull. YKK and Riri are a couple of great brands and a reliable indicator of quality.

Advertisement
Sofia VergaraPriyanka ChopraKylie Jenner