Gold Rush

Gold Rush
Linda Xiao for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Monica Pierini.
Rating
4(843)
Notes
Read community notes

The Gold Rush was created in the early aughts at Milk & Honey, the famed cocktail speakeasy on the Lower East Side in New York. It came to be when T.J. Siegal, a friend and colleague of Sasha Petraske, the founder of Milk & Honey, came in one night and asked for a whiskey sour. Spying a batch of honey syrup Mr. Petraske had whipped up for a different cocktail, Mr. Siegal asked for his drink to be made with that instead of sugar. The winning result, silkier and richer in flavor than the average whiskey sour, was soon served to customers. —Robert Simonson

Featured in: Shake Up Your Evening Cocktail With Some Honey

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement


Ingredients

Yield:1 drink, plus additional honey syrup
  • 3ounces honey
  • 1ounce warm water
  • Ice
  • 2ounces bourbon
  • ¾ounce fresh lemon juice
  • ¾ounce honey syrup
Ingredient Substitution Guide

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Make the honey syrup: In a sealed container, combine the honey and warm water; shake until combined. (Honey syrup makes ½ cup, and will keep, covered, at room temperature, for up to 1 week.)

  2. Step 2

    Prepare the cocktail: Fill a cocktail shaker halfway with ice. Add the bourbon, lemon juice and ¾ ounce honey syrup; shake until chilled, about 15 seconds.

  3. Step 3

    Strain into a rocks glass filled with one large ice cube. No garnish.

Ratings

4 out of 5
843 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

or, just read the step-by-step directions which clearly spell out which ingredients are for the honey syrup and which go into the single serving drink

The ingredient list needs to be fixed. There should be subheadings for the Honey Syrup (3 oz honey, 1 oz water) and the Gold Rush itself: (ice, etc.)

I love this cocktail. I just had it -- but I was out of honey and lemon. But that large ice cube sure did the trick. :-)

I'm a beekeeper and bourbon lover and have been making this drink for years. Skip making honey syrup. Bourbon, squeeze half a lemon, add a teaspoon +/- of honey. Stir, Add ice last as the honey doesn't mix in if chilled. The melting ice adds the water of the honey syrup. Feeling frisky? Add a dash or two of bitters. My version of a margarita is the same: tequila (though I prefer mezcal), honey, half a lime

Right before everything shut down at the end of February 2020, the bartender at the Iroquois Hotel made me a very tasty variation on the Gold Rush that included pineapple. I’ve tried to re-create it by adding pineapple juice to this cocktail equal to the amount of bourbon, which makes it a little less boozy.

As snarky as it is true.

What you have is the recipe for the Hot Toddy served at the Bushmill Distillery in Ireland. The only thing missing is a dash of spice (cinnamon, clove & allspice)

So it’s a “cold toddy.”

I make something similar with Mike’s Hot Honey. The spice kick is delicious!

Here is 3:1, honey:water; the PDT cocktail book is 2:1 - play around and see what you like better. You'll be modulating how forward the honey is in the drink. You definitely don't need to boil it, only long enough to meld the two - like making simple syrup.

Wonderful I am always looking for ways to use the honey from my bees. I will replace simple syrup with honey syrup going forward. Thanks for sharing

Only if you don't shake it

It's worth mentioning that honey syrup can last at least a month if refrigerated, almost certainly longer, given that simple syrup will also last a month when refrigerated. This is particularly helpful if you are making larger batches of honey syrup if you intend to make this cocktail on the regular, or if you want to make other cocktails with honey syrup (might I recommend the Athol Brose?)

This is made significantly better with the additional of a regal shake: throw a grapefruit peel in the shaker with the drink, which expresses the oils in the peel and rounds the finished product.

This is basically a Bee's Knees made with bourbon instead of gin- we've "invented" this at home not knowing that there was a name for it. Very good either way!

Delicious. Everyone we have made it for love it and instant favorite!

long ago i thoroughly enjoyed a drink called the weekender in new orleans at cure. replacing half an ounce of the bourbon with mezcal immediately returned me to that balmy afternoon.

Added one and a half lemon. Probably could do 2. Whipped eggs longer and really rose out of small pan

The same recipe but prepared with rye whiskey has been sold as the Hotel Saskatchewan cocktail. Published in Bottoms Up! in 1951.

This becomes a Bees' Knees if you swap in gin for bourbon. Less sweet, more bracing, still delicious.

similar to a Bees Knees cocktail......

Go straight to the horse's mouth—buy Petraske's "Regarding Cocktails." This one's in there.

Made this drink with less honey and juice from a lemon and it was delicious! The key is mixing the honey with warm water, which melts the honey. My wife and I are tequila drinkers, but this got us more schnockered than our normal tequila drinks. So we're fans! It's 5:00 somewhere right now...

It's much easier to measure honey (and almost everything else) by weight, as we do here in Europe. One fluid ounce of honey weighs 40 grams, so pour 120 grams of honey into a small saucepan on a kitchen scale. Add your ounce of water, heat until combined, done. No spatulas, not a drop of wasted honey on the counter, no cup to clean.

Seems a tad high in sweetness just reading the recipe. Almost 4 oz of sugar. Ugh.

The recipe makes enough honey syrup for more than five drinks. Each drink has a little more than half an ounce of actual honey.

No, the recipe includes making a batch of honey syrup sufficient for 5 drinks.

It's actually less than one oz per drink.

I do a similar whiskey sour with maple syrup - let’s call it a Sugarhouse Sour. I prefer it with a good rye, but bourbon is a natural.

Hot Toddy-esque! Just cold. Makes me feel like I made a healthy choice for a “buzzzzz.”

We all loved this cocktail. I used lightly cinnamon flavored honey that I had on hand. It lent a lovely delicate note but I think this would be great with any honey. I wonder how it would be with agave instead.

I make something like this with bourbon, lemon juice and Domaine de Canton (which is a French liqueur made with ginger and brandy). I eye ball proportions - but I think it translates to 2 parts bourbon, 1 part lemon juice and 1 part Domaine de Canton.

This is made significantly better with the additional of a regal shake: throw a grapefruit peel in the shaker with the drink, which expresses the oils in the peel and rounds the finished product.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Credits

Recipe from T.J. Siegal, Milk & Honey, New York City

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.