I'm checking the Elsevier article sharing policies and I think there is a problem with their license of the accepted manuscript (post-review article). Indeed, the instructions say:
Authors can share their accepted manuscript:
Immediately
- via their non-commercial personal homepage or blog
However,
After the embargo period
- via non-commercial hosting platforms such as their institutional repository
I don't understand the reason of this limitation, but ok, these are the rules.
However, Elsevier requires you to add the CC-BY-NC-ND license notice into the accepted manuscript. But, here's the flaw: if I can distribute the article on my website with CC-BY-NC-ND license, this means that anyone can re-share the article without limitations (excluding commercial intent), so anyone can upload it to any non-commercial repository. This, in turns, means that I can then upload it to my university repository without embargo.
Isn't this an obvious flaw of the Elsevier's policies?