Menu
Review Highlights
“Some tasty flavors I've tried are passion fruit, cookies and cream, EVOO and strawberry, coffee crunch.” in 9 reviews
“My friend and I shared the Exotic Fruits flavor, Buttermilk Blueberry, and Matcha Rocky Road.” in 5 reviews
“I was able to try the miso cherry and the chocolate torta and they're awesome but I'd definitely recommend the chocolate torta.” in 4 reviews
Location & Hours
Other Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Nearby
in Shaved Ice, Desserts, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
in Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about OddFellows Ice Cream Co..
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
157 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- 185133Jun 17, 2024
The flavors here are so unique. The fluffy peanut butter flavor was delicious and they had the perfect ratio of peanut butter to ice cream. The service is also great (funny & sweet) and the ambiance inside feels like an old-school ice cream shop. I love this place and if you want to try unique flavors come here!
Helpful 1Thanks 2Love this 0Oh no 0 - 279334379Jun 5, 2024
Decent sized ice cream shop near the water, so a really convenient location to stop by at on a hotter day. Unfortunately, many other people had the same idea, and the store was absolutely packed. It took ~20 minutes to get a scoop!
I got a coffee and pecan crunch ice cream, and it was good. Strong coffee flavor which was great, and the pecans added a nice crunch. I do wish there were a lot more pecans though.
Overall, not super special ice cream, and since it's such a good location, I expect the wait to always be pretty long!Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - May 13, 2024
A cute little story near the brooklyn bridge with a lot of unique flavors. I tested the banofee pie (my second favorite I enjoyed the banana and graham cracker flavors), the miso peanut butter ( really good and rich but I didn't want more than one taste of it since it was so rich) and the vegan coconut mochi mango (really good and the one I chose for a scoop! Got a little too sweet at the end)
Prices are definitely a little steep and it was wild to me that the soft serve cost more than a scoop.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jun 13, 20241 check-in
As a lover of unique ice cream flavors, I'd been wanting to try OddFellows Ice Cream Co. for a while. This location wasn't busy on a Sunday (late) afternoon. The interior had red and white striped walls, a large lit up sign, and some seating. Most of the flavors were tamer than I had expected, and some of them had run out by that point in the day. My sister and I chose the Miso Cherry, and got a small cup to share. I really liked it, especially with the real pieces of cherry mixed in. My boyfriend said it tasted like someone had spilled soy sauce into ice cream, but inventive flavors aren't for everyone. Would definitely return to try more!
Helpful 2Thanks 1Love this 2Oh no 0 - Jul 26, 2023
An ice cream float from OddFellows could not have been a better summer treat under the raging sun. We only saw signs for ice cream and boozy root beer floats plastered on the window outside, so it was a happy surprise to see ice cream floats on the menu. The loveliest workers there let me sample the matcha and coconut mango sticky rice flavors. My husband really enjoyed the latter, so we got that for our float. There were mochi bits in there to mimic sticky rice; it tasted nothing like sticky rice but the texture def added a little oomph. He also chose cream soda to go with the ice cream. We were blown away by how the worker poured the soda into our cup; we kept thinking it would overflow at any second but damn was she precise. We were thrilled that we got to take the remaining soda in the glass bottle to go. 10/10 would come back again for another float.
Note: they only have b0oZy root beer floats.Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - 44503584Nov 29, 2023Updated review
Lovely little ice cream shop that served quality ice cream with a good variety of flavors! They're known for their quirky, unique flavors that rotate.
I suggest checking in advance if they have flavors you might like since sometimes the flavors are sooo unusual that not a single one tickles my fancy and wasn't worth the trip over.
There's some seating inside and the service is always pleasant and quick. The queue can get long, especially if people are trying lots of flavors before ordering.Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 0Oh no 0Feb 6, 2019Previous reviewGreat little spot. The ice creams here are VERY UNIQUE and out of the box.
I had 5 different flavors:
PB&J: so good. Very peanut buttery and intense.
Black pepper fig: liked this too. So unique! The black pepper does get overwhelming after half a scoop.
Sesame Nutella: love love love! I don't taste the Nutella nearly as strongly as I hoped. But I still liked this!
Vanilla: typical vanilla. Not amazing to me, but my friend liked it.
Evoo blood orange: an okay flavor. The evoo flavor is strong. Wish the blood orange was more intense and zingy. - 35464992Oct 7, 2023
Not my favorite specialty ice cream place. It was not busy when we got there so we chatted with the employee (Luna?) about their ice cream offerings and ice cream in general. We had the tales marshmallow skies and the green hills of Pandan, two of the flavors part of the Sonic collaboration. About $14 for two smalls. The small was a lot for me but I think it's because they were too sweet.
Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Sep 28, 2023
We came in the nick of time before a group of kids came in. Managed to try some of the flavors and decided on cookie jar and the strawberry rose Sonic the hedgehog collaboration. I enjoyed the cookie jar as it's a mix of birthday sprinkle, cookie dough, cookies and cream which are some of my faves. My daughter enjoyed the strawberry rose but I thought it was a bit artificial. The sugar cone was delicious and must get with your ice cream.
There is a bathroom inside.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Mar 26, 2023
I'm not even a big ice cream person, but I have to say I was thoroughly impressed with the flavors they had to offer.
After sampling quite a few flavors, we went with the banoffee pie and coconut mango sticky rice. Banoffee pie was sweet and creamy and tasted like bananas, and the coconut mango sticky rice had chewy bits of mochi (?) that added to the texture.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - 595212908Jan 17, 2023Updated review
Keepin it real out here in Dumbo
My first time trying this expensive ice cream, actually we got it for our photoshoot, unfortunately dropped it before i had a chance to even try it. The workers were super cool and hooked us up with another scoop, that def made the ice cream taste better. The ice cream actually tasted great. I can appreciate all the classic & unique flavors. It was great in the winter, can't wait to grab a scoop in the summer and enjoy it by the water.Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 2Oh no 0Oct 30, 2022Previous reviewKeepin it real out here in Dumbo
Def some pricey ice cream (still reasonable for the location), but they definitely justified it with the quality and all the amazing flavors. The staff were super helpful with helping us choosing the best flavors. On a nice sunny day, some OddFellows ice cream by the water, doesn't get better than that.
You Might Also Consider
in Juice Bars & Smoothies
in Desserts, Bakeries