The 11 Best Reef-safe Sunscreens of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Best Overall

Thrive Natural Care Body Mineral Sunscreen

View on Amazon View on Thrivecare.co

While many reef-safe sunscreens have a grainy texture or leave a white cast, Thrive's Body Mineral Sunscreen felt like a moisturizing lotion, impressing us enough to give it our top spot. It came out of the container easily and rubbed into our skin smoothly. It absorbed within a minute on our hands, arms, and other parts of our body and took longer to fully absorb into our face and neck areas, but within 15 minutes it felt like a silky moisturizer on our skin. The scent was mildly herbal and floral, and did not smell artificial, which we appreciated. It never felt cloying, oily, or sticky, and there was no irritation or dryness.

This sunscreen does not transfer to other fabrics or surfaces and is water-resistant for up to 80 minutes. We reapplied after this time and didn't burn at all in the hot Mexican sunshine. We were also impressed with how long the bottle lasted — we used it extensively during a five-day vacation to Mexico, applying it three times daily, and only went through half of the container. This does help offset the high price, although those on a budget may have a hard time with the price tag. That being said, we think it is worth the investment considering how great it feels on our skin and how well it works.

The Details: 50 SPF | 5.8 ounces | 80 minutes of water resistance

Best for Water Sports

Maui Naturals Surfer Honey All Natural Sunscreen Lotion SPF 30

View on Mauirain.com

Whether you're swimming, surfing, or snorkeling, you need a sunscreen that will continue to protect your skin long after it's become wet. While Hawaii officially banned non-reef-safe sunscreens in 2021, Maui Naturals has been making our top-scoring Maui Surfer Honey sunscreen since 2009, thanks to its quick absorption qualities and its ability to stay put. We love that the sunscreen didn’t transfer or come off after a sweaty workout, and we think the formula sets in perfectly for a variety of outdoor activities.

The formula is creamy and hydrating and reminds us of a daily moisturizer thanks to its lightweight texture. It's easy to apply and feels gentle even on sensitive skin. Made in Hawaii, the reef-friendly formula is free of harmful chemicals like oxybenzone, petrochemicals, and nanoparticles, and includes natural ingredients like aloe vera, jojoba oil, and honey. We’re big fans of the hint-of-marshmallow aroma that comes from the sunscreen, as we found it to be subtle and sweet. The sunscreen is an off-white shade and left a little white cast that went away after the lotion had a few minutes to set into the skin.

The Details: 30 SPF | 3 ounces | Up to 80 minutes of water resistance

Best Scent

Hawaiian Tropic Mineral Sun Milk Body Lotion SPF 50

$13 at Amazon $15 at Target $18 at Walgreens

This Hawaiian Tropic sunscreen will instantly transport you to the beach thanks to its subtle but deliciously tropical scents. The milky texture applies like silk on the skin and, although it’s a little watery, it absorbs quickly without leaving a pesky residue behind. Plus, it didn't transfer at all when we rubbed our arms with a black T-shirt after application. While working out and swimming in the pool, none of the sunscreen came off or felt slimy, which led us to believe that this sun lotion lives up to its 80-minute water resistance.

We love the button applicator for applying the sunscreen, but we wish the bottle was more durable to avoid any possibility of spills occurring in a suitcase. That being said, we still think this is one of the best sunscreens we tried thanks to the silky texture, moisturizing effect, and sweet island aroma.

The Details: 50 SPF | 1.7 ounces, 3.4 ounces | Up to 80 minutes of water resistance

Best Fragrance-free

Blue Lizard Sensitive Mineral Sunscreen SPF 50

$15 at Amazon $15 at Target $21 at Walmart

For travelers looking for sunscreen that doesn’t have any added scent, this tube of Blue Lizard lotion is your best option. We’re big fans of the hydrating liquid texture that comes out of the bottle seamlessly and easily spreads around the body. Blue Lizard uses smart-cap technology that makes the cap of this tube change from translucent to blue if there is a harmful level of UV rays outside, so all you have to do is take the bottle out of your bag to see if applying is urgently needed. Because the formula is very watery, it might take some extra rubbing in to get the sunscreen to absorb, so we think the formula is best designed for dry skin rather than oily skin combinations. The sunscreen has a slight white cast and a residual greasiness, but it still feels hydrating and lightweight.

The Details: 50 SPF | 5 ounces | Up to 80 minutes of water resistance

Best Sheer

Pipette Mineral Sunscreen

$22 at Amazon $15 at Target View on Pipettebaby.com

Mineral sunscreen has a bad rap for being overly thick and pasty, but the Pipette Mineral Sunscreen defies expectations by absorbing quickly without leaving any white cast or greasy residue behind. The non-nano zinc oxide formula provides broad-spectrum protection from harmful UV rays without damaging coral reefs, so you can feel good whether you’re swimming or snorkeling in the ocean. Other natural ingredients include sugarcane-derived squalene to help make the texture extra spreadable and red gooseberry extract for sun protection to create a formula that is designed to be gentle enough for babies, toddlers, and children. We did notice that after getting out of the water, some of the sunscreen ran off and transferred to a shirt, but it didn’t cause any skin irritation or stinging in the eyes.

The Details: 50 SPF | 4 ounces

Best for Families

Reef Repair Reef Safe Sunscreen SPF 50

View on Reefrepair.com

We think the gentle and natural ingredients in Reef Repair’s Suncream make it an excellent choice for the entire family. The purchase includes two 1.7-ounce tubes of sunscreen that you can easily pack in a carry-on or personal item bag without having to worry about stocking up when you arrive at your destination. We loved that a little bit of the thicker-consistency sunscreen provides plenty of coverage, and it blends in quickly. It did feel a little sticky during application and slightly chalky when it dried, but the sunscreen stayed put when the skin came into contact with water, so it will work well for water activities. In addition, the formula is kid- and reef-friendly. It doesn’t include oxybenzone or octinoxate, so you can relax on vacation knowing you’re protecting reefs and wildlife as well as your family, too.

The Details: 30 SPF | 1.7 ounces | Up to 40 minutes of water resistance

Best for Sensitive Skin

MDSolarSciences Mineral Creme

$32 at Amazon View on Mdsolarsciences.com $43 at Dermstore

We love that this TSA-approved MDSolarSciences sunscreen uses ingredients like titanium dioxide and zinc that are designed for sensitivities like acne- or rosacea-prone skin but are still reef-friendly. For extra transparency, you can click on the name of every ingredient included in the sunscreen to learn more about its purpose on the MDSolarSciences site. When it comes to mineral sun lotions, this one was a bit thick, but after rubbing it in thoroughly, the white cast went away, and it absorbed into the body and face evenly. When on vacation, many people bring sunscreen for the face and another tube for the rest of the body, but this product does it all so you can pack less. Since the formula is gentle on the body and face, we think this is an excellent all-in-one sunscreen that is easy to travel with, too.

The Details: 50 SPF | 1.7 ounces, 3.4 ounces | 80 minutes of water resistance

Best Splurge

Isdin Eryfotona Actinica Mineral SPF 50+ Sunscreen

$70 at Amazon $70 at Isdin.com $73 at Dermstore

If you like to splurge on your skincare, you'll be hard-pressed to find a better sunscreen than Isdin's mineral sunscreen. Although this lightweight formula does leave a slight white cast when first applied, it absorbs into the skin quickly and turns into a sheer effect. The watery texture — a welcome difference from thick, goopy sunscreens — also helps you cover more surface area with a smaller amount.

"I put on a ton of sunscreen on the back of my hand (more than two fingers worth), and it disappeared pretty much instantly once I spread it on," said Travel + Leisure testing editor Jackie Cucco. "This makes it more realistic to actually apply the real amount you're supposed to use since it doesn't get messy."

Since this sunscreen is meant for your face, Cucco loved that it didn't feel greasy or oily on her skin, and instead gave a slight matte effect that worked great under makeup. When it came time to wash her hands or apply hand sanitizer, the sunscreen stayed put and didn't need reapplication. She never saw it run while sweating out in the sun, either. The only downside to this product is its high price point, but it's well worth the money in our opinion, and the size is decent for skincare.

The Details: 50 SPF | 3.4 ounces | Up to 40 minutes of water resistance

Best Stick

Vertra Invisible Sunscreen Face Stick

View on Vertra.com

If you're looking for easy sunscreen application, it doesn't get much simpler than Vertra's Invisible Sunscreen Stick. T+L editor Taylor Fox described it as "ChapStick for your face" and loved that she didn't have to rub it in to get good coverage. "It doesn't feel dry at all, and I wouldn't really say it's greasy either," she says.

Fox tested the clear version of this sunscreen and found that it didn't rub, transfer, or create any white cast. You can also purchase tinted options that will provide more coverage if you wish. The sunscreen didn't run due to sweat or water, and Fox didn't feel like she had to reapply it more frequently than advertised. That being said, she wouldn't suggest applying it over makeup because it would probably smear due to the application design. The stick is quite small, which was handy for packing but could get a little annoying if it falls to the bottom of your bag, and you have to dig around to find it. Overall, we feel like this is a good option for light packers and people who don't want to touch their face when applying and reapplying sunscreen.

The Details: 45 SPF | 0.35 ounces | Up to 80 minutes of water resistance

Best for Face

Tatcha The Silk Sunscreen

$64 at Sephora $62 at Kohls.com

Finding a sunscreen that looks and feels good on your face can be tricky, but luxury brand Tatcha makes the choice much easier. This sunscreen performs double duty by providing SPF 50 sun protection and offering a host of benefits for your face thanks to skin-friendly ingredients like hyaluronic acid and niacinamide, which help with hydration and creating an even complexion. Silk extracts leave a smooth finish and help skin look radiant alone or under makeup.

We found this sunscreen easy to get out of the container and liked the watery texture that didn't feel sticky or thick. It is incredibly lightweight and truly lives up to its name — we felt like there was nothing on our skin after applying. Regardless, the sunscreen still provided excellent protection when reapplied correctly. It is fragrance-free, which we appreciated as a face sunscreen worn so close to our nose, and it has a slight peach tint that disappears after blending. We did take this sunscreen with us on a trip and found that the bottle had exploded in our suitcase during our flight, which was a hassle to clean up and made us lose quite a bit of product. We would love to see a bottle design in the future that would prevent something like this from happening. Otherwise, we loved how this felt on our face and will be using it again.

The Details: 50 SPF | 1.7 ounces