The 7 Best Tortilla Warmers for Your Next Taco Night

Best Overall

IMUSA Sunburst Cloth Tortilla Warmer

$13 at Amazon $24 at Walmart $5 at Sur La Table

Cloth is a preferred material for many cooks, both amateur and professional. This warmer comes in two sizes (10 and 12 inches) and multiple designs, keeping up to 12 tortillas warm for over an hour without them getting soggy. Heat your tortillas as usual and then throw them inside the polyester pouch to maintain heat or take them directly from a store-bought package, stack them in the warmer, and microwave anywhere from 15 seconds to a minute, depending on how many tortillas are inside. Even if you've never used a tool like this before, it's hard to go wrong with the directions printed on the back.

Compared to other warmers, it's lightweight and easy to store—even on your wall as a bright addition to your kitchen. Use it for pitas, wraps, arepas, pancakes, biscuits, and more. The two-sided food-grade plastic insulation will maintain temperature and keep contents soft. Just steer clear of fried and oily foods or you're bound for stains. Hand washing is recommended, although you may machine wash on gentle. Turning inside out is advised to protect the longevity of the fabric, and air drying is a must. This product is not oven safe.

Sizes: 10 inches, 12 inches | Material: Polyester, plastic | Microwave Safe: Yes

Best Ceramic

KooK Ceramic Tortilla Warmer

$30 at Amazon $35 at Walmart

Eye-catching colors adorn this hand-painted, durable warmer, which measures just under 9 inches in diameter. Made of ceramic, it's microwave-safe, but you might have to wear oven mitts when taking it out. It's also top-rack dishwasher-safe and can hold up to 12 standard tortillas. You should not use it in the oven though.

The top on this model is semi-fitted to allow steam to escape, while keeping tortillas warm. Although, as with other lidded warmers, condensation is a concern. To alleviate heat loss, line the interior with a dish towel or napkin once you remove it from the oven or microwave. This will doubly insulate your tortillas and keep the bottom ones from sticking to the ceramic. Though Kook does package this well, reviewers have sometimes received a chipped version. When that happens, the company quickly sends a replacement.

Dimensions: 8.5 x 4 inches | Material: Ceramic | Microwave Safe: Yes

Best Terracotta

Fox Run Terra Cotta Tortilla Warmer

$24 at Walmart $30 at Home Depot View on Lehmans.com

Terracotta, or “baked earth” in Italian, is one of the oldest materials used to cook food. I own this model and love the beauty of the design, as well as the ease of use. It is slightly smaller with a 7 x 2.75-inch interior space, but it still accommodates 12 standard tortillas. It can be heated in an oven up to 464 degrees, although it is microwave safe if you're crunched for time, and the glazed interior will keep tortillas warm for up to 30 minutes. I extend this by lining the warmer with a dish towel or aluminum foil after the tortillas come out of the oven. 

To use this extremely attractive warmer, soak the base in warm water, and then heat the base and lid. The glaze inhibits the natural steaming advantages of terracotta, so the moisture from the water bath keeps the tortillas soft without getting them wet. Unlike unglazed clay options, this model does not absorb oils and odors, providing for easy cleanup. Don't put it in the dishwasher, though. Just wipe it down with a damp cloth or paper towel.

Dimensions: 8.5 x 4.75 inches | Material: Terracotta clay | Microwave Safe: Yes

Best Plastic

Nordic Ware Tortilla Warmer

$14 at Amazon $14 at Walmart $21 at Wayfair

The workhorse of many Mexican restaurants, plastic tortilla warmers remain affordable, easy-to-use options for dinner at home. Made from durable, BPA-free, and melamine-free polypropylene, this one can comfortably hold 12 to 14 standard tortillas. It's meant for heating tortillas in the microwave only, though, and should not be placed in the oven. It can be cleaned in the dishwasher on the top shelf, but because of the resin-like plastic, it may only require a quick wipe with a damp towel.

A quick 30 to 45 seconds in the microwave yields tortillas that will hold heat for up to 20 minutes. Perhaps the biggest advantage it offers is the small hole in the cover to ventilate steam, keeping tortillas from getting soggy. With its attractive sunburst design, this kitchen accessory makes an efficient and inexpensive option for any dinner table.

Dimensions: 10.5 x 3.9 inches | Material: Plastic | Microwave Safe: Yes

Best Large-Scale

Norpro Tortilla and Pancake Keeper

$23 at Amazon $23 at Walmart

If you have a big, hungry family, the Norpro Tortilla and Pancake Keeper is the solution. At almost 10 x 10 inches, it can accommodate up to 30 standard tortillas. The plastic construction is one of the thickest, sturdiest materials of any warmer on this list, is microwave safe, and can be washed in the dishwasher on the top shelf. It is not meant for oven use.

With such a cavernous interior, heat should dissipate quickly, but your tortillas will remain warm for up to 30 minutes thanks to top-tier insulation. That said, condensation can be an issue. This is often easily fixed by wrapping your tortillas in wax paper before heating. As a bonus, this warmer makes the perfect vehicle for keeping flatbreads, chapatis, pancakes, or even beans and rice, but it is also large enough to hold pasta, veggies, or even cold dishes, like potato salad.

Dimensions: 9.75 x 4.75 inches | Material: Plastic | Microwave Safe: Yes

Best Decorative

Su Casa Bonita Blue Talavera Tortilla Holder

$55 at Etsy

If you're looking for a beautiful art piece to hold your tortillas, look no further. This one is handmade in Mexico, featuring lead-free and fade-resistant paint, and each order is unique. It's microwave safe, can be used in the oven at a low temperature, and is safe in the dishwasher, but with any hand-painted item, hand washing is a better choice. This gorgeous 8 x 8 x 6-inch dish is large enough to hold 12 standard tortillas. 

For best results and longevity, warm your tortillas on a griddle or in a cast-iron pan ahead of dinner, and then place them in a warmer in the oven at low temperature. This allows time for you to prepare fillings for your feast. When you're ready to open the taco bar, grab some oven mitts, pull out the warmer, and enjoy warm, flexible tortillas.

Dimensions: 8 x 6 inches | Material: Ceramic | Microwave Safe: Yes

Best Stoneware

RSVP International Stoneware Tortilla Warmer

$30 at Amazon $47 at Walmart $31 at Wayfair

When choosing a tortilla warmer, you may wonder what the difference is between ceramic and stoneware. Stoneware is a type of ceramic that has a thick, porous exterior that's more durable than other ceramic materials. The RSVP Stoneware Tortilla Warmer is a heavy-duty choice for taco enthusiasts and cooks in general, as it can be used for other dishes, like baked brie. The food-safe, glazed, and lead-free stoneware can be used in the microwave or oven up to 350 degrees.

Due to the high firing temperature of stoneware, it holds heat much longer than other options—in this case, up to an hour. For family dinners, this one has the capacity for up to 20 8-inch tortillas. Placing a damp paper towel under the lid when finished heating will distribute some moisture to counterbalance the dry heat stoneware typically produces. It's safe for use in the dishwasher, though it's wise to hand wash because the material is so porous and weighty.

Dimensions: 8.5 x 3 inches, 10 x 3 inches | Material: Glazed stone | Microwave Safe: Yes