This week the documentary 'You cannot milk a Black-tailed Godwit' will premier in my home country of The Netherlands. It follows a Frisian dairy farmer who warmly welcomes each spring a large numbers of meadow-birds on his land to breed, including the Netherlands' National Bird the Black-tailed Godwit, and their families.
The trailer already shows the profound love of farmer Bote de Boer for 'his' birds. It is the same love I saw when interviewing a Dutch mixed-poultry farmer on the implementation of EU water protection law when I was a student: With tears in his eyes he told me about showing his grandson a White stork, something which his father had shown him in the 1950's, however something he could never show his own son in the 1980's when frogs disappeared from their land and the storks with it.
The movie also shows how Bote is exceptional, and how other farmers -including his own sons- point out that his way of farming is not viable despite public subsidies. While environmental efficiencies and pollution control by farmers made the return of the Storks above and other freshwater nature possible, the combined economic roadmap presented to Dutch farmers today is still one of post-war intensification for 'food security', requiring big investment to stay afloat against low market power (and pay back these large technical investments to banks). And it has turned most Dutch meadows into giant pool table, single-species grass plantation.
Bote is convinced that it does not have to be this way, and I agree. At the same time I fully understand that most farmers with similar ideals but fewer means or supportive family like Bote, do not feel taken seriously. None of this is news. And when the European Commission presented in 2009 its vision for a European Green Deal and 'Farm to Fork Strategy' that 'would leave no one behind', I was very hopeful for a fairer, credible, more coherent, and more predictable policy and corresponding legal framework.
Today I was relieved that the #NatureRestorationLaw can help provide more credibility and predictability on the environmental side of this equation. At the same time I have a bitter aftertaste about the large political capital spent on sowing division - almost successfully. While burning bridges is the least thing we need in succeeding on the other sides of the equation: Fairness and coherence.
Only this could facilitate a different economic roadmap than today, and one that is not only attractive enough for farmers like Bote, but also for his sons. There are plenty of local examples where this is already possible today, but they lack scale. Therefore I hope that the upcoming European elections will vote in a new set of lawmakers that are genuinely committed to deliver on this unmet part of the Green Deal.
Next week I will watch this this documentary in The Netherlands together with my own father. Hope it will inspire my and others future work on a more restorative future for nature and caring farmers.
Engenheiro Florestal | Engenheiro de Meio Ambiente | Engenheiro de Segurança do Trabalho | PRAD | QSMS | Gestão Ambiental | Licenciamento Ambiental
3wA área melhor de trabalhar! Show!