At a high level, acquiring ad space in the living room is a great move for the future. But I'm not sure Walmart has the software DNA to execute a smartTV OS platform strategy using Vizio's SmartCast, WatchFree+, and TVs. They will have to invest significantly to scale operations to compete against Amazon and Roku, in particular. Even Samsung with its engineering resources and chops makes a so-so smartTV experience.
Although Walmart sees potential for growing the rapidly expanding Vizio Platform business, there could be some challenges with swallowing the Vizio business in whole including the TV hardware business. Walmart will have to continue to expand the existing scale of SmartCast adoption (18M SmartCast accounts), which trail competitors at 200M Fire TV units sold vs. 150M active Google TV units vs. 80M Roku active accounts (not apples-to-apples but provides sense of scale). If Best Buy decides to slow or cease sales of 'Walmart TVs', that could slow adoption of SmartCast, for example. Can Walmart make up for any shortfalls in TV sales through its proprietary offline and online channels? Moreover, margins on TVs are razor thin (Walmart is accustomed thin-margins) and Walmart may have done better by acquiring a pure TV OS platform like Roku, rather than Vizio, which has greater global scale, resources, and a TV OEM partner ecosystem.
If done right, perhaps the TV is a ripe platform for e-commerce and (AI) innovation. Walmart could offer flash sales slotted as commercials (a new and improved 30 second HSN experience), pizza delivery during games (before/during sports events), exclusive live music concert streaming and much more.
Tangentially, I continue to believe Meta and Roku would make for an ultimate strategic and accretive tie up. Meta is advertising. Meta has the ad sales and tech infrastructure in place that Roku is trying to re-invent. Meta could use the TV platform as a defensive position against Apple TV+. Meta could allocate a percent of the capital it's spending on metaverse to expand Roku globally. What's more social than TV?
And for Comcast, SmartTVs are the new STBs! They could offer a 55"/65"/75" X1 OS TV for $25-$35/month packaged with Internet and OTT services including sports. It was always their game to lose and as they continue to bleed subscribers each quarter, it's time they took a chance to reinvent the business.
Senior Client Partner at Uber
1moLet’s goooooo Patrick Colletto! 🚀🚀