Author of six books, founder of a magazine (Entertainment Weekly), creator of three journalism degrees (at CUNY; now emeritus...more soon). Available for speaking, boards, consulting
In my paper on California's Journalism Preservation Act, I examine the long history of newspapers' hostile reception of new technologies and competitors, from radio to AI. It's quite a tale. Here's that section from the paper: https://lnkd.in/e3mB2B9p
As ever, Jeff, correctly observed. FLASH: Newspapers could be selfish jerks. But even the jerkiest also did substantial social good in town after town. Papers breathed life-giving coverage into community events and activities, provided basic watch dog functions and occasionally committed acts of courage on behalf of the voiceless, all while paying US taxes and facing down physical threats and lawsuits. Reading you, it's hard to imagine you ever worked in a newsroom that did the difficult things. And what about those you exalt? Hisself, the harmless nerd tending his kludgy website? What has he put back after his nationwide strip-mining destabilized local democracies? Those profits, sluiced from every zip code, fund things named after ... Hisself. What about his Soul Bros at the platforms? They are, if anything, more predatory than newspapers were, crushing competition. In your serial uxoriations, you are reliably indifferent to their ill effects on youth/women/democracy. Section 230 is a massive subsidy of today's wealthiest jerks, saving them from hiring moderators, lawyers, insurers. Surely by now even Silicon Publishing's Whataboutist-in-Chief could support trillion-dollar platforms shouldering grown-up business costs?
I suspect that this is behavior that may be termed "reasonable under the circumstances" (leastwise from the incumbent newspaper's perspective).
Author of six books, founder of a magazine (Entertainment Weekly), creator of three journalism degrees (at CUNY; now emeritus...more soon). Available for speaking, boards, consulting
3moReminder: What I post on Medium, I also post on my blog, Buzzmachine: https://buzzmachine.com/2024/04/15/newspapers-can-be-jerks/