Jesse Cooke’s Post

View profile for Jesse Cooke, graphic

NY and PA Insurance Defense Litigator / History Buff-alonian

30 years ago on June 23, 1994, Oakland A’s pitcher Bobby Witt watches his would-be perfect game vanish before his eyes after a caught-on-tape, verifiably lousy call by umpire Gary Cederstrom. Witt had set down every one of the Royals’ first 16 batters before Kansas City's Greg Gagne's 6th inning bunt. The video left no doubt that Gagne was out when A’s first baseman Troy Neel threw to Witt covering the bag, but the ump called Gagne safe. There was no instant replay, coach’s challenge, appeals process, or anything else to do about it. Immediately thereafter, Witt recalled “my mindset was that I was going to show him and everybody else that he was wrong.” This winning attitude was nothing new to the player who persevered through the nickname "Witt n' Wild" due to control problems early in his major league career as a Texas Ranger. After the rotten call, Witt went on to have a one-hit shutout for what would be the best game of his career. Six days after that near perfect game, his son Bobby Witt, Jr. was born. 25 years later, Bobby Jr. was drafted by the Kansas City Royals as the second overall pick in the 2019 draft. Witt, Sr. says, “I just love watching him play. It doesn’t matter if he succeeds or not. Just having him do what he loves the way he does it, any father would cherish that.” Oh, but Bobby Jr. is definitely succeeding. ESPN reported just this past week, “Since the end of July 2023, Witt has been the best player in baseball.” And Witt, Sr. is his son’s biggest fan. Last year, Witt, Sr. was at Globe Life Field in Arlington, TX where his son and the Royals were playing the Rangers. In the 9th inning, Bobby Jr. sent a fly ball into the stands. Of the 17,760 fans in attendance, you’ll never guess where that ball landed. If I may respectfully suggest a point to all this: One day you’re starting your dream job, The next day the peanut gallery’s calling you names because your execution is a little off, Another day your performance is damn near perfect, When the next thing you know you’re on the losing end of a bad call. But if you stay vigilant in keeping your best attitude, with luck, one day, maybe a generation from now, you might find yourself in the box suite of your life watching some kid set the world on fire all because you played the long game, and remembered what was important, and didn’t let the small stuff get you down. And if you’re like Bobby Witt, Sr., that kid setting the world on fire might even handwrite a message on a very special souvenir ball: “Hit by Bobby Witt Jr. Caught by Bobby Witt Sr. April 11, 2023.”

  • No alternative text description for this image
Jesse Cooke

NY and PA Insurance Defense Litigator / History Buff-alonian

3w

It always feels so cool when Paul Hartzell reads my stuff.

Christian Martin AIC, LPCS

Sr. Vice President - Chief Claims Officer at Berkley Entertainment (a Berkley Company)

3w

Can never have too many of these baseball stories! 👊

Mark Snyder

P&C insurance claims knowledge source

3w

Great story!

Gordon McCallum

Collaborating to Support Healthcare Workforce Management Needs

3w

Wow what an amazing story! Thank you Jesse Cooke for putting this together!

Sean Fodera

📚 𝐈𝐏 𝐃𝐞𝐚𝐥 𝐌𝐚𝐤𝐞𝐫, 𝐍𝐞𝐠𝐨𝐭𝐢𝐚𝐭𝐨𝐫, 𝐄-𝐛𝐨𝐨𝐤 𝐈𝐧𝐧𝐨𝐯𝐚𝐭𝐨𝐫

3w

I never really got to "watch" my kids play baseball and softball. I was coaching both of them for 12 years, and experienced the highs and lows of their careers up close and personal. Then I played alongside them in a very competitive softball league for five years. Me on the mound, my daughter at second, and my son in center (and my now-son-in-law in left center). If you hit the ball off me, you had better have hit it down the lines, because the Foderas were not going to let you get far on the basepaths.

Byron "Garry" Stewart

Attorney at Law at Byron G. Stewart

3w

You have made your Kansas City connections extremely happy with this post Jesse Cooke. Not to mention the life lessons, and business lessons, it contains for all of us. The only thing I would add is that the Oakland A's used to be the Kansas City A's from 1954 to 1967, and began play as the Philadelphia A's in 1901.

Dan Weeks

Senior Editor US, Markets 360 at BNP Paribas CIB | Series 7/Series 24/Series 63 Licensed

3w

"control problems early in his major league career as a Texas Ranger" To say the least. Specifically, Witt gave up more than 100 walks in six of his first seven MLB seasons. But to give credit where credit is due, after 1992 he never walked 100 batters in a full season. And losing the perfect game must have been awful, but how much more awful would it be to pitch perfect baseball for 12 innings and then lose the perfect game, the no-hitter and the game itself in the 13th inning? (Harvey Haddix, May 26, 1959.) https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/MLN/MLN195905260.shtml

Even with today’s technology umpires continue to make terrible calls that can influence the outcome of a game.

Like
Reply
Armando Batastini

Office Managing Partner, Providence Office, Nixon Peabody LLP; Rhode Island Bar Foundation President

3w

I was at this game -- had just gotten out of the Navy and driven cross-country to visit friends. Awful call; great story.

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics