Chief Innovation Officer (CIO) / Head of Launch Sevices - Space-Tech LLC President / CTO Gravitec Inc.
Okay, I'm going to say what others are thinking. The Boeing Starliner has way to many reliability issues to be a human-rated spacecraft. Had anything remotely like this had happened with Crewdragon NASA would have pulled the plug. https://lnkd.in/eTnaEBhE
Oh my goodness. No. When we experience any kind of test failure or anomaly (and this is a flight TEST), we do what is known as a Stop Work, and hold the test configuration until the root cause can be identified. With all the helium leaks and RCS issues, they need to identify the cause in the closest configuration to the identification of the problem before they change things up and lose traceability. Choosing to pause and evaluate is not "stuck and can't come home". They may very well be able to come back tomorrow, at the cost of permanent loss of any chance to figure out what went awry and how to fix it. Although there may be further undisclosed issues, nothing currently publicly acknowledged indicates that they are actually stuck. At the moment.
It’s because all the issues are in the service module. Theyre staying on orbit for testing because when they come back and jettison it will burn up.
They launched with a helium leak. This is the type of thing I would expect from my Aerospace Engineering students when launching their senior project liquid rocket.
NASA should admit that Boeing just built a dud. Don't risk the human crew just for Boeing's ego. Send SpaceX Dragon to bring them back to Earth safely.🙏
For every human launch made, ideally there should be an extra launch vehicle with an empty capsule on hot stand by. Of course, that would be quite expensive redundancy to keep in place.
At least no parts from the Starliner flew off during launch! 🤣🤣 They should shutdown operations at Boeing, overhaul all the management teams, and replace those MBAs at the top of the decision hierarchy with engineers and people with hands on experience from the factory floor! Also, send a SpaceX capsule to bring those astronauts safely to earth! 🥸
I bet it works about as well as their airplanes... hope the crew brought duct tape and extra bolts... I refuse to fly on a Boeing aircraft and wouldn't fly on their spacecraft either...
The entity they created to shield themselves from liability just plead guilty to fraud.
I feel bad for the astronauts. They were supposed to return in a week. It's not clear if they would return this month. Stuck or not stuck, they are working overtime away from their families to troubleshoot issues with their spacecraft.
New Frontier Aerospace, Inc.
2wHector, if I were NASA I would reenter Starliner autonomously and bring the crew home on a Dragon. Yes, I know that would be embarrassing for Boeing, but it would be far safer for the crew. And in the long run it would highlight Boeing wisdom (which is hard to come by lately). This probably should have been the plan from the get-go -- safety should be first.