Harry W Severance, MD’s Post

View profile for Harry W Severance, MD, graphic

Consultant/Advisor | Preparedness Proponent | Workforce Advocate | Life Sciences & Research |

Physician-Owned Hospitals versus Corporate Healthcare - Is That the Real Question? This Medscape article by Charlotte Huff discusses existing Federal regulations essentially banning physician-owned hospitals - and new legislative proposals (H.R. 977/S. 470) to lift some of those bans.   This article notes that available reports, analyses, and debaters on f this issue are conflicted on whether physician-run hospitals improve patient outcomes - or just “cherry pick” optimal patients, increase or reduce competition or costs, and improve rural healthcare?   MY TAKE: What SHOULD be looked at - the OTHER SIDE of the equation: What happens when you REMOVE all clinically-practicing doctors and nurses from hospital management decision making groups = totally NON-physician-run hospitals? - Studies should look at similar outcomes analyses from Corporate Healthcare Systems where CLINICALLY PRACTICING doctors and nurses have been progressively and purposefully ELIMINATED (citing conflicts of interest) from senior decision-making boards and policy groups. Link - https://lnkd.in/e35CQxDx FYI: current Federal mandates including Stark Laws, Anti-Kickback Statutes, the Affordable Care Act - all support this corporate mantra of Doctor/Nurse conflict of interest!   I think we would find that – in such corporate situations (now increasingly dominating healthcare) where these major decision-making boards are now made up of and recruited from successful “Captains of Industry” with no clinical backgrounds - and with their focus entirely on profit (what they were recruited for) and with no clinically practicing physician/nurse input= no conscience – that patient outcomes and other measures the article mentions -are worse, healthcare workplaces are more turbulent, violent and increasingly in disarray, more doctors and nurses are quitting healthcare.    – BUT - profits are up. U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, & Pensions American Medical Association American College of Emergency Physicians Tennessee Medical Association Paige Haeffele Michael Arroyo Peter Stavros Chadd Kraus Noah Tong Aria Bendix Joseph Choi Ryan Stanton Molly Gamble Susanna Vogel Molly Fredriksson Deidre McPhillips Gabe Kelen, Erin Schumaker Alison Haddock, MD, FACEP Susan Morse Heather Landi Steven Ross Johnson Ben Leonard Amy Feldman C. Scott Franklin Claire Sandström Christina Jewett Jesse Ehrenfeld MD MPH Kevin Hern Larry Bucshon, M.D. Samantha Koehler Linda Restrepo Linda Lawrence Tisha Titus, MD, MPH Jonathan Fisher, MD, MPH Leon C. Adelman, MD, MBA, FACEP, FAAEM Shannon Firth Hannah Miao

US Lawmakers Could Lift Restrictions on Doc-Owned Hospitals

US Lawmakers Could Lift Restrictions on Doc-Owned Hospitals

medscape.com

Larry Bucshon, M.D.

Member of Congress, Retired Cardiothoracic and Vascular Surgeon

2mo

The moratorium on physician owned hospitals needs lifted. It is only in place to prevent competition. This was part of the deal to get AHA support of the ACA, which included guaranteed annual payment updates in Medicare Part A for 5 years which physicians didn't get in Part B. POHs are shown to decrease costs and the argument they cherry pick patients is not supported by the facts. And the quality data shows similar if not better results at POHs.

Linda Restrepo

EDITOR | PUBLISHER Inner Sanctum Vector N360™

2mo

Absolutely, the financial aspect of healthcare is a crucial but often sensitive topic. In my experience with physician-run hospitals, analyzing procedures for income is a necessary part of ensuring sustainable operations. It's important to recognize that all medical services involve costs and expenses, from paying doctors to purchasing equipment and dealing with insurance mandates. However, the key question remains: does this financial focus improve or jeopardize patient outcomes? The emergence of Medical Clubs in private practices adds another dimension to this discussion, highlighting evolving models of healthcare delivery. It's a complex issue that requires a careful balance between financial sustainability and patient care.

Melissa Yowell

Driving Financial Growth/Operations Optimization/Strategic Business Optimization/Regulatory Compliance

2mo

Competition is always good but the physicians in leadership positions always have to look at the sustainability of the hospital and how it benefits patients. And unfortunately a lot of them just don't get this part of it. You still have to make money to pay salaries and buy the equipment and supplies needed to care for patients and to keep the lights on and machines operating properly.

Like
Reply

Physician run hospitals and clinics and contract management groups seem to be doing pretty well. What many have done is peel off much of the dead administrative weight that non clinical oriented management create.

Like
Reply
Corrine Hibbert.

DrPH MPH BSN CHES® Health Policy & Mgmt | Population Health

2mo

Yes, profits are up, nothing else really matters.

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics