Alexandra Marvar’s Post

View profile for Alexandra Marvar, graphic

Freelance Writer

Permit me a rant: I feel like I'm being bombarded by stories of small businesses, creators, entrepreneurs, start-ups and nonprofits being — frankly — *taken* by "fancy" publicists / PR firms. The Food Section's editor sent out a note this a.m. about a PR firm she engaged that took the (probably 💰💰💰) contract apparently without even the dimmest idea about how to draft a pitch to explain why what she's doing matters. And they later told her as much. She had to, on her own, then come up with an outside-the-box idea — like IRL food events — to build audience. So, like... why did they even take her money? If they didn't know how they were going to do the job? Spoke to a #freelance #journalist this week who was reporting in Ukraine while being *harassed* over text by a publicist who wanted him to change petty inconsequential details (not factual inaccuracies) on a lifestyle story that had run weeks earlier. As if that's OK. Later it was revealed her clients had no idea she was making these requests and she hadn't even passed along this journalist's initial requests for interview for the story. Shocking behavior. And apparently she's one of the biggest names in the game for her industry. I've also watched my copywriting clients go through it. So sad. $5K/month retainer to a supposedly baller PR firm, only to be on weekly calls where literally no progress or action happens in between. And the only "results" are half-baked paywalled articles that run when someone on the account has time to call in a desperate favor. I was grossed out by it. Not all publicists are bad. I know some tremendously thoughtful ones. But some are "smoke and mirrors" as another professional I know recently put it. And some are downright vampires. 👁👁 Anyone else seeing this or is it just me 👁👁 #pr #scams

I will add thank god for people like Jasmine L. Pierce (she's not alone but she definitely comes to mind first!) who geniunely care about and understand their clients

Like
Reply
Brad Kay ⚡️

Founder | Brand Builder | Marketer | Business Insider and Forbes CMO To Watch | Advisor

2mo

Hi Alex! I have much to say about this topic as well. This is the #1 complaint (and request) of our clients for these exact reasons.

Brady Dale

Co-writer on the Axios Crypto newsletter. Please don't pitch on LinkedIn. My 📧 is easy to find.

2mo

As anyone who has worked in a newsroom with me can tell you: Don't even get me started. To say that my view is *considerably dimmer* than yours is an understatement.

Simon Spichak

I Help People Access Affordable Therapy @ Resolvve | Science and Technology Journalist

2mo

When I started out writing, I did a lot of science content on Medium. The funniest thing that happened to me was a PR rep for a supplement company getting in touch with me because they wanted me to write a piece about a certain supplement. Some of my articles on Medium were already pretty skeptical of the supplement space, I assumed they'd read some of my previous pieces. They wanted fair coverage, and the supplement they were offering was mostly supported in mouse studies as well as few limited human studies. They also didn't do a very good job of answering any of the questions I had for the company about how the supplement worked. Long story short, they weren't very happy with the piece I had proposed and ghosted me.

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics