Your team is divided on the project approach. How will you navigate conflicting feedback to ensure success?
Navigating conflicting feedback within a team can be a challenging aspect of project management, but it's a common scenario that tests your leadership skills. As a leader, your role is to steer the team towards a unified approach while respecting diverse opinions and fostering a collaborative environment. It's crucial to address the divide promptly and strategically to ensure the project's success. By understanding the underlying concerns, promoting open communication, and guiding your team through structured decision-making processes, you can transform disagreement into a driving force for innovation and improvement.
-
Nadeem AhmadFollow for posts on leadership & innovation | Tech Exec turned Bestselling Author | Helping leaders navigate innovation…
-
Girish NeelamanaCEO @ Mercedes-Benz Bridgeway Motors | Luxury Advisory Board Member I Founder - Luxility (Luxury Mobility)
-
Sivashankar K KBusiness Development Manager
When faced with a divided team, the first step is to listen actively to all perspectives. Encourage each team member to articulate their views and concerns without interruption. This demonstrates respect for their expertise and commitment to understanding the root of the conflict. By creating a safe space for open dialogue, you'll gain valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each proposed approach, which is essential for informed decision-making.
-
Dr Mahmood Hussain
Founding Partner of M&CO Legal | International Arbitrator | Mediator | Chairperson of the steering committee of the ICC UAE Commission on Arbitration & ADR for the term 2023-2025
When my team is divided, I listen to everyone's ideas and create a safe space for discussion. I focus on our common goals, weigh the pros and cons, and look for a compromise. For example, when my team couldn't agree on whether to expand into the UK market or focus on our current one, I suggested doing both in phases to include everyone's input.
-
Nadeem Ahmad
Follow for posts on leadership & innovation | Tech Exec turned Bestselling Author | Helping leaders navigate innovation in business
When your team is divided on a project approach, success hinges not just on decision-making but on the ability to listen actively to all perspectives. This means not only hearing but fully understanding each team member’s concerns and suggestions. Encourage open discussions where everyone feels safe to express their ideas and concerns without judgment. For example, hold a meeting where each team member can present their viewpoint and the reasoning behind it. This process helps uncover the root of the disagreement and often reveals a middle ground or a new approach that might not have been considered. In an environment where all voices are valued, you can build consensus and guide the team towards a unified, successful project strategy.
-
Elói Guimarães
Planejamento e Gestão de Performance Comercial na Ticket Serviços
Navegar por feedbacks conflitantes requer escuta ativa e entendimento das perspectivas de todos os membros da equipe. É essencial analisar objetivamente cada feedback, considerando dados e impacto no projeto, e identificar pontos comuns. Facilitar a comunicação aberta e respeitosa ajuda a mediar conflitos e promover brainstormings. Avaliar alternativas com a equipe, considerando prós e contras, e alinhar feedbacks aos objetivos do projeto é crucial. Com base nessas discussões, tomar uma decisão informada, documentá-la e monitorar o progresso, ajustando conforme necessário, garante que todos se sintam ouvidos e que a melhor abordagem seja adotada para o sucesso do projeto.
-
Subuhi Zia
Co-Founder & CEO at Noxlumyn | Helping Agencies Unlock Growth One Candidate At A Time
The number of times I have seen a problem snowballing just because of miscommunication is higher than I would like to admit. Here's a quick way to fix the problem as a leader - Mediate - Listen - Resolve In these situations, the best thing a leader can do to be honest is to Just Listen To Both Sides carefully. Chances are both parties have just misunderstood one another and now both of them are feeling unheard. Giving them space to talk and air out their frustrations in a controlled and professional environment helps cool everyone down. And once people have cooled down, they're going to be more amenable to any solutions or resolutions you may have to offer. Often times, they will come up with one on their own!
-
Dorothy B.
Active listening is crucial for project managers to manage conflicts and make informed decisions by addressing disagreements and aligning everyone on the plan. • Conduct a meeting with key stakeholders to understand perspectives. • Analyze issues objectively and identify core areas of disagreement. • Understand the root causes to devise resolution strategies. • Facilitate a collaborative discussion to explore potential solutions. • Use data-driven analysis and visualization tools to evaluate tradeoffs. • Document the agreed-upon plan and communicate to the entire project team. • Establish clear roles and decision-making processes to prevent future conflicts. • Regularly check in with the team to address new issues and make adjustments.
After gathering all viewpoints, it's important to evaluate the feedback objectively. Remove personal biases and focus on the project's goals and constraints. Consider the potential impact of each approach on the project's timeline, budget, and quality. This step requires critical thinking and the ability to weigh the pros and cons of each option without favoritism, leading to a more balanced and strategic decision.
-
Nadeem Ahmad
Follow for posts on leadership & innovation | Tech Exec turned Bestselling Author | Helping leaders navigate innovation in business
Resolving project conflicts requires more than discussion; it demands objective evaluation of all feedback. Assess the impact, feasibility, and alignment with project goals for each proposal. For example, use quantifiable data like estimated costs and potential ROI to evaluate suggestions. This objective framework helps depersonalize discussions and focus on what best advances the project’s success. When you evaluate feedback objectively, you guide your team to a consensus that combines the strengths of all suggestions, ensuring the project moves forward effectively.
-
Jayakumar Mohanachandran
Fractional Chief Information Officer | Advisor | Mentor | Techpreneur | President - CIO Association, UAE, Worlds largest association of Chief Information Officers
After gathering all viewpoints, it's important to evaluate the feedback objectively: - Set aside any personal preferences or allegiances and focus on the project's goals and constraints. - Carefully consider the potential impact of each approach on the project's timeline, budget, and quality.
-
Tonya D. Harrison
Optimizing Business Operations | Empowering New Leaders | Healthcare Consulting | Advisor for Small Business Owners
Navigating conflicting feedback within a team can be challenging but also presents an excellent opportunity for growth and collaboration. The goal is to be as objective as possible. Review all data available. Also, consider the alignment with objectives, identify constraints, and get the entire team's input. Allowing everyone to provide feedback as well as the pros and cons of each option will help others see things from a different perspective. After reviewing all information and feedback, determine the best approach. The solution may include elements from both approaches.
-
Aman Kaur⚡️
Program Manager | Transformation & Strategy | Co-Chair REACH Network (DEI) | STEM Enthusiast
Establish criteria for evaluating the different approaches, such as feasibility, cost, time, potential risks, and alignment with project goals. This provides a clear framework for assessing each option.
-
Octavian Goncalves
Once all opinions have been gathered, I would like to let you know that impartial feedback will be appreciated. Consider how each strategy might affect the project's budget, schedule, and quality. This step necessitates critical thinking and the capacity to objectively assess the benefits and drawbacks of each alternative, resulting in a more strategic and well-rounded choice.
Building consensus is about finding common ground and forging a path forward that the team can collectively support. This involves negotiating and possibly combining elements of different approaches to create a hybrid solution. Facilitate discussions that encourage team members to see the value in each other's perspectives and to compromise where necessary. A consensus-driven approach not only resolves the conflict but also strengthens team cohesion.
-
Girish Neelamana
CEO @ Mercedes-Benz Bridgeway Motors | Luxury Advisory Board Member I Founder - Luxility (Luxury Mobility)
Navigating conflicting feedback within a team requires a strategic approach to build consensus and ensure project success. Begin by actively listening to all perspectives, ensuring each team member feels heard and valued. Facilitate an open discussion to identify common goals and areas of agreement. Use data and evidence to objectively evaluate different approaches, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each. Encourage collaborative problem-solving to integrate the best aspects of each suggestion. If needed, seek a compromise that aligns with the project objectives. Maintain clear communication, fostering a culture of respect and teamwork to drive the project forward effectively.
-
Paul Winnister
Leadership Expert ► I help leaders and organisations thrive in complexity ► Keynote speaking, leadership workshops & executive coaching ► Program Director ► Former Air Force Pilot
Consensus isn't about decision by committee, as ultimately the accountable person needs to make the call. It's about blending the different ideas and taking the best of each to come up with the most suitable path forward. If you've actively listened to each person's ideas, and discussed the pros and cons, the building consensus is easier. Even if that person's idea does not feature in the final decision, they will recognise that their idea has been considered and will be more likely to get behind the option that's decided. This dynamic is especially true when building a consensus around a project - as there will be multiple options and the way ahead may not be clear. But someone has to pick one, and bring the team behind it.
-
Sivashankar K K
Business Development Manager
To move forward, I strive to build consensus among the team. I facilitate discussions that aim to align everyone's interests and find a middle ground. In one project, I organized a brainstorming session where we merged different ideas into a hybrid approach. This collaborative effort not only satisfied most team members but also led to a more innovative solution. Building consensus helps in creating a unified team direction.
-
Jayakumar Mohanachandran
Fractional Chief Information Officer | Advisor | Mentor | Techpreneur | President - CIO Association, UAE, Worlds largest association of Chief Information Officers
Building consensus is about finding common ground and forging a path forward that the team can collectively support: - Facilitate discussions that encourage team members to see the value in each other's perspectives and to compromise where necessary to create a hybrid solution. - Look for areas of overlap and shared goals among the different viewpoints.
-
Octavian Goncalves
Finding common ground and paving a way forward that the team can all support is the key to developing consensus. Establishing a hybrid solution entails negotiating and potentially merging components of other systems. Facilitating talks encourages team members to understand the value of one another's viewpoints and to make concessions where needed. In addition to resolving the disagreement, a consensus-driven strategy improves team cohesiveness.
Once you've listened, evaluated, and worked towards consensus, it's time to decide decisively. Clearly communicate the chosen approach, ensuring that the rationale behind the decision is transparent. This helps to mitigate any residual resistance by showing that all feedback was considered. A decisive decision reflects strong leadership and provides the team with a clear direction to move forward.
-
Jayakumar Mohanachandran
Fractional Chief Information Officer | Advisor | Mentor | Techpreneur | President - CIO Association, UAE, Worlds largest association of Chief Information Officers
Once you've listened to all perspectives, objectively evaluated the feedback, and worked towards building consensus, it's time to make a decisive decision: - Transparently share the decision with the team, outlining the rationale behind it. - By showing that you have taken the time to listen and evaluate all viewpoints, you can help mitigate any lingering resistance to the decision.
-
Aman Kaur⚡️
Program Manager | Transformation & Strategy | Co-Chair REACH Network (DEI) | STEM Enthusiast
Reiterate the project’s overall goals and objectives to ensure everyone is aligned on the desired outcomes. This can help refocus the discussion on what is most important and relevant to the project’s success.
-
Octavian Goncalves
After listening, considering, and trying to reach an agreement, it's time to make a firm decision. Make sure the reasoning behind the choice is transparent and express the selected course of action clearly and concisely. Demonstrating that all comments were taken into account helps lessen any lingering reluctance. Making a firm choice gives the group a clear path forward and demonstrates strong leadership.
-
Rattanbir Singh
A Veteran; An Educationist committed to Advocacy and Inclusivism and a Trainer of Leaders
Decisiveness is critical. In the Army, hesitation could jeopardize missions. As a Principal, quick, informed decisions often addressed issues before they escalated. After evaluating feedback, make a clear decision. Explain the reasoning behind it, emphasizing how it aligns with the project’s goals. Picture a motorcycle ride; once the route is chosen, you commit to it, ensuring timely arrival. Decisive leadership instils confidence and maintains momentum.
-
Sivashankar K K
Business Development Manager
In situations where consensus is challenging, I step up to make decisive decisions. I weigh all the gathered information and choose the path that best aligns with our objectives. For example, during a tight deadline, I had to choose a project management tool amidst differing opinions. I opted for the one with the best overall functionality and ease of use, ensuring we stayed on track. Decisive action prevents stagnation and keeps the project moving forward.
Effective communication is critical in ensuring that your team understands and embraces the chosen approach. Articulate the decision, the expected outcomes, and the roles and responsibilities of each team member. Clear communication prevents misunderstandings and aligns the team's efforts. It also reinforces trust in your leadership by showing that you are guiding the team with clarity and purpose.
-
Jayakumar Mohanachandran
Fractional Chief Information Officer | Advisor | Mentor | Techpreneur | President - CIO Association, UAE, Worlds largest association of Chief Information Officers
Effective communication is critical in ensuring that your team understands and embraces the chosen approach: - Clearly communicate the decision, explaining the rationale behind it and how it aligns with the project's goals. - Clearly define the expected outcomes of the selected approach, including key milestones and success metrics.
-
Octavian Goncalves
Efficient communication guarantees that your team comprehends and accepts the selected strategy. Clearly state the choice, the anticipated results, and each team member's duties and obligations. Effective communication unites the team's efforts and avoids misunderstandings. Demonstrating that you are leading the team with clarity and purpose also strengthens the team's faith in your leadership.
-
Rattanbir Singh
A Veteran; An Educationist committed to Advocacy and Inclusivism and a Trainer of Leaders
Clear communication eliminates confusion. In both the Army and school environment, I learned that clarity in directions prevents misunderstandings. Once a decision is made, articulate it accurately and clearly to your team. Use visual aids or summary notes if needed. For example, in photography, a clear brief ensures everyone understands the creative vision. Effective communication helps align efforts and keeps everyone on track.
-
Sivashankar K K
Business Development Manager
Clear communication is crucial throughout this process. I make sure to articulate the reasons behind my decisions and the expected outcomes. After choosing a project approach, I held a team meeting to explain my decision and how it supports our goals. I also addressed any concerns and answered questions to ensure everyone was on the same page. Transparent communication builds trust and aligns team efforts.
-
Mischa Hollenstein
Leadership Guide - leadership coach & professional safari guide I recruiting trainer I communication I employee development I seminars I speaker I salestraining
In Konfliktsituationen ist eine klare und effektive Kommunikation entscheidend. Stellen Sie sicher, dass alle Teammitglieder ihre Perspektiven ohne Unterbrechung teilen können. Fragen Sie sich: „Wie kann ich die Kommunikation so gestalten, dass alle sich gehört und respektiert fühlen?“ Ein Beispiel wäre, strukturierte Diskussionen mit festgelegten Redezeiten einzuführen, um sicherzustellen, dass alle Stimmen gehört werden. Dies stärkt das Vertrauen und die Zusammenarbeit im Team.
Lastly, foster adaptability within your team. Emphasize the importance of being flexible and open to change, as projects often evolve and new challenges arise. Encourage ongoing feedback and be prepared to make adjustments as necessary. By promoting adaptability, you prepare your team to handle future conflicts with resilience and agility, ensuring long-term project success.
-
Nadeem Ahmad
Follow for posts on leadership & innovation | Tech Exec turned Bestselling Author | Helping leaders navigate innovation in business
To effectively manage diverse opinions and ensure project success, promote adaptability within your team. This means encouraging a mindset open to change and willing to explore different approaches. For instance, when team members are attached to their own ideas, emphasize the benefits of flexibility and the potential for discovering even better solutions through collaboration. Implementing trial periods for different approaches can also demonstrate practical outcomes and help align perspectives. When you foster adaptability, you not only resolve current disagreements but also build a team that's resilient and responsive to evolving project demands and challenges.
-
Sivashankar K K
Business Development Manager
Projects often require adaptability, especially when initial plans face unforeseen challenges. I encourage the team to remain flexible and open to adjustments. For instance, when a project milestone was delayed due to an external factor, we quickly adapted our strategy to mitigate the impact. By fostering a culture of adaptability, the team can pivot smoothly and maintain progress despite obstacles.
-
Nicole Jones-Gerbino
President of PBS Radiology - Servant Leader | Authentic Communicator | Solution Seeker
Creating a safe place to attempt solutions is important. 1. Clearly identify the scenarios where failure can’t happen, vs. those where some negotiation in result is possible. 2. Encourage people to try, evaluate, and make adjustments. Clearly identify the measurements of success and timing of this approach. 3. Set the tone and example of how to approach changes as the leader.
-
Octavian Goncalves
Finally, encourage flexibility in your staff. Stress the value of being adaptable and willing to change because new problems and project changes frequently occur. Encourage constant input and be ready to make changes as needed. Encouraging adaptability ensures long-term project success since it equips your team to deal with future disputes with resilience and agility.
-
Rattanbir Singh
A Veteran; An Educationist committed to Advocacy and Inclusivism and a Trainer of Leaders
Adaptability is vital. In the Army, operational conditions change rapidly and unpredictably, hence flexibility is essential. As a Principal, adapting to new educational trends improved school performance. Therefore, I would say that you must encourage your team to be open to adjustments. View feedback as a tool for continuous improvement. Just like in my motorcycling, I have to constantly adapt to road conditions for a successful and enjoyable ride, fostering adaptability will ensure that your project can navigate challenges and seize opportunities.
-
Rattanbir Singh
A Veteran; An Educationist committed to Advocacy and Inclusivism and a Trainer of Leaders
Consider team morale and long-term vision. In the Army, keeping morale high enabled strong camaraderie and that is what is crucial for mission success. As a Principal, a positive culture enhanced productivity. Regularly check in with your team, acknowledge their contributions, and celebrate small wins. Balance immediate project needs with your organization’s long-term goals. Besides, I realised early on in the pursuit of my hobbies and interests that a motivated and aligned team is the greatest asset when you are out in the field. Encourage continuous learning and improvement to sustain success.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Project Team ManagementHow do you balance the need for direction and autonomy in your project team?
-
Coaching & MentoringHow would you address conflicting priorities among team members during a cross-functional project?
-
Project ManagementWhat are the most common mistakes when using different project leadership styles?
-
Project LeadershipHow can critical thinking help project leaders create a positive team culture?