The first step in supplier evaluation is to define the criteria that are relevant and important for your procurement objectives. These criteria may vary depending on the type and complexity of the goods or services you are procuring, industry standards, regulations, and your own preferences and expectations. Common criteria used to evaluate suppliers include quality, cost, delivery, service, innovation, and sustainability. Quality measures how well the supplier meets specifications, standards, and requirements for the product or service. Cost evaluates how competitive the supplier's pricing is in comparison to market rates and budget. Delivery assesses how timely and accurate the supplier's delivery of the product or service is. Service looks at how responsive and supportive the supplier's customer service is. Innovation examines how proactive and creative the supplier is in developing new solutions. Finally, sustainability evaluates how ethical and responsible the supplier is in terms of environmental, social, and governance practices.
-
The upfront work here is critical to ensure standardization in supplier evaluation. I recommend having the stakeholders (business units / different functions as well as procurement) populate a supply chain requirements document. Why? - It forces each area of the business to document what is actually important (no hip shooting!) - The document is shared to all in advance so there can be no challenge about certain parameters - It becomes the input need for supplier evaluations e.g. need for 5% cost reduction on product to meet market expectation. Parameters become; 1 - Price 2 - Year on Year cost reduction % 3 - Cost Breakdown 4 - Willingness to collaborate on cost This will ensure that you are evaluating what is important.
-
Quality, cost and delivery are now basic requirements. From my experience the key things I look out for are financial health, current customer base and technological innovation. The financial health of a supplier confirms their longevity, ability to invest and innovate and guarantee supply security for my own business. This also will help in confirming how fluid they are or would be in terms of investment into new technology or innovation. The companies they do business with helps define thier code of business principle based on those organsations they work with. This also helps tick the quality box too. Technological investment. What sort factory do you and what are your investments plans in improving them in future.
-
Parameters for supplier evaluation: Quality, Cost competitiveness, Delivery performance, Financial stability, Compliance, Experience, Capacity, Innovation Tendency, Risk management, Communication, Sustainability, Contract terms, Internal processes, Geographic location. Thorough evaluation ensures informed decisions and reliable partnerships.
-
In services procurement, formal criteria like cost, technology availability, and contract adherence help narrow down potential suppliers. But, to make the final decision, it's crucial to be sure about the quality of service. A good approach is to organize workshops with suppliers, letting them explain how they'll solve your business problems and achieve success using your key business indicators. Rather than just checking a supplier's capabilities, it's better to assess how well they can use those capabilities to meet your company's specific needs. You can also gather feedback from other clients of the supplier and use their experiences as part of the evaluation process.
-
Evaluating potential suppliers involves: 1. Financial and Operational Health: - Tools: Financial ratios, KPIs, site audits. 2. Compliance and Legal Risk: - Tools: Compliance audits, contract management software. 3. Reputation and Data Security: - Tools: Third-party reports, security audits. 4. Sustainability and CSR: - Tools: Sustainability audits, ISO 14001. 5. Risk Management and AI: - Tools: VRM software (SAP Ariba, Coupa), AI-driven insights. 6. Supplier Relationship Management (SRM): - Tools: SRM software, performance tracking. These criteria ensure comprehensive supplier performance and risk evaluation
The next step in supplier evaluation is to use various tools and methods to collect, analyze, and compare data and information on the suppliers based on the criteria you have defined. Request for Information (RFI) documents ask suppliers to provide basic information about their company, products, services, capabilities, and qualifications. Request for Proposal (RFP) or Request for Quotation (RFQ) documents ask suppliers to provide detailed information about their pricing, terms, conditions, and delivery. Supplier Audits involve visiting the supplier's premises, inspecting their facilities, processes, systems, and records. Supplier Scorecards measure and track the supplier's performance on various criteria. Finally, Supplier Portfolio Analysis classifies the suppliers into different categories based on their strategic importance and performance level. All of these tools can help you assess the supplier's actual performance and risk level, monitor and evaluate their ongoing performance, compare and negotiate with different suppliers, prioritize your supplier relationships, and allocate resources accordingly.
-
In supplier evaluation, tools like RFI, RFP/RFQ documents, supplier audits, scorecards, and portfolio analysis are vital. RFIs gather basic supplier information, while RFPs/RFQs detail pricing and terms. Supplier audits involve on-site inspections. Scorecards track performance, and portfolio analysis categorizes suppliers by importance. These tools aid in assessing performance, managing risks, monitoring ongoing performance, comparing suppliers, prioritizing relationships, and resource allocation effectively.
-
Completing supplier Financial Health Assessments is absolutely critical and is often overlooked. I had to manage one supplier going in to CCAA (Chapter 11). It cost ~$5million, took a team of 3 people 2 years full time to manage the exit, 7 years later you can still feel the impact. Create a portfolio approach to understanding the risk in your supply chain but don't just measure - act on the information that you receive - e.g. you may need a second source or exit the vendor in question. This is a continual and regular process.
-
Business intelligence tools are prevailent in the market and it is a difficult choice to make when it comes to evaluating efficiency and comprehensiveness. Often you go with most popular tool but it is important to research vendors that provides data intelligence. Lay out risk factors and data attributes that are key in meassuring risk and give higher weightage to the tool that covers most factors.
-
Request for Information (RFI): Ask suppliers to provide basic information about their company, products, services, capabilities & qualifications. Request for Proposal (RFP) or Request for Quotation (RFQ): Request detailed information about the supplier's terms, conditions & delivery. Supplier Audits: Visit the supplier's premises to inspect their facilities, processes, systems, and records. Supplier Scorecards: Measure and track the supplier's performance on various criteria over time. Supplier Portfolio Analysis: Classify suppliers into different categories based on their strategic importance & risk profile. Supplier Evaluation Questionnaire: Provide a concise yet detailed questionnaire to solicit necessary information from suppliers.
-
Supplier Scorecards, audits, KPI's, Due Diligences, financial analysis, risk assessment, SRM software, QMS, compliance monitoring. Tailor these tools may provide us a good instinct of the suppliers capability.
The final step in supplier evaluation is to apply some best practices that can optimize the process and results. Start by defining the evaluation criteria and weighting them according to your procurement objectives and priorities. Then, use a combination of different tools and methods to gather data from multiple sources and perspectives. Involve relevant stakeholders from different departments and functions in the evaluation process and decision making. Furthermore, it's important to communicate with the suppliers throughout the evaluation process, providing them with constructive feedback and recognition. Lastly, review and update your criteria, tools, methods, and results periodically to adapt to changing needs and circumstances. By following these steps and best practices, you can evaluate the performance and risk of potential suppliers using various criteria and tools, and select the best partners for your procurement success.
-
There are certain criteria which may be defined in the stage of bidding and floating the tender (RFP). These criteria depend on the nature of the project and quality parameters constraints such as: 1. QCBS Method (Quality cum Cost based selection) - here quality has more weightage over the cost/prices quoted for the project, majorly the ratio is 70:30. Each technical parameter has its own weightage and accordingly the bidder will be assessed. 2. LCS (Least Cost based selection) - here the bidder which submit the least cost bid (L-1 bidder) will be the proposed bidder. 3. QBS (Quality based selection) - here technical capabilities and quality is the major concern irrespective of financial bid (just it should be aligned with IE)
-
Best practices for supplier evaluation include: 1. Clearly define evaluation criteria that align with business goals and objectives. 2. Regularly review supplier performance using key performance indicators (KPIs) and metrics. 3. Monitor and measure supplier performance through periodic reviews and feedback. 4. Identify potential issues early on and take appropriate action to maintain optimal supplier relationships. 5. Establish a supplier evaluation system that regularly assesses suppliers.. 6. Ensure a successful supplier evaluation by outlining a schedule, providing a concise questionnaire, visiting supplier facilities, and involving the right staff members in the evaluation process.
-
In the 'gather data from multiple sources and perspectives" section, I'd add: Conduct benchmarking interviews with a few long-term customers/clients to validate their experience and whether the supplier's performance aligns with your objectives.
-
Establish Clear Evaluation Criteria: Clearly communicate evaluation criteria to suppliers, ensuring transparency and alignment of expectations. Regular Performance Reviews: Conduct regular performance reviews based on predefined schedules. Regular reviews facilitate ongoing communication and improvement opportunities. Risk Management: Integrate risk management into supplier evaluation by assessing potential risks related to geopolitical factors, market conditions, and supply chain disruptions. Collaborative Approach: Foster collaboration with suppliers to address challenges and jointly identify improvement opportunities. A collaborative approach strengthens long-term relationships and encourages continuous improvement.
-
Define Clear Evaluation Metrics: Be clear about what metrics are most important for your business. Consistency in these metrics ensures that all suppliers are evaluated on the same basis. Involve Cross-Functional Teams: Include representatives from purchasing, quality control, production, and finance in the evaluation process. This ensures that all relevant perspectives are considered.
-
To evaluate potential suppliers, define key criteria such as quality, reliability, cost, delivery time, financial stability, and sustainability practices. Gather relevant information about the suppliers, such as financial statements, references, certifications, and industry reports. Conduct a supplier assessment using tools like questionnaires, site visits, performance metrics, and risk assessment. Score and rank suppliers based on their performance against each criterion, weighting the criteria based on their importance to the organization. Make an informed decision based on the evaluation results, considering overall performance, risk factors, and alignment with the organization's goals and values.
-
By evaluating potential suppliers using comprehensive criteria, utilizing diverse tools, incorporating best practices, and considering additional factors, organizations can make informed decisions that minimize risks and optimize supplier performance. A robust supplier evaluation process contributes to the development of strong and mutually beneficial supplier relationships, fostering stability and resilience within the supply chain.
-
Finally, it is worth considering what are the reward mechanisms to incentivize supplier performance. For example, some companies host annual supplier conferences where they give a "prize" or "award" to top-performance suppliers. This is a powerful tool to improve suppliers' performance.
-
Additionally we shall consider the suppliers; Sustainability Practices: Evaluate their environmental and social responsibility efforts, aligning with your company's values.
-
In my experience of Procurement, all the above criteria mentioned for evaluating the supplier is great. In addition to it, I believe one of the important aspects to consider would be the after sales services and how they respond to their customers. Most of the suppliers will qualify for cost, quality, documentation, timely communication, etc, but after sales service is something where I found the supplier may have a delayed response which eventually delays the needs of the buyer.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Supply Chain OptimizationWhat are the most effective methods for supplier feedback and improvement?
-
Supplier SourcingYou need to evaluate supplier performance. How do you know if they’re delivering the goods?
-
Logistics ManagementWhat are the best ways to manage supplier performance after development?
-
Supplier EvaluationHow do you manage and mitigate the impact of supplier cost changes on your budget and profitability?