Let me explain the title of my review: I'm not an atheist, I'm a very devout Christian. I am not saying that the life of Christ is a lie. Jesus Christ Superstar the MOVIE is what's a lie. I'm more familiar with a version of it from 2000, but the 1973 one (which I have seen once) is more popular, so I am putting my review here.
Biblically speaking, Jesus was God and man in the flesh, but this movie treats him as just a man. In this musical with just singing and no spoken dialogue, many songs contain this theological heresy.
In "I Don't Know How To Love Him", Mary Magdelene says Jesus is just a man. In songs like "Heaven On Their Minds", Judas pretty much asks Jesus if He really thinks He's more than just a man.
On top of that, when some lepers come to Jesus and ask to be healed, He tells them: "There are too many of you, be gone!" Um, is this the same guy who helped 10 lepers, one of whom thanked Him? Is this the guy who fed 5,000 people and discouraged His FOLLOWERS from turning them away?
In the song "Gethsemane", Jesus asks God "Why should I die?" Dude, that's your purpose- to die on the cross for the sins of mankind. That was your message. Yes, Jesus did ask in the garden of Gethsemane for God to "let this cup pass from me" (Matt. 26: 39) if it was God's will, but He understood that was what He was dying for. Jesus was hoping for there to be another way, but He never asked, "WHY should I die?"
Then He asks: "Would I be more noticed than I ever was before? Would the things I've said and done matter anymore?" Jesus stated many times that He came to save the world from sin, such as to Nicodemus in John 3. He knew that He came to die for our sins. He never thought that He would die for literally nothing!
I could give more examples, but you get the idea. The other 1 star reviewers have given more examples, so please add them on top of my review.
Martin Scorsese did a movie to explore Jesus's humanity- it was called The Last Temptation of Christ, and was heavily controversial by non-viewers. That's not theologically perfect either, but that was to show how Jesus would struggle with His fate to die for mankind. For what it attempts to do, I think that movie is beautiful.
The difference between JCS and Last Temptation is this- Last Temptation, which was directed by a Catholic and warns that it's not intended to be a Bible adaptation, dares to show a Jesus who struggles with being 100% God and 100% man. He knows over time that He is God's Son- even though He knows this at age 12 in The Gospels. It takes a "what-if" approach to the struggle of being God and man at once.
Jesus Christ Superstar, which uses scenes from The Bible, says Jesus was just a man, who simply thought Himself to be God. Tim Rice, who wrote the songs and does not belong to any faith (not quite an atheist, but not a believer), even says that he sees Jesus as just a man and that was his intent with writing the play of which this film is based on. Maybe someone who views Jesus like THAT shouldn't be making a musical about Him.
Jesus Christ Superstar may be popular, but it shouldn't be. How there's Christians who praise this is unknown to me. I once liked it myself, and I regret that now. It's super, alright. Super blasphemous.
Reverse Recommendations: Better Jesus movies include (but are not limited to and listed in no order): The Gospel Road, The King of Kings (1927), The Passion of the Christ, The Greatest Story Ever Told, The Jesus Film, Jesus of Nazareth, The Visual Bible: Matthew, Son of God, and The Gospel of John. In fact, my favorite Biblical movie, and movie in general, is Pasolini's The Gospel According To St. Matthew. I recommend that one above any other Jesus movie.
Note: Some have noted that there is no resurrection scene. I've heard you can see him walking towards the bus at the very end, but I myself am not sure of this. Yes, I said BUS. Did I mention that this movie is set in the desert and yet there's buses and pool parties?
Biblically speaking, Jesus was God and man in the flesh, but this movie treats him as just a man. In this musical with just singing and no spoken dialogue, many songs contain this theological heresy.
In "I Don't Know How To Love Him", Mary Magdelene says Jesus is just a man. In songs like "Heaven On Their Minds", Judas pretty much asks Jesus if He really thinks He's more than just a man.
On top of that, when some lepers come to Jesus and ask to be healed, He tells them: "There are too many of you, be gone!" Um, is this the same guy who helped 10 lepers, one of whom thanked Him? Is this the guy who fed 5,000 people and discouraged His FOLLOWERS from turning them away?
In the song "Gethsemane", Jesus asks God "Why should I die?" Dude, that's your purpose- to die on the cross for the sins of mankind. That was your message. Yes, Jesus did ask in the garden of Gethsemane for God to "let this cup pass from me" (Matt. 26: 39) if it was God's will, but He understood that was what He was dying for. Jesus was hoping for there to be another way, but He never asked, "WHY should I die?"
Then He asks: "Would I be more noticed than I ever was before? Would the things I've said and done matter anymore?" Jesus stated many times that He came to save the world from sin, such as to Nicodemus in John 3. He knew that He came to die for our sins. He never thought that He would die for literally nothing!
I could give more examples, but you get the idea. The other 1 star reviewers have given more examples, so please add them on top of my review.
Martin Scorsese did a movie to explore Jesus's humanity- it was called The Last Temptation of Christ, and was heavily controversial by non-viewers. That's not theologically perfect either, but that was to show how Jesus would struggle with His fate to die for mankind. For what it attempts to do, I think that movie is beautiful.
The difference between JCS and Last Temptation is this- Last Temptation, which was directed by a Catholic and warns that it's not intended to be a Bible adaptation, dares to show a Jesus who struggles with being 100% God and 100% man. He knows over time that He is God's Son- even though He knows this at age 12 in The Gospels. It takes a "what-if" approach to the struggle of being God and man at once.
Jesus Christ Superstar, which uses scenes from The Bible, says Jesus was just a man, who simply thought Himself to be God. Tim Rice, who wrote the songs and does not belong to any faith (not quite an atheist, but not a believer), even says that he sees Jesus as just a man and that was his intent with writing the play of which this film is based on. Maybe someone who views Jesus like THAT shouldn't be making a musical about Him.
Jesus Christ Superstar may be popular, but it shouldn't be. How there's Christians who praise this is unknown to me. I once liked it myself, and I regret that now. It's super, alright. Super blasphemous.
Reverse Recommendations: Better Jesus movies include (but are not limited to and listed in no order): The Gospel Road, The King of Kings (1927), The Passion of the Christ, The Greatest Story Ever Told, The Jesus Film, Jesus of Nazareth, The Visual Bible: Matthew, Son of God, and The Gospel of John. In fact, my favorite Biblical movie, and movie in general, is Pasolini's The Gospel According To St. Matthew. I recommend that one above any other Jesus movie.
Note: Some have noted that there is no resurrection scene. I've heard you can see him walking towards the bus at the very end, but I myself am not sure of this. Yes, I said BUS. Did I mention that this movie is set in the desert and yet there's buses and pool parties?
Tell Your Friends