Gary Kett's Reviews > Panzer: The Illustrated History of Germany's Armored Forces in WWII

Panzer by Niall Barr
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
U 50x66
's review

it was ok

The text in the book is effective for the purpose. However, I was saddened the numerous errors in the captions for the images since it is an illustrated History and I expected the images to be correct to what the captions stated. For example, the pg 23 image caption states "An entire battalion of German armour, spearheaded by Panzer II tanks..." the tanks are actually Panzer III's. I thought perhaps this may have been simply a typo, however as I progressed through the book the number of caption errors just kept increasing. As another example, on pg 41 the image shows a group of Pz I tanks and the caption states one tank has its turret facing backwards. Actually this is an Sd.Kfz. 265 Type A Panzerbefehlswagen with its turret in the correct facing. Being a very unusual tank, this can almost be forgiven. However, pg 128 the caption states that the German tank in the image is a Tiger I in St Lo, but it is clearly a Pz IV is just poor editing of the captions to the images. These are only a few of the many such caption errors. Otherwise, the book is a good read for the amount of space it has to talk about German armoured history. Considering their low numbers in respect to other tank types, I found the Tiger I and Tiger II seemed to dominant more than they deserved. I found the bibliography contained many good references, but considering the topic, there are many sources that appear were not utilized such as the Spielberger German Armor and Military Vehicle Series in which they would have caught many errors including the Sd.Kfz. 265 Type A. As for the 200 unpublished photographs, I actually had difficulty in identifying them. I could not recall ever seeing the image on pg 51 of the 38(T) crossing a pontoon bridge, but this was not overly speculator. Overall, the book was ok, but could have been much more impressive were it not for the many caption errors which made some interesting information in the actual text now suspect. If the captions have so many errors, how can one be confident about the text?



1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Panzer.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 4, 2020 – Started Reading
June 5, 2020 – Shelved
June 5, 2020 – Finished Reading

No comments have been added yet.