|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
|
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0743482778
| 9780743482776
| 0743482778
| 3.97
| 184,686
| 1601
| Jul 01, 2004
|
really liked it
|
Score one for androgyny and desire. Twelfth Night is like if She’s The Man with Amanda Bynes started off with a shipwreck and instead of being a soccer Score one for androgyny and desire. Twelfth Night is like if She’s The Man with Amanda Bynes started off with a shipwreck and instead of being a soccer captain named Duke, Channing Tatum was an actual damn Duke. Just kidding, of course the film is a modern retelling of the Big Bad Bard’s romantic comedy. For the uninitiated, it is the story of siblings Sebastian and Viola who are separated by a storm. Viola disguises herself as a page boy in the service Duke Orsino, who is in love with Olivia, but Viola loves Orsino and Olivia loves Casario except Casario is actually Viola. Pretty simple right? Now throw in some comical subplots about making Malvolio believe she too is in love with Orsino and we got a proper sexy story and, ‘If music be the food of love, play on,’ lets proceed onward! ‘Dost thou think, because thou art virtuous, there shall be no more cakes and ale?’ Bring on the cakes and don’t spare the ales because this is a pretty riotous play that plays with the concept of gender as much as it plays with the concept of disguises and the roles we play. Shakespeare uses the act of disguising oneself for multiple purposes here, with Viola in disguise as Casario and others in disguise as scholars to trick Malvolio, and while the latter is more an act of deception, Viola serves as a pretty excellent look that, particularly to a modern audience, can be an interesting look at gender fluidity and queer desires. Vita Sackville-West, who would dress in men’s clothing and go by the name Julian in order to escort her lover, Violet, around Paris and is often remembered for her relationship with Virginia Woolf, named the protagonists of her novel The Edwardians Sebastian and Viola after this play for that very reason. ‘If this were play'd upon a stage now, I could condemn it as an improbable fiction.” The act of taking on a disguise, however, also functions on several layers, from acknowledging ones self in the form of a role all the way to a rather metafictional level acknowledging that these are in fact characters in a play. Viola, for instance, when asked if she is a comedian responds ‘I am not that I play,’ as a sort of witty nod to her role as Casario. The idea of Viola taking on the role of a man can also be thought of as subversive to the notion that roles of women characters were commonly filled by men and thus Viola playing a man is comical as it nudges the idea of a man playing a woman who is then playing a man. Which is pretty great. We also have Shakespeare showing us characters who are even unwittingly playing a role, such as Orsino’s lofty language of love being viewed as fairly farcical–Orsino is in love with the idea of loving Olivia more than actually in love with Olivia and playing a role of lover rather than being an “authentic” lover. As often with Shakespeare there is a “play-within-a-play” and whole one isn’t necessarily stated as such we can view Fabian, Sir Toby and Sir Andrew as a sort of audience to the “performance” of Malvolio. Neat! ‘Be not afraid of greatness. Some are born great, some achieve greatness, and others have greatness thrust upon them.’ A romcom of gender bending and love triangles as only Shakespeare could deliver, Twelfth Night is a total delight. ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Jul 24, 2024
|
Mass Market Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1594206767
| 9781594206764
| 1594206767
| 4.28
| 13,818
| Oct 13, 2015
| Oct 13, 2015
|
it was amazing
|
‘There are moments that cry out to be fulfilled’ writes poet Mary Oliver, and what can be a more momentous moment in our lives than the moments when l
‘There are moments that cry out to be fulfilled’ writes poet Mary Oliver, and what can be a more momentous moment in our lives than the moments when love, like a great gale of passion, overcomes us, uproots us, sends us tumbling on a force greater than ourselves towards a new horizon. Such are the moments fulfilled by Oliver’s sublimely succinct words in Felicity, the final collection of poetry from the Pulitzer Prize winning poet published in 2015. ‘Poems arrive ready to being,’ she writes, ‘poems are the only transportation,’ and each poem transports us into the disarming glow of love and wonderment for the world around us. It is a collection that bestows a quiet grace into the reader’s heart, a collection that harmonizes with awe, a collection that reads like overlooking the vast beauty of nature on a cozy, rainy day while one’s heart is so full of love and longing for another it feels like the body cannot contain it. If such love were to burst free and land upon a page, it would be these poems. NOT ANYONE WHO SAYS Not anyone who says, “I’m going to be careful and smart in matters of love,” who says, “I’m going to choose slowly,” but only those lovers who didn’t choose at all but were, as it were, chosen by something invisible and powerful and uncontrollable and beautiful and possibly even unsuitable — only those know what I’m talking about in this talking about love. Love overtakes us, it surprises us, it penetrates our defenses and puts down our best efforts at resistance and Oliver’s words flow forward into the heart like a wave of such endearing affect, unable to be ignored or held dearly. These are poems that will call to mind the face of a loved one or make you yearn for a heart beating somewhere back down a road you hope to return to. They capture the moments of fear evaporated into felicity upon diving in and being thankful for the plunge as she writes in I Did Think, Let’s Go About This Slowly: I did think, lets go about this slowly. This is important, this should take some really deep thought. We should take small thoughtful steps. But, bless us, we didn’t. I mean, thats the kind of poem you can read at a wedding. And maybe should. There’s just this freeing energy here to match the feelings of giving in to love, to aching for another, to unabashedly loving the tender or sappy moments that would cause you to roll your eyes otherwise. The small moments, the hands brushing together, the gazes across a room betraying your heart, the moments of falling asleep with your phone in hand mid-text because, like in I Don’t Want to Lose, you’ve stayed awake beyond exhaustion not wanting to lose a single, precious minute: I don’t want to lose a single thread from the intricate brocade of this happiness. I want to remember everything. Which is why I’m lying awake, sleepy but not sleepy enough to give it up. Just now, a moment from years ago: the early morning light, the deft, sweet gesture of your hand reaching for me. These are poems that just make you want to gush. They are so sweet and cute yet deeply penetrating. I’ve always felt Oliver is a perfect balance of accessible and meaningful and while these might not be her strongest poems they arrive directly into the tenderest parts of my heart that I’d only show to those who I’d weather the worst storms with. But like, come on, how adorable is this and a perfect blend between her thoughts on love and Oliver’s signature love for the wild world: EXCEPT FOR THE BODY Except for the body of someone you love, including all its expressions in privacy and in public, trees, I think, are the most beautiful forms on the earth. Though, admittedly, if this were a contest, the trees would come in an extremely distant second. Published in 2015 just a few years before Oliver’s passing in 2019, these poems arrive two years after the death of her lifelong partner, Molly Malone Cook. The couple have such an adorable love story, having met in the home of poet Edna St. Vincent Millay where Oliver was working and striking up a lasting partnership where Molly would often answer work calls on behalf of Mary and pretend to be her to the point that it was widely considered that reaching Molly was the same as reaching Mary. I love them and their love. I also just love love. But anyways, Molly had recently passed before the publication of Felicity though she is felt in every poem. ‘The leaves are all in motion now the way a young boy rows and rows in his wooden boat, just to get anywhere. Late, late, but now lovely and lovelier. And the two of us together — a part of it.’ There is a sense of loss here, yet a sense of love enduring, of love surviving the washing away of time and even death. Its a love that survives brokenness the way love can heal the parts of you that you might have once thought broken. The sort of love you’d have to feel to write about it. May we all find such a love. EVERYTHING THAT WAS BROKEN Everything that was broken has forgotten its brokenness. I love now in a sky-house, through every window the sun. Also your presence. our touching, our stories. Earthy and holy both. How can this be, but it is. Every day has something in it whose name is Forever. This is a short collection of rather short poems, but the effect is rather lasting. I adored the Rumi quotes that break up each section and the poems on life as a journey. We see this journey as something lit by the light of love in Oliver’s gaze, and it is a gorgeous path to take along with her. Grasp these poems by the hand, it is so lovely to have one’s hand held. 5/5 A VOICE FROM I DON'T KNOW WHERE It seems you love this world very much. “Yes, I said. “This beautiful world.” And you don’t mind the mind, that keeps you busy all the time with its dark and bright wonderings? “No, I’m quite used to it. Busy, busy, all the time.” And you don’t mind living with those questions, I mean the hard ones, that no one can answer? “Actually, they’re the most interesting.” And you have a person in your life whose hand you like to hold? “Yes, I do.” It must surely, then, be very happy down there in your heart. “Yes,” I said. “It is.” ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Jul 15, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0593403223
| 9780593403228
| 0593403223
| 4.44
| 3,305
| Oct 17, 2023
| Oct 17, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
The early stages of infatuation driving towards dating can be a time of hyper self-conscious anxiety. Especially someone like Momo, the already self-c
The early stages of infatuation driving towards dating can be a time of hyper self-conscious anxiety. Especially someone like Momo, the already self-conscious focal character in Eunnie’s utterly adorable If You’ll Have Me as she falls for PG, a girl who seems to radiate cool and has a long string of admirers. But could PG have feelings for her back, or is Momo setting herself up for heartbreak? As gorgeously illustrated as it is sweet, this sapphic graphic novel is about as heartwarming as it gets in a story about navigating self-doubt and learning to believe that you deserve to be loved. While the miscommunication trope can often be overused in romance stories, Eunnie applies it in a way that becomes a heartfelt investigation into the anxieties and assumptions that that lead towards miscommunication, transforming it from a frustrating plot device into a rather insightful look at the ways we self sabotage or fall into confirmation biases. With an inclusive cast of dynamic characters and warm, lovely artwork If You’ll Have Me will certainly have your whole heart by the time it is over. [image] Momo and PG are just SO cute together There is a fantastic comic shop in Ann Arbor, Mi I used to frequent in my college days—Vault Of Midnight—and on a trip back home last weekend I stumbled across this fantastic recommendation while browsing: [image] Photo Text: >”One of the most ADORABLE LGBTQ love stories you will ever read <3 10/10 LOVE THIS BOOK!” So shoutout to whomever wrote this recommendation, you are awesome and I appreciate you. How could I not pick this up with such a glowing recommendation, and then share this recommendation with you all. Everything said is true, this is simply adorable. While this is shelved as a queer, YA romance, the characters are slightly older than most and attending their first year of college, which really helps bring out the anxious energy as these are young women having to navigate a much larger world than before and only having themselves and friends to rely on as they balance dating, school and trying not to forget about taking care of themselves in the maelstrom of activity. Momo has always been one to keep her head down, avoid parties, focus on school and be there for everyone else, though tends to get walked all over ensuring everyone else has a good time and gets homework done. But when she finally finds the courage to speak to PG on the pretext of seeing if she is okay, it opens a whole new world of having to be herself and be vulnerable that she wasn’t prepared for. [image] Photo Text: “What did you guys do if you didn’t date?” “We passed geometry.” What really made this work is the depth to the rather dynamic characters here. PG, who’s escapades while she skips class might be a bit more R-rated, seems like she has it all together and a sort of stereotypical “bad boy heartbreaker” type but a mid-book reveal into her recent past caught me by surprise and added a fantastic layer of nuance to this story. Eunnie does well by giving a lot of space for the scenes and characters to breathe, expanding on family and friendship circles to give a much more textured perspective on who they are. Miscommunication does become a dominant crux to the various relationships here, but in a way that really highlights why miscommunication can occur and the self-sabotage of each character feels quite realistic where its hard to not be empathetic to them. Centering on Momo was an excellent choice as well, as many of her issues can be seen as tripping over her own lack of self-confidence although both primary characters bash against their own walls of confirmation biases. But I also enjoyed much of Momo’s internal dialogue, particularly how she frantically tries to assess every situation and read into how she thinks she should act. But it makes for some entertaining scenes that also make Momo so endearing: [image] Photo Text: [option box: compliment his face / hair / eyes] Momo: He has eyes. I mean-- Friend: “He does have nice eyes!” Momo is so adorable and leans into being nerdy and I love that for her, but she also lacks self confidence and I think a big theme of this book is learning to believe you DO deserve things. Or, as PG says, to allow yourself to be selfish sometimes. PG: You like being there for people. That’s not a bad thing Momo: What if I’m doing it for selfish reasons, though? What if I’m doing it because…I want people to like me? PG: You care about people because it makes you happy. I don’t see the problem, as long as you remember to care about yourself. So take care of yourself, remember you deserve love and definitely check out Eunnie’s amazingly adorable If You’ll Have Me. It’s just so pure and sweet, has great nuance and depth and plays with themes of misconceptions and learning to love yourself and be loved. A total winner, thank you Vault of Midnight employee for recommending this! 5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Apr 29, 2024
|
Apr 29, 2024
|
Apr 29, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
Cho, Zen
*
| 4.34
| 845
| Nov 29, 2018
| Nov 29, 2018
|
really liked it
|
Zen Cho: and then the dragon flew through the sky Me: *sobbing in public* Goddammit. Okay but this was surprisingly beautiful and bittersweet. Zen Cho’s Zen Cho: and then the dragon flew through the sky Me: *sobbing in public* Goddammit. Okay but this was surprisingly beautiful and bittersweet. Zen Cho’s Hugo award winning novelette If at First You Don’t Succeed, Try, Try Again begins as a story about failed transformation but sneaks up on you through the snark to be a transformative story about the power of persistence and love. It is a charming fairy tale in the best of ways, harnessing an exciting mythology about the imugi—imugi are to dragons as the caterpillar is to the butterfly more or less—but zooms in from the grand scale where hundreds of years are a blink in the vastness of the cosmos to the span of a few decades to harmonize the human with the folkloric. Cho captures the feeling of failure, be it the thwarted ambitions to become a dragon or to attain tenure at a University, but shows how transformation can come in surprising ways and when one road to our future becomes barricaded we must not be defeated and discover another path forward. Sometimes the path may be rocky or seem aimless, but its usually more scenic and if we keep on keeping on as Bob Dylan said, we might just get to where we are going. ‘Sometimes,” it said, “you try really hard and it’s not enough. You put in all you’ve got and you still never get where you thought you were meant to be...It hurts. Knowing it wasn’t enough, even when you gave it the best of yourself. But you get over it.’ Zen Cho has a great sense of humor that resides comfortably in both the snarky and the sweet and that made this quite an endearing read. I enjoyed how Byam—the imugi central to the story—has gender neutral pronouns (using “it” which is also the pronouns for Murderbot in Martha Wells great series) though during their relationship with Leslie takes on a female presenting form. Cho tends towards queer narratives, which I really appreciate. The way this moves from the more magical to the mundane of daily domesticity is done so beautifully and makes the quotidian on equal footing with the mystical. The transformation here is quite moving and sad, but we see how the bittersweetness of a lifespan of love can become the cocoon for meaningful metamorphosis. Short but sweet, I’m drying my eyes and thankful I read If at First You Don’t Succeed, Try, Try Again. 4/5 Oh and it appears the only way to read this is to claim the free ebook version HERE and I didn’t go into libraries to NOT give people free access to stories so please claim a free copy. ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Apr 18, 2024
|
ebook
| |||||||||||||||||
1250857457
| 9781250857453
| 1250857457
| 4.06
| 233,378
| Dec 26, 2023
| Dec 26, 2023
|
really liked it
|
‘Perhaps we make our own magic with words,’ writes Rebecca Ross in a novel that shows the power of words to be a bright beacon that can push back even
‘Perhaps we make our own magic with words,’ writes Rebecca Ross in a novel that shows the power of words to be a bright beacon that can push back even the darkness of a world ripped apart by warring gods and enchantments. A magic spell usually requires reciting an incantation and while we seal a marriage with a kiss the spoken vows are what unites us. Words are the closest thing to magic we have in this life and Ruthless Vows, the second and concluding volume of Ross’ Letters of Enchantment series certainly champions the written word as a force of hope, courage, or even ‘a shield to protect me.’ Jumping in just days after the shocking conclusion to Divine Rivals, Ruthless Vows brings us a story of the strength, sorrow, sacrifice but also of love that can ‘burn with splendor’ and might be enough to bring an end to a vicious war writ large by divine forces, or are the immortal powers too great to contend with? Ruthless Vows is an emotional labyrinth of twists and touching character development that effectively reverses the roles in its predecessor novel and guides it towards a shocking yet satisfying conclusion. This is a love story built on language as much as it is a love letter to language and it filled my heart with bliss to read this lovely second half of an epic adventure. ‘The sun would continue setting and rising , the moon would persist in waxing and waning , the seasons would bloom and molt , and the war would still rage until one god or both fell to their grave.’ Admittedly, I found Divine Rivals to be a stronger novel if we take each separately in their own context, though Ruthless Vows does bring a great conclusion to this tale while still leaving just enough to speculation to give our minds a reason to continue wrestling with these stories as if in perpetuity. It is once again framed around the charming and heartfelt romance between Iris and Kitt who’s ‘souls weren’t mirrors but complements, constellations that burned side by side’ that gives us a marvelously strong emotional handhold to weather the tumult and turmoil of the war raging across the narrative. Their love story is beautiful and pure and you can’t ask for a better pair of characters to root for. Especially when they deliver tender lines such as: ‘May your hand be in mine, by sun and by night. Let our breaths twine and our blood become one, until our bones return to dust.’ Essentially these books are two people thinking “wow the way you write stirs me into the blossoming of love” which is pretty charming and they fall for the mannerisms of the mind before they even know the poetry of the body. I love the union of language to be a bond that transcends the physical, and enjoy the beauty of the ideas ‘I would love to see your words catch fire with mine.’. But the language of love and epistolary romance is what drives this book and this is a book ‘for anyone who sought a different realm through a wardrobe door,’ as Ross writes, a book for those ‘who wrote a letter and is still waiting for a reply, Or who dreams of stories and bleeds words.’ Which is always something I can root for. Especially coupled with the framing that it is their words reaching out across space and time ‘that your words found me here, even in the darkness,’ and become an emotional compass to guide one another through the hardest moments. As if it was meant to be, cosmically ordained and bestowed upon them through their shared love of making the world more beautiful one perfect phrase after another. A feat they can only accomplish together. ‘[H]is best words emerged,’ Roman realizes, ‘when he was with her.’ ‘ was only thinking how strange it is. To think how many people we cross paths with in our lives. How someone like me has found someone like you.’ What logophile wouldn’t swoon, as many did in the first volume. And Here, however, the roles are reversed with Kitt uncertain who is writing to him—Iris using her middle name was a nice touch as it recalled Roman’s use of Carver but also fit her need for secrecy as this is war and loose lips sink ships as they say—and it manages to keep the romantic tension high without feeling recycled either as the dramatic events keep rolling in. ‘Did you think I would let him steal this last moment from me? When I surrender only to you, take you in my hands and burn with you before the end comes?’ While Divine Rivals was more slow-burn character development, Ruthless Vows really hits the ground running through a more plot-driven narrative that is, admittedly, still sort of a slow-burn. Personally I prefer the interpersonal dramas over the war drama but this does drive towards a rather satisfying conclusion that pulls all the small threads from the first book into a brilliant and dynamic full picture. The book plays with a lot of dualities that really make the plot sing too, with Forrest and Kitt’s “condition” due to Dacre’s magic (no spoilers but the uneasiness about Forrest lends an uneasiness about Kitt that reminded me a bit of Peeta from Mockingjay), but also the duality of relationships like Iris/Roman, Forrest/Sarah or Attie/Tobias juxtaposed with the fallout from Dacre/Enva makes the reader contemplate how each is better together but always at the risk of collapse or tragedy. ‘Keep writing. You will find the words you need to share. They are already within you, even in the shadows, hiding like jewels.’ That duality extends further into the craft of the duology itself. You can’t have one without the other, which is why the novels hinge at such a cliff-hanger moment. You have to combine them for them to make their magic, like ingredients in a potion, like Roman and Iris. It is also perhaps why Iris seems the strongest character in the first and we stretch out in her head a bit more whereas in this volume it is more Roman’s struggle in his captive state and emotional turbulence to keep aloft. And, as this is a war novel, sacrifices will unfortunately befall our merry band of lovers. Though this also gives a necessary weight to the story and all the twists and tragedies make the pay-off land with a greater blow as Ross reminds us that war always comes at an all too great of cost. ‘I see the beauty in what has been but only because I have tasted both sorrow and joy in equal measures’ is a line just as applicable to the experience of reading this series. Ideally one should think of this as the second half of a story rather than a sequel and I’d be curious how this book would read if it were bound as one full volume. That said I think taking a bit of a break between them was beneficial for my own reading habits and I didn’t find this one quite as engaging so I took forever to read it, but it almost feels more like, say, how the recent Dune films are just two parts to a continuous story not a sequel. But I did like how this fleshed out the world, especially the magic realms. Though I also wish this had a map of Cambria. Who doesn’t love a good fantasy world map. Maps even come up. A lot. ‘Tuck my words into your pocket. Let them be your armor.’ For those who found the world building a bit flat in the first, rest assured a lot of the little ideas that pop up get much more grounding here. The enchanted buildings, for instance, play a larger role in this novel and have a rather well-executed explanation that makes sense to have saved until later. But as we get more detail about what we already know, we also discover the world is much more vast and layered than we initially thought as well. An intricate magic system around how the gods function and move about the works is unveiled and it threatens the Cambria as the characters know it as much as if reorders the readers own understanding of it. ‘I would betray you a thousandfold for her.’ While this is more a personal preference than a criticism, I did like the gods more when they were offstage and still potentially more metaphor than physical presence. Or even a halfway point may have been preferred, something like a Sauron that is menacing and omnipresent without having to interact much. Once we have Dacre moving through the text it was nice to have him humanzied but it also reduced his menace, sort of how Randall Flagg is more menacing as an idea than a character with flaws, foibles and finicky temperament in King’s The Stand. Also Enva was cool but it was almost too little and too late with her character compared to Dacre. I did, however, really enjoy the way she shifts the closure of the story in ways that don’t need a sequel, though a prequel would be welcomed. Better yet short stories about the gods, who we learn more of but only get half histories. The overall ending was mostly satisfying if a bit predictable and aiming more for a happy ending instead of an emotional impact with a message, but it still managed to pull off both for the most part. ‘I look forward to the next chapter. The one you will write in your story, as well as the one we write together.’ Overall, I found the Letters of Enchantment duology to be a delightful time full of magic and marvel where the charming romance truly carried the weight brilliantly. Ruthless Vows gets into some pretty intense territory with war crimes and and the fallout of choosing sides (Kitt’s story also enters some pretty gritty aspects of being caught between a rock and a hard place that has echoes of Kurt Vonnegut’s undercover broadcaster in Mother Night). There’s some gripping tales of betrayal and cloak and dagger maneuvers as a war rages on and information is worth more than gold. I greatly enjoyed the importance of language too and how Ross shows the importance of journalism in framing conflict and how this can quickly be weaponized into propaganda. But most of all, I loved the love story that burns brightly in all the darkness. A fantastic read that is greater than the sum of its two parts, a moving story, and one I won’t soon forget. 3.5/5 ‘Write me a story where there is no ending, kitt. write to me and fill my empty spaces.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Apr 14, 2024
|
May 28, 2024
|
Apr 14, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
8886200390
| 9798886200393
| B0CJTGG5HM
| 3.76
| 105
| Mar 27, 2024
| Mar 27, 2024
|
really liked it
|
Viscera Objectica from Yugo Limbo is an odd little curio of a short graphic novel, but one that quietly blossoms into something surprisingly heartwarm
Viscera Objectica from Yugo Limbo is an odd little curio of a short graphic novel, but one that quietly blossoms into something surprisingly heartwarming. Told by a trans masc tailor who has many lovers but has never felt compelled to stick around and love, it is a story of finding one’s heart stitched somewhere unexpected. A simple yet fun line-art style bring this brief and breezy story to life, drawing on Pygmalion from Ovid’s Metamorphoses in a new way for this tale of a tailor in love with a doll named Theu. [image] ‘But it is a love fully realized.’ Quirky but surprisingly touching, Yugo Limbo takes a story that is often explored for critiques on objectification and ownership and makes it rather soft and warm. The narrator gives love to the doll, finds happiness in its companionship and feels that it is ‘something that transcends the idea of “unreciprocated love…” It is still, like Pygmalion, a love professed to an object from their owner, yet here it is shown as a way to feel joy in a situation where the doll is quite literally an inanimate doll (I believe this is definitely meant literally and not metaphorically) and a place to which the narrator can give emotional connection. ‘To love an object. You give your love. You expect nothing in return. Simply to give is your joy. Your love.’ Following the story, Yugo Limbo includes a short segment on people feeling a sense of love for an object, such as their own experience as a 10 year old for Miro’s Chicago, the statue right across from the Daley Center in Chicago. There are stories of love for a VW bus, a VCR, an abandoned building, and an art exhibit ‘Love Beyond Expression’ that dealt with this subject. [image] Short but fairly sweet in its unconventionality. It was interesting to see this take on things, especially as it is quite different than any other versions of Pygmalion. This also made me want to check out Yugo Limbo’s much longer work, Be Kind, My Neighbor, which sounds quite unique as well. A surprising little gem. I love the final page in which the author writes: THANK YOU FOR READING (& UNDERSTANDING) (HOPEFULLY) (IF NOT THATS OK) (maybe think about it over coffee) (jk you do you homie) 3.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Apr 08, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
0063274825
| 9780063274822
| 0063274825
| 3.68
| 27,344
| Aug 19, 2021
| Jul 11, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
Give me all the unhinged narrators. I love a novel that spirals in on its own intensity and insights, that’s my happy zone of books even if there is n
Give me all the unhinged narrators. I love a novel that spirals in on its own intensity and insights, that’s my happy zone of books even if there is nary a plot to be found. French author Maud Ventura’s debut, My Husband, is an unnerving psychological whirlwind of overthinking, manipulation and dark comedy that examines a woman’s obsession with her husband over the course of a week and it is such a gripping cacophony of chaos. I loved this so much and found myself fixated on this novel as much as she was on the minute details of her interpersonal interactions. A translator and high school literature teacher by day, the narrator’s acutely insightful mind latches onto every minute detail and assesses them the way one would a novel with Ventura brilliantly capturing the ways anxious overanalysis can culminate towards catastrophizing and reckless behavior. As the distress rises towards a fever pitch and all the screws begin to rattle loose, what is revealed are the harsh reactions to a patriarchal society and the tensions between conformity or resistance in a mental chess match to assert control. The prose, wonderfully translate by Emma Ramadan, really helps keeps the intensity going and this book just pulls you along. A disquieting and intensely introspective examination of marriage, manipulation or the fragile and faulty sense of self when constructing oneself for the gaze of others, My Husband is a dark delight that crackles with social criticisms and suspense and builds towards an impressive surprise punch of an ending. ‘When it comes to love, I’ve learned nothing: I love too intensely and I’m consumed by my own love (analysis, jealousy, doubt)—so much that when I’m in love, I always end up slightly extinguished and saddened. When I love, I become harsh, serious, intolerant. A heavy shadow settles over my relationships. I love and want to be loved with so much gravitas that it quickly becomes exhausting (for me, for the other person). It’s always an unhealthy kind of love.’ This book is wild, yet it remains playfully ponderous and engaging as the narrator’s mental state swirls like a stormcloud. It’s an addictive book that captures the idea of an addictive and overthinking personality and couldn’t stop thinking about it, and I’d like to extend a massive thank you to Luh for recommending this and discussing it with me for days. I even bought clementines because of the incredible scene where, in a party game where they are all assigned different fruits, she is utterly appalled that her husband picks a clementine for her and a pineapple for his friend’s wife. ‘he associates his best friend’s wife with a summery, exotic fruit, acidic and ample…he married a clementine. He lives with a winter fruit, a banal and cheap fruit, a supermarket fruit. A small, ordinary fruit that has none of the indulgence of the orange nor the originality of the grapefruit. A fruit organized into segments, practical and easy to eat, precut, ready for use, proffered in its casing.’ This segment is indicative of the spiraling, anxious thoughts she has and how outraged she can become over perceived insults. She does not let the clementine slight go and I giggled every time it came back up. The novel does well to draw the reader into seeing the narrator as unhinged though will ultimately ask big questions on why this is our perception. ‘I don’t have to tell him everything: the couples that last are the ones that keep the mystery alive.’ ‘I was very much in love with my boyfriend. So I kept wondering, why am I so passionate, so very intense?’ Ventura admits in an interview with The Bookseller on her inspirations for the story, ‘I was very sad too because a honeymoon phase doesn’t last. But that kind of intense love changes over time and I wanted to explore that in fiction. Can it ever last? But then I thought: ‘Would it be worse if it didn’t go away?’’ Ventura captures the feeling of overwhelming emotional intensity, showing a woman who—despite 15 years of marriage—is still caught in the uncertainty and insecurity of the crush stage and will do anything to keep that intensity alive. Her actions are all highly calculated and manipulative, secretly recording conversations to analyze them later, keeping a notebook of observations and a double-entry of perceived slights from her husband and the punishments she’ll dole out to balance it out. Her punishments and then grief are discussed in her feeling of affininity with Phaedra of Greek Mythology. ‘No one can see my neuroses except me. The way I see myself is not how other people see me. Everything is okay. I belong here.’ Control is a major part of this story and our only perspective on the events are from the rather claustrophobic vantage points of the narrator’s disquieted inner monologue ‘which center on my husband to a worrying degree—it’s difficult to quantify, but I’d say approximately 65 percent.’ She lives her life trying to present a calm and collected exterior to hide the maelstrom of emotions inside her and this lends itself to every aspect of her life being highly calculated and organzied, even assigning different colors to each day of the week in a rather self-fulfilling prophecy on how that day will play out. This works well into the narrative tension: ‘the white of Sunday is not as simple as it seems. Optics teaches us that white is the result of a combination of every color (and not the absence of color, as I once thought). It’s not the purity of the bride or the emptiness of the blank page: Sunday is neither neutral nor naive. White is the synthesis of every color, just as Sunday is the synthesis of every day of the week. It’s the final result, the last chapter, the solution.’ What we see, however, is a sense of identity that is merely self-mythologizing in order to feel control over her own interiority. We are aware, however, that this is likely incongruous with the self as seen by others. It is reminiscent of ‘being a sovereign and unique subject amidst a universe of objects,’ while also ‘an object for others…nothing more than an individual in the collectivity on which [she] depends,’ as Simone de Beauvoir discusses in The Ethics of Ambiguity. Ventura excels at having the narrator manipulating the reader and keeping us on a very short leash to guide us through her week only as she wishes us to see it. ‘Their grammar is inclusive: if one of the two of them is the main character of the story, the other is never erased because of it—the other’s point of view is always included in the narrative.’ An aspect that really had this book sink under my skin was how the narrative follows through rather quotidian life but incisively analyzed down to the detail with her picking apart even the most mundane events as if it were a novel to be decoded. ‘He says “I,” referring only to himself, and it embarrasses me,’ she observes at a party, ‘I’ve analyzed enough literary texts in my life to know that it’s not innocuous.’ She also interprets her life in context to the books she reads, with The Lover by Marguerite Duras adding texture to her thoughts, such as fixating on the line ‘I’ve never done anything but wait outside the closed door’ as a premonition of her future married life where she feels ‘like furniture’ always awaiting her husband. The aspects of her job as translation are quite interesting as well, with her obsession over words and how the language we use might inform our thinking and expressions of love/ ‘Absorbed in my translation, I wonder if that expression, so difficult to translate into French, testifies to the fact that English-speakers love differently than us. Do they make more effort? For them, is it possible to make love last? To reignite a desire that’s been extinguished? How do they do it? ’ When translating from an English novel it distresses her that their expressions could corrupt her marriage. ‘Will “let you go” one day seep into my marriage?’ she stresses, ‘how can we protect ourselves from this English blight?’ In terms of language too, its poignant that her husband is never named, ‘My husband has no name; he is my husband, he belongs to me,’ she quips which is part of a larger subversive attitude towards gendered objectification where her husband is more an object for her to control through her manipulations. The idea of him existing outside her gaze—or before she knew him—‘ is surreal, even revolting.’ Its why his acting out of character, at least how she expects, triggers a panic in her. Her husband orders lasagna when he never does, her husband has a work nickname not belonging to her, or even her husband being overly friendly with a waitress are all cause for alarm to her. The latter especially as the waitress seems inferior to the abilities she has cultivated: ‘There’s an English expression for this: wife material.’ ‘I read somewhere that there are three kinds of women: the woman in love, the mistress, and the mother. That seems right to me. I spent my childhood and adolescence being the woman in love…when I had children, I never moved to the next stage. I never changed categories to become a mother.’ At the heart of the story is a rather blistering critique on gender normative roles under patriarchy and how she feels constricted by them. She purchases a book of etiquette to ‘learn all of these rules by heart’ in order to present as proper “ladylike” by standards of society, she obsesses over her appearance to satisfy the male gaze, but she also resents a lot of the expectations. She observes that husbands get to be the “fun” parent while she deals in the mundane and labor aspects, or that questions about the family and kids are always addressed to her instead of the husband. In her belief that there are three types of women–those in love, the mistress or the mother–she finds only love to be a worthy role. Which has lead her to resent her children because ‘most of the time I’m too busy being in love to be a good mother’ and controlling the intensity of her marriage occupies all her thoughts and is never enough. ‘In reality, marriage didn’t calm me down. I realized at the very moment we said “I do” that my husband could still divorce me…I was constantly awaiting the next step. I discovered a world of proofs of love, with commitment everywhere and love nowhere. And fifteen years after our first date, I still sleep just as poorly.’ As Glennon Doyle once wrote, ‘a very effective way to control women is to convince women to control themselves,’ and we see how the narrator has fallen under this sort of control and self-sabotage by putting her entire identity into the intensity of her marriage. As Ventura discusses ‘what she has done in living for her man is making her miserable.’ It is a false self entirely constructed in the reflection of a man. ‘So with these two opposites—independent or dependent characters—you end with the same point: women should live for themselves.’ Otherwise we see her controting her own logic to justify anything and, without spoiling anything, there are some shocking revelations that are rather humorously rationalized. The book ends on a real knockout moment that perfectly encapsulates Ventura’s messages and themes. My Husband rides a frenetic energy that spirals on its own anxieties and builds towards a nearly maddening tension. Though we also much wonder who is the truly unhinged person here, the narrator or the society that imposes the stresses that lead her to believe her actions are justified in order to perform her role for the sake of society and love. A twisted but darkly comic novel and one where I found myself just as obsessed with reading it as the narrator’s obsession with her husband, My Husband is a startling and satisfying little book. 4.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Apr 04, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1250857430
| 9781250857439
| 1250857430
| 4.20
| 471,947
| Apr 04, 2023
| Apr 04, 2023
|
really liked it
|
I have endless love and respect for the written word. It’s why we are all here, isn’t it? To celebrate language and the way words can tell a story, ho
I have endless love and respect for the written word. It’s why we are all here, isn’t it? To celebrate language and the way words can tell a story, how it can be made malleable to capture abstract ideas, can transform and transcend images and emotions and pass them from one person to another. I love the way a sentence can celebrate an idea, become a symbol dressed in finery of poetic phrases like a christmas tree with each word twinkling in the dark. ‘I Want my words to be like a line, cast out into the darkness,’ professes Iris Winnow in Rebecca Ross’ Divine Rivals. It is an honorable goal, and one that illuminates another power of the written word: to reach one another across vast spaces, be it kilometers, the distance of decades to read the words of a life now only a memory, or the immeasurable distance between two hearts. In a war torn world just adjacent to WWI Europe but infused with magic and monsters, war correspondent Iris Winnow wields words as her weapon to bear witness to bloodshed and reconnect soldiers with their loved ones while also looking for her brother who is hopefully still alive in the mess. Yet her words are somehow reaching another, a secret pen-pal with whom their respective letters mysteriously arrive upon the other’s floor and the written word becomes the catalyst for a blossoming love that might give each the strength to carry on as ‘war creeps like a shadow’ across the land leaving sorrow in its wake. It is a moving novel and while there are certainly criticisms to be had, I find it to be greater than the sum of its occasionally flawed details. An epic, epistolary YA novel that is more magical realism than fantasy, Divine Rivals manages to be a charmingly cozy read while still descending into the devastation of war as two rival journalists leave their world behind to not only look war in the face but to look inside themselves and find that amidst all the bravery to and battles they must also learn ‘it takes courage to let down your armor, to welcome people to see you as you are.’ Reader: I loved it. ‘Keep writing. You will find the words you need to share. They are already within you, even in the shadows, hiding like jewels.’ The focus on writing and the epistolary romance really charmed me here. I enjoy how they come to love one another through their words like a line directly to pure consciousness shorn of physical features and only the mannerisms of thought. But this is not only about love for another born through language but the idea of finding oneself in your own words too, using language to dig inside oneself and confront what it is you truly feel. ‘I think I was always writing for myself, to sort through my loss and worry and tangled ambitions. Even now, I think about how effortless it is to lose oneself in words, and yet also find out who you are.’ I find this quite beautiful and also find language and poetry and even writing book reviews to be an exercise in understanding myself and trying to fumble together a thought that hopefully can be understood by others. It makes for a lovely theme in this book and the way they find their voices. How ‘even in the silence, I hope you will find the words you need to share,’ and I truly adore how writing and all the imagery around it becomes the vibes on which this book really thrives. Typewriters and letters by candlelight, the creek of wooden floorboards, half remembered legends and mystical lore scrawled on old parchment, people bundled up in scarves and tweed against the crisp spring rain winding through cobblestone streets—Divine Rivals has old European academia aesthetics at its most cozy. This novel is a feast of vibes, moving into idyllic rolling hills and pastures and then confronting natural beauty with the beastly as the landscape cracks into the chaos of bombs and bloodshed. Ross excels at juxtaposing innocence with the inhumanity of war to emphasize its tragedy and trauma. While Oath and this war exists in its own reality where magic is real and the old gods have awoken and drawn nations under their influence for the purpose of war (Dacre and Enva feel very much inspired by Haded and Persephone), it also feels very akin to WWI era Europe of the 1910s. It does well in capturing the awfulness of the trenches and bombardments and while the waiting under silence shredded by sirens warning Dacre’s flying demons dropping bombs from the sky does have a strong London Blitz WWII feel however, the amalgamation works as the story doesn’t seem to be trying to function as an analogy but merely a familiar framework. It does seem to romanticize the aesthetics of the time but thankfully it manages to avoid romanticizing the war. And quite the opposite as the horrors and sadness are on full display. ‘I don’t want to wake up when I’m seventy-four only to realize I haven’t lived.’ This is a very character driver story and the first half moves at a bit of a slow pace, though I enjoyed this and found it quite cozy. It helps that the characters are rather charming. Iris Winnow is absolutely fantastic and I enjoyed seeing the novel lead by a tough young woman that is able to hold her own, be self-driven and take action. I just adored her and how she deal with her struggles and grief, the latter of which makes up a big portion of this novel and within the opening hundred pages of this book she loses pretty much everything she has and just picks herself up and keeps going. Her story moves through moments both heartwrenching and heartwarming as she must learn 'You are worthy of love,' but also 'worthy to feel joy right now, even in the darkness.' Iris deserves it all honesty. Roman C. Kitt is a shit. I say that out of love as he did grow on me quite a bit and I do love how much he loves Iris but there were moments when I debated starting an ao3 account to write fan-fiction about slapping him. While it is explained why he is apprehensive to reveal his true self to Iris, his excuses are still pretty eye rolling and frustrating that he hides behind the unfamiliar name. ‘Let us make our names exactly what we want them to be…’ NO “CARVER” you tell that lovely young woman who you are! I did like when she's kind of mean to him, and their respective snark and banter really worked for me. It’s cute, especially when they move from frustration to lines like 'you deserve all the happiness in the world. And I intend to see that you have it.' Its just endlessly endearing. There is an undercurrent of class issues acting upon the novel, from Iris being working class and frowned upon by the Kitt family especially when he bridges class relations in his interest in her. But it also plays into the war and the journalism narrative with the wealth families of Oath insisting on a false neutrality that is shattered when Iris experiences the realities of the war. 'I hear that you're to be neutral reporters, but I also don't think that's quite possible, if I'm frank...I think the best piece of advice, Miss Winnow, is to write what you see happening and what you feel and who we are and why it's vital that the people in Oath and the cities beyond join our effort. Is that something you think is possible?' Her job is to remain neutral but is this even possible when she sees what is happening, knowing that taking a stance will be dismissed as sensationalism by those in power back Oath. Those in power seem to all have secret goals of business dealings with Dacre, assuming he will win the war and using their influence to help achieve this goal. Such is the case with the family to whom Kitt's father wished him to marry into: they have developed what is essentially mustard gas and are providing it to Dacre's army even knowing it will be used on soldiers from Oath. It all makes for an intriguing look at how the idea of "neutrality" is usually just lip service to shame anyone who would take a side against their unspoken beliefs. All of this is fairly secondary, at least in this novel, but it seems to be setting the stage for the next. ‘Grief is a long, difficult process, especially when it is so racked by guilt.’ Their coming together and the fear that is mistaken as self-preservation makes for an interesting exploration here. It is a book about finding oneself and being willing to let others find you. I like how, for a book about war it isn’t a book about powerful force, but something far more vulnerable and empowering: ‘Sometimes strength isn't swords and steel and fire, as we are so often made to believe. Sometimes it's found in quiet, gentle places.’ So much of their grief comes hand in hand with guilt and it keeps them from being able to openly go hand in hand with each other. ‘I am so afraid,’ Iris admits, ‘and yet how I long to be vulnerable and brave when it comes to my own heart.’ its a good lesson to learn. ‘ I think we all wear armor. I think those who don't are fools, risking the pain of being wounded by the sharp edges of the world, over and over again. But if I've learned anything from those fools, it is that to be vulnerable is a strength most of us fear. It takes courage to let down your armor, to welcome people to see you as you are.’ It’s what makes their letters so freeing–they are able to be themselves and hide behind their words while at the same time use their words to expose their hearts to one another. It is quite magical. Speaking of magic, the magic in this book is honestly a bit hit or miss and sometimes it feels like it forgets it is a magical land with small tidbits of magic popping up almost as an afterthought. I didn't mind though, it was kind of fun I thought. Those who desire robust worldbuilding will find this novel wanting, though truthfully if you just say “this is how this shit is” I’m like “oh okay cool” and can just roll with it without really needing context but I see how that might be frustrating for some. I do really like the lore and the mysteries of the old gods—which I assume will be explained more in part 2—but until the very end I wasn’t sure if it was going to mostly be a metaphor. ‘You are worthy to feel joy right now, even in the darkness.’ Through all the sorrow and violence it is ableak time for love, but sometimes one needs to watch something beautiful bloom—like a war-time garden—to feel ‘I grew something living in a season of death.’ We see creation and joy as a repudiation of death and destruction and their love stands in opposition of all the loss around them. I did feel their coming together happened a bit too quickly knowing there is a second book, but thats okay. I did really enjoy the aspect of her putting Roman in his place however and having more of that would be nice. ‘You remove a piece of armor for them; you let the light stream in, even if it makes you wince. Perhaps that is how you learn to be soft yet strong, even in fear and uncertainty.’ I really enjoyed Divine Rivals and found it to be quite cute and cozy even though it gets rather intense and devastating. I’m certainly looking forward to part two and raced out to pick it up as soon as I finished this one. The aesthetics in this are on point, Iris is an incredible character, I love the cast and side characters and queer representation and just really loved reading this. Reading this just gave me nonstop joy and even if it had some flaws, the overall effect of enjoyment overrides it all. Thanks to everyone who recommended this, can’t wait for more! 4/5 ‘Because you are not alone. Not in your fear or your grief or your hopes or your dreams. You are not alone.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Apr 04, 2024
|
Apr 15, 2024
|
Apr 04, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1662522622
| 9781662522628
| B0CNQD45VQ
| 3.48
| 19,471
| Apr 01, 2024
| Apr 01, 2024
|
liked it
|
Even the sturdy rationality of logic bends and breaks against the tempests of love. Such is the case of the titular lovers in Isabel Allende’s Lovers
Even the sturdy rationality of logic bends and breaks against the tempests of love. Such is the case of the titular lovers in Isabel Allende’s Lovers at the Museum who defy both legal and logical laws in their amorous adventures around the Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain. Pitting pragmatism against passion, Allende examines art and romance as the bits of magic and wonder left alive in a harsh world of volatile politics and scandals. As a lover or love, a lover of art and especially a lover of art museums, I found this to be a delightful little short story that is a bit slight but still rather sweet, surreal and satisfying. There is a rather alluring charm to the idea of a magical museum that opens its heart to those caught in a maelstrom of passion. The story focuses on the investigation of the two, dubbed the “Bewitched Lovers,” after they are found wrapped up together—she in a tattered wedding dress and he fully nude—on the floor of the museum as if they were an installation piece on the topic of sudden and overpowering ‘carnal love.’ Their presence eludes logic, having confronted no guards, set off no alarms and appearing on no cameras despite confessing to a series of sexual escapades around the museum. But was it truly the museum or an alternate space in the fabric of time, ‘some fantastical palace.’ Or was everyone too focused on the latest scandal—we are told a scandal involving the Pope has gripped the world—and too wrapped up in politics and sensationalism to notice the magic working right under their noses? I enjoy how their story even takes on political connotations in the newspaper. 'But in this case it was the vice of love, easy enough to forgive.' Short, sweet and full of Isabel Allende’s direct but lovely writing, Lovers at the Museum is a nice little piece that reminds us that art is still a space for magic in the world. It is charming how it chucks aside social conventions, such as her being a runaway bride fleeing expectations, and emboldens the whimsicality of impulsivity in the face of desire. And while I gather the attempt to write a moment of swift and potent romance, it felt like there's some murky question around consent that didn't sit quite right. It felt a bit uncool that the runaway bride was quite drunk and in a state of grief while he admits he had not drank at all, giving an impression he may have taken advantage of her. While the story is nothing overly fantastic, its embracing of the fantastical is worth the quick trip into this story. 3.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Apr 03, 2024
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||
3.72
| 59,118
| 1984
| Sep 08, 1998
|
really liked it
|
I realized while I was [image] This book has EVERYTHING: bleakness, desire, shame, novella length, devastating self-reflections, perfect prose, class commentary, power dynamics, depressing family dynamics, queer desire, smadding—you know that thing where the book is so sad it makes you smile because depraved and depressing novels are very much your jam, you freaky little book nerd, you—regret, French people, critiques of masculinity, critiques of colonialism, metafiction, unhinged decision making, this is a festival of fucked and feverish feelings in 120pgs and a pleasure unto death. I read this in a single sitting and I’m sitting here hours later still emotionally shaken. This is very much my sort of thing. Oh wait, I’m getting ahead of myself, we should do a Review right? Stefon, this is a GOODREADS. Okay, okay, you’re right, here goes: Memory is a butterfly flitting by in flashes and if we try to pin it down, to put our finger on the fluttering of the past, it often turns to powder upon our fingers. Memory fades or is altered by our act of trying to capture it, yet memory also has the ability to seemingly fold time. ‘Very early in my life, it was too late,’ French author Marguerite Duras writes in The Lover, a statement that directly addresses the method for which past and present become intertwined and timeless in her recollections much the way this novelistic memoir blends biography and fiction. The result is pure literary bliss. Winner of the 1984 Prix Goncourt and presented here in beautiful translation by Barbara Bray (for which she was awarded the Scott Moncrieff Prize in 1986) that captures the endlessly poetic potency of Duras’ prose, The Lover is a novel of memory, but it is also an examination of desire and navigating the self amidst family, death, social class and social taboos. This is also a novel of crossings such as the girl’s crossing of the Mekong river that often feels like the center of gravity to the narrative, the crossing of culture and age between the girl and the older Chinese man who becomes her lover, and even a crisscrossing of the timeline found in the fragmentary narrative style. A whirlwind of reflections and the ravages of desire, The Lover is as crisp as it is confident and completely shook up my heart. [image] From the 1992 film adaptation by Jean-Jacques Annaud Duras constructs a portrait of a woman across her many ages, all spiraling into one, and opens on a pitch perfect look at the course of a life all within one face: ‘One day, I was already old, in the entrance of a public place a man came up to me. He introduced himself and said, “I’ve known you for years. Everyone says you were beautiful when you were young, but I want to tell you I think you’re more beautiful now than then. Rather than your face as a young woman, I prefer your face as it is now. Ravaged.’ This was a book that completely ravaged me as well. With Duras’ exquisite prose punctuated by bold assertions and harsh assessments, with the exhaustion of fragile love at the mercy to society yet burning with unquenchable passion, with the haunting looks at family and identity in the clutches of social order and colonialism, and with the rapid fire of memories that are practically flung into your face. The story is told in brief vignettes that ignore any linearity. The reflections come almost at random and almost all at once, as if Duras has dropped and shattered a jar of memories and is frantically gathering them up as they attempt to roll away underfoot. These memories are based in biography (though no previous knowledge of Duras is necessary) but take wings of fiction, almost as if to impress the theme that to touch memory or to try and understand or shape it is to rewrite it and overlay the elusive past. It’s as she writes herself: ‘The story of my life doesn’t exist. Does not exist. There’s never any centre to it. No path, no line. There are great spaces where you pretend there used to be someone, but it’s not true, there was no one. The story of one small part of my youth I’ve already written, more or less — I mean, enough to give a glimpse of it. Of this part, I mean, the part about the crossing of the river. What I’m doing now is both different and the same.’ You can feel this strong lifeforce in every sentence and word as Duras transforms herself into art upon the page. The story bears many similarities to the film Hiroshima mon amour , for which Duras’ wrote the screenplay, and plays with Duras’ own experience in Vietnam when it was still called French Indochina. It was her most popular novel, published when Duras was 70, though while working on the 1992 film adaptation she would lament over the popularity of the book. In her biography Marguerite Duras: A Life by Laure Adler, Duras is quoted as telling director Jean-Jacques Annaud ‘the Lover is a load of shit…it’s an airport novel. I wrote it when I was drunk.’ Personally I found it delightful but I do enjoy the admission of intoxication during the writing process as the cavalcade of observations strung across tenuous connections does indeed feel like the confident logic of a brilliant mind greased up and ready to rant after a few drinks. ‘She wasn’t sure that she hadn’t loved him with a love she hadn’t seen because it had lost itself in the affair like water in sand and she rediscovered it only now, through this moment of music flung across the sea.’ The novel is best remembered for the relationship between the teenage girl and the older, wealthy Chinese man she meets after crossing the Mekong River. Crossings are a large theme of the novel, and while the girl only crosses the river twice, the second time to leave the man behind and return to France, the narrator is now crossing for a third time—metaphorically—to reinvestigate the site of her memories. It is a taboo relationship, though the focus is less on the torrid love affair and more on the curious power dynamics between them. He is wealthy, experienced and much older (it is mentioned he would be arrested due to her being so young), yet, socially, she holds all the power. She is French and white and he is Chinese. She is the colonizer and he is the colonized. Even her poverty seems to not matter and she admits he is only able to obtain her because of his access to wealth. ‘poverty had knocked down the walls of the family and we were all left outside, each one fending for himself. Shameless, that’s what we were. That’s how I came to be here with you.’ A lot of this book takes a swift swipe at the house of cards that is patriarchy and masculinity. The girl (the unnamed characters make them fairly symbolic as a larger social critique, perchance?) has no masculine figure in her life (her father has been in the ground a minute) and often adopts elements of gender-role-reversal. It is in order to obtain a way away from this life as she understand that the goal in life is ‘not that you have to achieve anything, it’s that you have to get away from where you are.’ Her most distinguishing visual element frequently referenced in the text is a large, flat-brimmed hat usually worn by men. While being noted as a discounted hat to nudge the aspect of her poverty and resourcefulness, it also shows her taking on a masculine role almost as a costume and a symbol of her desire for independence. It works, as it does attract her lover and gives her access to his money, and we see how she frequently describes him in terms of weakness and subservience to her. Even his sense of dominance as sexually experienced is described in terms as a response to fear: ‘he’s a man who must make love a lot, a man who’s afraid, he must make love a lot to fight against fear.’ This stems from another element of the strange power dynamic too. Even despite the inappropriateness , legally and socially, of him sleeping with a minor she is still in a position of dominance due to her status as a white, French family. There is a startling moment where he is trying to impress her family, showing them the sights and cuisine and they refuse to even acknowledge he exists. The man is in tears asking why they abuse him so as they ignore him, gorging themselves on food and insulting the city. It is a powerful moment that shows the rampant racism embedded in obdurate social hierarchies where even this millionaire is less than human to the poor, white family. ‘I am worn out with desire.’ More on the family in a moment but I can’t move away from the erotic aspects of the novel and the discussions on sex and the body as a sort of metaphor for land being colonized without also bringing up the queer desires in the novel. The narrator reflects on Hélène Lagonelle and her nude body, bold and unashamed as if oblivious to the desire and power her naked figure represents. It is through her that the narrator wishes to pass her sexual appetites for the man into her, almost as if conquering Hélène’s body by having his be the one to take it as he does her own. ‘I’d like to devour and be devoured by those flour-white breasts of hers,’ she thinks, ‘I am worn out with desire for Hélène Lagonelle.’ ‘We, her children, are heroic, dersperate.’ Her family is another major theme of the novel, such as her disdain for her older brother, her passion and awareness of mortality found in her younger brother and most notable, the struggles to keep a family and her own mental state together found in the mother. The Lover is as much a portrait of the mother as it is the daughter. It is a family held together by shame, disgraced by their fall from financial security yet still higher on the social hierarchy in French Indochina. But also this passage completely slayed me: ‘We're united in a fundamental shame at having to live. It's here we are at the heart of our common fate, the fact that all three of us are our mother's children, the children of a candid creature murdered by society. We're on the side of the society which has reduced her to despair. Because of what's been done to our mother, so amiable, so trusting, we hate life, we hate ourselves.’ While society is constantly seen as the oppressor—more so for the lover, who is even threatened to be cut off from his family fortune if he continues with the girl—they also, shamefully, cling to society in the ways it gives them a leg up. It becomes rather self-effacing. Though the brother, who is a real shithead, also further represents colonialism, refusing to find work and spending his days engaged in theft and perversion to uphold himself. The younger brother, however, becomes the doorway through which the narrator learns ‘immortality is mortal.’ His death shakes her and makes her realize life is fleeting and death is inevitable. ‘its while its being lived that life is immortal, while its still alive. Immortality is not a matter of more or less time, its not really a question of immortality but of something else that remains unknown’ All this culminates into her turning both inward and backward on her life in reflection. It is notable that her reflections tend to focus on photographs and images of herself, as a primary theme of the novel is the idea that the self shown to the world, ones image, is what society values. There is a strong juxtaposition of interior self versus exterior self, and her reflections attempt to bridge the gaps. ‘It's as if they were happy, and as if it came from outside themselves. And I have nothing like that.’ In her novel Shame, French Nobel Prize winner Annie Ernaux contrasts her ideas of memory with that of Marcel Proust, for whom memory is exterior to the self. She explains his perspective of memory found in ‘things linked to the earth that recur periodically, confirming the permanence of mankind.’ For Ernaux, however, she finds ‘ the act of remembering can do nothing to reaffirm my sense of identity or continuity. It can only confirm the fragmented nature of my life and the belief that I belong to history.’ Duras’ The Lover seems to align more with Ernaux, particularly in the fragmented nature of the self as reflected by the narrative style, but also that the external self is a false self that does not serve as a reliable compass towards identity. It is more fit for social hierarchy and posturing, though she also finds this serves a purpose that the interior self cannot achieve. It is only late in life with a ‘ravaged face’ that she feels her external and internal self align more authentically. A moving and often devastating read, The Lover contains multitudes in its succinct space. It is no wonder this has become a classic work and Duras certainly demonstrates her exemplary prowess of prose and thought. 4.5/5 ‘And it really was unto death. It has been unto death.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||||
3.95
| 109,790
| Nov 15, 2022
| Nov 15, 2022
|
really liked it
|
I’m in my rom-com era (aka living my best life) and Lynn Painter’s The Do-Over made for a sugary sweet dose of joy that warmed my heart in these chill
I’m in my rom-com era (aka living my best life) and Lynn Painter’s The Do-Over made for a sugary sweet dose of joy that warmed my heart in these chilly winter months. When a perfectly planned Valentine’s Day descends into a heartbreaking mess of car wrecks, crushed dreams and cheating boyfriends, Emilie Hornby just wants to go to sleep and start the next day fresh. But when she awakens she discovers that it is Valentine’s Day…over and over and over again like death by a thousand cuts with her dreams repeatedly dashed despite her daily attempts to avoid disaster. Filled with a lot of charm, Taylor Swift references and perhaps an overabundance of cuteness, The Do-Over is a delightful time-loop story that manages to mostly balance out the over-caffeinated plot and underdeveloped supporting cast with its exploration into heavier themes of fractured families, and the pressures of expectations from society one’s own self. It gleefully charges into chaos but it polishes up real nice in this touching story about confronting your own life and living for yourself as well as a romantic collision with love where you least expect it. ‘This wasn't about boys and girls and love and attraction, this was about a human soul needing to feel seen.’ I have a soft spot for rom coms and while I think I still preferred Painter’s Better Than the Movies which still lingers like a tattoo kiss, this made for a perfectly cute Valentine’s Day read. Its cozy like a warm embrace of like an old cardigan under someone’s bed. The Do-Over reads like an adorable time-loop blend of Groundhog’s Day meets Ferris Bueller’s Day Off with the casting budget of a teenage after-school special so don’t expect too much from the side characters. I did enjoy the brief subplot about her friend trying to get with the boy from his cross country team but most of the cast is fairly ornamental since you can’t have too much character development in a time-loop story. Even the main cast is a bit flat, though we do see some growth with Emilie as she goes from the rather stereotypical follow-the-rules teen to embracing her own destiny. Emilie has seen this story before and she didn’t like the ending, but each day she keeps trying to avert the inevitable to no avail, yet her morning car-wreck with Nick each day seems to point towards another path her life could take, even if he is a bit of a prick (but a prick with a devilish smile, that James Dean, daydream look in his eye and scent of..*checks notes* clean soap). I found Nick frustrating but I did enjoy that he has only been pretending to not know Em out of a shyness and his fear of vulnerability makes him rather thorny, something my former teenage self can certainly empathize with. ‘Josh was the perfect boyfriend for me on paper…but I didn’t realize until I watched him kiss Macy that the paper didn’t always translate.’ I enjoy that, like Better Than the Movies, this story explores how life can’t be perfectly packaged and planned because life will always throw the unexpected. And while these surprises can bring heartache—her parents divorce, the recinded program, Nick’s grief over his brother—they can also open doors to greater joys than we ever imagined. Em lives by checklists and checking boxes but the road not taken looks real good now that she’s caught in an endless loop of downfall. ‘No matter how it turns out—good or bad—I’m going to start living for me and what I want, instead of for other people and what I think they want me to do.’ This is a story about accepting the unexpected and living for you. I do have to admit the Day of No Concequenses being referred to as DONC in the text and speech (do they say the letters or pronounce it “donk”?) was irritating, but I liked the idea that Em decided to rip the Band-Aid off and skip But also. Painter does something with names in her book. Em Hornby + Nick seems a reference to rom-com writer Nick Hornby much like how in Better than the Movies the couple adds up to a reference to Elizabeth Bennet from Pride and Prejudice. While a bit more a great romantic concept than actual execution, The Do-Over is a heartwarming, cuddly good time with lots of laughs. I felt the relationship was well orchestrated even with the aspect that Nick never remembered the previous runs through the recurring day and they remain to each other a stranger whose laugh they could recognize anywhere. I also really loved the insertion of confessions at the start of each chapter that gave hints into the loneliness Em tries to swallow down. But i suppose if this story is over why am i still writing pages, so in conclusion, this is a cute book full of fun. 3.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
Hardcover
| ||||||||||||||||||
1250908264
| 9781250908261
| 4.41
| 3,889
| Jan 09, 2024
| Jan 09, 2024
|
it was amazing
|
Valentine's Day had long been the favorite holiday for Valentina. Named after the day and annually visited by an adorable cupid only she can see, Vale
Valentine's Day had long been the favorite holiday for Valentina. Named after the day and annually visited by an adorable cupid only she can see, Valentina spent her childhood bringing love to everyone on Valentine’s Day until one year the day brings nothing but stressful surprises that completely upends her life. Now she has one year to prove she can find true love or she must give her heart away to never feel either the joys or pains of love in a faustian deal not with the devil but the ghost of St. Valentine himself. So begins Lunar New Year Love Story, the sweepingly gorgeous and emotional graphic novel from Gene Luen Yang (of American Born Chinese fame) and brought to life through eye-popping illustrations from LeUyen Pham. This is a beautiful, multi-faceted story that explores much more than romantic love as Valentina confronts family and cultural identity in a story rife with symbolism and dualities. With mesmerizing artwork and a story that is as heartbreaking as it can be heartwarming, Lunar New Year Love Story is an incredible YA coming-of-age graphic novel that will steal your heart (they let me have mine back, don’t worry). [image] I didn’t always hate Valentine’s Day One thing I really appreciate in a good graphic novel is when the story is given the room to breathe. This is on the longer side for a YA but it really lets all the nuances and textures of the story have space to flourish and the slower pace lets each frame squeeze out every drop of emotional intensity. There is a large set-up that completely grabbed me and I enjoyed the way it shows how the things we love in childhood start to fade or become a source of embarrassment in teenage years. The shift from loving Valentine’s Day is really heartbreaking here as it descends into a bleakness about the realization opening oneself to love also means being vulnerable to heartbreak and betrayal, perfectly rendered in the eerie moment when her cute cherubic companion melts into a ghastly ghoul of St. Valentine. There is a really extraordinary blend of various cultural spiritualities and customs here showing the way an immigrant family, for instance, may contain multitudes and Val spends much of the story sifting through the interplay of her Vietnamese heritage and grandmother’s christianity. All of this in an attempt to understand herself through her history and hope to break the family curse of being unlucky in love. [image] Caption: “Our family is unlucky in love” The dualities here are wonderful, such as how Val’s involvement in the Korean Bukcheong lion dance juxtaposes with the story of christian martyrs facing down the lions, the way life is juxtaposed with death, or the way the two potential love interests—cousins Leslie and Jae—are all placed in proximity to examine the idea of yin and yang. [image] There is also a really adorable romance going on amidst all the self-discovery of her culture and (view spoiler)[the surprise that her mother never died but simply left (hide spoiler)]. We see how Les may make her happy but is not a source of stability or loyalty, a rather heartbreaking lesson to learn. And with Jae we see how grief can cast a long shadow over our lives, but that love can be a light in the darkness. It is a moving story full of both sadness and laughs while the deal over her heart is always haunting her every move. [image] ‘Lions roam the world…majesty and misery…there is no hiding. How good it is, then to find someone with whom you can become the lion.’ This was such an extraordinary graphic novel with a really lovely story, a lot of excellent exploration of culture and heritage, and a art style that was an absolute joy to get lost within. The colors are incredible, movement is wonderfully captured and the art beautifully and seamlessly flows between reality and the metaphysical aspects. Lunar New Years Love Story is a massive success. 5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||
1662515561
| 9781662515569
| B0C8ZLMMD5
| 3.82
| 868
| unknown
| Aug 22, 2023
|
really liked it
|
‘A reprieve from solitude, at last. What are we to one another, if we cannot be this?” What, me crying at the end of a Homer retelling? Couldn’t be… Fin ‘A reprieve from solitude, at last. What are we to one another, if we cannot be this?” What, me crying at the end of a Homer retelling? Couldn’t be… Fine, you caught me, but Calypso’s Guest, a short tale by Pulitzer Prize winning author Andrew Sean Greer, has a soft, forlorn beauty that sent a ripple of emotion through me like a stone dropped in a calm, moonlit pond. It is subtle, small, yet oh so sweet as Greer takes the tale of Calypso and Odysseus from Homer’s Odyseey from the islands of ancient Greece into the solitude of the stars in this queer love tale. It manages to capture an essence of an epic in the space of a few short pages and reads with a quiet, bittersweet melancholy, a lovesick tale baked under bloated suns now softly adrift through the ‘wine-dark void of space’. ‘You must come to think of it as home’ This was a creative and rather whimsical work that manages to do a lot of really exciting world building in a short space. It is the story of Calypso, though instead of being banished by Zeus for her support of Atlas and the Titans, here it is a man sent into exile for having aided The Others—god-like creatures bent on destroying his people—and, after countless years of solitude, finds a man crash landed on his planet. It follows the familiar tale with a few fun deviations as their bond grows despite the new companions desire to return to his palace off in space. And I really enjoyed the story of the prison world, a place where there ‘were no predators except one’s nightmares.’ ‘For he had come, my weary traveler, to his journey’s end. He had crash landed in my prison…’ The story excels at capturing a sense of loneliness but also love and contrasting the narrator’s numbed sense of existence when stretched out by immortality to the passionate and adventurous personality of the visitor. It is all delivered as if in a gorgeous minor key and even knowing where it was headed it still enchanted with surprises in it’s fresh, sci-fi wrappings. ‘ The moons looked in the window at us, a pair of mismatched eyes, and what did they see? A room littered with pillows and books and quietly blinking lights, lit by a single bronze lamp; a room made of much living, and in it, the ones who had lived it: a man in love, standing in the doorway with a dog on its leash. And another, seated at a table, planning his escape. ’ Admittedly, Calypso’s Guest is a bit slight, though there’s little more one could as for it anyways. It is a queer yearning to outshine the stars, yet a tale of inevitable separation, two hearts beating out a limitless distance in the endlessness of space. A quick read, but one that truly engulfs you for a few brief moments of small, bittersweet beauty. 4/5 ‘What is a person except this heap of loss? Otherwise—what wasted breath.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jan 26, 2024
|
Jan 26, 2024
|
Jan 26, 2024
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||
0008608032
| 9780008608033
| 0008608032
| 3.97
| 1,380
| Jun 11, 2024
| Jun 11, 2024
|
it was amazing
|
To be burnt out and drowning in anxieties and familial dysfunction is one thing but if the world is quite literally drowning in the endless rains of c
To be burnt out and drowning in anxieties and familial dysfunction is one thing but if the world is quite literally drowning in the endless rains of climate catastrophe you better hold on tight to the ones you love. Such is the case in Julia Armfield’s Private Rites, a feverishly haunting tale loosely modeled as a queer retelling of William Shakespeare’s King Lear with the passing of an estate to the three daughters of a celebrity architect in a water-logged near future teetering on the brink of utter collapse. Armfield delivers her signature blend of literary horror that truly sinks under your skin through jittery examinations of grief, love and family in a society seemingly resigned to its own extinction. It’s a sort of catastrophe apathy that aches with the dull yet distressing pain of a bruise, one that conjures up memories of society haphazardly attempting to be the same as it always was amidst the recent pandemic, with Armfield keeping much of the calamity in the background and scene setting of taking ferries to work over sunken portions of the city or the endless chaos of closures due to rain. Much like her previous novel, the extraordinary Our Wives Under the Sea, Armfield always resonates deeply with me in a way that reminds me of Jeanette Winterson using horror to shine a light on concepts of love and loss instead of fairy tales as Winterson does. With a disquieting gaze at a society resigned to its own destruction, the violent reactions in those overwhelmed by such loss, fraught interpersonal relations that juxtapose the hardships of fixing a breaking world with the difficulties of love, Private Rites hits high notes of anxiety and trauma both past and present in a story utterly drenched in dread. ‘What happened, then? Two mothers and a father. Three sisters and a house. A house which, once invaded, could not be closed again, was left open to the elements, to whomever wished to come inside.’ The famous passage from King Lear, ‘We that are young, Shall never see so much, nor live so long,’ takes on an eerie new layer of meaning in Armfield’s reconfigured Lear tale as the young sisters at the center of the story live under the growing dread that the number of possible tomorrows is rapidly reaching an end. It is a slow burn apocalypse of rain as ‘seasons and weather patterns blur into one,’ something that becomes so steady it seeps into normalcy. It remains a constant tone soaking every passage, omnipresent like a thorn in the mind yet left to fester as an overwhelming problem to hide behind a bandage of carrying on instead of addressing. ‘The great washout of the world and no sense that it might have been otherwise.’ Like in a western this watery landscape becomes a character in its own right with Armfield even giving “the city” its own perspective to chronicle the slow collapse and resignation of society in the face of impending doom. ‘It is difficult, these days, to know how to be. Not a new phenomenon, of course, but one lent a certain urgency by the situation. People protest, or forget to protest. People hoard food, medical supplies, use them up and hoard them again…they suspect that there is less time than predicted, throw parties to celebrate the endless ending, pretend the coming on of something new. It’s always been this way, always worsening. A contradiction: the fact of something always being the case and yet that case being flux, deterioration.’ In the overbearing hopelessness we find ‘Archaic practices resurfacing the way trends will,’ and cult behavior and erratic interactions begin to infest society. One might think of the ways society pushed to return during the recent pandemic and all the rhetoric of the “new normal”. In interview with Country Town & House, Armfield addresses her ideas around this: ‘Something I’ve been preoccupied with throughout my career is the concept of a pervasive norm – the way that banality and dailiness always assert themselves no matter the extremes people find themselves in. This can be a good thing, inasmuch as it shows how adaptable people can be, but it also signifies a kind of apathy and powerlessness in the face of an overriding system, and I’m extremely interested in that.’ The concept of drowning in the overwhelming weight of it all is expertly metaphor as literal drowning, with oceans and water being a common theme in Armfield’s works. ‘I looked around and realised how prevalent the ocean and the water is in a lot of really formative lesbian media,’ she explains. She has previously spoken on this in an interview with Them Magazine while discussing Our Wives Under the Sea with water as ‘a symbol of something forbidden,’ that functions as ‘a very natural setting for coming-out narratives…the sea can be very calm on the surface, and something can be going on underneath. That speaks to the way that we as queer people have to be so many different things to so many different people.’ Such imagery permeates Private Rites as the turmoil beneath the surface of everyone begins to boil over under the constant stress of the world. ‘Death, after all, puts an end to the argument, but it also prolongs the silence forever.’ At the center of this is the Carmichael family, who’s patriarch, Stephen Carmichael, passes away as the story sets out. Praised as a ‘true genius’ for his architectural marvels that make him ‘the hero of the domestic space…snatching homes from sites grown uninhabitable and lifting them up out of harm's way.’ He is like a Frank Lloyd Wright responding to climate crisis, yet creating homes with a price sticker that cannot act as a life raft to the average person. Left behind are three sisters, Isla, Irene and Agnes, the latter born from a second wife who arrived after the tragic end of the elder sisters’ mother and quickly vanished after Agnes’ birth. It is a family where resentment has grown in the absence of trust and love and each plays out the role of a villain in the minds of the other. ‘Sisterhood, [Irene] thinks, is a trap. You all get stuck in certain roles forever.’ Yet as the world becomes increasingly hostile, each seeks to fill the wound left by a lost mother and frequently finds only disappointment. ‘The rain falls, the night continues–black horizon and the pull of what’s beneath.’ An aspect that hit hard are the ways problems seems to compound upon problems and avoidance only worsens them. ‘The problem is’ becomes nearly a mantra amidst the prose, each exposing another facet of issues, each amalgamating towards apocalyptic distress. ‘The problem, of course, is the general worsening of things—things being housing, and the weather, and The State Of It All. The problem is private companies springing up every other week to mishandle the business of dealing with it and siphon off funding in the process. The problem is the fact that there’s no money, and nowhere to put people, and the fact that they’re working on a skeleton staff with no time and no way to do more than they’re already doing…They are, as Jude reflects, a ship being mended as it sails, except that they aren’t really being mended and their sailing has become less a smooth progress and more the basic act of staying afloat.’ The novel is effectively anxiety inducing as it speaks exactly to the growing issues in our own time. Working a library, for instance, one can see the ways for-profit privatization erodes public goods and grows a class divide where private services become more expensive and public services, like Jude’s job, are understaffed and underfunded. And we consider it all just the way things are and dismiss any attempt at deconstructing or attempting sustainable alternatives. ‘The problem, of course, is that there’s always something, and it can be easier on occasion to ignore it and take your partner back to bed.’ The problem is, hardships are easier to ignore and hope they go away. Global catastrophe feels beyond a singular person and easier to hope for a miracle. Cults appear who have ideas around sacrifice, for instance, and little beyond magical thinking seems to be occurring. To fix the world is hard, yet to live in a failing world is harder. ‘We love people before we notice we love them, but the act of naming the love makes it different, drags it out into different light.’ Something Armfield does so effectively, however, is examine love in the light of all these hardships. With each sister, Armfield examines relationships—Irene has recently separated from a partner, Isla’s Jude (they are possibly the best character in the book) remains calm and loves her despite her rather thorny personality, and Agnes is slipping into a partnership with Stephanie who provides a stability in an unstable world. But love is hard. ‘The problem with love, of course, is that it frequently asks too much of unlovable people. It can be hard, on even the best of days, to compel oneself to be selfless and patient and undemanding or even halfway reasonable when one is not given to any of those behaviours. But these are nonetheless the qualities that love demands. Despite the hardships, love is viewed as being worth it, something that could be applied to the world itself. To save the world would require great sacrifices and a lot of effort but, like love, it could be worthwhile. I’ve always believed love makes it all bearable, a bad day of crisis washes away when you see the one you love, when they show they care by bringing you food (like Jude), when they hold you as you break down and keep your pieces together (like Stephanie). Love gets you through. ‘I could be good with this, if I could have this,’ thinks Agnes, ‘I don’t think it would matter if things had been different or we’d had a different world or more to hope for. I could be happy here.’ ‘Any horror story could be said to work in two pieces: the fear of being wholly alone and of realizing that one has company.’ Private Rites is, ultimately, a horror novel though one that keeps the horror pushed aside until it becomes too much and bursts upon everyone. ‘This is the wrong genre’ Agnes thinks as the dramatic conclusion begins, which perfectly mirrors the horror faced by society as the terror of collapse bursts in after decades of trying to push climate crisis out of their minds. The violence of the ending is shocking and alarming because we see it enacted by the long plans of people and at their hands, however is the climate collapse not also the slow work of human hands either actively bringing about the violence or passively allowing it? Armfield juxtaposes the two for sharp, searing effect and while it arrives as rather jarring it is a reminder that the problems we push aside never vanish. They fester and, eventually, attack. ‘You can hear it if you listen; the slow dissolution, the panic becoming something else.’ A slow burn of a novel spiraling between perspectives and giving the city a space to chronicle its own decay, Private Rites slowly seeps into the reader and shakes them to the core. Haunting and hellishly relevant, it is a tale of family, of resentment, of collapse and consequences. But at the heart of matters, it is a story about love. Endlessly engaging and eerily compelling, Armfield has delivered another masterful novel. 4.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jun 28, 2024
|
Jul 28, 2024
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
4.49
| 134,978
| Dec 07, 2023
| Dec 19, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
Get ready to sob and love every moment of it because Heartstopper is back! Alice Oseman continues to deliver queer joy and charming storytelling with
Get ready to sob and love every moment of it because Heartstopper is back! Alice Oseman continues to deliver queer joy and charming storytelling with an adorable balance of cute romance and earnest investigations of heavy, complex emotions. It feels like it has been forever but it’s so lovely to be back with this crew. [image] Heartstopper has always plunged into difficult yet relatable subjects and this fifth volume is no different. Oseman has always done an excellent job at crafting her characters to feel like authentic teenagers and here we get to witness them growing up a bit more and heading into the next stage of life: college. We also get to experience Nick setting out in the world on his own while Charlie is back at home and even after 5 marvelous volumes I’m always thrilled to find the characters reading as increasingly nuanced yet still familiar. Going away to college issues were addressed in Oseman’s much earlier novella Nick and Charlie, and while this touches on some similar themes this is a completely different story. [image] Though college isn’t the only hurdle here, as anxieties about sex dominate a lot of Charlie’s narrative. As always, Oseman does a great job at representing these issues in an age-authentic way and the character’s emotions practically jump right off the page. There’s some other interesting dynamics to this story too, from discussions on asexuality and also a peek into Charlie’s mom’s childhood. While some of the side characters are a bit more in the background, I’ve always found the series does a good job of making them all rather dynamic and interesting instead of all just extensions of the main characters. All in all, this is another heartwarming edition to an already endearing series. I can’t wait for the next volume, though *gasp* I hear it is to be the final episode in the Heartstopper saga. 5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Dec 15, 2023
|
Dec 15, 2023
|
Dec 15, 2023
|
Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||||
0147514010
| 9780147514011
| 0147514010
| 4.16
| 2,270,277
| Sep 30, 1868
| Nov 17, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
Some books read like a lifelong friendship, each page a warm or comforting embrace as you laugh and weep along with the characters. Little Women by L.
Some books read like a lifelong friendship, each page a warm or comforting embrace as you laugh and weep along with the characters. Little Women by L.M. Alcott is an enduring and endearing classic that will nestle its way so deep into your heart that you’ll wonder if the sound of turning pages has become your new heartbeat in your chest. To read the novel is a magical experience, and we are all like Laurie peering in through the March’s window and relishing in the warmth within. I have long loved the film adaptations and make it a holiday tradition to ensure I at least watch it every December (it has Christmas in it, it counts), so it was fascinating to finally read the actual novel and return to character I feel I’ve always known yet still find it fresh and even more lovely than ever before. Semi-autobiographical, Alcott traces the lives of the four March sisters, Meg, Jo, Beth and Amy, and their struggles to make their own way in a society that offers little use for women beyond the household. An emotional epic and moving family saga full of strong characters, sharp criticisms on society and gender roles, and a beautiful plea to dispense with the worship of wealth and find true purpose and value in simplicity, nature and generosity. ‘I've got the key to my castle in the air, but whether I can unlock the door remains to be seen.’ Little Women will leave your heart full and your pen dry from underlining the seemingly endless lovely passages. I’d like to thank Adira and her wonderful review for convincing me to finally actually read this and not just watch the movie again (I did last night though, because who doesn’t want to relive the joy of yelling “Bob Odenkirk?!” in a theater and later sobbing) because, just when I thought I couldn’t love this story more, now I’m fully engulfed by it. Surely enough has been written about this book already, but i like to ramble about things I love so here’s a more I guess (I’ll try to keep it shorter than usual [having finished writing it now, I failed]). But how can you not be with such incredible characters? Jo is of course the favorite, but I think part of loving this book is wanting to be Jo and realizing you are Amy, but each character touches your heart in their own way. Mr. Laurence and Beth’s connection with the piano and lost daughters makes me teary just writing this. Alcott based the story on her real family and one can read a genuine love for the characters pouring from every page. ‘Wealth is certainly a most desirable thing, but poverty has its sunny side, and one of the sweet uses of adversity is the genuine satisfaction which comes from hearty work of head or hand, and to the inspiration of necessity, we owe half the wise, beautiful, and useful blessings of the world.’ Alcott was a transcendentalist and many of her beliefs shine through in the novel. Much of this came from her father and one will be pleased to learn that the real Mr. March—Amos Bronson Alcott—was as radical in his time as his fictional counterpart. An abolitionist who also advocated for women’s rights, Amos became a major transcendentalist figure along with his friend, Ralph Waldo Emerson. Alcott’s mother was equally radical for her time too, and many of their teachings arrive here through Mrs. March to her children. There is, of course, the belief in nature as the ideal, such as when the March girls, having little jewelry, adorn themselves in flowers instead. Even Laurie states ‘I don’t like fuss and feathers,’ another instance of a return to simplicity over flashy status symbols. There is also the belief in generosity, which is seen throughout with the March family always involved in helping others, and the belief that hard work is important, but not for profit reasons but because it leads to spiritual and emotional happiness and freedom. ‘Then let me advise you to take up your little burdens again; for though they seem heavy sometimes, they are good for us, and lighten as we learn to carry them. Work is wholesome, and there is plenty for every one; it keeps us from ennui and mischief; is good for health and spirits, and gives us a sense of power and independence better than money or fashion.’ Towards the start of the novel, the mother advises the children to be like Christian from John Bunyan’s allegorical novel The Pilgrim's Progress and we can see how Little Women follows a similar fashion of Pilgrim’s being knowledge gained through the travel of a life lived, and each daughter is shown to face certain trials and must learn to bear their burdens, like Jo’s anger, Amy’s desire to be liked, Meg’s desire for vanity, Beth’s passivity. But the largest burdens here are those of love and labor. ‘Women, they have minds, and they have souls, as well as just hearts. And they’ve got ambition, and they’ve got talent, as well as just beauty. I’m so sick of people saying that love is all a woman is fit for.’ The relationship to work is threaded through the entire novel. We have Jo and Amy who wish to be great and break from the traditional mold for women in society. Jo wants to be a writer, though she only publishes scandalous stories under a false name, and Amy desires to be a painter. And neither will settle for anything less than greatness ‘because talent isn't genius, Amy states, ‘and no amount of energy can make it so. I want to be great, or nothing.’ Meg and Beth, on the other hand, show different routes a woman can take. The novel questions if women can find happiness outside marriage and caring for a household, and these struggles bash against social expectations along the way. ‘ I'll try and be what he loves to call me, 'a little woman,' and not be rough and wild; but do my duty here instead of wanting to be somewhere else.’ ‘ I can't get over my disappointment in not being a boy,’ Jo quips, and a major part of Little Women is a critique of gender roles and how they stifle people in society. Laurie is an excellent foil to Jo, in many ways, but is also a way that Alcott addresses and subverts gender expectations. Jo and Laurie both use shortened versions of their name that seem to cross gender expectations (even though Laurie didn’t like being called Dora) and in many ways Jo tends to represent more masculine behavior while Laurie often a more feminine role. While Meg dresses in finery and tries to fill the traditional role of a woman, Jo prefers to romp in nature in simple or dirty garments and behave, by her own admission, like a boy. Recently there has been a lot of discussion on the author’s gender and sexuality, with even the New York Times writing an opinion piece wondering if Alcott or Jo was a trans man. I know that frustrates some people but personally I find it interesting to think about, even if a bit anachronistic, but it seems to be a genuine question people investigate about authors who subvert gender expectations (think how often it was avoided to discuss Virginia Woolf’s sexuality in the past and now we have letters and look at scenes in Mrs Dalloway and think “oh yea, that makes total sense”). Honestly, I say Jo is whatever you want Jo to be. Trans, lesbian, ace, or just a girl pushing back on gender norms. I think the key detail is that Jo was breaking out of the mold, so let that empower you as you best see fit. Personally I thought the marriage to Friedrich felt tacked on anyways (I enjoy the way the Gerwig adaptation addresses this) but, side note, I do see how Alcott weaves in the transcendentalist notion of the “universal family” and belief in learning about and supporting other cultures here. Friedrich is German, Meg marries the English John, and Laurie is said to be half-Italian, which all comes as a rebuttal to the anti-immigration sentiments of the times. ‘I like good strong words that mean something,’ Jo says and that appeals to my love of language as well. This book deals with love in many ways, but feels like a romance between book and reader as you enjoy every page. Little Women was ahead of its time and still stands proudly today as an endearing work that dares challenge social convention. But most importantly, it feels like a friend. Finishing is hard as now I’ll miss the days with the March sisters, and I find books that take you from childhood to adulthood often hit the hardest because you feel as if you’ve grown up together. An emotional read, also a genius one, Little Women is a favorite now forever. 5/5 ‘ Watch and pray, dear, never get tired of trying, and never think it is impossible to conquer your fault.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Dec 04, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0241207002
| 9780241207000
| 0241207002
| 3.67
| 74,562
| Oct 20, 2016
| Oct 20, 2016
|
it was amazing
|
‘It was the worst of times, it was the worst of times.’ I find autumn to be my favorite time of year so it was little surprise that Ali Smith’s artisti ‘It was the worst of times, it was the worst of times.’ I find autumn to be my favorite time of year so it was little surprise that Ali Smith’s artistic expression of the season in Autumn would become a favorite book. It is a season that enfolds multitudes of contradictions inside itself, all tumbling about like the fallen leaves in the breeze yet somehow harmonizing the discordance into a bittersweet emotional symphony. It is the season of decay with the days eroding towards dark and cold yet the seasons proclaims a defiant death throe of comforting weather and vibrant colors like ‘a second spring when every leaf is a flower,’ as Albert Camus once wrote. Warm days with a crisp underbite. Personally, autumn has always felt like the ideal catalyst for the moments we synthesize as key details in our personal bildungsromans: the start of new school years bringing change and the excitement of new things or, in college years, the season coincides with that first taste of campus freedom and the intense early scenes of a university romance. ‘Autumns seem that season of beginning,’ Truman Capote wrote, and these beginnings conflicting with the symbolic endings of the season are a gorgeous contradiction that has always captured not only my heart, but many of the great writers and poets throughout the ages. Jane Austen tells us this in Persuasion, touching upon autumn as: ‘that season of peculiar and inexhaustible influence on the mind of taste and tenderness — that season which has drawn from every poet worthy of being read some attempt at description, or some lines of feeling.’ There is a high bar for autumnal expression and Ali Smith not only meets the challenge but creates something that combines the calendar season with a specific sort of political autumn in 2016. Above all, Smith captures the contradictory nature of autumn into a heartrending exploration of what it means to be a person and one person among many. While being rather melancholy in tone, Autumn reads rather playfully as it saunters through prose composed of puns, paintings and political polarization. To speak of a plot seems beside the point as Smith extracts meaning from quotidian moments, creating a collage of images that amalgamate towards an otherwise ineffable impression. Elisabeth,the central character in Autumn writes of of underrecognized British pop artist Pauline Boty’s collage work that ‘an image of an image means the image can be seen with new objectivity, with liberation from the original,’ and Smith’s narrative can be viewed as representing autumn in a similar regard. In this way, Autumn catalyzes past and present as well as the personal and political in a deeply moving work where each beautiful sentence fell into my heart like leaves cascading off the trees. ‘ The trees are revealing their structures. There’s the catch of fire in the air. All the souls are out marauding. But there are roses, there are still roses. ’ Ali Smith wrote in The Guardian that her Seasons Quartet—a series of books that could plausibly be read as stand-alones or in any order (of which Autumn is the first) though do travel in a thematic movement forward like the passage of time they represent—‘would be about not just their own times, but the place where time and the novel meet.’ Time is central to everything here, even in its invisibility, and all the aspects of “past” and “present” presented here as the narrative sashays across the timeline seem to find the Brexit referendum as the major hinge between them. It represents not just the dividing line between “before” and “after” Brexit, which is something deeply felt in times of historical change just like how the Covid pandemic in 2020 often becomes a reference for “before” and “after” (Smith writes about this later in Companion Piece), but also a political dividing line between people. Smith spends several lengthy passages emphasizing this: ‘All across the country, people felt bereaved and shocked. All across the country, people felt righteous. All across the country, people felt sick. All across the country, people felt history at their shoulder. All across the country, people felt history meant nothing. All across the country, people felt like they counted for nothing. All across the country, people had pinned their hopes on it. All across the country, people waved flags in the rain. All across the country, people drew swastika graffiti. All across the country, people threatened other people. All across the country, people told people to leave. All across the country, the media was insane. All across the country, politicians lied. All across the country, politicians fell apart…’ This collective contradictory feeling, this sort of metaphorical autumn or “fall,” creates an uneasy backdrop to the novel. Smith excels at threading small details as subplots through the story that quietly emphasize this. There is the back-and-forth of graffiti on a wall spitefully telling people to go home and being reminded the UK is their home or the idea of being divided getting a physical manifestation as an electrified fence across the town at which Elisabeth’s mother eventually assaults with trinkets she finds at an antiques shop ‘bombarding that fence with people’s histories.’ Though my favorite is the rather humorous paperwork drama that unfolds with Elisabeth assailed by bureaucratic barriers in an attempt to renew her passport. As someone who often has to ask for multiple forms of ID in order to register people for a library card, Elisabeth being unable to provide ID without being able to renew her ID because of specifications that come across as comically absurd was rather darkly delightful to read. But all these details—Smith is extraordinary at writing about nothing, the quiet moments are so cathartically perfect—really add up to dynamically portray the specifics of the moment in time. ‘That's the thing about things. They fall apart, always have, always will, it's in their nature.’ Within the larger political is a rather intimate tale of the personal: the friendship between Elisabeth and Daniel which begins when she is a young girl and he, the aging neighbor, becomes a sort of caregiver so Elisabeth’s mother can dodge responsibilities and head out to town. This friendship becomes her sort of coming-of-age narrative, making a home in her heart that will inform the rest of her life. ‘The lifelong friends,’ Daniel, already an old man, says to her in her youth, ‘sometimes wait a lifetime for them.’ And sometimes it is the absences that speak loudest, with the past of their times together—experiencing art and playing thought and language games that excite and exercise the imagination and often tend to bend towards the political—juxtaposed with the present as she reads to him in a elderly care facility while he remains asleep at the ripe old age of 101. It is a really moving story and as Smith places each piece of their time together into the collective portrait of life the story only becomes sadder yet more beautiful. ‘A great many men don’t understand a woman full of joy, even more don’t understand paintings full of joy by a woman.’ The artist Pauline Boty is first introduced to her by Daniel and becomes a symbol within the novel not only for a feminist resistance against a patriarchy that would always try to delegitimize or sweep aside women’s efforts, but also an expression of art forged from political unrest. In this way, Smith ties the story of Boty with that of Christine Keeler and the Profumo Affair, from which her painting, Scandal 63, became a political statement (the painting has notably been lost). [image] Pauline Boty with her painting of Christine Keeler, ‘Scandal 63’ Smith continues this legacy of forming art from the political. It is in the nature of art it seems, adapting and creating as if in refusal to be legislated into silence. Take the word “Brexit” for instance, a word that didn’t exist until the UK moved to break from the EU but now is a commonly known term: language creates and adapts to meet the times. ‘Language is like poppies. It just takes something to churn the earth round them up, and when it does up come the sleeping words, bright red, fresh, blowing about.’ I loved the moments with Daniel and Elisabeth where their word games became political expressions even without her realizing it, such as the incredible scene where Daniel takes Elisabeth’s image of a man with a gun and his with a man dressed as a tree and creates a story representing political oppression and violence against those who deviate from the socially-enforced “norms”. In a way a novel is a rebuttal against the news, particularly in times when people no longer trust the media. ‘I’m tired of the news. I’m tired of the way it makes things spectacular that aren’t, and deals so simplistically with what’s truly appalling,’ we are told, and a novel is a way to take those same details and organize them in ways that emphasize the emotional undercurrents that are often left out. A way to create a fiction that can do battle with the fictions told by those in power to obtain or retain power. ‘Always be reading something,’ Daniel advises, ‘even when we're not physically reading. How else will we read the world?’ This is why I find literature to be so important, it helps us read the world. ‘I'm tired of the vitriol. I'm tired of anger. I'm tired of the meanness. I'm tired of selfishness. I'm tired of how we're doing nothing to stop it. I'm tired of how we're encourageing it. I'm tired of the violence that's on it's way, that's coming, that hasn't happened yet. I'm tired of liars. I'm tired of sanctified liars. I'm tired of how those liars have let this happen. I'm tired of having to wonder whether they did it out of stupidity or did it on purpose. I'm tired of lying governments. I'm tired of people not caring whether they're being lied to anymore. I'm tired of being made to feel this fearful.’ In times of unrest, a beautiful story can really help us sort out our feelings. It remind me of the lines by Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish: ‘ A poem in a difficult time / is beautiful flowers in a cemetery.’ It is in art we can find hope, and hope is important to hold onto. ‘Hope is exactly that, that’s all it is, a matter of how we deal with the negative acts towards human beings by other human beings in the world, remembering that they and we are all human, that nothing human is alien to us, the foul and the fair, and that most important of all we’re here for a mere blink of the eyes, that’s all.’ And that is what the season of autumn reminds me of most: hope. It is a season of both endings and beginnings, it is a season of death and decay but it also bursts with color and reminds us to hold on. Winter is coming and we need to hold our inner warmth to get through and, as Smith shows us here, the connections we have with others is the greatest of warmths. ‘We have to hope that the people who love us and who know us a little bit will in the end have seen us truly. In the end, not much else matters.’ Autumn is a powerful little book, so alive in prose that often feels like it is riffing, so deep in emotions that creep across the page so quietly, and so full of hope and heartfelt joy even in moments of bleakness. I’ve been meaning to read this for a few years and am glad I did it during the titular season, reading it while on a trip through Atlanta all alive in colorful leaves and the warm yet crisp weather of early November. This was an experience of a novel that dug deep in me and Ali Smith is an incredible writer. Once the season turns, I am eager to read the next book. 5/5 ‘There's always, there'll always be, more story. That's what story is...It's the never-ending leaf-fall.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 19, 2023
|
Nov 19, 2023
|
Nov 19, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0062955772
| 9780062955777
| 0062955772
| 4.03
| 2,123
| Aug 29, 2023
| Aug 29, 2023
|
really liked it
|
Italian theoretical physicist Carlo Rovelli wrote that quantum mechanics is essentially about relationships, that ‘an electron is nowhere when it is n
Italian theoretical physicist Carlo Rovelli wrote that quantum mechanics is essentially about relationships, that ‘an electron is nowhere when it is not interacting,’ which is all a beautiful reminder that the ways we live, love and interact with one another is what makes up our world. Wendy Xu brings this up in her gorgeous new graphic novel, The Infinity Particle, and through this touching sci-fi story expands on these ideas between humans as well as a future with interpersonal relationships with AI. After moving Mars for an exciting job working for a pioneering engineer in the field of AI, Clementine finds herself caught up in the mysteries surrounding her boss’ personal AI unit, Kyle. Though attempting to help him uncovers big ethical issues surrounding AI as well as emotions deep within each other. Stunning in both artistic and emotional quality, Infinity Particle probes ethical quandaries of autonomy and consent, moving at an exciting pace through the growing mysteries of this highly engaging and thoughtful graphic novel. [image] I’m sure you’ve seen that the news is constantly full of stories concerning AI on issues of consent and also bias (also we should be paying artists, writers and actors), though Infinity Particle takes questions of consent to the future on issues about how much autonomy a self-sufficient AI would have in society. Xu—who’s graphic novels I always adore and I highly recommend Tidesong—presents us with questions on identity in a really interesting way and aspect on AI’s developing emotions as well as emotional connections. I enjoyed how much the story is steeped in STEM and ethical issues without getting overly complex while still being quite ponderous. I also loved all the AI companions who are incredibly cute: [image] The cat buddy especially since he reminds me of the Lumbercats from that Kipo and the Age of Wonderbeasts show. The art in this is breathtaking and really pops in its minimal color palette. Xu has creative use of panels to push dialogue along, never gets overly wordy, and keeps the pace moving quite efficiently. That said, while it doesn’t necessarily feel too rushed it does sort of hit all the plot points and reach the conclusion a bit hurriedly. Still, this hits some strong emotions. There is a really adorable romance plot, but also a lot of time spent on feelings of loss. The story only hints at the backstories of characters, but in ways where the small glimpses explode into big feelings in your heart and make you really feel for the characters. This was a lot of fun and really heartfelt and adorable. It is interesting to see how many graphic novels seem to be tackling issues around AI’s integrating with society—I enjoyed this one more but Pixels of You also takes an interesting look at AI ethics as well as a romantic relationship between a flesh and blood human and AI human—which I suppose is a future reality we are rapidly approaching so its nice to see books already probing the big questions. Wendy Xu is always a delight and The Infinity Particle was a lovely read. 4.5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Oct 17, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1250799058
| 9781250799050
| 1250799058
| 3.84
| 88,034
| Oct 03, 2023
| Oct 03, 2023
|
liked it
|
I think I liked this best when it didn’t feel like it was auditioning for Tiktok content creation… The past speaks in a multitude of voices, though far I think I liked this best when it didn’t feel like it was auditioning for Tiktok content creation… The past speaks in a multitude of voices, though far too often those with power use it to silence the voices that make them uncomfortable or dismiss them as discordant and dangerous. The titular house in Starling House, the southern gothic fantasy from Alix E. Harrow, is not only a place around which many rumors are whispered but one where such discordant voices may just be waiting in its gloomy eaves just waiting to be heard. Starling House is a rather cozy horror that, despite an unfortunately slogging pace, wraps you up in irresistible prose and intoxicating, uneasy atmosphere as it teases out its secrets. Combing the legacy of Southern Gothic with a rather Beauty and the Beast-esque romance and other fairy tale elements, we watch as Opal goes from poverty and struggling to care for her younger brother into becoming caretaker of Starling House where it’s reclusive Warden holds back a shocking secret. Despite a story that is overly reliant on miscommunication and an ambitious narrative that doesn’t land all its tricks, Starling House is a satisfying and sinister good time that examines the way storytelling can reshape the truth and why some truths seem to be a vortex of violence. ‘He told me Hell was real, and so were its demons.’ While I felt that this book was reaching to pull off too many techniques that, ultimately, felt unnecessary, it isn’t to saw Harrow is a bad writer. Quite the contrary, as this story really engulfs you in its dreariness and dread. It is a slow-burn narrative, one that is perhaps a bit stretched out, but it functions quite well as a thematic exploration of the ways the truths we try to bury will always return. Harrow raws on the tradition of American gothic writers, such as Nathaniel Hawthorne and Edgar Allan Poe, and the ways the focus is less on a specific evil but on the ways evils are folded into the very fiber of the past, such as an American legacy of colonialism and slavery. Though Harrow also figures into the legacy of women’s rage that speaks so sharply in the Southern Gothic and seems to channel many of the ideas of outsiders and moral frustrations that appear in the works of Flannery O'Connor and offers a specific Southern US setting. It is her first story to take place in home of Kentucky, something she spoke about in a conversation with NPR: ‘This is the first book that I set fully in, like committed to writing about Kentucky…One of the reasons that I had found that difficult to do before is because I find it to be a place of very mixed experiences that I love very, very, very much, and which has just an incredible violence and terror to it.’ That legacy of violence and terror is certainly present here, in the ways that, like the best of Southern Gothic, grotesqueries and spooky settings tend to function as a symbol of past sins that seep like shed blood towards the present. ‘Starling House makes me think of an underfed pet or a broken doll, a thing unloved by the person who promised to love it best.’ Starling House is the perfect symbol of all the silenced rage and sacrificed lives that haunt the town if one knows under which rocks of history to look. It is a house that calls to Opal all her life. ‘Because I dreamed of Starling House long before I ever saw it. Because sometimes when the light slants soft through the west windows and turns the dust mots into tiny golden fireflies I like to pretend the house belongs to me, or that I belong to it.’ Though, as readers learn, this is no ordinary haunted house. In his introduction for the novel Burnt Offerings, horror author Stephen Graham Jones offers two distinctions of haunted houses: the Stay Away Houses and the Hungry Houses. Jone’s explains that Stay Away one's drive people away but‘Hungry Houses aren't complete without people to digest for reasons or decades or centuries,’ though here we have an interesting twist that the house—more a character than a setting itself—draws people in to keep to care for it and protect the secrets it holds dear. The way Harrow excels at making settings a character is really wonderful and in keeping with many gothic themes, though the town itself feels rather underutilized, more existing off-page or in history than really engaged with in the present. This is an aspect of the novel overall that felt rather lackluster. There is a lot of potential for town itself to feel like a character, either cloyingly or comfortingly, (which is something that Stephen King has long been known for executing with incredible results) though it almost feels like an afterthought after the initial set-up. Characters like the librarian in particular—I often find helpful librarian characters to be eyerollingly saccharine caricatures of the field or only serve as twee nods (see also: vocational awe) but here she felt really authentic and to function the way a modern library setting would to the point where I wonder if Harrow has worked in libraries—or even the brother feel under used. And E. Starling, who seems should be a major figure in the book, gets far too little page time. There are a lot of little strands that either fall flat or seem left underexplored and occasionally it felt like Harrow was trying to pack in as many tropes or ideas as possible to appeal to a vast variety of “to read” lists instead of doing any of them particularly well. Two examples are how, while racism comes up here, it feels more just a nod and under examined which is a shame as it fits really well into the major themes of Southern Gothic, and a character is briefly mentioned as bisexual almost as if to say “put this on library lists for LGBTQ books, please” rather than earnest attempts at representation (as someone who is pansexual it’s like…oh yay rep but also seems just something an author can say without having to explore and still have a straight relationship so is it really?). I also appreciated the footnotes (which do sort of get explained) but she abandons the technique a third of the way through the book and makes it feel tacked on rather than integrated. Harrow does a good job, however, at stradling the line between YA and adult fiction and I think this is a book that would really appeal to readers of both genres. That said, I think this might have worked better as a YA. The horror elements are fairly tame (its almost cozy), the romance (which feels very unearned and out of nowhere) isn’t exactly spicy, and the characters felt much more like older teens than adults. Opal especially feels more like a fiery teenage character with too much on her plate than a mid-twenties woman struggling to feed her brother in a rent-free hotel room. ‘I slam the door as I leave, because if you’re going to act like a hormonal teenager you might as well commit to the role,’ she says at one point, and I think this would have benefitted to Harrow commiting to Opal’s role by making her a teen. ‘The house has always had a taste for the brave ones.’ I did like the characters, however. Arthur, who seems an allusion to the similarly reclusive Arthur “Boo” Radley from To Kill a Mockingbird, is constantly mentioned as being ugly. This ties into the Beauty and the Beast allusions, but it also is part of a larger theme that what is considered ugly is cast aside and ignored. It is, perhaps, almost gratuitous how much Opal talks about how ugly he is (but then almost like flicking a lightswitch is in love with him) but it does seem to fit the themes quite well. ‘They averted their eyes from evil, and in doing so, became complicit in it.’ What does really work is the exploration of how a place can be trapped or haunted by the past. Opal is given a multi-figure offer to dig up some secrets by the Big Bad Company of the novel and decides to do some digging for her own sake (for a character that is supposed to be really intelligent, she is always the last to know and not since reading Verity have I so much wanted to shout “pay attention to the important clues oh my god what are you doing”). We discover so many histories are enfolded inside, and each time she probes another voice emerges adding a new dimension to the tale, rewriting previously believed histories and often adding more layers of mystery than questions answered. ‘I was a songbird in a den of foxes, and they were so hungry.’ Power, we see, is often about shaping history for the purpose of the powerful. It is how stories fall through the cracks, or get reconfigured into something far from the truth. And then go to great lengths to ensure their version becomes the “history,” which, as anyone who has read the gothic tales can attest, tend to be the reason why ghosts and ghouls come screaming back from the grave. ‘They simply told themselves a different story, one that was easier to believe because they’d heard it before: Once there was a bad woman who ruined a good man. Once there was a witch who cursed a village. Once there was an odd, ugly girl whom everyone hated, because it was safe to hate her.’ Which all works really well and leads to a rather exciting conclusion, though for a novel that felt stretched out the climax (which is, admittedly, rather emotionally lovely and tender) feels rather rushed. Starling House is a rather thrilling, slow-burn gothic fantasy that was tough to put down. While I may have been rather critical, overall it is quite enjoyable and just felt like it needed more polishing to smooth out the elements and pacing. Those who enjoy gothic tales, fantasy and a bit of romance will find much to enjoy here and while this wasn’t my favorite it makes me really want to read Harrow’s earlier tales. A creepy yet charming story. 3.5/5 ‘It occurs to me that this lonely, beastly, bleeding boy is the only person who has ever fought for me, ever stood between me and the dark and told me to save myself.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Oct 04, 2023
|
Dec 26, 2023
|
Oct 04, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1954404131
| 9781954404137
| B09XVJPXQ5
| 4.07
| 3,473
| Apr 19, 2021
| Jan 17, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
**Winner of the 2023 National Book Award for Translated Fiction!** ‘You opened up my sunset.’ First love carves a trench in our hearts that lets our fir **Winner of the 2023 National Book Award for Translated Fiction!** ‘You opened up my sunset.’ First love carves a trench in our hearts that lets our first outpouring of love become a river we hope will flow for a lifetime. Even if that first sting of love is short and bittersweet, it often lingers like a shadow laying long across the landscape of the self. In Brazilian author Stênio Gardel’s The Words That Remain, a long lost first love quietly lingering as it remains folded inside a letter given to our narrator who is unable to read and ‘grew old wishing to know what it said.’ Having spent his life running from pain and homophobia, Raimundo spends the twilight years of his life learning to read in order to finally know the words his first lover, Cícero, hidden in the silence of the page much like queer relationships such as their own had to be kept hidden away from society. Told in a kaleidoscopic fashion transferring perspectives and frequently jumping all along the timeline on bridges of emotion and memory, the story is delivered in a steady stream of poetic prose—the English translation by Bruna Dantas Lobato is quite gorgeous and was certainly no simple task making it apparent why this is a strong contender for the National Book Award for Translation—that all culminates to quite a powerful experience. Heartbreaking yet hopeful and full of deep symbolism, The Words That Remain is a succinct and poetic expression on the resilience of queer people to be able to be themselves in the face of oppression and the way we carry and shift love across a lifetime. ‘I’ve been on so many roads, but I only wandered like that because I had to, hunting the distance, which only got farther and farther…’ I was awed by the sheer beauty of the writing in The Words That Remain, often arriving in long, run on sentences that make you feel as out of breath from their emotion as the characters using language to process their experiences. There are abrupt shifts along the timeline and between perspectives, leaving the reader to piece it together which can sometimes be jarring and confusing even when it works well but also seems to capture the instability experienced by the characters. Language is seen as a way to capture beauty, sort of how Raimundo views Cícero’s name, ‘Only six letters, but it could hold so much.’ The irony of the story is that Raimundo cannot read or write, having been brought up in a rural laborers home where ‘father said writing was for people who don’t need to put food on the table,’ and the hardships of working class poverty chase him his entire life around Brazil. And then there is the letter. ‘Cícero’s letter. Which was half-blessed, half-cursed, wholly mysterious,’ a symbol both of the love that was taken from them by beating from their respective fathers that send them running away from home and a constant reminder to Raimundo of his isolation from society, ‘because ignorance does that, excludes, isolates, and didn’t I live in isolation?’ But his isolation also comes from having to hide who he is, always fearing he will be exposed as a gay man and cast out because of it. ‘I’ll defend myself. I like men, but I still am one,’ and that desire to be seen as a man often brings a lot of internalized (and outward) homophobia. Which can get a bit rough to read, heads up, particularly the way his close relationship with Suzzanny begins with violent transphobia. In a way I was reminded a bit of McGlue by Ottessa Moshfegh though this is much more tender and optimistic. ‘The stars must have fallen and become the seeds of reality at his feet.’ The attitudes towards queerness are harsh and tragic here. We see Raimundo’s father beat him even after we learn the sad fate of the father’s brother, Dalberto, who ‘was half of his heart, the half he lost to the river and to his father’s tough fist.’ Even though we see him think ‘I wanted to stay by your side, to pull you out of the water as many times as you needed,’ we see him still succumb to fear and hurt his son for the very same thing. It is fear, fear ‘this can only take you to the bottom of the river or under the ground,’ and telling his son he is on a ‘path of death.’ This also seeps into the two lovers, feeling their experiences together was ‘A good taste, but that left something sour in the back of their minds.' They can't even feel good about feeling loved when so much of their lives has been teaching them to feel shame over it. So much of this is symbolized in the cross left where the uncle took his last breath, ‘the cross that marked the river and that would mark [Raimundo’s] life,’ which not only stands as a symbol of remembrance of the horrors committed and lives lost, but also that society tries to justify their homophobia through religion. The lack of the cross when Raimundo is older represents the changing attitudes in society, but also the removal of the cross reflects the removal of the shame he felt. ‘A man liking another man is not a death sentence, it’s a life sentence, full of life, I felt full of life.’ Shame makes up a large part of the novel, the way the father ‘only saw my shame,’ and the way his shame becomes self-hatred. The river from his hometown becomes rather symbolic of shame and there is a motif of drowning, both literal and metaphorically, throughout such as how shame registers ‘like my body is filled with stones.’ But we must let go of shame, and be who we really are. ‘Shame was of no use to me, what it did was open the door to the street, and when the door closed behind me, with the whole street out in front of me, the whole world out in front of me, I let go of shame’s hand.’ I love the way Gardel juxtaposes the image of letting go of shame’s hand with Raimundo’s desire to never let go of Cícero’s hand even if people see them together. But this also keys into a major theme of the novel: change. There is a campfire story about the devil offering change for the price of one’s soul, something we see haunts Cícero, but as the novel progresses we can see how change can actually free your soul. I quite enjoy how this is so well represented by the concept of poetry as Raimundo learns it in his reading classes: ‘Our teacher explained words in poems mean more than they seem, words are stretched, so where words alone can’t go, with poetry they can, they fly, like the bird, the bird that can hear loud silences, that can open up dawns, shrink rivers, horizon stretchers, only words can do that!’ Just like poetry can change what words are and can do, love can change a person and embracing one’s true self can do the same. We see that with Suzzanny being more than just her body, and we see the way love can change the context of how we see the world, when ‘I made the decision to see the world differently’ ‘their embrace irrigated the deep roots inside them, which clung to their guts and everything else inside them. Even their souls. And the roots turned their veins into sap and grew through their pores like branches climbing toward the sun. When they touched, they became entangled and turned into a single stalk, with a flower that opened on their chest. Yellow poppy in a blood red sepal.’ It is often said that first loves cut the deepest, and that sting can remain for a long time. Yet, they also say time can heal and how often as the years go by and new loves meld with us that the sting fades and what were painful memories now feel safe to touch. And while there was ‘a lifetime kept in that letter,’ will the words still mean the same thing when read many decades after they were written? Can we change when we are no longer ashamed of ourselves, and can our resilience in the face of aggression brought on by bad faith fear lead to happier times ahead? The Words That Remain drags us through tragedy but has an optimistic heart at its core, one that is full of striking imagery and phrases that are nearly overwhelming in their beauty. This is quite a moving read. 4.5/5 ‘even in old age we don’t stop wishing for something, the point of life is to keep going.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Sep 22, 2023
|
Sep 22, 2023
|
Sep 22, 2023
|
Kindle Edition
|
s.penkevich
>
Books:
love
(62)
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
![]() |
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
3.97
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Jul 24, 2024
|
||||||
4.28
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Jul 15, 2024
|
||||||
4.44
|
it was amazing
|
Apr 29, 2024
|
Apr 29, 2024
|
||||||
Cho, Zen
*
| 4.34
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Apr 18, 2024
|
|||||
4.06
|
really liked it
|
May 28, 2024
|
Apr 14, 2024
|
||||||
3.76
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Apr 08, 2024
|
||||||
3.68
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Apr 04, 2024
|
||||||
4.20
|
really liked it
|
Apr 15, 2024
|
Apr 04, 2024
|
||||||
3.48
|
liked it
|
not set
|
Apr 03, 2024
|
||||||
3.72
|
really liked it
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
||||||
3.95
|
really liked it
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
||||||
4.41
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
||||||
3.82
|
really liked it
|
Jan 26, 2024
|
Jan 26, 2024
|
||||||
3.97
|
it was amazing
|
Jul 28, 2024
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
||||||
4.49
|
it was amazing
|
Dec 15, 2023
|
Dec 15, 2023
|
||||||
4.16
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Dec 04, 2023
|
||||||
3.67
|
it was amazing
|
Nov 19, 2023
|
Nov 19, 2023
|
||||||
4.03
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Oct 17, 2023
|
||||||
3.84
|
liked it
|
Dec 26, 2023
|
Oct 04, 2023
|
||||||
4.07
|
it was amazing
|
Sep 22, 2023
|
Sep 22, 2023
|