What do you think?
Rate this book
Penric and Desdemona (Publication order) #9
Masquerade in Lodi
Bastard’s Eve is a night of celebration for most residents in the canal city of Lodi -- but not for sorcerer Learned Penric and his Temple demon Desdemona, who find themselves caught up in the affairs of a shiplost madman, a dangerous ascendant demon, and a very unexpected saint of the fifth god.
This novella falls between “Penric’s Fox” and “Penric��s Mission” in the internal chronology of the Penric & Desdemona tales.
This novella falls between “Penric’s Fox” and “Penric��s Mission” in the internal chronology of the Penric & Desdemona tales.
102 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 14, 2020
About the author
Lois McMaster Bujold
198 books38.4k followersLois McMaster Bujold was born in 1949, the daughter of an engineering professor at Ohio State University, from whom she picked up her early interest in science fiction. She now lives in Minneapolis, and has two grown children.
Her fantasy from HarperCollins includes the award-winning Chalion series and the Sharing Knife tetralogy; her science fiction from Baen Books features the perennially bestselling Vorkosigan Saga. Her work has been translated into over twenty languages.
Questions regarding foreign rights, film/tv subrights, and other business matters should be directed to Spectrum Literary Agency, spectrumliteraryagency.com
A listing of her awards and nominations may be seen here:
http://www.sfadb.com/Lois_McMaster_Bu...
A listing of her interviews is here:
http://vorkosigan.wikia.com/wiki/Auth...
An older fan-run site devoted to her work, The Bujold Nexus, is here:
http://www.dendarii.com/
Her fantasy from HarperCollins includes the award-winning Chalion series and the Sharing Knife tetralogy; her science fiction from Baen Books features the perennially bestselling Vorkosigan Saga. Her work has been translated into over twenty languages.
Questions regarding foreign rights, film/tv subrights, and other business matters should be directed to Spectrum Literary Agency, spectrumliteraryagency.com
A listing of her awards and nominations may be seen here:
http://www.sfadb.com/Lois_McMaster_Bu...
A listing of her interviews is here:
http://vorkosigan.wikia.com/wiki/Auth...
An older fan-run site devoted to her work, The Bujold Nexus, is here:
http://www.dendarii.com/
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 328 reviews
October 18, 2020
God I needed this. Once again my only complaint is the brevity - I could cheerfully walked around the city for at least two days.
January 3, 2022
4.5 stars
Squeeeee! I have lost all semblance of objectivity when it comes to these novellas. Bujold always delivers a wonderful mix of mystery, adventure, and theology; all balanced with a clear and compassionate view of the humans involved. I always come away feeling comforted.
ETA 3 Jan 2022: Just re-read, because my hardback copy finally arrived.
I loved it, again! A fine way to 'read in' the new year.
Squeeeee! I have lost all semblance of objectivity when it comes to these novellas. Bujold always delivers a wonderful mix of mystery, adventure, and theology; all balanced with a clear and compassionate view of the humans involved. I always come away feeling comforted.
ETA 3 Jan 2022: Just re-read, because my hardback copy finally arrived.
I loved it, again! A fine way to 'read in' the new year.
October 8, 2021
[9/10]
Desdemona is once again bored as her host, Penric, is spending too much time in an office, translating diplomatic letters for his new sponsor.
Busy work, sniffed Des. Make-work. A waste of our talents.
Penric is grateful to have exchanged the pervasive cold of Martensbridge for the humid, warm air of Lodi – a wonderful city of canals , palaces, commerce and gondolas in a lagoon. [I’ll give you three guesses for the source of inspiration in this]. The young temple sorcerer would welcome some peaceful interlude, after his career as a demonic healer in Martensbridge ended abruptly with mental burnout and depression. ( “A serious mismatch between soul and calling. Serious mismatch. It broke something.” ) . Des thinks her master needs something else to occupy his mind and keep him from brooding on that almost fatal failure. The case of a young man found almost dead and with his mind wandering in the middle of the sea seems like a good opportunity for both of them to escape the confines of the letter office.
As a creature of pure spirit, a demon requires a body of matter to support it in the world of matter.
Penric and Des realize as soon as they visit the young man in hospital that he is tormented by a demon he picked up while drowning. The demon itself is in an even sorrier state than its host after a series of failed or brutally interrupted ‘imprintings’. The chances of recovering either the man or the deranged spirit are extremely thin, and Penric needs assistance from a trained exorcist for this. In his religious order, a part of the Five Gods system prevalent across most countries, this would be the Bastard’s Saint for Lodi and environs. To his embarrassed surprise, Penric finds out that his needed Saint is Chio - a teenage girl from the Order’s house for orphans - and that she will also welcome a chance to evade from the careful eye of her Guardian and spend a night of adventure in Lodi.
“They give us great gifts, if they can be educated, and treated with understanding and respect. Like any other complicated thing of power and danger, which can kill you if misused. A water mill, a sailing ship, a hunting dog, a forge, a foundry – a human being. A pity and a waste when they are ruined.”
Penric and Chio return together to Lodi to find out that the young man has escaped from hospital and is wandering around city, on the eve of Festival Night, driven by a mad demon. Their quest becomes urgent both from the danger of the demon gaining ascendancy over its host and from what appears to be third parties interested in the young man and his mysterious accident at sea.
>>><<<>>><<<
I’ve read this episode out of order, but it doesn’t really matter. The Lodi interlude helps clarify the reasons Penric left Martensbridge and introduces the reader to the wandering from place to place period of the temple sorcerer. It is a great opportunity for the author to expand the world with new vistas and new cultural references and to explore variations on the previous three plot schemes that relied heavily on the murder investigation template.
While there is a criminal investigation of sorts still present here, the true focus is the relationship between hosts and demons and the role the Gods play as arbiters of this symbiotic cohabitation. Strong characterization and moral quandaries have always been a feature of Lois McMaster Bujold writing, well supported even in this shorter form by lively action, clear exposition and a wicked sense of humour.
Pen tried not to let his mind be diverted by the picture of a demonic chicken.
To me, and probably to other hundreds of hardcore fantasy fans, this is a clear Easter Egg and a reference to an infamous scene from Terry Goodkind’s “Sword of Truth” series. Penric’s continuous troubles in controlling either Desdemona or the young women he meets during his adventures when it comes to feminist points of view is another source of amusement, something that will soon come to a head in the next three episodes in the series (which I have already finished).
For my conclusion of this excellent addition to a fascinating series, I will quote once again Desdemona, the multiple-personality demon, as she sighs with fond exasperation:
‘Have I mentioned I actually like your overactive imagination?’
September 5, 2023
Going to be honest, this feels like a bit of a dud compared to the previous novellas, especially the magnificent Orphans of Raspay. Still not *bad* (it's Bujold), but the central problem doesn't feel quite as pressing or the antagonists quite as dangerous.
October 17, 2020
Shows us a previously unknown time in Penric's life filling in some of the unknowns in both the world building and his journey. I love how Bujold has embraced self publishing e-novellas; there are nine in this series now and the journey as a whole is delightful.
March 24, 2021
Delightful
Takes place over a night in Lodi (Bastard’s Eve) in Midsummer, as Penric and Des and Blessed Chio search for a young man ridden by a demon. After much wandering around Pen and Chio find the young man just in time. Really fun.
Takes place over a night in Lodi (Bastard’s Eve) in Midsummer, as Penric and Des and Blessed Chio search for a young man ridden by a demon. After much wandering around Pen and Chio find the young man just in time. Really fun.
August 11, 2023
One of the best of the series!
April 14, 2021
Penric, and his demon, Desdemona, are still relatively new in the canal city and seaport of Lodi, and his position as Archdivine Ogial's court sorcerer. When Penric is called to the Gift of the Sea charity hospice for sailors to see a "poor mad fellow" fished out of the sea by a fishing ship, whose problem might be of the supernatural kind, he finds, indeed, that the young man is demon-ridden.
While Penric is in the hospice physician's office discussing how how quickly they can get a Saint of the Bastard there to relieve the unidentified young man of his demon, the young man and the demon, alarmed by the visit from Penric and Desdemona, escape from the hospice. This makes a relatively simple, if unpleasant, task far more difficult. It's seemingly a good development when a woman and another young man show up--the demon-ridden young man's mother, and a friend, who was a shipmate on the ship the demon-ridden fell overboard from. More eyes, someone who can join the search knowing where in Lodi the young man, at least, might think to hide, etc. Penric also learns where to find the Bastard's Saint in Lodi. She's a young woman who grew up in the Bastard's orphanage on the Isle of Gulls, and still resides there.
The fact that all this has happened on Bastard's Eve, a night of revelry and partying in the streets, and a day and night Penric might reasonably have expected to have off, does not make things easier for him, or indeed for the Saint, Chio, whose birthday is officially Bastard's Day. Though truthfully, in addition to doing her job as the Saint, she's rather pleased to be able to get out on the town on Bastard's Eve, with less strict chaperonage than the orphanage would normally have allowed.
What follows has Penric and Chio learning new things about Lodi, the demon they're chasing, how Saints and sorcerers can work in relatively close proximity to each other (too close, and Desdemona would rather hide), and about that helpful young man who wants to help find and rescue his friend. And who may have an interest in the demon-ridden young man's sister.
It's a great little adventure, and a visit with Penric and Desdemona. Recommended.
I bought this book.
While Penric is in the hospice physician's office discussing how how quickly they can get a Saint of the Bastard there to relieve the unidentified young man of his demon, the young man and the demon, alarmed by the visit from Penric and Desdemona, escape from the hospice. This makes a relatively simple, if unpleasant, task far more difficult. It's seemingly a good development when a woman and another young man show up--the demon-ridden young man's mother, and a friend, who was a shipmate on the ship the demon-ridden fell overboard from. More eyes, someone who can join the search knowing where in Lodi the young man, at least, might think to hide, etc. Penric also learns where to find the Bastard's Saint in Lodi. She's a young woman who grew up in the Bastard's orphanage on the Isle of Gulls, and still resides there.
The fact that all this has happened on Bastard's Eve, a night of revelry and partying in the streets, and a day and night Penric might reasonably have expected to have off, does not make things easier for him, or indeed for the Saint, Chio, whose birthday is officially Bastard's Day. Though truthfully, in addition to doing her job as the Saint, she's rather pleased to be able to get out on the town on Bastard's Eve, with less strict chaperonage than the orphanage would normally have allowed.
What follows has Penric and Chio learning new things about Lodi, the demon they're chasing, how Saints and sorcerers can work in relatively close proximity to each other (too close, and Desdemona would rather hide), and about that helpful young man who wants to help find and rescue his friend. And who may have an interest in the demon-ridden young man's sister.
It's a great little adventure, and a visit with Penric and Desdemona. Recommended.
I bought this book.
November 30, 2020
A Soggy Mess
As opposed to the generally fast paced, dramatic, and character-driven tales of Penric and Desdemona, this story is boring and plot-less. This should be a tale of recovery from Penric's near suicide. It should offer us a view of his growing friendship with his demon, not a short, meandering search in a boring town for a, frankly, boring demon. None of the characters were well drawn or deep. The demon ridden man was inconsequential. The saint, meh. If the author is simply cranking these stories out mechanically, I'm out.
As opposed to the generally fast paced, dramatic, and character-driven tales of Penric and Desdemona, this story is boring and plot-less. This should be a tale of recovery from Penric's near suicide. It should offer us a view of his growing friendship with his demon, not a short, meandering search in a boring town for a, frankly, boring demon. None of the characters were well drawn or deep. The demon ridden man was inconsequential. The saint, meh. If the author is simply cranking these stories out mechanically, I'm out.
April 1, 2022
On Bastard’s Eve at Lodi, Pen, Des and the Blessed Chio must locate a missing young man whom, it is discovered, is unexpectedly ridden by a demon. Pen and Chio talk of much while wandering around, and thankfully, manage to rescue the man in more than one way.
Again, Bujold delivers a compassionate, comforting, and entertaining tale.
Again, Bujold delivers a compassionate, comforting, and entertaining tale.
March 24, 2024
I figured out the mystery aspect fairly early on in the story, but that did not detract from my overall enjoyment of the book. I'm enjoying spending a little more time in this world with its bite-sized novellas after finishing a very long audiobook.
November 14, 2020
13 Nov 2020
Plot: Sorcerer-priest and ride along demon accompanies a teenaged-girl demon-eater to go and hunt down a possessed man in fantasy Venice-ish.
1. I have to admit, I'm a little disappointed this book is set earlier in Penric's life, without his entire set of gloriously weird and hypercompetent in-laws getting in on the act. But it's still Pen and Des and Bujold, Chio was an absolute delight, and so were Iserne and Ree. Most Penric books leave me longing for more stories about the supporting characters, and this was not an exception.
2. I LOVE the entire universe of the World of the Five gods so much? The theological system is so simple, and you still get so much mileage out of it. Every bit of expanded lore is just makes it feel richer and more lifelike. I now badly need to know what happens in Lodi to make it home to so many saints. Do they like, import them? Is it because this is set a century and a half (more?) before Curse of Chalion and saints have become less common over the decades? Is it early installment weirdness or Chalion maybe just doesn't have saints because of the Curse? I WANT TO KNOW.
3. The story is a pretty standard combination exploration of new setting, minor not-quite-murder mystery, and world-building expansion. It's still a fun read, mostly because Bujold is physically incapable of sketching out characters without imbuing every individual one with enough personality to drive an entire novella forward. I usually go into paroxyms of joy because her writing has zero purple prose and all the emotional weight of a meteor slamming into your head. Just-ugh.
4. Bonus points for a random guy mentioning what a pretty, pretty boy Penric is. Because I am the most basic of bitches and this is something that I hope for every time I hear a new Pen & Des book is out.
Plot: Sorcerer-priest and ride along demon accompanies a teenaged-girl demon-eater to go and hunt down a possessed man in fantasy Venice-ish.
1. I have to admit, I'm a little disappointed this book is set earlier in Penric's life, without his entire set of gloriously weird and hypercompetent in-laws getting in on the act. But it's still Pen and Des and Bujold, Chio was an absolute delight, and so were Iserne and Ree. Most Penric books leave me longing for more stories about the supporting characters, and this was not an exception.
2. I LOVE the entire universe of the World of the Five gods so much? The theological system is so simple, and you still get so much mileage out of it. Every bit of expanded lore is just makes it feel richer and more lifelike. I now badly need to know what happens in Lodi to make it home to so many saints. Do they like, import them? Is it because this is set a century and a half (more?) before Curse of Chalion and saints have become less common over the decades? Is it early installment weirdness or Chalion maybe just doesn't have saints because of the Curse? I WANT TO KNOW.
3. The story is a pretty standard combination exploration of new setting, minor not-quite-murder mystery, and world-building expansion. It's still a fun read, mostly because Bujold is physically incapable of sketching out characters without imbuing every individual one with enough personality to drive an entire novella forward. I usually go into paroxyms of joy because her writing has zero purple prose and all the emotional weight of a meteor slamming into your head. Just-ugh.
4. Bonus points for a random guy mentioning what a pretty, pretty boy Penric is. Because I am the most basic of bitches and this is something that I hope for every time I hear a new Pen & Des book is out.
November 12, 2020
5 stars just for the joy of getting to spend a little more time with Penric and Des, this time in the Venice-inspired city of Lodi. We meet a young saint, brave danger, and solve a mystery. It's a lovely world to visit, and a perfect escape!
July 18, 2021
This one was perfect!
December 17, 2021
I love this series so damn much.
July 18, 2022
Actual rating: 3.5 stars.
February 17, 2024
The first half of Masquerade in Lodi trends towards one of the better Penric novellas, with a great mystery setup in a Venice-alike during the heart of a celebration... unfortunately it's all over too soon. The twist isn't well set up enough to be poignant, and when it comes, it basically leaves a full third of the story to wrapping things up. It's nice to get a good denouement, even in a short story, but in this case it comes off as wrapping things up too neatly and ensuring we got all the details. Penric in particular is made more daft than usual in order to have characters explain things to him and.... eh? It's fine.
January 7, 2023
I always look forward to my Christmas/birthday gift of the new Penric book, and this one did not disappoint!
November 22, 2020
3.5? Rounded up to 4
I've loved all the Penric novellas so I was surprised when I realised that it wasn't quite grabbing me and it was taking me me quite a while to finish. Not sure why exactly - maybe it's a timing issue, or maybe it's just me. But it did come together nicely two-thirds of the way through, and of course it is Penric and Des, so it still gets the thumbs up from me, but this is my least favourite Penric so far.
I've loved all the Penric novellas so I was surprised when I realised that it wasn't quite grabbing me and it was taking me me quite a while to finish. Not sure why exactly - maybe it's a timing issue, or maybe it's just me. But it did come together nicely two-thirds of the way through, and of course it is Penric and Des, so it still gets the thumbs up from me, but this is my least favourite Penric so far.
October 19, 2020
I liked this a lot. It was a fun little adventure with a happy ending. I liked the new characters we met and would not mind seeing them again. We get to see a 29 year old Penric at his new position in Lodi after leaving Martinsbridge. Lodi is a new city we’ve not seen yet and was an interesting setting.
October 24, 2022
This latest story in the Penric & Desdemona series fits in as book #4, even though there are other stories that have already been written that are chronologically set later. I love this series.
While the story can be read on its own, I strongly recommend starting at the start.
Nothing more to add at this re-read.
While the story can be read on its own, I strongly recommend starting at the start.
Nothing more to add at this re-read.
October 31, 2020
Originally published at Reading Reality
Penric, whose adventures have featured in this novella series since its beginning in Penric’s Demon, is a fascinating character. Or perhaps that should be characters. And that is part of the fascination.
Because Penric was knocked sideways out of the life he planned to lead by the advent of Desdemona in his life, and there his adventures definitely began.
That sounds like a romance, doesn’t it? But that’s not what this is. Not at all. Not that Penric doesn’t have his own romantic adventures, and not that Desdemona didn’t have hers. Two centuries worth of them.
In the World of the Five Gods, those five gods are not just worshipped. They are real, can appear before their followers, and can act directly upon the world. But mostly they act indirectly, through their priests, their learned divines, of which Penric is one, and their god- or goddess- touched Saints, one of whom is featured in this entry in the series.
Those gods are the Mother, the Father, the Sister, the Brother and the fifth god whom Penric serves, the “master of all disasters out of season”.
Penric is a Learned Divine of the White God, the Lord Bastard. Desdemona is the demon who shares Penric’s head. They are partners. He provides the physical body which allows her to move in the world, and she gives him magic. And the benefit of her two centuries of experience – sometimes whether he wants it or not. From Penric’s perspective it’s often like have a dozen older sisters and aunts giving him advice whether he’s asked for it or not. Generally not.
The series began when Desdemona jumped from her previous host, the dying Learned Divine Ruschia, to young Penric, knocking his life into another channel from the one he was expected to have as the younger son of a prosperous landowner.
He also expected to be bored out of his skull, but life with Desdemona inside his skull has been anything but boring. Often dangerous, occasionally life-threatening, but never, ever dull.
In Masquerade in Lodi, Penric is definitely not bored. Tired, footsore, terrified and manipulated, occasionally all at the same time, but never, ever bored.
Even if the story begins by his thwarted attempt to take a half-day off in preparation for the local festival in honor of his god. But then, the Lord Bastard is the god of misfortune and bad luck, along with prostitutes, executioners and vermin.
And Penric runs into pretty much all of the above as he attempts to squire a very young Saint of his order along on a mission to find a demon-touched man who may or may not be either a murderer or a potential victim. Or both.
Whether he is saint or villain, the young man’s mother is still expecting him to come home. It’s up to Penric, with the help and sometimes hindrance of the saint, to make it happen.
Escape Rating B+: The beginning of Masquerade in Lodi may be a bit confusing for faithful readers of this series. The book published immediately before this one, The Physicians of Vilnoc, takes place several years and a whole lot of life and adventures after Masquerade in Lodi. Some fairly dangerous and rather significant adventures, including Penric’s marriage.
Those events are still in Penric’s future in Lodi, and it takes a bit of a reset to get one’s reading self back on track. A worthwhile mental adjustment, but definitely an adjustment. The book whose events immediately precede this one is Penric’s Fox, and that was several books ago.
On my oft-cited other hand, one of the things that this entry in the series does very well, is to not just tell its adventure but also to show and not tell a whole lot more about how the system works.
By that I mean the system of gods, temples, demons, saints and worship. Because this religion functions for the actual good of its people, which is rare in fantasy. Usually the “church” is a source of evil or oppression or corruption or villainy or all of the above. Not in the World of the Five Gods.
So when Penric is called to the dockside mission to investigate the case of a man who might be demon-touched or might merely be out of his own head, it’s normal and accepted and expected. When Penric discovers that the poor man is harboring an untamed demon, there are no torches and pitchforks. No signs of the “evil eye”.
Instead, there’s a process in place for Penric to take the poor man to a Saint of the White God to have the demon taken by the Lord Bastard. A process which the victim will survive.
Except, it’s not nearly that simple. Otherwise there wouldn’t be an adventure. But in the discussion between Penric, his demon Desdemona, all of the Temple officials who become part of the merry chase of the escaped victim, the young Saint who is occasionally god-touched but always way more observant and intelligent than anyone expects, we learn a wondrous amount of stuff about this world, how it works, and both Penric’s and his god’s place in it.
And we get a tour of friends and enemies in low places, because nothing about the victim, the demon, or the reason they met in the first place is remotely as it seems.
Discovering how everyone got to be in this pickle in the first place is all the fun.
Penric, whose adventures have featured in this novella series since its beginning in Penric’s Demon, is a fascinating character. Or perhaps that should be characters. And that is part of the fascination.
Because Penric was knocked sideways out of the life he planned to lead by the advent of Desdemona in his life, and there his adventures definitely began.
That sounds like a romance, doesn’t it? But that’s not what this is. Not at all. Not that Penric doesn’t have his own romantic adventures, and not that Desdemona didn’t have hers. Two centuries worth of them.
In the World of the Five Gods, those five gods are not just worshipped. They are real, can appear before their followers, and can act directly upon the world. But mostly they act indirectly, through their priests, their learned divines, of which Penric is one, and their god- or goddess- touched Saints, one of whom is featured in this entry in the series.
Those gods are the Mother, the Father, the Sister, the Brother and the fifth god whom Penric serves, the “master of all disasters out of season”.
Penric is a Learned Divine of the White God, the Lord Bastard. Desdemona is the demon who shares Penric’s head. They are partners. He provides the physical body which allows her to move in the world, and she gives him magic. And the benefit of her two centuries of experience – sometimes whether he wants it or not. From Penric’s perspective it’s often like have a dozen older sisters and aunts giving him advice whether he’s asked for it or not. Generally not.
The series began when Desdemona jumped from her previous host, the dying Learned Divine Ruschia, to young Penric, knocking his life into another channel from the one he was expected to have as the younger son of a prosperous landowner.
He also expected to be bored out of his skull, but life with Desdemona inside his skull has been anything but boring. Often dangerous, occasionally life-threatening, but never, ever dull.
In Masquerade in Lodi, Penric is definitely not bored. Tired, footsore, terrified and manipulated, occasionally all at the same time, but never, ever bored.
Even if the story begins by his thwarted attempt to take a half-day off in preparation for the local festival in honor of his god. But then, the Lord Bastard is the god of misfortune and bad luck, along with prostitutes, executioners and vermin.
And Penric runs into pretty much all of the above as he attempts to squire a very young Saint of his order along on a mission to find a demon-touched man who may or may not be either a murderer or a potential victim. Or both.
Whether he is saint or villain, the young man’s mother is still expecting him to come home. It’s up to Penric, with the help and sometimes hindrance of the saint, to make it happen.
Escape Rating B+: The beginning of Masquerade in Lodi may be a bit confusing for faithful readers of this series. The book published immediately before this one, The Physicians of Vilnoc, takes place several years and a whole lot of life and adventures after Masquerade in Lodi. Some fairly dangerous and rather significant adventures, including Penric’s marriage.
Those events are still in Penric’s future in Lodi, and it takes a bit of a reset to get one’s reading self back on track. A worthwhile mental adjustment, but definitely an adjustment. The book whose events immediately precede this one is Penric’s Fox, and that was several books ago.
On my oft-cited other hand, one of the things that this entry in the series does very well, is to not just tell its adventure but also to show and not tell a whole lot more about how the system works.
By that I mean the system of gods, temples, demons, saints and worship. Because this religion functions for the actual good of its people, which is rare in fantasy. Usually the “church” is a source of evil or oppression or corruption or villainy or all of the above. Not in the World of the Five Gods.
So when Penric is called to the dockside mission to investigate the case of a man who might be demon-touched or might merely be out of his own head, it’s normal and accepted and expected. When Penric discovers that the poor man is harboring an untamed demon, there are no torches and pitchforks. No signs of the “evil eye”.
Instead, there’s a process in place for Penric to take the poor man to a Saint of the White God to have the demon taken by the Lord Bastard. A process which the victim will survive.
Except, it’s not nearly that simple. Otherwise there wouldn’t be an adventure. But in the discussion between Penric, his demon Desdemona, all of the Temple officials who become part of the merry chase of the escaped victim, the young Saint who is occasionally god-touched but always way more observant and intelligent than anyone expects, we learn a wondrous amount of stuff about this world, how it works, and both Penric’s and his god’s place in it.
And we get a tour of friends and enemies in low places, because nothing about the victim, the demon, or the reason they met in the first place is remotely as it seems.
Discovering how everyone got to be in this pickle in the first place is all the fun.
October 20, 2021
I've read these last few Penric & Desdemona books (8-10) late and out of order, but with this one, I'm finally caught up. This one was another very solid entry. Like all of Bujold's long series, each story adds a little bit of richness to her characters which adds up to in turn make the whole series more than the sum of its parts.
March 8, 2021
Notes:
It would be fun if the Saint girl becomes a visiting character. I enjoyed the later half more than the first bit.
It would be fun if the Saint girl becomes a visiting character. I enjoyed the later half more than the first bit.
November 3, 2020
As ever, Penric is an enjoyable protagonist. It was interesting to go back to a time when he isn’t so self assured and mature in his judgements. Bujold has a habit of dotting around, so the publishing chronology isn’t the same as the internal chronology. But while it’s worth knowing, so that the characterisation is consistent, other than that, I don’t find it too much of a problem.
Bujold is an experienced author, with a smooth, readable style and while I did enjoy this one, I was aware that there wasn’t quite the same depth of plotting, this time around. We get told that Penric is reeling from some personal losses, but I would have preferred to have had this demonstrated.
I also felt that the pacing was slightly off – the main part of the plot didn’t feel quite substantial enough to sustain the story for its length. It didn’t help that I guessed early who the culprit was – and this time around I was right. It didn’t mean that the adventure dragged – Bujold is too good a writer to let that happen, but it wasn’t as intense and fulfilling a read as usual. Which means that it was good, rather than outstanding. I’ll take that. Writers who can work at Bujold’s level consistently are rare – and an 8 is perfectly respectable.
Recommended for fans of the series – but if you have just picked this one up, I do recommend that you go back to the beginning and start from there. Though if you do, I suggest you follow Bujold’s internal chronology, rather than the publishing one.
8/10
Bujold is an experienced author, with a smooth, readable style and while I did enjoy this one, I was aware that there wasn’t quite the same depth of plotting, this time around. We get told that Penric is reeling from some personal losses, but I would have preferred to have had this demonstrated.
I also felt that the pacing was slightly off – the main part of the plot didn’t feel quite substantial enough to sustain the story for its length. It didn’t help that I guessed early who the culprit was – and this time around I was right. It didn’t mean that the adventure dragged – Bujold is too good a writer to let that happen, but it wasn’t as intense and fulfilling a read as usual. Which means that it was good, rather than outstanding. I’ll take that. Writers who can work at Bujold’s level consistently are rare – and an 8 is perfectly respectable.
Recommended for fans of the series – but if you have just picked this one up, I do recommend that you go back to the beginning and start from there. Though if you do, I suggest you follow Bujold’s internal chronology, rather than the publishing one.
8/10
October 25, 2020
The newest Penric book goes back a little in time for a short adventure. A sailor has fallen overboard and apparently a dolphin with a demon rescues him and then promptly dies and the demon jumps to the almost drowned sailor. The almost drowning plus the totally unexpected demon drives the sailor to madness and Penric is sent to help the sailor by bringing him to a saint to usher the demon out of him. Of course nothing is ever simple, either helping the sailor or the unexpectness that the saint is a very young relatively inexperienced woman. As usual the Penric novellas are hard not to read in one sitting (the only reason not to is of course then you have to wait a while for the next one!).
November 23, 2020
I have to confess, I was a little disappointed with this book. There was little purpose to it, I felt. It didn’t quite reveal anything new that we didn’t already know. It didn’t move Penric’s story forward. And it didn’t give us more insight into his character. There was no character development or progression in this novella. It was just a light read with familiar characters and a rather basic plot. I enjoyed it, but I wanted more.
April 9, 2022
Penric is wonderful in this story. It is fun to see him in a place where everyone respects him and he doesn't have to hide. His interactions with Chio are so much fun. Chio was so relatable and genuine. Her mix of child-like wanting to explore and have fun vs her duty make her an enjoyable character. This story is similar to "Penric's Fox" but in a totally different setting making the problem's Penric has to overcome quite different. I really had a great time reading this.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 328 reviews