What do you think?
Rate this book
The Sinclair’s Mysteries #3
The Mystery of the Painted Dragon
When a priceless painting is stolen, our dauntless heroines Sophie and Lil find themselves faced with forgery, trickery and deceit on all sides!
Be amazed as the brave duo pit their wits against this perilous puzzle! Marvel at their cunning plan to unmask the villain and prove themselves detectives to be reckoned with – no matter what dangers lie ahead . . .
Be amazed as the brave duo pit their wits against this perilous puzzle! Marvel at their cunning plan to unmask the villain and prove themselves detectives to be reckoned with – no matter what dangers lie ahead . . .
339 pages, Paperback
First published February 9, 2017
About the author
Katherine Woodfine
35 books467 followersKatherine Woodfine is the author of the bestselling SINCLAIR'S MYSTERIES series, beginning with THE CLOCKWORK SPARROW which was shortlisted for the Waterstones Children’s Book Prize, longlisted for the Branford Boase Award, and nominated for the CILIP Carnegie Medal.
Until 2015 she worked for reading charity Book Trust on projects including the Children’s Laureate and YALC. She was also part of the founding team behind children's books podcast Down the Rabbit Hole. She now combines writing with events and reviewing children's books.
Her latest book is NIGHTFALL IN NEW YORK, the final book in the TAYLOR & ROSE SECRET AGENTS series which follows the heroines of the SINCLAIR'S MYSTERIES as they venture into the thrilling world of Edwardian espionage. Find out more at katherinewoodfine.co.uk and @followtheyellow
Until 2015 she worked for reading charity Book Trust on projects including the Children’s Laureate and YALC. She was also part of the founding team behind children's books podcast Down the Rabbit Hole. She now combines writing with events and reviewing children's books.
Her latest book is NIGHTFALL IN NEW YORK, the final book in the TAYLOR & ROSE SECRET AGENTS series which follows the heroines of the SINCLAIR'S MYSTERIES as they venture into the thrilling world of Edwardian espionage. Find out more at katherinewoodfine.co.uk and @followtheyellow
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 150 reviews
February 6, 2017
3.5 stars. This is the 3rd book in the Sinclair Mystery Series.
When a priceless painting is stolen, Sophie & Lil are on the case. Faced with forgery, trickery & deceit from all angles. Will the brave duo be able to solve this mystery?
Gosh, how I liked this book. It took me back to my childhood reading Enid Blyton. It's written in the same style as Enid Blyton's mystery books and I'm sure it will be a hit with children (and adults) aged 9+.
I would like to thank NetGalley, Egmont Publishing and the author Katherine Woodfine for my ARC in exchange for an honest review.
When a priceless painting is stolen, Sophie & Lil are on the case. Faced with forgery, trickery & deceit from all angles. Will the brave duo be able to solve this mystery?
Gosh, how I liked this book. It took me back to my childhood reading Enid Blyton. It's written in the same style as Enid Blyton's mystery books and I'm sure it will be a hit with children (and adults) aged 9+.
I would like to thank NetGalley, Egmont Publishing and the author Katherine Woodfine for my ARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 3, 2023
Вже чекаю на останню частину ❤️чудовий детективний янг едалт) моя щира рекомендація всієї серії
February 7, 2017
This summer, I read the first book in the Sinclair Mystery series. It was my first new Middle Grade book in a decade, and I was really excited to find something that was a genre I love, in a historical setting (also LOVE), just with younger protagonists. The third book in the series, The Mystery of the Painted Dragon is no different from the first in the lovely vibes it gave me, and the pure rush of enjoyment I get from reading a mystery, and solving it along with the protagonists.
Katherine Woodfine knows how to put together a great mystery, one with interesting characters, a devious hidden plot and historical markers that always put a smile on my face!
I loved the familiar characters of Sophie and Lil, who have come a long way in capability since the first book, and the introduction of Leo was fabulous - not only was she an amazing artist, but she was also differently abled, walking with a crutch and I'm giving this book major ticks for including diverse ability representations. I don't often read about a physically challenged protagonist, and this encourages me to seek them out more often.
Katherine Woodfine knows how to put together a great mystery, one with interesting characters, a devious hidden plot and historical markers that always put a smile on my face!
I loved the familiar characters of Sophie and Lil, who have come a long way in capability since the first book, and the introduction of Leo was fabulous - not only was she an amazing artist, but she was also differently abled, walking with a crutch and I'm giving this book major ticks for including diverse ability representations. I don't often read about a physically challenged protagonist, and this encourages me to seek them out more often.
November 5, 2021
Ojoj, w trzeciej części cyklu "Tajemnice domu handlowego Sinclairs" to się dopiero działo! Pochłonęłam tę książkę w jeden dzień i niczego nie żałuję, bo choć nie jestem grupą docelową tej pozycji to bawiłam się wyśmienicie i dałam się porwać tej historii.
Sophie i Lil usiłują pomóc studentce sztuki, która została oskarżona o kradzież wartościowego obrazu. Czy dziewczyna jest winna? Co łączy ją z wystawą, z której zostało skradzione dzieło? Dlaczego cała sprawa ma w sobie więcej tajemnic niż początkowo zakładano?
"Szmaragdowy smok" to naprawdę dobra książka dla młodzieży. Wzbudza w czytelniku emocje a autorka zdecydowanie potrafi zbudować napięcie i trzymać młodszego czytelnika w niepewności. Starszym pewnie łatwiej przyjdzie odgadnięcie zagadki i po raz kolejny odkryje, że pewne rzeczy już dawno powinny się zakończyć w normalnym świecie.
Sophie i Lil usiłują pomóc studentce sztuki, która została oskarżona o kradzież wartościowego obrazu. Czy dziewczyna jest winna? Co łączy ją z wystawą, z której zostało skradzione dzieło? Dlaczego cała sprawa ma w sobie więcej tajemnic niż początkowo zakładano?
"Szmaragdowy smok" to naprawdę dobra książka dla młodzieży. Wzbudza w czytelniku emocje a autorka zdecydowanie potrafi zbudować napięcie i trzymać młodszego czytelnika w niepewności. Starszym pewnie łatwiej przyjdzie odgadnięcie zagadki i po raz kolejny odkryje, że pewne rzeczy już dawno powinny się zakończyć w normalnym świecie.
February 26, 2017
Hooray for Katherine Woodfine! This is the third book in the Sinclair's Mysteries, and it's just as adventurous, rich in period detail, and full of buns and fantastic female friendship as her first two outings. I love a good art heist (as you know), and I love Sophie and Lil's exciting world. I can't WAIT to find out how Sophie finally outwits the Baron ... roll on the fourth book, out later this year! 8+
*Please note: this review is meant as a recommendation only. Please do not use it in any marketing material, online or in print, without asking permission from me first. Thank you!*
*Please note: this review is meant as a recommendation only. Please do not use it in any marketing material, online or in print, without asking permission from me first. Thank you!*
July 9, 2021
'This - being a detective, I mean - it's all I've got.'
The cover - it's green! Very apt, of course, considering the mystery of the book, but it's just terrific anyhow as well! This is my favourite one so far. (Although I'll immediately say that The Midnight Peacock will top this one too...) It's just a bit of a shame that they've changed the title style and turned it into the black-on-white text in a plate instead of the old coloured lettering in gold. But, well, that's just a very small matter.
The book resembles Book 1 a bit more, I think. It's much more centered around Sinclair's once again, and about the upper-class regions of London. Don't worry - there are still enough links with the East End. Woodfine dives into art, specifically paintings, for this book, a fully separate world of anything we've seen so far. Lil's family is expanded. Other characters are introduced while older ones pop up (although it's a shame that Veronica isn't around). A big amount of time is given to Leo, the new character. She is rather interesting, but the downside of it all is that Sophie and Lil are much less present compared to Books 1 and 2. Many chapters go by without them making an entrance.
The author is playing with the series-long plot a bit, here - and as a result of that, with the reader as well. It's clear that everyone thinks Sophie is overthinking it, always on the lookout for the Baron. As for myself, I can assert that I was very certain at the start of The Painted Dragon that of course the Baron would be featured... but in the end even I started second-guessing myself. Was I right or wrong? That's a spoiler I'm not telling, you'll have to read the book (or another review) to find out. Whatever the outcome, let me tell you it's masterfully done, as always.
This book also introduces a much clearer feministic viewpoint. It has always been there, of course, but up to now it was more of an undercurrent, some quick opinions made by both Lil and/or Sophie. They're modern women - for those days, obviously (and maybe even for our days, who'll say) - and they have a clear idea of what society (and its standpoint on women) is like and what it should actually be. But everything becomes much more explicit now, with the introduction of the suffragettes. That element too is nicely interwoven with the rest of the story, and from I know Woodfine paints a correct picture of them. In these days, with feminism once again riding the high waves, you'd think that it would be romanticised a bit, but that's clearly not the case here. 'Terrifyingly' accurate!
9.7/10
The cover - it's green! Very apt, of course, considering the mystery of the book, but it's just terrific anyhow as well! This is my favourite one so far. (Although I'll immediately say that The Midnight Peacock will top this one too...) It's just a bit of a shame that they've changed the title style and turned it into the black-on-white text in a plate instead of the old coloured lettering in gold. But, well, that's just a very small matter.
The book resembles Book 1 a bit more, I think. It's much more centered around Sinclair's once again, and about the upper-class regions of London. Don't worry - there are still enough links with the East End. Woodfine dives into art, specifically paintings, for this book, a fully separate world of anything we've seen so far. Lil's family is expanded. Other characters are introduced while older ones pop up (although it's a shame that Veronica isn't around). A big amount of time is given to Leo, the new character. She is rather interesting, but the downside of it all is that Sophie and Lil are much less present compared to Books 1 and 2. Many chapters go by without them making an entrance.
The author is playing with the series-long plot a bit, here - and as a result of that, with the reader as well. It's clear that everyone thinks Sophie is overthinking it, always on the lookout for the Baron. As for myself, I can assert that I was very certain at the start of The Painted Dragon that of course the Baron would be featured... but in the end even I started second-guessing myself. Was I right or wrong? That's a spoiler I'm not telling, you'll have to read the book (or another review) to find out. Whatever the outcome, let me tell you it's masterfully done, as always.
This book also introduces a much clearer feministic viewpoint. It has always been there, of course, but up to now it was more of an undercurrent, some quick opinions made by both Lil and/or Sophie. They're modern women - for those days, obviously (and maybe even for our days, who'll say) - and they have a clear idea of what society (and its standpoint on women) is like and what it should actually be. But everything becomes much more explicit now, with the introduction of the suffragettes. That element too is nicely interwoven with the rest of the story, and from I know Woodfine paints a correct picture of them. In these days, with feminism once again riding the high waves, you'd think that it would be romanticised a bit, but that's clearly not the case here. 'Terrifyingly' accurate!
9.7/10
June 30, 2023
Чудовий підлітковий детектив з літнім вайбом. Прочитала за 2 дні на одному подисі.
Одним словом, задоволена.
10/10💛
Одним словом, задоволена.
10/10💛
November 3, 2022
3.5 stars, another quality entry in the 1909 London mystery series featuring the magical (not literally) Sinclair's department store. I think the suspense factor has increased in each successive book. Looking forward to the final installment, #4.
February 20, 2017
This author can write, it's as simple as that. Her writing flows so easily and her scene setting is superb. I felt myself transported back to 1909 London without a hiccup.
This is a story that I loved. The strong female lead characters appealed to me as they will to girls aged 9+ and even young teenagers. Another element of the story that may appeal to specific girls is the focus on art. A few of the main characters, namely Leo and Jack, meet at a prestigious art school. Furthermore, the crime that is committed in this story is the theft of a priceless piece of art. So, middle graders with a flair for art or who love painting and drawing will especially like this book, although I'm not saying that its appeal is limited to only those readers with a particular interest in the arts.
This is a story about a couple of female detectives who need to crack the case of a stolen painting which has been stolen from the exhibition hall at a large department store. The writing and story is reminiscent of Enid Blyton and this author definitely knows how to set up a mystery. I loved some of the characters, especially Leo who was so interesting and sweet. I also thought that Lil was great and her brother Jack. One thing I didn't like was how obsessed Sophie was with the Baron. The whole Baron thing I found a little boring but it wasn't bad enough to detract seriously from the story. I hadn't read the first few books in the series and this didn't turn out to be a problem and so it is possible to read this book as a standalone. Overall, a lovely read.
My rating: * * * *
Many thanks to the author, Katherine Woodfine, the publishers Egmont Publishing and NetGalley for my review copy.
This is a story that I loved. The strong female lead characters appealed to me as they will to girls aged 9+ and even young teenagers. Another element of the story that may appeal to specific girls is the focus on art. A few of the main characters, namely Leo and Jack, meet at a prestigious art school. Furthermore, the crime that is committed in this story is the theft of a priceless piece of art. So, middle graders with a flair for art or who love painting and drawing will especially like this book, although I'm not saying that its appeal is limited to only those readers with a particular interest in the arts.
This is a story about a couple of female detectives who need to crack the case of a stolen painting which has been stolen from the exhibition hall at a large department store. The writing and story is reminiscent of Enid Blyton and this author definitely knows how to set up a mystery. I loved some of the characters, especially Leo who was so interesting and sweet. I also thought that Lil was great and her brother Jack. One thing I didn't like was how obsessed Sophie was with the Baron. The whole Baron thing I found a little boring but it wasn't bad enough to detract seriously from the story. I hadn't read the first few books in the series and this didn't turn out to be a problem and so it is possible to read this book as a standalone. Overall, a lovely read.
My rating: * * * *
Many thanks to the author, Katherine Woodfine, the publishers Egmont Publishing and NetGalley for my review copy.
February 23, 2017
The best kind of children’s book: one big and little kids can enjoy! 4/5.
This review was originally posted on my book blog.
The Mystery of the Painted Dragon is the third of Katherine Woodfine’s Sinclair’s Mysteries and is every bit as enjoyable as the first two installments in the series.
I love these books. They are fun mysteries set in London at the start of the twentieth century. Our amateur sleuths are two independent young ladies – Lil and Sophie – who are smart, resourceful and tenacious. For me, how they take care of themselves and each other is the best thing about these stories. This book has added girl power with the appearance of the Suffragette movement, making the feminist message all the more obvious.
That said, I’m sure readers of both genders will enjoy these books as the male characters are given plenty to do, getting along well with Lil and Sophie as their friends, with only a light hint of romance for the future.
The Mystery of the Painted Dragon, like its predecessors, gives us a self-contained mystery while also continuing an ongoing story-line about Sophie’s parents and the series’ mysterious Moriarty-style bad guy, The Baron. The stakes aren’t quite as high for Lil and Sophie in this book, but the puzzles they have to solve are still intriguing and we’re treated to a locked-room mystery too.
Overall: don’t dismiss these mysteries as children’s books and so not for you. If you must, buy them for your daughter, son, niece, nephew or grandchild (hell, buy them for the neighbours’ kids), then sneakily read them yourself!
This review was originally posted on my book blog.
The Mystery of the Painted Dragon is the third of Katherine Woodfine’s Sinclair’s Mysteries and is every bit as enjoyable as the first two installments in the series.
I love these books. They are fun mysteries set in London at the start of the twentieth century. Our amateur sleuths are two independent young ladies – Lil and Sophie – who are smart, resourceful and tenacious. For me, how they take care of themselves and each other is the best thing about these stories. This book has added girl power with the appearance of the Suffragette movement, making the feminist message all the more obvious.
That said, I’m sure readers of both genders will enjoy these books as the male characters are given plenty to do, getting along well with Lil and Sophie as their friends, with only a light hint of romance for the future.
The Mystery of the Painted Dragon, like its predecessors, gives us a self-contained mystery while also continuing an ongoing story-line about Sophie’s parents and the series’ mysterious Moriarty-style bad guy, The Baron. The stakes aren’t quite as high for Lil and Sophie in this book, but the puzzles they have to solve are still intriguing and we’re treated to a locked-room mystery too.
Overall: don’t dismiss these mysteries as children’s books and so not for you. If you must, buy them for your daughter, son, niece, nephew or grandchild (hell, buy them for the neighbours’ kids), then sneakily read them yourself!
February 2, 2020
These books always feel comforting to read, and I feel like the quality of the story stays very consistent. They're not the most complex mysteries, but the way the characters interact and talk to each other is compelling enough to keep me reading. I'm more interested in how they'll solve the mystery than what it is.
This book introduced new characters, but they all fit together with the existing cast of characters perfectly. I also liked that more minor characters from the previous book appeared in this one to help out occasionally.
It was cute as always, and I'm happy to keep reading these books whenever I need something light and fun.
This book introduced new characters, but they all fit together with the existing cast of characters perfectly. I also liked that more minor characters from the previous book appeared in this one to help out occasionally.
It was cute as always, and I'm happy to keep reading these books whenever I need something light and fun.
November 4, 2023
4.5 Stars! Only knocked half a star off due to the mystery being a bit easier for me to me to guess this time. Oh but what FUN! I adore the characters, including returning faves like the Lims. All the elements of the mystery and it’s varied aspects of resolution were a blast too. Excited to start Book 4 right away!!
May 5, 2019
Немного чересчур прямолинейное, но славное чтение
May 10, 2020
3.5 stars
November 30, 2019
This is the third Sinclair Mystery in the series. A valuable piece of art is stolen from Sinclair's department store and it is down to the gang to solve who is the thief is.
I was delighted to see a return from the Lim family who were all introduced in the previous novel. The Painted Dragon stars another heroine Leo, an 'afflicted' young girl who has begun studying at the Spencer Institute for Art. I loved Leo's character who is quiet and reserved but her traits compliment her and are useful when solving the mystery. Katherine just keeps on gifting us with loveable characters. Although Leo walked with a cane and had limitations, she wasn't written in a pitiful way. Leo's disability was part of her character but it wasn't the main focus. There was so much more to her.
Do not be put off by the fact the Sinclair Mysteries are middle grade, I am twenty-four and can't get enough. I will be ordering the next instalment immediately.
Although I guessed who was behind the mystery, it was exciting to see it all unfold with the same suspense as the previous two books.
I was delighted to see a return from the Lim family who were all introduced in the previous novel. The Painted Dragon stars another heroine Leo, an 'afflicted' young girl who has begun studying at the Spencer Institute for Art. I loved Leo's character who is quiet and reserved but her traits compliment her and are useful when solving the mystery. Katherine just keeps on gifting us with loveable characters. Although Leo walked with a cane and had limitations, she wasn't written in a pitiful way. Leo's disability was part of her character but it wasn't the main focus. There was so much more to her.
Do not be put off by the fact the Sinclair Mysteries are middle grade, I am twenty-four and can't get enough. I will be ordering the next instalment immediately.
Although I guessed who was behind the mystery, it was exciting to see it all unfold with the same suspense as the previous two books.
February 18, 2017
The third book in this series, and I loved it so much. A dragon painting disappears, we have new characters (I loved them all), sweet illustrations (plus one for Sophie and Lil), and lots more!
As some of you might recall (if you read my reviews), the previous book brought a new character (and also some side characters) to the mix. I didn't like the new character.
In this one we also have a new character (and some new fun side characters), the mystery revolves around her and paintings. I loved Leo from the start. I even noticed that I was sad when we got to other parts of the book. I just wanted more and more Leo. Leo was such a strong, good girl, and I was just cheering and hoping that she would continue drawing, painting, making art in general. Not stop because of all the stuff that is happening to her.
Lil was definitely another favourite of mine, then again, she is just too awesome. Being an actress (and getting famous more and more), and also doing the detective stuff, and also work side jobs. Wow. Plus I loved seeing more of her family, in this case, her brother!
Plus I love how Lil still stands firm, tells it as it is. As I also said in the other book's review, I just love how she acts, it isn't like she is from that age, but from this age.
Sophie was quite fun, and she is still a very likeable character, but her constant Baron Baron Baron stuff, did not only annoy her friends, but also me, the reader. I get that the Baron is important, I get that the Baron did some really bad stuff, but really? Is it necessary to focus so much on someone?
The painting, and the whodunnit . Eh. I knew from the moment that that person asked for the painting that he was the one doing stuff. Not really a spoiler, it is just so clear from that point that I don't even care to put something like spoiler around it. It was a bit boring. I kept hoping for a new twist or turn, and I was frustrated with the characters taking so long. It is a shame, I love books which keep me on my toes, not immediately give me the right suspect immediately.
As with the previous book we have little parts in between the story which tell us about the dragon paintings. Since there are more than one of those. I definitely liked those little pieces, as it gave more insight in the dragons and what was going on with them.
Mei and her family also make an appearance, and I have to say I have a higher tolerance for Mei in this book. It was quite nice to see her around, and also see her help out.
Also as with the previous book, there is some romance, and I was really delighted to see that one popping up. It does fit with the ages of the characters.
What more? Oh yes, I want to visit Sinclair's! Sooooooo much. I wouldn't mind spending some days in that store. Visiting the millinery, the book store, the candy store, and all the other fun stores. *daydreams*
The ending was pretty great, well the actual ending that is, not the ending to the mystery. I am so happy for Lil and Sophie, they deserve this, and I hope it will mean more, and even bigger mysteries for them. Congrats girls!
The cover is once again gorgeous, I am glad that they don't suddenly decide to change, as so many other series sadly did. The cover is supershiny, and I just the various details that one only truly spies when they have read the book.
All in all, this was a great read with fantastic new characters (more Leo please), a mystery that was pretty decent (even if it was predictable), and much much more! Highly recommended!
Review first posted at https://twirlingbookprincess.com/
As some of you might recall (if you read my reviews), the previous book brought a new character (and also some side characters) to the mix. I didn't like the new character.
In this one we also have a new character (and some new fun side characters), the mystery revolves around her and paintings. I loved Leo from the start. I even noticed that I was sad when we got to other parts of the book. I just wanted more and more Leo. Leo was such a strong, good girl, and I was just cheering and hoping that she would continue drawing, painting, making art in general. Not stop because of all the stuff that is happening to her.
Lil was definitely another favourite of mine, then again, she is just too awesome. Being an actress (and getting famous more and more), and also doing the detective stuff, and also work side jobs. Wow. Plus I loved seeing more of her family, in this case, her brother!
Plus I love how Lil still stands firm, tells it as it is. As I also said in the other book's review, I just love how she acts, it isn't like she is from that age, but from this age.
Sophie was quite fun, and she is still a very likeable character, but her constant Baron Baron Baron stuff, did not only annoy her friends, but also me, the reader. I get that the Baron is important, I get that the Baron did some really bad stuff, but really? Is it necessary to focus so much on someone?
The painting, and the whodunnit . Eh. I knew from the moment that that person asked for the painting that he was the one doing stuff. Not really a spoiler, it is just so clear from that point that I don't even care to put something like spoiler around it. It was a bit boring. I kept hoping for a new twist or turn, and I was frustrated with the characters taking so long. It is a shame, I love books which keep me on my toes, not immediately give me the right suspect immediately.
As with the previous book we have little parts in between the story which tell us about the dragon paintings. Since there are more than one of those. I definitely liked those little pieces, as it gave more insight in the dragons and what was going on with them.
Mei and her family also make an appearance, and I have to say I have a higher tolerance for Mei in this book. It was quite nice to see her around, and also see her help out.
Also as with the previous book, there is some romance, and I was really delighted to see that one popping up. It does fit with the ages of the characters.
What more? Oh yes, I want to visit Sinclair's! Sooooooo much. I wouldn't mind spending some days in that store. Visiting the millinery, the book store, the candy store, and all the other fun stores. *daydreams*
The ending was pretty great, well the actual ending that is, not the ending to the mystery. I am so happy for Lil and Sophie, they deserve this, and I hope it will mean more, and even bigger mysteries for them. Congrats girls!
The cover is once again gorgeous, I am glad that they don't suddenly decide to change, as so many other series sadly did. The cover is supershiny, and I just the various details that one only truly spies when they have read the book.
All in all, this was a great read with fantastic new characters (more Leo please), a mystery that was pretty decent (even if it was predictable), and much much more! Highly recommended!
Review first posted at https://twirlingbookprincess.com/
December 17, 2023
3,25⭐/5
Jak to często bywa w tego typu seriach, w końcu musi nadejść moment, w którym dana historia zwyczajnie zaczyna nudzić, a pomysły na jej rozwinięcie zaczynają gasnąć. Tak jest w przypadku serii o tajemnicach domu handlowego Sinclairs. W „Szmaragdowym smoku” próżno szukać satysfakcjonującej opowieści i interesujących, dobrze rozbudowanych bohaterów. Formuła zwyczajnie autorce się wyczerpała.
Na tle poprzedniej części, „Szmaragdowy smok” wypada bardzo kiepsko. Co prawda, akcja nadal jest wartka, główna zagadka kryminalna w pomyśle wygląda bardzo dobrze, jednak wykonanie i rozwinięcie akcji średnio autorce wyszło. Klimat powieści jest bardzo podobny do poprzednich części, w tekście nadal widać i czuć zainteresowanie Woodfine epoką wiktoriańską i brudnym Londynem, ale to zupełnie nie wystarczyło, by „Szmaragdowy smok” czymkolwiek się wyróżniał. Owszem, sama koncepcja na tę część była ciekawa, ale ostatecznie okazało się, że do niczego to nie doprowadziło, nadal autorka nie rozwiązała głównej zagadki związanej ze znajomością Barona z rodzicami Sofie, a jedynie zrobiła sobie lepszy podjazd pod kolejną książkę, która w mojej ocenie zapewne będzie jeszcze bardziej naciągana niż „Szmaragdowy smok”. W tej części mamy przedstawiony jeszcze raz ten sam schemat, co bardzo męczy czytelnika i drażni ze względu na to, że zmierza to donikąd. Równie dobrze książka mogłaby nie powstać, można ją przeskoczyć i przeczytać część czwartą, by poznać zakończenie całej serii. Ponownie Woodfine nakreśliła kolejnych bohaterów (Leo i Jacka), którzy są ciekawi, wpływają na fabułę i zachowanie głównych bohaterek, ale przez wprowadzenie nowych postaci, te wcześniejsze tracą wiele na rozwinięciu, nie są bardziej rozbudowani, a wręcz ponownie robią te same błędy, nie ponosząc za nie konsekwencji (choć na plus pojawienie się znanych z poprzedniej części Songa i Mei). To bardzo denerwuje, zwłaszcza, że autorka mogła napisać to o wiele lepiej. Sophie straciła swoją osobowość i wręcz zachowywała się jakby nagle przestała myśleć chcąc tylko za wszelką cenę dowiedzieć się prawdy o przeszłości swoich rodziców i ich związku z Baronem. Zupełnie nie kupiłam całej historii i wręcz męczyłam się czytając ją. Mam nadal jednak nadzieję, że finał serii wynagrodzi mi zaznane rozczarowania i w końcu autorka wjedzie na odpowiednie tory i dowiezie to, co powinna.
Jak to często bywa w tego typu seriach, w końcu musi nadejść moment, w którym dana historia zwyczajnie zaczyna nudzić, a pomysły na jej rozwinięcie zaczynają gasnąć. Tak jest w przypadku serii o tajemnicach domu handlowego Sinclairs. W „Szmaragdowym smoku” próżno szukać satysfakcjonującej opowieści i interesujących, dobrze rozbudowanych bohaterów. Formuła zwyczajnie autorce się wyczerpała.
Na tle poprzedniej części, „Szmaragdowy smok” wypada bardzo kiepsko. Co prawda, akcja nadal jest wartka, główna zagadka kryminalna w pomyśle wygląda bardzo dobrze, jednak wykonanie i rozwinięcie akcji średnio autorce wyszło. Klimat powieści jest bardzo podobny do poprzednich części, w tekście nadal widać i czuć zainteresowanie Woodfine epoką wiktoriańską i brudnym Londynem, ale to zupełnie nie wystarczyło, by „Szmaragdowy smok” czymkolwiek się wyróżniał. Owszem, sama koncepcja na tę część była ciekawa, ale ostatecznie okazało się, że do niczego to nie doprowadziło, nadal autorka nie rozwiązała głównej zagadki związanej ze znajomością Barona z rodzicami Sofie, a jedynie zrobiła sobie lepszy podjazd pod kolejną książkę, która w mojej ocenie zapewne będzie jeszcze bardziej naciągana niż „Szmaragdowy smok”. W tej części mamy przedstawiony jeszcze raz ten sam schemat, co bardzo męczy czytelnika i drażni ze względu na to, że zmierza to donikąd. Równie dobrze książka mogłaby nie powstać, można ją przeskoczyć i przeczytać część czwartą, by poznać zakończenie całej serii. Ponownie Woodfine nakreśliła kolejnych bohaterów (Leo i Jacka), którzy są ciekawi, wpływają na fabułę i zachowanie głównych bohaterek, ale przez wprowadzenie nowych postaci, te wcześniejsze tracą wiele na rozwinięciu, nie są bardziej rozbudowani, a wręcz ponownie robią te same błędy, nie ponosząc za nie konsekwencji (choć na plus pojawienie się znanych z poprzedniej części Songa i Mei). To bardzo denerwuje, zwłaszcza, że autorka mogła napisać to o wiele lepiej. Sophie straciła swoją osobowość i wręcz zachowywała się jakby nagle przestała myśleć chcąc tylko za wszelką cenę dowiedzieć się prawdy o przeszłości swoich rodziców i ich związku z Baronem. Zupełnie nie kupiłam całej historii i wręcz męczyłam się czytając ją. Mam nadal jednak nadzieję, że finał serii wynagrodzi mi zaznane rozczarowania i w końcu autorka wjedzie na odpowiednie tory i dowiezie to, co powinna.
August 25, 2020
My favourite part of this series is definitely meeting Katherine Woodfine's charming supporting characters. In the last book, we met the lovely Mei and the Lim family. In this one, we meet aspiring painter Leonora Fitzgerald (whose need to get around with a crutch doesn't define or disable her) - as well as the dashing brother of one of our heroines, Jack Rose.
The dark criminal conspiracy at the heart of this series continues to reveal itself as Sophie and Lil turn to the mystery of a priceless stolen painting - one in a series of dragon-inspired artwork by a long-dead painter.
As always, a really cracking final act full of action and adventure, as Sophie and Lil set into motion their most elaborate plan yet to solve a mystery that the authorities can't seem to figure out.
Enjoyed the moments with the Suffragettes too, underscored by the final decision by Sophie and Lil not to let any man - not even their eponymous boss, Mr. Sinclair - make decisions about who they are and will be.
Must admit that these books work better for me in theory than execution though. Nothing wrong with it, per se, but Woodfine's writing tends towards the serviceable for me, especially in its more repetitive, exposition-heavy moments.
3.5 stars
The dark criminal conspiracy at the heart of this series continues to reveal itself as Sophie and Lil turn to the mystery of a priceless stolen painting - one in a series of dragon-inspired artwork by a long-dead painter.
As always, a really cracking final act full of action and adventure, as Sophie and Lil set into motion their most elaborate plan yet to solve a mystery that the authorities can't seem to figure out.
Enjoyed the moments with the Suffragettes too, underscored by the final decision by Sophie and Lil not to let any man - not even their eponymous boss, Mr. Sinclair - make decisions about who they are and will be.
Must admit that these books work better for me in theory than execution though. Nothing wrong with it, per se, but Woodfine's writing tends towards the serviceable for me, especially in its more repetitive, exposition-heavy moments.
3.5 stars
April 19, 2021
Boy is this series good for what ails me! I love each book so much, but this may have been my favorite. I was delighted to see Mei Lim and her family make a reappearance (and other characters from Book 2 briefly too). I love the additions of Leo and Jack in this book. The pacing of this book was particularly well crafted, I thought, and the last big scuffle was so wonderfully written for the careful reader, so many things had to be in place to pull it off. Each book is satisfying in itself, but also sets up the continuing mystery plot lines for the next book (and the spin off series). I’m heading right into the fourth book now.
I just remembered that there are two loose ends from this book (Tremayne and Pennyfeather) that I am curious about for Book 4. Will they get picked up again? Were they red herrings? Mistakes?
I just remembered that there are two loose ends from this book (Tremayne and Pennyfeather) that I am curious about for Book 4. Will they get picked up again? Were they red herrings? Mistakes?
July 25, 2020
Quite an enjoyable read. I started reading The Painted Dragon without having read the first two books in the series - didn't matter at all. Characters' previously established relationships are well explained as well as any prior events relevant to this plot. And I'll definitely be starting the series from the beginning now.
Aimed at readers 9+ and well written for this age group but still an enjoyable read as an adult.
As historical fiction it was also generally a good read - a diverse cast of characters appear without any of the kind of derogatory language you find referring to them that you can find in modern-written historical detective series (I'm looking at you Miss Fisher..).
I would definitely recommend for young readers who enjoy a good mystery.
Aimed at readers 9+ and well written for this age group but still an enjoyable read as an adult.
As historical fiction it was also generally a good read - a diverse cast of characters appear without any of the kind of derogatory language you find referring to them that you can find in modern-written historical detective series (I'm looking at you Miss Fisher..).
I would definitely recommend for young readers who enjoy a good mystery.
June 15, 2021
When a priceless painting is stolen, our dauntless detectives, Miss Sophie Taylor and Miss Lillian Rose, find themselves faced with trickery and deceit on all sides!
Be amazed as the brave duo pit their wits against a fiendish puzzle! Marvel at their cunning plan to unmask the villain and prove themselves detectives to be reckoned with - no matter whet danger lies ahead. And will Sophie find the truth about what really happened to her parents.
I loved this book and recommend it for 9+. It is very thrilling and a joy to read. I couldn't have wanted a better book
Be amazed as the brave duo pit their wits against a fiendish puzzle! Marvel at their cunning plan to unmask the villain and prove themselves detectives to be reckoned with - no matter whet danger lies ahead. And will Sophie find the truth about what really happened to her parents.
I loved this book and recommend it for 9+. It is very thrilling and a joy to read. I couldn't have wanted a better book
June 11, 2017
Another great installment of a great kids series.
June 5, 2021
Read- June 2021 for Whatever-A-Thon
- Bit annoying that they didn't figure out The Baron was involved until the end but still rather enjoyable.
- Bit annoying that they didn't figure out The Baron was involved until the end but still rather enjoyable.
January 2, 2024
Класне продовження цієї дитячої комфортної детективної історії. Якщо сподобалися попередні частини, то ця сподобається також🥰
June 9, 2023
Another good installment in The Sinclair's Mysteries series. I enjoyed seeing all our old characters come back to help solve this mystery. I love how Woodfine keeps the main characters the same but brings in new characters and the book relates around a different aspect of the culture in 1909 (this one being art students and an art museum).
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 9, 2019
Another exciting mystery from Sinclair's is over and once again I have enjoyed it! With twists and turns; and new characters I'm really rather sad that there's only one more book to read!
December 9, 2020
With a priceless piece of artwork gone our mystery solvers have another mystery on there hands. Sophie and Lil have to use there smarts and wits to out smart the crook who took the painting. They have to prove that they are the best mystery solvers ever. Can they catch the crook or will the painting and the crook vanish and never seen again.
January 3, 2024
Just as much fun as the first three, but like the second, a bit slow to start with lots of emphasis on a new character that becomes central to the mystery that unravels later. Another cover just as charming, with contents to match. This time the mystery involves an art heist, a locked room theft no less. The group of our four young detectives is a bit disjointed at first, with no case to consume them and Sophie handling small fry inquiries like lost cats.
I DID enjoy the secret society meeting, and the idea of hidden messages contained in century old paintings, along with the references to the suffragettes (and their radical tactics!). A few possible romances are afoot, though they are definitely (and quite right) subplots and the mystery remains center stage, and there's some nice mentions of previous characters that make cameo appearances here too. Another solid entry. Excited to read the last installment in the series, The Midnight Peacock, when I can find it.
I DID enjoy the secret society meeting, and the idea of hidden messages contained in century old paintings, along with the references to the suffragettes (and their radical tactics!). A few possible romances are afoot, though they are definitely (and quite right) subplots and the mystery remains center stage, and there's some nice mentions of previous characters that make cameo appearances here too. Another solid entry. Excited to read the last installment in the series, The Midnight Peacock, when I can find it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 150 reviews