What do you think?
Rate this book
The Stars We Hold
Weary of the ravages of World War II, seventeen-year-old Nada is no stranger to loss. Her father was killed by the Ustaše – a fascist, Croatian regime working to cleanse Yugoslavia of Serbs – and the boy she secretly loves, Henrik, abandoned her to join the Partizan resistance. It’s why Nada holds tighter to those she cares about. So when she discovers her mother and sisters were ripped from their home by the Ustaše, Nada has to do something.
Desperate to get her family back, Nada tracks down the Partizan resistance to enlist their help. It’s there, deep in the forest, she stumbles upon Henrik, but he’s changed. Callous and cold, he thwarts her hopes of a rescue mission at every turn…until he catches Nada sneaking off to save her family by herself. He has no choice now but to go with her and fight to keep her alive.
With their sights set on Jasenovac – the Ustašes’ sadistic death camp – a perilous journey lies ahead of them. If they fail to infiltrate the regime leader’s home, steal a map of the camp, break into Jasenovac and escape with her loved ones, Nada will lose what remains of her family…forever.
Desperate to get her family back, Nada tracks down the Partizan resistance to enlist their help. It’s there, deep in the forest, she stumbles upon Henrik, but he’s changed. Callous and cold, he thwarts her hopes of a rescue mission at every turn…until he catches Nada sneaking off to save her family by herself. He has no choice now but to go with her and fight to keep her alive.
With their sights set on Jasenovac – the Ustašes’ sadistic death camp – a perilous journey lies ahead of them. If they fail to infiltrate the regime leader’s home, steal a map of the camp, break into Jasenovac and escape with her loved ones, Nada will lose what remains of her family…forever.
347 pages, Paperback
First published June 28, 2024
About the author
Melissa Armstrong
1 book12 followersMelissa Armstrong has been addicted to writing ever since her 4th grade teacher delighted in her stories and asked to read them to the class. She’ll never forget the way it felt to witness her fellow students’ enjoyment and laughter in response to her words. Today, she strives to evoke that same magic from her romantic YA novels. Aside from writing and reading, Melissa has a deep love for nature and interior design. While born and raised in Australia, she lives in North Carolina with her husband, daughter and their sock-stealing Rottweiler.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews
July 19, 2024
This month I hosted a read-along for The Stars We Hold and we all collectively agree…this book is phenomenal! I loved The Stars We Hold and could not put it down. I fell asleep reading way past my bedtime each night because this story was just that gripping.
While the plot is compelling and the well thought out and researched setting is immersive, I think my favorite thing about this story was the characters. TSWH is told from 2 different POVs (our childhood friends to enemies to lovers Henrik and Nada), but there are 4 characters that we follow throughout the book. I loved their found family dynamic and as I mentioned on this live, I loved how each character was relatable. Though I love our conflicted, broody MMC Henrik and adored the lighthearted Vinko, my favorite characters were our two girls: Nada and Ester. Both strong in their own way, both brave in their own way, and both willing to do whatever it takes to rescue their family.
I can’t gush about this book enough. If you love Ruta Sepetys’s books, if you loved All the Light We Cannot See, you will love The Stars We Hold. Highly highly recommend! It’s available in print and on KU and the dual narrator audiobook will be out sometime in August 🥳
While the plot is compelling and the well thought out and researched setting is immersive, I think my favorite thing about this story was the characters. TSWH is told from 2 different POVs (our childhood friends to enemies to lovers Henrik and Nada), but there are 4 characters that we follow throughout the book. I loved their found family dynamic and as I mentioned on this live, I loved how each character was relatable. Though I love our conflicted, broody MMC Henrik and adored the lighthearted Vinko, my favorite characters were our two girls: Nada and Ester. Both strong in their own way, both brave in their own way, and both willing to do whatever it takes to rescue their family.
I can’t gush about this book enough. If you love Ruta Sepetys’s books, if you loved All the Light We Cannot See, you will love The Stars We Hold. Highly highly recommend! It’s available in print and on KU and the dual narrator audiobook will be out sometime in August 🥳
June 9, 2024
Thank you Melissa for having me be part of the ARC team! I overall enjoyed this book and very much appreciated a different venture and story into a different part of WWII that I personally had never heard of. Overall, I’d say it was more of a 3.5 star for me! There were some things that didn’t sit 100% with me and here’s my thoughts on it all.
- It’s very fast paced story (which is sometimes such a nice change up!) and the scenes felt back-to-back with very little “still” moments in between. It felt like we’d have one crazy action packed scene and then the story skips immediately to the next one. I personally love more context, build up and hearing the characters inner thoughts and feelings leading up to things.
- I had a hard time connecting to the characters or feeling very much chemistry or development from them. I was kind of turned off by the harshness of some of their actions but at the same time did somewhat appreciate the realistic aspect of it all. I think it’s fair to say most of us wouldn’t think twice about hurting someone else when it comes to our family but I guess the lack of guilt/conscience is what didn’t totally sit right with me. It seemed almost too easy for them to do certain things and like it was water off their backs.
- There was one part where Nada is almost admiring and infatuated by the violence Henrick is revealing and it rubbed me soooooo wrong. Maybe the way it was worded because I can see the point that was trying to be made but it felt a bit ick.
- I feel a bit bad for Ester. I feel like I don’t know HER I only know how she serves everyone around her and what benefits she brings to them. I think she was enough of a character that she deserved more background and development for herself. I felt like we did get more of that with Vinko who was also a secondary character.
- There also felt like some big moments that need more buildup and context and maybe even some lingering thoughts after the fact. There were times things felt very skipped over when we had been waiting the entire book for that moment to happen.
- Was hoping for a little more romance and connection. There were some really great moments but Henrick constantly pushing Nada away got old quickly because I feel like his thoughts didn’t back up his actions in a way that made sense.. his “reasoning” ultimately made sense but also kind of beat around the bush and made me feel unclear for a bit of the book. I just found myself being annoyed at how he acted because there were better ways to go about what he was trying to accomplish. And then when he finally did let her in I just personally hated the way he did it and wanted it to be more sweet.
- I do love hearing a story from a demographic I was completely unaware of, as brutal and gory as it was to read at times. I very much outwardly cringed at a few sentences. But I think it’s important to acknowledge the severity and absolutely horrid moments these people experienced.
Overall, I really appreciate where Melissa was taking this story and I think she did a great job! I love that she intermixed romance with historical fiction (two of my favorite genres together, what a WIN) and she kept me on the edge of my seat from chapter 1.
- It’s very fast paced story (which is sometimes such a nice change up!) and the scenes felt back-to-back with very little “still” moments in between. It felt like we’d have one crazy action packed scene and then the story skips immediately to the next one. I personally love more context, build up and hearing the characters inner thoughts and feelings leading up to things.
- I had a hard time connecting to the characters or feeling very much chemistry or development from them. I was kind of turned off by the harshness of some of their actions but at the same time did somewhat appreciate the realistic aspect of it all. I think it’s fair to say most of us wouldn’t think twice about hurting someone else when it comes to our family but I guess the lack of guilt/conscience is what didn’t totally sit right with me. It seemed almost too easy for them to do certain things and like it was water off their backs.
- There was one part where Nada is almost admiring and infatuated by the violence Henrick is revealing and it rubbed me soooooo wrong. Maybe the way it was worded because I can see the point that was trying to be made but it felt a bit ick.
- I feel a bit bad for Ester. I feel like I don’t know HER I only know how she serves everyone around her and what benefits she brings to them. I think she was enough of a character that she deserved more background and development for herself. I felt like we did get more of that with Vinko who was also a secondary character.
- There also felt like some big moments that need more buildup and context and maybe even some lingering thoughts after the fact. There were times things felt very skipped over when we had been waiting the entire book for that moment to happen.
- Was hoping for a little more romance and connection. There were some really great moments but Henrick constantly pushing Nada away got old quickly because I feel like his thoughts didn’t back up his actions in a way that made sense.. his “reasoning” ultimately made sense but also kind of beat around the bush and made me feel unclear for a bit of the book. I just found myself being annoyed at how he acted because there were better ways to go about what he was trying to accomplish. And then when he finally did let her in I just personally hated the way he did it and wanted it to be more sweet.
- I do love hearing a story from a demographic I was completely unaware of, as brutal and gory as it was to read at times. I very much outwardly cringed at a few sentences. But I think it’s important to acknowledge the severity and absolutely horrid moments these people experienced.
Overall, I really appreciate where Melissa was taking this story and I think she did a great job! I love that she intermixed romance with historical fiction (two of my favorite genres together, what a WIN) and she kept me on the edge of my seat from chapter 1.
May 28, 2024
GENRE: YA Historical Fiction
MY RATING: 5/5
Characters: 5/5
Storyline: 5/5
Writing style/structure: 5/5
Overall enjoyment: 5/5
MY THOUGHTS
This was one of my most anticipated reads of 2024 and to say that I ‘enjoyed’ this book would be the wrong word. This book broke me and put me back together again! It is rare that I cry whilst reading, but this story had me sobbing multiple times. It was heart-wrenching, dark and wrought with danger. But it was also hopeful, light-hearted in places with heavy emphases on family and what you are willing to do in order to keep them safe.
The Stars We Hold is a little-known history novel that features the true experiences of the author’s father in Yugoslavia during WWII. I do not want to know which parts of this book are factual as there are some heinous acts spoken of in this book that I don’t want to even imagine happening in real life.
I appreciated the Serbo- Croatian Pronunciation & Translation Guide at the beginning of the book. It enhanced my reading experience, as I wasn’t guessing how to say certain words, nor their meanings. It also had a fantastic opening sentence. “There were no demons as relentless and cruel as hunger, loss, and war.” This sets the tone from the very beginning.
This book has a release date of 28 June 2024. I was provided an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review. My opinion is that you should definitely read it. But, there is a lot of triggering content in this book so be aware. Some of the subject matter may make you uncomfortable, but I think that is kind of the point. Although it is a work of fiction, it still touches on what actually happened to people back in World War Two, which isn’t often spoken about. There was a quote in the beginning of the book that states “For all the evil the Germans waged throughout Europe, it spoke volumes that a Nazi was repulsed and horrified by the Ustaše”. This alone should give you some idea of what you would be going into, should you pick this book up.
MY RATING: 5/5
Characters: 5/5
Storyline: 5/5
Writing style/structure: 5/5
Overall enjoyment: 5/5
MY THOUGHTS
This was one of my most anticipated reads of 2024 and to say that I ‘enjoyed’ this book would be the wrong word. This book broke me and put me back together again! It is rare that I cry whilst reading, but this story had me sobbing multiple times. It was heart-wrenching, dark and wrought with danger. But it was also hopeful, light-hearted in places with heavy emphases on family and what you are willing to do in order to keep them safe.
The Stars We Hold is a little-known history novel that features the true experiences of the author’s father in Yugoslavia during WWII. I do not want to know which parts of this book are factual as there are some heinous acts spoken of in this book that I don’t want to even imagine happening in real life.
I appreciated the Serbo- Croatian Pronunciation & Translation Guide at the beginning of the book. It enhanced my reading experience, as I wasn’t guessing how to say certain words, nor their meanings. It also had a fantastic opening sentence. “There were no demons as relentless and cruel as hunger, loss, and war.” This sets the tone from the very beginning.
This book has a release date of 28 June 2024. I was provided an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review. My opinion is that you should definitely read it. But, there is a lot of triggering content in this book so be aware. Some of the subject matter may make you uncomfortable, but I think that is kind of the point. Although it is a work of fiction, it still touches on what actually happened to people back in World War Two, which isn’t often spoken about. There was a quote in the beginning of the book that states “For all the evil the Germans waged throughout Europe, it spoke volumes that a Nazi was repulsed and horrified by the Ustaše”. This alone should give you some idea of what you would be going into, should you pick this book up.
May 28, 2024
♾️⭐️
This book is phenomenal! I never thought I’d read another historical fiction that rivaled the Nightingale- but here we are.
I cried within the first couple chapters, laughed, had a lot of deep thoughts and was left wishing the book hadn’t ended.
Nada is fierce in all the ways that count and her growth throughout the book was so beautiful to see.
Henrik was firm in believing what he told himself all the time he spent away, but watching his walls crumble was everythinggggg.
I am utterly fascinated with all things WW2 & this book delivered in every single way. Action packed and fast paced the entire time, a heist, love and loss and sheer determination to find their loved ones; no matter the cost.
This is a top read this year for me. I was absolutely blown away with this incredible book and I will recommend it always!
This book is phenomenal! I never thought I’d read another historical fiction that rivaled the Nightingale- but here we are.
I cried within the first couple chapters, laughed, had a lot of deep thoughts and was left wishing the book hadn’t ended.
Nada is fierce in all the ways that count and her growth throughout the book was so beautiful to see.
Henrik was firm in believing what he told himself all the time he spent away, but watching his walls crumble was everythinggggg.
I am utterly fascinated with all things WW2 & this book delivered in every single way. Action packed and fast paced the entire time, a heist, love and loss and sheer determination to find their loved ones; no matter the cost.
This is a top read this year for me. I was absolutely blown away with this incredible book and I will recommend it always!
June 2, 2024
Words to describe this book?! A captivating emotional roller-coaster! I was so lucky to be a part of the ARC team for The Stars We Hold and in return to give my honest opinion. I am SO impressed by Melissa’s writing - the descriptions were IMPECCABLE and I found myself rooting for alllll the characters!
This book has it all: found family, slow burn romance, high stakes, historical events, period drama vibes, action and adventure, enemies to lovers. 🙌🏻
I loved this so much!
This book has it all: found family, slow burn romance, high stakes, historical events, period drama vibes, action and adventure, enemies to lovers. 🙌🏻
I loved this so much!
June 28, 2024
I am going to give you a glimpse into my dramatic and emotional side. Sometimes when I finish a book I get this feeling, and I just know that I will never be the same. Every now and then a book shocks me and becomes so much more than a book. This is one of those books. If I could give this book more than five stars, I would. It blows my mind that this author was turned down by so many publishers. The story she paints for the reader is beautiful, emotional, heart-wrenching, and incredible. I am a mood reader, so when I say I did not want to put down a book, it is a huge compliment. I did not want to put this down. I was drawn in almost immediately. This is one of the most beautiful love stories I have ever read. It is a love letter to friendship, and the bond of family. There are certain books that I will hang, my hat on and recommend to everyone. This is absolutely one of those books.
Technically this is a history novel based on true events. It is set during WW2. If that appeals to you, great! If it doesn��t, hi nice to meet you. I’m going to be completely honest. I was so very hesitant to read this book because it is not what I normally reach for at all. I am so happy I did though. Just trust me when I say, you need to read this book. Normally with heavier books, I need to take breaks while reading. I did not want to with this one. I needed to know what happened next. Be prepared this book will rip your heart out, put it back together, and then rip it out again. It also opened my eyes to historical events I did not even know occurred.
I am probably getting redundant, but when I am passionate about something. I do not want to stop talking about it. I will stop for now though.
This was an ARC book I received for free, but it was my honor to read and review it. Read this book on June 28th, it is so worth it!
Technically this is a history novel based on true events. It is set during WW2. If that appeals to you, great! If it doesn��t, hi nice to meet you. I’m going to be completely honest. I was so very hesitant to read this book because it is not what I normally reach for at all. I am so happy I did though. Just trust me when I say, you need to read this book. Normally with heavier books, I need to take breaks while reading. I did not want to with this one. I needed to know what happened next. Be prepared this book will rip your heart out, put it back together, and then rip it out again. It also opened my eyes to historical events I did not even know occurred.
I am probably getting redundant, but when I am passionate about something. I do not want to stop talking about it. I will stop for now though.
This was an ARC book I received for free, but it was my honor to read and review it. Read this book on June 28th, it is so worth it!
June 15, 2024
Such a dazzling debut!
I love when historical novels are inspired by family history and this was a very intriguing addition to that list.
I have a lot to say about this novel so I suppose I’ll start with the very first note I took which was about the prose! This book felt FANCY to me, the descriptions were colorful and the word choice felt very frilly. Honestly at times that felt a bit distracting, especially in the beginning. It felt too elegant for the story being told, but as the book wore on I didn’t notice it as much and came to appreciate the unique writing style.
While some of the word choices felt frilly I also think the tone was a bit all over the place but my perception of that could be because of my own background on the history and what age group I though this novel was intended for.
At times it felt as though I was reading a realistic war drama that explored the atrocities of war and other times it felt as though I was along for a ride with Indiana Jones. I don’t think that mix is a bad thing at all but it was just a surprise to me, because I truly thought I would be reading a very historically accurate and detailed look at a time in history I didn’t know much about. That being said, the adventure elements and action sequences were EXQUISITE so I wasn’t mad about the surprising mix of genres.
As a YA or NA novel I think this absolutely SLAYS. If you go into this expecting a solid action adventure novel you will be very pleased. I’d describe this as a mix of Divine Rivals and a J’Nell Ciesielski novel. If you go into this expecting something like Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys you may be a bit underwhelmed as it’s not really in that vein of storytelling.
This is a novel that really drives home the set pieces and the fighting hearts of its main characters and that is a very compelling combination. I only wish that some more of the heist planning has been mentioned on page because there was plenty of room for it. The lack of this made for a few moments of thinking things seemed too convenient. Many things that happened felt far fetched and sometimes I just yearned for a bit more explanation.
Yes, characters faced hardships but the journey was relatively straight forward and not too difficult. For it being the middle of a war it just seemed all too easy to me… I wish there was some sort of authors note at the end of the book that explained what was fact and what was fiction to help explain some of these plot points as well. (I was given an ARC so this may change in future editions)
The last thing I want to talk about is our 4 main characters. I felt that Henrick and Nada were very well rounded characters and I was very much invested in their relationship. For Vinko and Ester I only wish they could have had more build and that they could have gotten their big hero/sacrifice moment.
Overall this is a STUNNING debut and I am so very excited to have Melissa Armstrong writing in the historical genre! If you go in knowing it’s a historical adventure new adult novel rather than a straight historical fiction drama you will be over the moon!
I was given an ARC by the author. My review is voluntary and honest.
I love when historical novels are inspired by family history and this was a very intriguing addition to that list.
I have a lot to say about this novel so I suppose I’ll start with the very first note I took which was about the prose! This book felt FANCY to me, the descriptions were colorful and the word choice felt very frilly. Honestly at times that felt a bit distracting, especially in the beginning. It felt too elegant for the story being told, but as the book wore on I didn’t notice it as much and came to appreciate the unique writing style.
While some of the word choices felt frilly I also think the tone was a bit all over the place but my perception of that could be because of my own background on the history and what age group I though this novel was intended for.
At times it felt as though I was reading a realistic war drama that explored the atrocities of war and other times it felt as though I was along for a ride with Indiana Jones. I don’t think that mix is a bad thing at all but it was just a surprise to me, because I truly thought I would be reading a very historically accurate and detailed look at a time in history I didn’t know much about. That being said, the adventure elements and action sequences were EXQUISITE so I wasn’t mad about the surprising mix of genres.
As a YA or NA novel I think this absolutely SLAYS. If you go into this expecting a solid action adventure novel you will be very pleased. I’d describe this as a mix of Divine Rivals and a J’Nell Ciesielski novel. If you go into this expecting something like Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys you may be a bit underwhelmed as it’s not really in that vein of storytelling.
This is a novel that really drives home the set pieces and the fighting hearts of its main characters and that is a very compelling combination. I only wish that some more of the heist planning has been mentioned on page because there was plenty of room for it. The lack of this made for a few moments of thinking things seemed too convenient. Many things that happened felt far fetched and sometimes I just yearned for a bit more explanation.
Yes, characters faced hardships but the journey was relatively straight forward and not too difficult. For it being the middle of a war it just seemed all too easy to me… I wish there was some sort of authors note at the end of the book that explained what was fact and what was fiction to help explain some of these plot points as well. (I was given an ARC so this may change in future editions)
The last thing I want to talk about is our 4 main characters. I felt that Henrick and Nada were very well rounded characters and I was very much invested in their relationship. For Vinko and Ester I only wish they could have had more build and that they could have gotten their big hero/sacrifice moment.
Overall this is a STUNNING debut and I am so very excited to have Melissa Armstrong writing in the historical genre! If you go in knowing it’s a historical adventure new adult novel rather than a straight historical fiction drama you will be over the moon!
I was given an ARC by the author. My review is voluntary and honest.
June 12, 2024
5 stars.
Wow! I can’t believe as much as there is known about WW2, that this time in history, overlapping on the heels of WW2, is so unknown. I was never educated about the racial cleansing in Eastern Europe as the ideology of the nazi’s spread outside of their regime into other territories that took matters into their own hands.
The Stars We Hold is beautifully written. Every chapter is action packed and I read the last 20% of the book with a heightened pulse and tears in my eyes. The selfless sacrifices that were made throughout the book were heartbreaking and sobering.
I love the author’s connection to the storyline, and that some of the events were drawn from true accounts and her own personal, familial connection to this time period. Anyone that loves WW2 historical fiction will love this book!
Content considerations: themes of war - detailed and gruesome violence, killing, on page death. Strong language from one specific character. As a YA, I think it falls into the older teen age, depending on reader and their language/descriptive violence tolerance, erring on the conservative side I’d say 18+
Wow! I can’t believe as much as there is known about WW2, that this time in history, overlapping on the heels of WW2, is so unknown. I was never educated about the racial cleansing in Eastern Europe as the ideology of the nazi’s spread outside of their regime into other territories that took matters into their own hands.
The Stars We Hold is beautifully written. Every chapter is action packed and I read the last 20% of the book with a heightened pulse and tears in my eyes. The selfless sacrifices that were made throughout the book were heartbreaking and sobering.
I love the author’s connection to the storyline, and that some of the events were drawn from true accounts and her own personal, familial connection to this time period. Anyone that loves WW2 historical fiction will love this book!
Content considerations: themes of war - detailed and gruesome violence, killing, on page death. Strong language from one specific character. As a YA, I think it falls into the older teen age, depending on reader and their language/descriptive violence tolerance, erring on the conservative side I’d say 18+
May 28, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
The Stars We Hold is a brilliant YA historical fiction novel with captivating characters and beautiful prose that had me racing through the pages.
I loved this one. It was fierce and tender. I fell in love with the characters. It was fast and adventurous, with a wonderful romance and gorgeous relationships. The writing was fantastic, and the ending was lovely. I can’t wait to read more by Melissa Armstrong!
Thank you to the author for the free ARC!
The Stars We Hold is a brilliant YA historical fiction novel with captivating characters and beautiful prose that had me racing through the pages.
I loved this one. It was fierce and tender. I fell in love with the characters. It was fast and adventurous, with a wonderful romance and gorgeous relationships. The writing was fantastic, and the ending was lovely. I can’t wait to read more by Melissa Armstrong!
Thank you to the author for the free ARC!
June 6, 2024
The Stars We Hold by Melissa Armstrong ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
There are no words to describe the haunting beauty of this book. The richness of the story, the complexity of the characters, the gut wrenching final chapters.
This story is YA historical fiction, set in WW2 and based on true events of the Authors Grandfather.
It's follows the stories of childhood friends Nada and Henrick, and their journey through war, away from eachother, and then eventually finding their way back together despite all of their broken bits. This story is a love letter to friendships, family and what we would endure for those we love the most.
This book is giving Tomorrow When the War Began (John Marsden), The Bronze Horseman (Paullina Simons), and the Tattooist of Auschwitz (Heather Morris) vibes and it was totally un-put-down-able....
I had such a sense of nostalgia reading this book, it's poignant and I can already tell it's something I will be reccomending friends and family to read.
There are no words to describe the haunting beauty of this book. The richness of the story, the complexity of the characters, the gut wrenching final chapters.
This story is YA historical fiction, set in WW2 and based on true events of the Authors Grandfather.
It's follows the stories of childhood friends Nada and Henrick, and their journey through war, away from eachother, and then eventually finding their way back together despite all of their broken bits. This story is a love letter to friendships, family and what we would endure for those we love the most.
This book is giving Tomorrow When the War Began (John Marsden), The Bronze Horseman (Paullina Simons), and the Tattooist of Auschwitz (Heather Morris) vibes and it was totally un-put-down-able....
I had such a sense of nostalgia reading this book, it's poignant and I can already tell it's something I will be reccomending friends and family to read.
June 29, 2024
The story of Nada and Henrik is a compelling historical fiction of courage, love and survival amidst devastating circumstances.
This is a YA so I wanted to give content warnings: fairly descriptive violence, some F-words, and a short and vague open door scene.
This is a YA so I wanted to give content warnings: fairly descriptive violence, some F-words, and a short and vague open door scene.
May 28, 2024
This book had me in tears 😢 happy and sad ones. When reading certain parts, uggggh my heart cracked 💔 This book was so good. I felt it in so many ways. Everyone needs to read and experience this story. I could not put it down. I fell so deeply for these characters. I cried with them, I screamed with them, I laughed with them...... Nada & Henrik are fighting to get to their families and keeping their friends safe. I was on the edge of my seat at times. The feelings/emotions I experienced throughout this book. I didn't want it to end. I can't wait to have the physical copy in my hands... ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
July 21, 2024
4.5!!!
I had chills, tears and giggles throughout my whole experience reading this book!! “The Stars We Hold” is such a painfully beautiful story that moved me in so many ways. It exposed and shed light on a side of history I had never before even heard referenced all while keeping me emotionally engaged and attached to the characters and their personal stories which reflected so much of what real people faced during this era. I have so much love for this story and these characters!! 🥹🫶✨
I had chills, tears and giggles throughout my whole experience reading this book!! “The Stars We Hold” is such a painfully beautiful story that moved me in so many ways. It exposed and shed light on a side of history I had never before even heard referenced all while keeping me emotionally engaged and attached to the characters and their personal stories which reflected so much of what real people faced during this era. I have so much love for this story and these characters!! 🥹🫶✨
June 6, 2024
Genre: YA historical fiction/historical romance
Content warnings: Standard world war II content - violence, death, racism, fascism, ethnic cleansing. Some detailed descriptions of the violence, but not gratuitous. Parental death. Brief mentions of child death, implied sexual assault, torture. Frequent swearing. I'd give this an age rating of 14+
Rating: 3.5/5
A big thank you to the author, Melissa Armstrong, for providing me with an ARC copy of this book.
I'm going to start this review by being straight-up: this book wasn't really for me. But at the time of writing this, I am the only reader so far who seems to feel this way, as all the other Goodreads reviews are four or five stars. This is definitely not a bad book by any means, and if you like certain tropes and plot devices, there's a good chance you'll enjoy it like everyone else here so far. Unfortunately, though, I was not a big fan.
Despite that overall opinion, the aspect of this book that most convinced me to read it - the Yugoslavian history - is something that Melissa Armstrong deserves huge praise for. The novel discusses the Croatian Ustase regime's rule of the country during World War II, and their persecution of Serbs, Jews, Romanis and political dissenters, which was so brutal that even the Nazis condemned them. These atrocities are rarely discussed - I'm an avid historical fiction reader and this is the first book I've come across that's so much as mentioned them - but they should be talked about more. These people deserve to be remembered just as much as any other victims of genocidal regimes, and for that reason, I am so, so glad that Melissa Armstrong decided to tell this story, in honour of her Croatian father whose experiences inspired some aspects of the plot. This is more than just a novel: it's a testament to the bravery and sacrifices of not just the Yugoslav people, but all people living under brutal governments.
Onto the content of the book itself. The pacing is mixed: it starts off fast as Nada's family are taken by the Ustase, then slows down for most of the book until near the end, when the group attempt to save them. These few chapters - the last twenty percent or so - are by far the best part of the novel, and prompted me to rate it a 3.5 instead of just 3 as I was originally going to give it. They were fast paced, emotional, and well described. Unfortunately, I found the rest of the book lacking a little in some of those aspects: while there would occasionally be fast-paced scenes, things felt slow and a little dragged-out in the middle, and I'm not really sure why, although I think my lack of connection to the characters might be the reason for this.
Speaking of the characters, I had mixed feelings about most of them. Vinko was my favourite - I enjoyed the humorous touch he brought to an otherwise very dark story - but I found his constant swearing (a pet peeve of mine in historical fiction) and his nicknaming of Nada irritating after a while. I want to make clear, though, that these are purely personal peeves, not an issue with the author's writing: Vinko was a well-developed character, the best developed of all of them in my opinion. Henrik - the male main character - was also well developed, but unfortunately I couldn't stand him for most of the book: while I understand why he behaved the way he did, I found him to be a very selfish character, and some of the things he did were hard for me to forgive. He did redeem himself well later - by the end of the book, I liked him - but it took all the way until just before the rescue mission for this change to happen. I'm okay with a love interest character starting off cruel and then developing to be more likable later on, but for me, this came a little too late in the story, and for that reason I couldn't really root for the romance, which was a huge aspect of this novel. Nada, the female main character and Henrik's love interest, was a lot more likable than he was - I loved her strength, and especially admired how she didn't change her mind about what she wanted after Henrik tried to stop her - but she didn't really stand out to me as a protagonist. Hers is a common character type in novels such as this, and there was nothing particularly memorable about her when compared to other strong female protagonists I've read about. The character I have the strongest feelings about, though, is Ester. She's the opposite of Nada, being the soft blonde to her badass brunette, and I loved their sisterly friendship (I also loved Nada and Vinko's friendship; the friendships and found family dynamic was one of my favourite things about this novel), but Ester by herself doesn't stand strong as a character in my opinion. She received the least "page time" of the main four, and seemed to serve more as a plot device than a character in her own right: she'd pop up every now and again to help heal other characters' injuries, and to reassure Nada of her strength and Henrik's feelings for her, but I felt she rarely did anything as a character for herself. In a lot of scenes, her dialogue also read as unnatural for a seventeen-year-old girl, as if written specifically to be quoted in reviews/social media: "That fiery streak in you leads to fierce determination, to intense focus on what's important," being one example I found, and then also the line "I've been a side character to the Henrik and Nada story for a long time", which pretty much confirms my theory outright. Then again, her way of speaking is consistent, and Nada tells her she has a way with words, which makes me think it was the author's deliberate choice to make her a bit precocious and poetic. It doesn't really change how I feel about her, though. My overall view on these characters is that they all had a lot of potential, but with the exception of Vinko, none of them fully lived up to it.
Lastly, I want to discuss the writing itself. For the most part, it is good - well suited to the YA target audience and with no grammar mistakes - but a lack of description in some scenes made this story sometimes difficult to visualize; there were a few parts where it didn't really feel like it was set in WWII, and I wasn't totally sure where the characters were geographically. A bit more description in these scenes would've helped not only in picturing things, but also in setting the (usually dark) mood. I do want to say, though, that the final few scenes of the book were an exception to this, as I thought those were very well described and a lot easier to picture than the rest of it.
Overall, my view is that The Stars We Hold is a very important story which needed to be told, but a few changes would've made it a better reading experience for me: namely, more description and some different choices in development for the main characters. Please don't let my mixed review of this novel put you off reading it, though, if you think it's something you might enjoy: if you like a slow-burn enemies-to-lovers romance (the enemy stage lasted too long for my liking, but if you prefer it that way then you'll love this), YA historical fiction set in a little-known place/era, and/or the found family trope (despite the issues I had with the individual characters, this trope was very well done), then do check this novel out and decide for yourself if you agree or disagree with my critique.
Content warnings: Standard world war II content - violence, death, racism, fascism, ethnic cleansing. Some detailed descriptions of the violence, but not gratuitous. Parental death. Brief mentions of child death, implied sexual assault, torture. Frequent swearing. I'd give this an age rating of 14+
Rating: 3.5/5
A big thank you to the author, Melissa Armstrong, for providing me with an ARC copy of this book.
I'm going to start this review by being straight-up: this book wasn't really for me. But at the time of writing this, I am the only reader so far who seems to feel this way, as all the other Goodreads reviews are four or five stars. This is definitely not a bad book by any means, and if you like certain tropes and plot devices, there's a good chance you'll enjoy it like everyone else here so far. Unfortunately, though, I was not a big fan.
Despite that overall opinion, the aspect of this book that most convinced me to read it - the Yugoslavian history - is something that Melissa Armstrong deserves huge praise for. The novel discusses the Croatian Ustase regime's rule of the country during World War II, and their persecution of Serbs, Jews, Romanis and political dissenters, which was so brutal that even the Nazis condemned them. These atrocities are rarely discussed - I'm an avid historical fiction reader and this is the first book I've come across that's so much as mentioned them - but they should be talked about more. These people deserve to be remembered just as much as any other victims of genocidal regimes, and for that reason, I am so, so glad that Melissa Armstrong decided to tell this story, in honour of her Croatian father whose experiences inspired some aspects of the plot. This is more than just a novel: it's a testament to the bravery and sacrifices of not just the Yugoslav people, but all people living under brutal governments.
Onto the content of the book itself. The pacing is mixed: it starts off fast as Nada's family are taken by the Ustase, then slows down for most of the book until near the end, when the group attempt to save them. These few chapters - the last twenty percent or so - are by far the best part of the novel, and prompted me to rate it a 3.5 instead of just 3 as I was originally going to give it. They were fast paced, emotional, and well described. Unfortunately, I found the rest of the book lacking a little in some of those aspects: while there would occasionally be fast-paced scenes, things felt slow and a little dragged-out in the middle, and I'm not really sure why, although I think my lack of connection to the characters might be the reason for this.
Speaking of the characters, I had mixed feelings about most of them. Vinko was my favourite - I enjoyed the humorous touch he brought to an otherwise very dark story - but I found his constant swearing (a pet peeve of mine in historical fiction) and his nicknaming of Nada irritating after a while. I want to make clear, though, that these are purely personal peeves, not an issue with the author's writing: Vinko was a well-developed character, the best developed of all of them in my opinion. Henrik - the male main character - was also well developed, but unfortunately I couldn't stand him for most of the book: while I understand why he behaved the way he did, I found him to be a very selfish character, and some of the things he did were hard for me to forgive. He did redeem himself well later - by the end of the book, I liked him - but it took all the way until just before the rescue mission for this change to happen. I'm okay with a love interest character starting off cruel and then developing to be more likable later on, but for me, this came a little too late in the story, and for that reason I couldn't really root for the romance, which was a huge aspect of this novel. Nada, the female main character and Henrik's love interest, was a lot more likable than he was - I loved her strength, and especially admired how she didn't change her mind about what she wanted after Henrik tried to stop her - but she didn't really stand out to me as a protagonist. Hers is a common character type in novels such as this, and there was nothing particularly memorable about her when compared to other strong female protagonists I've read about. The character I have the strongest feelings about, though, is Ester. She's the opposite of Nada, being the soft blonde to her badass brunette, and I loved their sisterly friendship (I also loved Nada and Vinko's friendship; the friendships and found family dynamic was one of my favourite things about this novel), but Ester by herself doesn't stand strong as a character in my opinion. She received the least "page time" of the main four, and seemed to serve more as a plot device than a character in her own right: she'd pop up every now and again to help heal other characters' injuries, and to reassure Nada of her strength and Henrik's feelings for her, but I felt she rarely did anything as a character for herself. In a lot of scenes, her dialogue also read as unnatural for a seventeen-year-old girl, as if written specifically to be quoted in reviews/social media: "That fiery streak in you leads to fierce determination, to intense focus on what's important," being one example I found, and then also the line "I've been a side character to the Henrik and Nada story for a long time", which pretty much confirms my theory outright. Then again, her way of speaking is consistent, and Nada tells her she has a way with words, which makes me think it was the author's deliberate choice to make her a bit precocious and poetic. It doesn't really change how I feel about her, though. My overall view on these characters is that they all had a lot of potential, but with the exception of Vinko, none of them fully lived up to it.
Lastly, I want to discuss the writing itself. For the most part, it is good - well suited to the YA target audience and with no grammar mistakes - but a lack of description in some scenes made this story sometimes difficult to visualize; there were a few parts where it didn't really feel like it was set in WWII, and I wasn't totally sure where the characters were geographically. A bit more description in these scenes would've helped not only in picturing things, but also in setting the (usually dark) mood. I do want to say, though, that the final few scenes of the book were an exception to this, as I thought those were very well described and a lot easier to picture than the rest of it.
Overall, my view is that The Stars We Hold is a very important story which needed to be told, but a few changes would've made it a better reading experience for me: namely, more description and some different choices in development for the main characters. Please don't let my mixed review of this novel put you off reading it, though, if you think it's something you might enjoy: if you like a slow-burn enemies-to-lovers romance (the enemy stage lasted too long for my liking, but if you prefer it that way then you'll love this), YA historical fiction set in a little-known place/era, and/or the found family trope (despite the issues I had with the individual characters, this trope was very well done), then do check this novel out and decide for yourself if you agree or disagree with my critique.
June 28, 2024
First and foremost, thank you to the author for the advanced copy and having me as part of the ARC team! This type of little known history is my JAM.
There's a lot to love about this book. The writing is beautiful. The history and world-building are done well, with enough info that I understand what's happening but now so much that it's overwhelming. I did find myself looking some things up as I went, but that's the beauty of historical fiction! I loved that there were words and phrases in Serbo-Croatian and that there was a pronunciation/translation guide to go along with it! For the most part, I loved the main cast of characters. Vinko especially was my favourite, a bit of comic relief, but still had his heartfelt/badass moments. Nada as a protagonist is fantastic. I love a strong-headed, tough and impulsive girl, especially when they can save themselves. I like that she messes up and has her moments, but she's still strong. Ester displayed a different kind of strength, and I loved her for it. The nurse of the group, the voice of reason at times, and Nada's biggest cheerleader. Ester had as much to gain or lose as Nada, but she went about it in her own way. Henrik was not my favourite, but other readers will love him. He's broody and tries to keep Nada at arm's length. While his development could've been more nuanced than just a 'I must push her away' 'oops I've slipped up and I must protect her but also no I must push her away again!' I think this is largely a personal preference and if you like an overprotective guy, you'll like Henrik. And by the end, he realises that Nada is tough and while she needs a partner, she doesn't need a protector, so in the end, he grew on me. It doesn't have a fully happy ending, but I do feel it's a good ending for the story. An author's note with some more of the history at the end explaining what happened afterwards would have been great, but I also love looking up what I've read in books so I'll definitely be doing my own research!!
The reason this was 4 stars is because I felt the two 'sides' of the story lacked some nuance. I understand the impulse to make the 'bad guys' purely bad/evil, and I'm not saying they weren't. But throughout history, people have joined the wrong side without fully buying into it. It's a complex issue, but sometimes people have had to join out of fear or desperation or because it was the only way to survive, but every encounter with the Ustase portray them as hate-filled, purely evil monsters. Vinko's brother was set up in a way that I thought would challenge this and add some complexity to the regime, but ultimately doesn't really delve into this. I wanted to see some nuance in the 'bad guys.' Even if it's just one of them hesitating for a moment before attacking. Even when the main characters overhear them, they're always bragging about doing the most horrible despicable thing, and I don't buy that absolutely every member of this group would be like that. People are more complicated than that, and making it solidly black-and-white, good vs bad lost some of that complexity that makes people and history so interesting. Likewise, we see the main cast of characters do some really bad things to their enemies, but they're almost always okay with it because the enemies are so clearly evil. There's a grey area that's clearly there and could have been explored more to add extra depth to both the main characters' growth and the historical context.
That being said, this is a solid YA historical. Very fast-paced and thrilling, and a quick read despite the heavy subject matter and violence.
There's a lot to love about this book. The writing is beautiful. The history and world-building are done well, with enough info that I understand what's happening but now so much that it's overwhelming. I did find myself looking some things up as I went, but that's the beauty of historical fiction! I loved that there were words and phrases in Serbo-Croatian and that there was a pronunciation/translation guide to go along with it! For the most part, I loved the main cast of characters. Vinko especially was my favourite, a bit of comic relief, but still had his heartfelt/badass moments. Nada as a protagonist is fantastic. I love a strong-headed, tough and impulsive girl, especially when they can save themselves. I like that she messes up and has her moments, but she's still strong. Ester displayed a different kind of strength, and I loved her for it. The nurse of the group, the voice of reason at times, and Nada's biggest cheerleader. Ester had as much to gain or lose as Nada, but she went about it in her own way. Henrik was not my favourite, but other readers will love him. He's broody and tries to keep Nada at arm's length. While his development could've been more nuanced than just a 'I must push her away' 'oops I've slipped up and I must protect her but also no I must push her away again!' I think this is largely a personal preference and if you like an overprotective guy, you'll like Henrik. And by the end, he realises that Nada is tough and while she needs a partner, she doesn't need a protector, so in the end, he grew on me. It doesn't have a fully happy ending, but I do feel it's a good ending for the story. An author's note with some more of the history at the end explaining what happened afterwards would have been great, but I also love looking up what I've read in books so I'll definitely be doing my own research!!
The reason this was 4 stars is because I felt the two 'sides' of the story lacked some nuance. I understand the impulse to make the 'bad guys' purely bad/evil, and I'm not saying they weren't. But throughout history, people have joined the wrong side without fully buying into it. It's a complex issue, but sometimes people have had to join out of fear or desperation or because it was the only way to survive, but every encounter with the Ustase portray them as hate-filled, purely evil monsters. Vinko's brother was set up in a way that I thought would challenge this and add some complexity to the regime, but ultimately doesn't really delve into this. I wanted to see some nuance in the 'bad guys.' Even if it's just one of them hesitating for a moment before attacking. Even when the main characters overhear them, they're always bragging about doing the most horrible despicable thing, and I don't buy that absolutely every member of this group would be like that. People are more complicated than that, and making it solidly black-and-white, good vs bad lost some of that complexity that makes people and history so interesting. Likewise, we see the main cast of characters do some really bad things to their enemies, but they're almost always okay with it because the enemies are so clearly evil. There's a grey area that's clearly there and could have been explored more to add extra depth to both the main characters' growth and the historical context.
That being said, this is a solid YA historical. Very fast-paced and thrilling, and a quick read despite the heavy subject matter and violence.
June 29, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I am in awe of this masterpiece. I’ve drafted review after review but don’t feel any of my words offer the depth of praises this book truly deserves. Melissa Armstrong’s novel The Stars We Hold is a historical romance that will rip you apart, then put you back together leaving you with a huge grin despite tears that haven’t dried.
Before I go too far in depth I want to say anyone reading this and really considering The Stars We Hold, go ahead and stop reading and just pick the book up. Trust me it’s worth it!
However if you want to know more about the what your getting yourself into with The Stars We Hold, it has all the tropes you could ask for from high tension romance of friends to enemies to lovers, cleaver and independent FMC, cold brooding but protective MMC, a sweet bestie and a lovable cinnamon roll, who despite his adorable-ness could destroy you, intense heists, fast paced action, ‘touch her and die’ vibes, friendships so deep they would do anything for each other (even if they don’t think it’s a good idea), and more!
The following oath if this review some might feel contain spoilers (nothing specific from the book will be shared, more vibes and overall thoughts) and will cover more specifics to help you make the best decision you can to pick this book up!
The writing used was seamless and engaging. The pace was perfect, jumping you right into the action, slowing down where needed (letting you gather yourself and prep for the action you know is about to come). The semi slow burn romance is FULL of tension and will leave you yelling at these two then blushing and giggling like a school girl with a crush. Henrik is definitely top material for any book boyfriend list! That being said the rest of the characters development are incredible and there won’t be anyone you don’t love! Especially Vinko, because everyone loves Vinko 😉. Melissa also does a beautiful and clear job at flashbacks giving you more glimpses of the characters pasts while never interfering with the flow of current events.
For those who it concerns, this book has the following:
- Spice: more closed door approach to the romance, while not depriving you. Scaling from a 1 being minimal kisses (comparable to hunger games) to a 5 being completely explicit with multiple scenes, I would put it at a 2.
- Language: there are a handful of swear words used, including a few F-words. But in no way excessive
- Gore: this story does take place during WWII so does have violence. There is one flashback in particular that may be disturbing for some, but given the context of the book I appreciated that the author didn’t shy too much from showing what that time truly was like for many. This aspect in particular is part of what I loved. Being told more about aspects of history I knew nothing about was a wonderful learning experience and I was grateful for it.
I had the privilege to have started following Melissa Armstrong on Instagram (@melissaarmstrongauthor) while she was still in the writing stages. I’ve seen glimpses (from what she’s shared) of her process and passion for this story. Based on real experiences from her dad, she truly seems to have poured her heart into this. I am grateful that despite any frustrations or setbacks along the way she stuck it out so I could experience this story. Writing is not always an easy thing to do but she does it so well and the world deserves what she has to offer. Honestly this book is so beautiful in so many ways and I hope you’ll pick it up and enjoy it as much as I have. Best read of 2024 and I can’t wait to keep rereading it! ❤️❤️❤️
I am in awe of this masterpiece. I’ve drafted review after review but don’t feel any of my words offer the depth of praises this book truly deserves. Melissa Armstrong’s novel The Stars We Hold is a historical romance that will rip you apart, then put you back together leaving you with a huge grin despite tears that haven’t dried.
Before I go too far in depth I want to say anyone reading this and really considering The Stars We Hold, go ahead and stop reading and just pick the book up. Trust me it’s worth it!
However if you want to know more about the what your getting yourself into with The Stars We Hold, it has all the tropes you could ask for from high tension romance of friends to enemies to lovers, cleaver and independent FMC, cold brooding but protective MMC, a sweet bestie and a lovable cinnamon roll, who despite his adorable-ness could destroy you, intense heists, fast paced action, ‘touch her and die’ vibes, friendships so deep they would do anything for each other (even if they don’t think it’s a good idea), and more!
The following oath if this review some might feel contain spoilers (nothing specific from the book will be shared, more vibes and overall thoughts) and will cover more specifics to help you make the best decision you can to pick this book up!
The writing used was seamless and engaging. The pace was perfect, jumping you right into the action, slowing down where needed (letting you gather yourself and prep for the action you know is about to come). The semi slow burn romance is FULL of tension and will leave you yelling at these two then blushing and giggling like a school girl with a crush. Henrik is definitely top material for any book boyfriend list! That being said the rest of the characters development are incredible and there won’t be anyone you don’t love! Especially Vinko, because everyone loves Vinko 😉. Melissa also does a beautiful and clear job at flashbacks giving you more glimpses of the characters pasts while never interfering with the flow of current events.
For those who it concerns, this book has the following:
- Spice: more closed door approach to the romance, while not depriving you. Scaling from a 1 being minimal kisses (comparable to hunger games) to a 5 being completely explicit with multiple scenes, I would put it at a 2.
- Language: there are a handful of swear words used, including a few F-words. But in no way excessive
- Gore: this story does take place during WWII so does have violence. There is one flashback in particular that may be disturbing for some, but given the context of the book I appreciated that the author didn’t shy too much from showing what that time truly was like for many. This aspect in particular is part of what I loved. Being told more about aspects of history I knew nothing about was a wonderful learning experience and I was grateful for it.
I had the privilege to have started following Melissa Armstrong on Instagram (@melissaarmstrongauthor) while she was still in the writing stages. I’ve seen glimpses (from what she’s shared) of her process and passion for this story. Based on real experiences from her dad, she truly seems to have poured her heart into this. I am grateful that despite any frustrations or setbacks along the way she stuck it out so I could experience this story. Writing is not always an easy thing to do but she does it so well and the world deserves what she has to offer. Honestly this book is so beautiful in so many ways and I hope you’ll pick it up and enjoy it as much as I have. Best read of 2024 and I can’t wait to keep rereading it! ❤️❤️❤️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 28, 2024
"'We all cling to something. Revenge. Compassion. Hope. Family. We need to. How else do we make it through days like this? ... What do you cling to, Henrik?' ... Henrik clung to his desperate need to keep others at arm’s length. To never be hurt by loss again... 'Sometimes we cling to the wrong things.'”✨
As someone who has a degree in History & enjoys learning about modern (WWII to present) history, I am shocked I knew nothing about this story. Mel has does an incredible job interweaving historical lessons for those of us unfamiliar with this genocide, while not making this read like a textbook. In fact, even if you aren’t a history buff or don’t read much historical fiction, you will still love this book.
Right from the start, this story takes hold of you and doesn’t let you go. Throughout this journey, you are guaranteed to laugh and cry. You will be on the edge of your seat as the suspenseful adventure carries forward while also remaining entranced by the quiet moments between the action. Mel’s atmospheric, descriptive writing will instantly teleport you directly into scenes. This is a story about perseverance, the moral tarnishing that comes with experiencing war and inhumane, evil acts, supporting family (forged by blood or friendship), finding or rediscovering love, and remaining steadfast in your strength of character, despite overwhelming odds working against you. ✨
“If Henrik decided to join her now, it would be because he wanted to be by her side in everything. He wanted to be what she needed. To have her back while she led the charge. To bolster her while she fought for her family unhindered... ‘I’ll conquer the impossible to have that with you. I mean it. I will wear myself down to the bones if it means having a life with you.’”✨
Literally from the first chapter to the final scene, you are sucked into this riveting story because there is something here for everyone. There is action, tragedy, tons of heart, slow burn tension/pining, shock, heist adventure, comedy & lessons in morality. Mel’s such a brilliant writer because nothing is wasted; every scene, every conversation adds depth and heart to the story. The emotion in this book will make you cry, clutch your heart, audibly gasp & make you swoon. I cannot recommend this masterpiece more. Just read it & transport yourself into this world, you won’t regret it.
✨
"'Don’t go. Hurt me like I hurt you... Because as long as you stay here to fight with me, I’ll still have you... Because, you have me. All of me. You always did. Always will.'”
May 29, 2024
"The Stars We Hold" by Melissa Armstrong is a breath taking and unforgettable journey through the harrowing landscape of World War II-era Yugoslavia. This extraordinary novel is much more than a historical love story; it is a vivid tapestry of resilience, loss, and the enduring power of hope. There were moments that had me laughing out loud and moments I couldn’t unsee in my mind. It moved me!
Set against the backdrop of the brutal Ustaše regime, Melissa expertly crafts the dual perspectives of Nada, a fiery and intelligent young woman, and Henrik, her childhood best friend turned lethal assassin. Their reunion amidst the chaos of war is both heart-wrenching and exhilarating, as they navigate the dangers posed by a fascist regime hell-bent on eradicating Serbians. The narrative brilliantly captures their struggle to rediscover their love, protect their families, and find their place in a world torn apart by hate.
Melissa's storytelling is reminiscent of the epic romance and historical depth found in "The Bronze Horseman," combined with the gripping intensity of "Tomorrow When the War Began." Drawing from the lived experiences of her own father, who witnessed some of the horrific atrocities committed against Jews and Serbians, Melissa infuses the novel with an authenticity and emotional depth that is both haunting and profoundly moving.
Despite the darkness of the era, "The Stars We Hold" is punctuated with moments of lightness and humour that provide much-needed relief from the overarching sorrow. These glimpses of humanity amidst the horror make the characters all the more relatable and their journey all the more compelling.
Melissa Armstrong has crafted a masterpiece that not only tells a powerful story but also honours the memories of those who suffered during one of history's darkest and less known and talked about times for those in Yugoslavia.
"The Stars We Hold" is a beautifully written, emotionally charged novel that will stay with you long after you've turned the last page. I eagerly anticipate more tales of Nada and Henrik in the future, and I am confident that readers will be as captivated by their story as I was. This is a book not to be missed.
I was fortunate enough to read this book as an ARC reader, after anticipating this book for so long, I read in over 2 sittings (why do we need sleeeeep!!) but this review is my true and honest opinion.
Tropes:
Touch her and die
Feisty FMC
Cold, but protective MMC
True accounts
Secret love
Set against the backdrop of the brutal Ustaše regime, Melissa expertly crafts the dual perspectives of Nada, a fiery and intelligent young woman, and Henrik, her childhood best friend turned lethal assassin. Their reunion amidst the chaos of war is both heart-wrenching and exhilarating, as they navigate the dangers posed by a fascist regime hell-bent on eradicating Serbians. The narrative brilliantly captures their struggle to rediscover their love, protect their families, and find their place in a world torn apart by hate.
Melissa's storytelling is reminiscent of the epic romance and historical depth found in "The Bronze Horseman," combined with the gripping intensity of "Tomorrow When the War Began." Drawing from the lived experiences of her own father, who witnessed some of the horrific atrocities committed against Jews and Serbians, Melissa infuses the novel with an authenticity and emotional depth that is both haunting and profoundly moving.
Despite the darkness of the era, "The Stars We Hold" is punctuated with moments of lightness and humour that provide much-needed relief from the overarching sorrow. These glimpses of humanity amidst the horror make the characters all the more relatable and their journey all the more compelling.
Melissa Armstrong has crafted a masterpiece that not only tells a powerful story but also honours the memories of those who suffered during one of history's darkest and less known and talked about times for those in Yugoslavia.
"The Stars We Hold" is a beautifully written, emotionally charged novel that will stay with you long after you've turned the last page. I eagerly anticipate more tales of Nada and Henrik in the future, and I am confident that readers will be as captivated by their story as I was. This is a book not to be missed.
I was fortunate enough to read this book as an ARC reader, after anticipating this book for so long, I read in over 2 sittings (why do we need sleeeeep!!) but this review is my true and honest opinion.
Tropes:
Touch her and die
Feisty FMC
Cold, but protective MMC
True accounts
Secret love
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 29, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ WOW!!! I’m really struggling to find my words right now! I was absolutely blown away by The Stars We Hold. I came across Melissa’s Instagram page some months ago and have been eagerly anticipating the release of The Stars We Hold ever since some of the first teasers of the book were dropped! What a beautiful, poignant, heart-wrenching debut novel from Melissa! First of all, this was by no means an “easy feel-good” type of book. However, I would not let that discourage anyone from picking this up and reading it immediately! The Stars We Hold is a little-known history novel based upon the author’s father’s true experiences in Yugoslavia during WWII. Growing up, I learned so much about the Nazi regime, but knew nothing about the Ustaše and the ethnic cleansing and persecution of Serbs in Croatia during this time period. Did you know that more than half a million Serbs were killed in Yugoslavia during WWII?? As I mentioned previously, the subject matter of this read is quite heavy and may not be for everyone, but I truly applaud Melissa for being able to weave these heartbreaking real-life events together with such resilient lovable characters and ALL the emotions to craft such a beautifully voiced story. There wasn’t a single part of the story that ever felt slow or that I needed to skim through. You’re thrown into the action from the very start and immediately sucked in and you better buckle up because you’re taken on a whirlwind roller coaster of emotions. This book will make you cry. And maybe cry a lot. However, it’s the kind of story that rips your heart out and makes you feel so deeply, as if you were right there living through it all and that is definitely a story worth reading for me. Nada, Henrik, Ester, & Vinko… *sigh* I don’t want to leave them yet! 🥹🤍
I would like to thank Melissa from the bottom of my heart for allowing me the opportunity to be a part of her ARC team! I truly feel honored that I was able to be among some of the very first readers to experience such a captivating story and I can’t wait for everyone else to be able to pick up this book and enjoy. 🤍
P.S. Melissa, you were right… I DO love Vinko and I think everyone else will too. 😉
I would like to thank Melissa from the bottom of my heart for allowing me the opportunity to be a part of her ARC team! I truly feel honored that I was able to be among some of the very first readers to experience such a captivating story and I can’t wait for everyone else to be able to pick up this book and enjoy. 🤍
P.S. Melissa, you were right… I DO love Vinko and I think everyone else will too. 😉
May 29, 2024
If you are looking for a book with nonstop action, bold MCs, swoony moments, that will hold your heart captive in your throat until you finish the last page, let me recommend this one!
Based on true events by the author's father, we learn the heartbreaking and inspirational story of Yugoslavia's own horrifying genocide during a time when the world was focused instead on the Nazi party.
Told in turns by Nada, a 17yo Serbian youth whose family has been sent to a concentration camp, and her childhood friend/sweetheart, Henrik, who is a fighting member of the resistance, the reader is tossed straight into the action, with well-timed flashbacks filling in the blanks of our MCs' timelines and relationship.
Cinematic in its storytelling (I could easily see this as a movie), we are moved along at a brisk pace, broken by brief, intimate moments where the slow-burn is bested only by the will-they/won't-they as our two [fantastically developed] MCs' stubbornness wages a battle of willpower.
Supported by wonderful side characters and truly villainous baddies, Amstrong does not shy away from the brutality of the Ustase's tortuous ways or their little regard for human life. The violence is graphic but its use is carefully intentional as the story progresses and we learn more about the atrocities and horrors befallen to the abducted Serbians from Nada and Henrik's village. (Check for TW.)
Overall, I was completely blown away by this book and the writing. It had me biting my nails and laughing, then tearing up and holding my breath, all within the space of a few pages. With never a lag in the storytelling, quick, witty dialogue and believable emotions, I was fully immersed in this story from beginning to end. I would say it felt a bit like Divine Rivals - in the way that it's a love story told during wartime - but truly this book is its own gem and I am so grateful to the author for letting me join the ARC team.
⭐️ Childhood friends to enemies to lovers
⭐️ Little-known history
⭐️ Heists
⭐️ “Touch her and die”
⭐��� Action and badassery
⭐️ Fiery, clever, determined FMC
⭐️ Badass, cold but protective MMC
⭐️ True accounts
⭐️ Secret love
Based on true events by the author's father, we learn the heartbreaking and inspirational story of Yugoslavia's own horrifying genocide during a time when the world was focused instead on the Nazi party.
Told in turns by Nada, a 17yo Serbian youth whose family has been sent to a concentration camp, and her childhood friend/sweetheart, Henrik, who is a fighting member of the resistance, the reader is tossed straight into the action, with well-timed flashbacks filling in the blanks of our MCs' timelines and relationship.
Cinematic in its storytelling (I could easily see this as a movie), we are moved along at a brisk pace, broken by brief, intimate moments where the slow-burn is bested only by the will-they/won't-they as our two [fantastically developed] MCs' stubbornness wages a battle of willpower.
Supported by wonderful side characters and truly villainous baddies, Amstrong does not shy away from the brutality of the Ustase's tortuous ways or their little regard for human life. The violence is graphic but its use is carefully intentional as the story progresses and we learn more about the atrocities and horrors befallen to the abducted Serbians from Nada and Henrik's village. (Check for TW.)
Overall, I was completely blown away by this book and the writing. It had me biting my nails and laughing, then tearing up and holding my breath, all within the space of a few pages. With never a lag in the storytelling, quick, witty dialogue and believable emotions, I was fully immersed in this story from beginning to end. I would say it felt a bit like Divine Rivals - in the way that it's a love story told during wartime - but truly this book is its own gem and I am so grateful to the author for letting me join the ARC team.
⭐️ Childhood friends to enemies to lovers
⭐️ Little-known history
⭐️ Heists
⭐️ “Touch her and die”
⭐��� Action and badassery
⭐️ Fiery, clever, determined FMC
⭐️ Badass, cold but protective MMC
⭐️ True accounts
⭐️ Secret love
June 22, 2024
Firstly thank you Melissa Armstrong for picking me to receive and ARC!!
I would like to just give a warning first. Not a bad warning just that this is a heavy book to read it’s set during World War II and deals with a party called the Ustaše, who have been described similar to the Nazis. So if this is a sensitive subject I just wants for fine a heads up. With that being said the way I would describe this book is that it was tragically beautiful. You follow Nada, the FMC, and Henrik, the MMC, on their efforts and experiences through trying to save the lives of Nada‘s family.
The FMC, Nada, is a fierce strong willed headstrong woman. When she puts her mind to something she follows through with it. Sometimes that can cause her to be brash and not always think everything through but it is also what keeps her going throughout the book. Her dedication to getting her family back and drive to do what she knows is right no matter the cost are inspiring.
Henrik, the MMC, is more of a calculating character. Where Nada is head strong and rushes into places or scenarios, Henrik takes his time and calculates what possible outcomes at occur. He is the eye of the storm that is Nada. They compliment each other.
The romance is the story was friends to lovers that was slow burn and the slow burn was sooo good. There were times where I wanted to yell at the characters to just get over themselves and get together but the way it all happened and came to a head was perfect 🫠 and the plot was inspiring. It’s not they my typical type of book to read and was an eye opener. The side characters in the book were amazing too and they brought other aspects to this heavy read I would describe one as compassion and the other as comedic relief which definitely helped when reading a book dealing with such dark subjects.
Overall I LOVED the book! I felt like I learned more about a subject I knew very little about and it made me appreciate what I have. If you are looking for a book that is a historical fiction romance and are interesting in World War II or are looking for an inspiring tale about bravery, love and unbreakable will when faced against unspeakable horrors then this is a book you won’t want to miss.
I would like to just give a warning first. Not a bad warning just that this is a heavy book to read it’s set during World War II and deals with a party called the Ustaše, who have been described similar to the Nazis. So if this is a sensitive subject I just wants for fine a heads up. With that being said the way I would describe this book is that it was tragically beautiful. You follow Nada, the FMC, and Henrik, the MMC, on their efforts and experiences through trying to save the lives of Nada‘s family.
The FMC, Nada, is a fierce strong willed headstrong woman. When she puts her mind to something she follows through with it. Sometimes that can cause her to be brash and not always think everything through but it is also what keeps her going throughout the book. Her dedication to getting her family back and drive to do what she knows is right no matter the cost are inspiring.
Henrik, the MMC, is more of a calculating character. Where Nada is head strong and rushes into places or scenarios, Henrik takes his time and calculates what possible outcomes at occur. He is the eye of the storm that is Nada. They compliment each other.
The romance is the story was friends to lovers that was slow burn and the slow burn was sooo good. There were times where I wanted to yell at the characters to just get over themselves and get together but the way it all happened and came to a head was perfect 🫠 and the plot was inspiring. It’s not they my typical type of book to read and was an eye opener. The side characters in the book were amazing too and they brought other aspects to this heavy read I would describe one as compassion and the other as comedic relief which definitely helped when reading a book dealing with such dark subjects.
Overall I LOVED the book! I felt like I learned more about a subject I knew very little about and it made me appreciate what I have. If you are looking for a book that is a historical fiction romance and are interesting in World War II or are looking for an inspiring tale about bravery, love and unbreakable will when faced against unspeakable horrors then this is a book you won’t want to miss.
June 27, 2024
I was honored to be selected as an ARC reader for this stunning novel. Melissa Armstrong is a master storyteller equal to NYT Bestselling historical fiction novelist Ruta Sepetys.
It was everything a WWII historical fiction novel should be: gritty, raw, and profoundly human. It depicted the real cruelties humans inflicted upon other humans without making them tastelessly gory. It struck that important balance many lesser authors disingenuously beautify or unnecessarily describe.
I loved all the plot twists. Just when you think things are bad—they get worse. Just when you think you know what will happen next—you don’t.
Themes:
There were so many rich themes in this book. The common enemies to lovers trope didn’t feel forced, but actually proved an important point: we often judge what we see on the outside when we have no idea what’s actually on the inside. And also, we often let our disappointment in who we think others should be stop us from seeing who they actually are.
I’m not even sure if this was the author’s intention, or if I was just me reading into it too much but every now and then a description would note the red star on Hendricks hat. Other Partizan wore similar hats but it was usually Hendricks star that was noted. You start to think of the star (a little) as symbolic of him.
Meanwhile, Nada clings to Hendrick’s lost button like one would cling to a lifeline, believing that as long as she has it, she is safe, or he is safe. But in many ways she was holding onto him, Hendrick (the star wearer) in her heart for two years; loving him, praying for him, never forgetting him. Stars also symbolize light—little bits of hope in all the darkness of the night (war) that guide us home.
Spice Rating:
There is one open-door scene. Although descriptive and reaching my upper echelon of comfortability for YA, the wording focused more on the emotional side of intimacy rather than the explicit.
The Stars We Hold releases June 28th—tomorrow!!!
Follow @melissaarmstrongauthor for all the links to buy this beautiful book.
It was everything a WWII historical fiction novel should be: gritty, raw, and profoundly human. It depicted the real cruelties humans inflicted upon other humans without making them tastelessly gory. It struck that important balance many lesser authors disingenuously beautify or unnecessarily describe.
I loved all the plot twists. Just when you think things are bad—they get worse. Just when you think you know what will happen next—you don’t.
Themes:
There were so many rich themes in this book. The common enemies to lovers trope didn’t feel forced, but actually proved an important point: we often judge what we see on the outside when we have no idea what’s actually on the inside. And also, we often let our disappointment in who we think others should be stop us from seeing who they actually are.
I’m not even sure if this was the author’s intention, or if I was just me reading into it too much but every now and then a description would note the red star on Hendricks hat. Other Partizan wore similar hats but it was usually Hendricks star that was noted. You start to think of the star (a little) as symbolic of him.
Meanwhile, Nada clings to Hendrick’s lost button like one would cling to a lifeline, believing that as long as she has it, she is safe, or he is safe. But in many ways she was holding onto him, Hendrick (the star wearer) in her heart for two years; loving him, praying for him, never forgetting him. Stars also symbolize light—little bits of hope in all the darkness of the night (war) that guide us home.
Spice Rating:
There is one open-door scene. Although descriptive and reaching my upper echelon of comfortability for YA, the wording focused more on the emotional side of intimacy rather than the explicit.
The Stars We Hold releases June 28th—tomorrow!!!
Follow @melissaarmstrongauthor for all the links to buy this beautiful book.
June 28, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 4.5/5 stars
Explore this little-known part of history in Yugoslavia during WWII. With war, there is always destruction and loss. War takes and takes, but Nada had enough taken from her already. She will not stand by as the Croatian Fascist movement takes the remainder of her family to a death camp and eventually to their impending doom. Determined, Nada and Ester set out on a mission to rescue their families & face the force of the Croatian regime. Perfect for the fans of Divine Rivals & The Book Thief, this historical fiction novel will pull at your heartstrings and make you feel hope amongst the destruction and despair.
This book wrecked me in more ways than one. With its beautiful prose to its loving characters, I loved this book from start to finish. The immersive and detailed storyline kept me invested the whole way through. I felt as if I was there experiencing all the heartbreak, all the pain, and all the beauty right beside Nada.
The cast of characters were funny and loveable. Vinko brings jest and humor to the group. The way that Nada and Vinko have this sibling dynamic when it comes to their humor. It fills my heart with so much joy every time. Then, there’s Nada and Ester's friendship which are total goals. They will do anything for each other! I am here for it!
The romance!!! My heart utterly melted! The push and the pull between Nada and Henrik were swoon-worthy. They are so adorable together, and I couldn’t help rooting for them the whole time. Henrick is the perfect man who is overly protective of Nada. A new fictional boyfriend for sure!
The Stars We Hold is a must-read for its heartbreakingly beautiful story within its pages.
HUGE thank you @melissaarmstrongauthor for sending me this ARC! Eternally grateful 🥹
Read if you like:
-Childhood friends to enemies to lovers
-Slow burn
-Little-known history
-forced proximity
-Touch her and unalive
-Action and badassery
-Fiery, clever, determined FMC
-Badass, cold but protective MMC
-True accounts
Explore this little-known part of history in Yugoslavia during WWII. With war, there is always destruction and loss. War takes and takes, but Nada had enough taken from her already. She will not stand by as the Croatian Fascist movement takes the remainder of her family to a death camp and eventually to their impending doom. Determined, Nada and Ester set out on a mission to rescue their families & face the force of the Croatian regime. Perfect for the fans of Divine Rivals & The Book Thief, this historical fiction novel will pull at your heartstrings and make you feel hope amongst the destruction and despair.
This book wrecked me in more ways than one. With its beautiful prose to its loving characters, I loved this book from start to finish. The immersive and detailed storyline kept me invested the whole way through. I felt as if I was there experiencing all the heartbreak, all the pain, and all the beauty right beside Nada.
The cast of characters were funny and loveable. Vinko brings jest and humor to the group. The way that Nada and Vinko have this sibling dynamic when it comes to their humor. It fills my heart with so much joy every time. Then, there’s Nada and Ester's friendship which are total goals. They will do anything for each other! I am here for it!
The romance!!! My heart utterly melted! The push and the pull between Nada and Henrik were swoon-worthy. They are so adorable together, and I couldn’t help rooting for them the whole time. Henrick is the perfect man who is overly protective of Nada. A new fictional boyfriend for sure!
The Stars We Hold is a must-read for its heartbreakingly beautiful story within its pages.
HUGE thank you @melissaarmstrongauthor for sending me this ARC! Eternally grateful 🥹
Read if you like:
-Childhood friends to enemies to lovers
-Slow burn
-Little-known history
-forced proximity
-Touch her and unalive
-Action and badassery
-Fiery, clever, determined FMC
-Badass, cold but protective MMC
-True accounts
May 28, 2024
Thank you to Melissa Armstrong for selecting me to be a member of the ARC team! I am honored to have received an early copy of your debut novel in exchange for an honest review.
𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘚𝘵𝘢𝘳𝘴 𝘞𝘦 𝘏𝘰𝘭𝘥 is captivating from the very first page! Armstrong has a way of pulling you right into the story and immersing you in a world most only know through childhood textbooks. It's packed with heart-pounding action and follows a strong FMC, Nada, and protective MMC, Henrik, as they embark on a daring quest to save her doomed family members. This YA historical fiction novel explores lesser-known WWII history and features true accounts from the war. It has it all - loyal friendships and strong familial bonds, grief and guilt and heavy scenes. I binged this in a weekend, unable to stop saying "just one more chapter".
It's simple yet complex and is so real that it feels incredibly intimate to the reader. It's like you're really there, fearful yet determined, fighting alongside Nada. Terrified for your friends and family, neighbors and community. Exhausted yet unwilling to give up. Full of doubt yet optimistic and through being underestimated. I quickly connected with Nada as she faced guilt, anger, and fear head-on with a fierce courage. I understood Henrik's internal conflict, but I couldn't wait for him to work through his own fears and open his heart to Nada. Their friendship was touching to witness, and their romance developed beautifully in contrast to such a dark time of war. I enjoyed the fast-paced plot, historical setting, and tender romance Armstrong masterfully crafted. After reading this, I'm eager for more war stories inspired by true accounts!
If you are a fan of 𝘋𝘪𝘷𝘪𝘯𝘦 𝘙𝘪𝘷𝘢𝘭𝘴 or 𝘓𝘰𝘷𝘦𝘭𝘺 𝘞𝘢𝘳, I think this story would appeal to you! It hits shelves June 28, so be sure to grab a copy!
𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘚𝘵𝘢𝘳𝘴 𝘞𝘦 𝘏𝘰𝘭𝘥 is captivating from the very first page! Armstrong has a way of pulling you right into the story and immersing you in a world most only know through childhood textbooks. It's packed with heart-pounding action and follows a strong FMC, Nada, and protective MMC, Henrik, as they embark on a daring quest to save her doomed family members. This YA historical fiction novel explores lesser-known WWII history and features true accounts from the war. It has it all - loyal friendships and strong familial bonds, grief and guilt and heavy scenes. I binged this in a weekend, unable to stop saying "just one more chapter".
It's simple yet complex and is so real that it feels incredibly intimate to the reader. It's like you're really there, fearful yet determined, fighting alongside Nada. Terrified for your friends and family, neighbors and community. Exhausted yet unwilling to give up. Full of doubt yet optimistic and through being underestimated. I quickly connected with Nada as she faced guilt, anger, and fear head-on with a fierce courage. I understood Henrik's internal conflict, but I couldn't wait for him to work through his own fears and open his heart to Nada. Their friendship was touching to witness, and their romance developed beautifully in contrast to such a dark time of war. I enjoyed the fast-paced plot, historical setting, and tender romance Armstrong masterfully crafted. After reading this, I'm eager for more war stories inspired by true accounts!
If you are a fan of 𝘋𝘪𝘷𝘪𝘯𝘦 𝘙𝘪𝘷𝘢𝘭𝘴 or 𝘓𝘰𝘷𝘦𝘭𝘺 𝘞𝘢𝘳, I think this story would appeal to you! It hits shelves June 28, so be sure to grab a copy!
June 26, 2024
The Stars We Hold is a deeply tragic but beautiful work of historical fiction that takes you on the ultimate coming of age, good versus evil adventure with the most amazing characters of friends and family.
“Nada’s heartbeat knocked harder against her ribs and the air around her thinned. Her eyes prickled with the threat of tears as her chest began to heave. No, not now. She needed to calm down. What was wrong with her?”
Nada, our female main character, is unfortunately in the middle of a war where one side hates her and her family just for being themselves. Reading her experiences is made all the more difficult knowing these experiences are things based on true events, but what makes all the heart wrenching moments worth it, is seeing who Nada is at her core. She’s full of life and loves whole heartedly. We see her fight and push forward, and even when she thinks about giving up, she leans on those who will hold her up, and it’s beautiful.
“He vowed a long time ago to never put himself in the position to feel heartache again. And yet here he was, drowning in it. A slow torture of his own making.”
Henrick, our male main character, is the boy forced into manhood, and the man who sacrifices for the greater good, and for those he loves. We see him struggle with living through the traumas of war and how he guards his heart from the pain of loss. I love the growth we see when Henrick finally realizes what he’s been holding on to is more toxic and more painful than opening his heart and holding on to love.
We wouldn’t have this incredible love story, without the help of our adorable and wonderful side characters, Ester and Vinko. Both with their own difficulties and troubles because of the war, they still stand by their friends through it all and they help bring together and complete this story.
I won’t be letting go of this story anytime soon! 💖
“Nada’s heartbeat knocked harder against her ribs and the air around her thinned. Her eyes prickled with the threat of tears as her chest began to heave. No, not now. She needed to calm down. What was wrong with her?”
Nada, our female main character, is unfortunately in the middle of a war where one side hates her and her family just for being themselves. Reading her experiences is made all the more difficult knowing these experiences are things based on true events, but what makes all the heart wrenching moments worth it, is seeing who Nada is at her core. She’s full of life and loves whole heartedly. We see her fight and push forward, and even when she thinks about giving up, she leans on those who will hold her up, and it’s beautiful.
“He vowed a long time ago to never put himself in the position to feel heartache again. And yet here he was, drowning in it. A slow torture of his own making.”
Henrick, our male main character, is the boy forced into manhood, and the man who sacrifices for the greater good, and for those he loves. We see him struggle with living through the traumas of war and how he guards his heart from the pain of loss. I love the growth we see when Henrick finally realizes what he’s been holding on to is more toxic and more painful than opening his heart and holding on to love.
We wouldn’t have this incredible love story, without the help of our adorable and wonderful side characters, Ester and Vinko. Both with their own difficulties and troubles because of the war, they still stand by their friends through it all and they help bring together and complete this story.
I won’t be letting go of this story anytime soon! 💖
June 13, 2024
✨ARC REVIEW✨
Title: The Stars We Hold
Author: Melissa Armstrong
Genre: Historical
Format: ebook (arc)
✨ 5/5
‘Nada gazed up at him. Humour gleamed in her eyes, and softness coloured his. Something profound settled inside her. Quietened. There he was. Her Henrik.’
An interesting and thrilling read giving an insight into a lesser known/publicised aspect of WW2. Historical fiction and romance rolled into one The Stars We Hold is captivating and action packed and sucks you from the start.
The book was well written, perfectly paced. I enjoyed the incorporation of words in the characters native language - with the added bonus of their translations at the start of the book - this helped give the character and the plot a feeling of authenticity appropriate for a book based on true events.
The characters were perfect - I felt a connection to each of them through the way they were portrayed - frustrated by Henrik, proud of Nada, sympathy for Ester and I simply loved Vinko. I cried when they cried and celebrated their successes.
An emotional roller coaster and without a doubt one of my favourite reads of the year - I was so excited to read this book and it definitely didn’t disappoint! I’m excited to see what the author produces next!
Thank you to the author for having me along on her arc team. The eARC was provided in exchange for an honest review.
Title: The Stars We Hold
Author: Melissa Armstrong
Genre: Historical
Format: ebook (arc)
✨ 5/5
‘Nada gazed up at him. Humour gleamed in her eyes, and softness coloured his. Something profound settled inside her. Quietened. There he was. Her Henrik.’
An interesting and thrilling read giving an insight into a lesser known/publicised aspect of WW2. Historical fiction and romance rolled into one The Stars We Hold is captivating and action packed and sucks you from the start.
The book was well written, perfectly paced. I enjoyed the incorporation of words in the characters native language - with the added bonus of their translations at the start of the book - this helped give the character and the plot a feeling of authenticity appropriate for a book based on true events.
The characters were perfect - I felt a connection to each of them through the way they were portrayed - frustrated by Henrik, proud of Nada, sympathy for Ester and I simply loved Vinko. I cried when they cried and celebrated their successes.
An emotional roller coaster and without a doubt one of my favourite reads of the year - I was so excited to read this book and it definitely didn’t disappoint! I’m excited to see what the author produces next!
Thank you to the author for having me along on her arc team. The eARC was provided in exchange for an honest review.
June 27, 2024
The Stars We Hold
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“I can’t lose anymore people I love. I can’t” (I cried😭)
Oh! Nada, & Henrik 😭 This was a BEAUTIFUL action packed WW2 story! back when @melissaarmstrongauthor had introduced TSWH i was IMMEDIATELY interested. I grew up watching movies on WW2 and being a history lover this was right up my alley.
I cried a lot through out this book. Nada having to risk her own life to save her family from the Ustaše was just an INSANE mission!! I was at the EDGE of my seat!
I kept thinking this story reminded me a lot of my favorite WW2 film — Saving Private Ryan — it has similar elements through out and i thought that was fantastic! and kept me interested!
This story really captures a lot of Nadas bravery! and I really love a tough as nails FMC. She discovers not only will she do whatever it takes to fave her family. Henrik too will do anything to save her….
“You said I left when you needed me most. I won’t do that again — Henrik
Nada Not being able to save everyone really resonated with me. I SOBBED some more, it was so sad , i knew she wanted to save everyone but it’s not always like that…..
“But you could always rise up and defeat them” 😉⭐️
OUTSTANDING JOB!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“I can’t lose anymore people I love. I can’t” (I cried😭)
Oh! Nada, & Henrik 😭 This was a BEAUTIFUL action packed WW2 story! back when @melissaarmstrongauthor had introduced TSWH i was IMMEDIATELY interested. I grew up watching movies on WW2 and being a history lover this was right up my alley.
I cried a lot through out this book. Nada having to risk her own life to save her family from the Ustaše was just an INSANE mission!! I was at the EDGE of my seat!
I kept thinking this story reminded me a lot of my favorite WW2 film — Saving Private Ryan — it has similar elements through out and i thought that was fantastic! and kept me interested!
This story really captures a lot of Nadas bravery! and I really love a tough as nails FMC. She discovers not only will she do whatever it takes to fave her family. Henrik too will do anything to save her….
“You said I left when you needed me most. I won’t do that again — Henrik
Nada Not being able to save everyone really resonated with me. I SOBBED some more, it was so sad , i knew she wanted to save everyone but it’s not always like that…..
“But you could always rise up and defeat them” 😉⭐️
OUTSTANDING JOB!
June 29, 2024
✨ARC REVIEW✨
Thank you to Melissa Armstrong for selecting me to be a member of the ARC team! I loved this book from the very first chapter.
“The Stars We Hold” is a little-known YA history novel that features the true accounts of the author’s father in Yugoslavia during WWII. I remember watching Schindler’s List as a teenager and the impact it had on me at the time. I had no idea that Yugoslavia experienced its own genocide from a Croatian regime called the Ustase and that their main goal was to eliminate Serbs. Thank you to Melissa Armstrong for bringing this to light.
It’s an emotional rollercoaster from the very first chapter all the way to the end. It is so well written and the attention to detail was so beautifully done it felt like I was experiencing the action and heartbreak right alongside the main characters. The slow burn was great and felt not over the top or unrealistic, considering they are literally fighting to survive.
This debut novel had all the feels and I’m so grateful to have been selected as part of the Arc team. Thank you again.
Check it out if you enjoy:
YA historical novel
Childhood friends to enemies to lovers
True accounts
Slow burn
Touch her and die
High stakes
Action packed
Thank you to Melissa Armstrong for selecting me to be a member of the ARC team! I loved this book from the very first chapter.
“The Stars We Hold” is a little-known YA history novel that features the true accounts of the author’s father in Yugoslavia during WWII. I remember watching Schindler’s List as a teenager and the impact it had on me at the time. I had no idea that Yugoslavia experienced its own genocide from a Croatian regime called the Ustase and that their main goal was to eliminate Serbs. Thank you to Melissa Armstrong for bringing this to light.
It’s an emotional rollercoaster from the very first chapter all the way to the end. It is so well written and the attention to detail was so beautifully done it felt like I was experiencing the action and heartbreak right alongside the main characters. The slow burn was great and felt not over the top or unrealistic, considering they are literally fighting to survive.
This debut novel had all the feels and I’m so grateful to have been selected as part of the Arc team. Thank you again.
Check it out if you enjoy:
YA historical novel
Childhood friends to enemies to lovers
True accounts
Slow burn
Touch her and die
High stakes
Action packed
June 24, 2024
My emotions are left in tatters.
The Stars We Hold is a beautiful tribute to the human heart and its resilience in the face of evil. Written with care, this vividly descriptive story captures your heart from the first page. I struggled because I didn’t want to put it down, but I didn’t want it to end. Not shying away from the ugliness of war, Melissa Armstrong paints a heart wrenching picture that will stay with you.
Nada has a strength and stubborn determination that you can’t help but admire. She’s been through hell and continues to walk through the fire for those she loves. Henrik is cold and closed off, and as you work through his and Nada’s memories it becomes clear why. Their past is delicately woven throughout the story; which I found deeply moving and at times made me cry. I can’t think of any part in this story that wasn’t done perfectly.
Filled with page turning action and a love that endures through the darkest of evil.
This is easily one of my top reads for the year. Don’t miss out on this one.
P.S- Everybody DOES love Vinko.
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
Thank you Melissa Armstrong for the beautiful PR Box, and sending me an eArc. My opinions are honest, and my own.
The Stars We Hold is a beautiful tribute to the human heart and its resilience in the face of evil. Written with care, this vividly descriptive story captures your heart from the first page. I struggled because I didn’t want to put it down, but I didn’t want it to end. Not shying away from the ugliness of war, Melissa Armstrong paints a heart wrenching picture that will stay with you.
Nada has a strength and stubborn determination that you can’t help but admire. She’s been through hell and continues to walk through the fire for those she loves. Henrik is cold and closed off, and as you work through his and Nada’s memories it becomes clear why. Their past is delicately woven throughout the story; which I found deeply moving and at times made me cry. I can’t think of any part in this story that wasn’t done perfectly.
Filled with page turning action and a love that endures through the darkest of evil.
This is easily one of my top reads for the year. Don’t miss out on this one.
P.S- Everybody DOES love Vinko.
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
Thank you Melissa Armstrong for the beautiful PR Box, and sending me an eArc. My opinions are honest, and my own.
June 3, 2024
I was honored to be part of the ARC team for this. Thank you Melissa!
The Stars We Hold is an amazing debut. One that is raw, unforgiving, and romantic. I am stunned this is the author's first book, but following her insta it has been a labor of love for a while.
Our lead watched her family be taken. She along with her friend decide to join up with the resistance army that could lead her to them. The same resistance army that her friend and crush has been a part of for the past year or so.
He has changed - physically and by war. At the sight of her and her friend, he finds himself not wanting her to see. He also does not want her to get injured on his watch - since she has no skills when it comes to a gun or use of a knife / dagger. She is a quick learner which shushes him up.
It's a journey and there is a revenge tale in that as well. Our female lead is after the man who frightened her and also harmed others. She is after him. She wants to kill him.
I read a lot of books that have to do with war and romance, with a YA / teen angle. This one is the first one that felt real, authentic. The author was emboldened by the stories of a personal relation in the war to write this.
I really hope that if you are looking for a book that does not shy away from the grittiness of war you choose this when it releases. There is a great female protagonist, a great male love interest, and a desire to see her family again.
The Stars We Hold is an amazing debut. One that is raw, unforgiving, and romantic. I am stunned this is the author's first book, but following her insta it has been a labor of love for a while.
Our lead watched her family be taken. She along with her friend decide to join up with the resistance army that could lead her to them. The same resistance army that her friend and crush has been a part of for the past year or so.
He has changed - physically and by war. At the sight of her and her friend, he finds himself not wanting her to see. He also does not want her to get injured on his watch - since she has no skills when it comes to a gun or use of a knife / dagger. She is a quick learner which shushes him up.
It's a journey and there is a revenge tale in that as well. Our female lead is after the man who frightened her and also harmed others. She is after him. She wants to kill him.
I read a lot of books that have to do with war and romance, with a YA / teen angle. This one is the first one that felt real, authentic. The author was emboldened by the stories of a personal relation in the war to write this.
I really hope that if you are looking for a book that does not shy away from the grittiness of war you choose this when it releases. There is a great female protagonist, a great male love interest, and a desire to see her family again.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews