Skip to Content

We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article.

ELLE Edit: The Ultimate Guide To The Best Mascaras Of All Time

From clever tubing formulas to the most innovative, effective wands, these are the mascaras everyone should try

By
best mascarapinterest
Elle UK

If you asked the ELLE UK beauty team for our desert island beauty picks, you'd be prying multiple mascaras from our tightly gripped hands. There's a reason its the product we reach for first thing each morning, and often the only thing you'll see us wearing on an early Monday morning. Wider-looking eyes and fluttery lashes? Sign us up.

Luckily for us, big, bold lashes stormed the SS24 runways from Simone Rocha to AZ Factory, with a full spectrum of dainty to OTT looks making a case for a well overdue mascara update.

So, where to look first? Of course, every brand under the sun has a hero mascara these days, and there's something to satisfy every single demand. Perhaps you're a super-natural kind of girl, who wants little more than a touch of barely there colour and lift, or maybe you don't feel quite ready for the day without a full-impact statement lash, loaded up with lashings of ultra-black pigment. Longevity ranks high in many people's list of priorities, while others veer towards bright blues and pinks for a punkish twist.

Whatever your predilection, we know just the mascara for you. From the cult classics to the latest lash innovations (hello, tubing mascaras), we've rounded up the best mascaras of all time: and believe us, we've tried every last one.

The ELLE UK Guide To The Best Mascaras Ever

1
Best volumising mascara

Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Universal Volumising Mascara

Perfect Strokes Universal Volumising Mascara
£21 at Sephora

This mousse-like formula envelops your lashes in a deep black colour, giving the illusion of a fuller flutter without any of that dreaded cakeyness. If you're looking to give lacklustre lashes a boost of volume (and skip the clumpiness typically associated with thicker mascaras), this is the fluffy formula we'd recommend.

2
Best mascara for length and lift

Refy Lash Sculpt Mascara

Lash Sculpt Mascara

Now this one might look slightly frightening – especially for anyone with a tendency to poke themselves in the eye when wielding a wand – but appearances can be deceiving. In fact, Refy Lash Sculpt is the strangely effective mascara we didn't know we needed: the curved brush is designed to slip snugly around the curve of your eyelid, allowing you to grab and lift every lash lash in one fell swoop. The result is a neat, clean and perfectly defined set of lashes that look slick and super-natural.

3
Best volumising mascara

Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Mascara

Lash Clash Mascara
Now 25% Off

Lengthening, volumising and totally clump-free, this XL mascara brush has been making the rounds on the ELLE UK beauty team. Famed for giving nothing but fluttery, extension-like lashes, this is the ideal mascara for fans of a big applicator and even bigger results.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
4
Best waterproof mascara

MAC MacStack Waterproof Mascara

MAC MacStack Waterproof Mascara

While some waterproof mascaras can feel overly drying and crumble away mid-day, Mac's glossy formula has got your back. It'll add major length that lasts and lasts, whether you're stuck on a humid commute or watching Netflix's latest tear-jerker.

5
Best luxury mascara

Chanel Noir Allure Mascara

Noir Allure Mascara

Looking for bold but defined lashes? This slim, flexible brush makes short work of catching every single lash as you apply. Housed in sleek, click-in packaging that screams quiet luxury, here you'll find a formula that both delivers longer results and looks chic in your make-up bag.

6
Best mascara for definition

Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara

Limitless Lash Mascara

If your current mascara has commitment issues and makes a smudging attempt to leave your lashes mid-way through the day, let us introduce you to this reliably flake-free formula. With a nifty comb for definition and separation, it gives your lashes a natural lift without ever looking clumpy.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7
Best blue mascara

Dior Diorshow Pump 'N' Volume Mascara

Dior Diorshow Pump 'N' Volume Mascara

Blue mascara is back in a big way this season: a flash of electric cobalt is the perfect way to refresh your beauty look with minimal effort. Swipe Dior's pigment-packed formula through curled lashes, leaving the rest of your make-up light and luminous for the most modern result.

8
Best tubing mascara

Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara

Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara

While eyelash extensions are a great time-saver, getting them too often can sometimes damage your lashes and leave them worse off than what you started with.

For the closest thing to lash extensions in a bottle, try a tubing mascara. Our all-time favourite is Hourglass' Unlocked mascara, which wraps around each individual lash to leave a glossy, vinyl-like coat that lasts all day without smudging. And the very best bit? Removing it couldn't be easier: just add water and the 'tubes' will simply fall away.

9
Best coloured mascara

Hermès Trait d'Hermès Mascara

Hermès Trait d'Hermès Mascara

If anyone can convince us that coloured mascara is a seriously chic move, it's Hermès. The most recent addition to the brand's sublime make-up collection, these slender golden wands come in a spectrum of deep, elegant colours, from a rich burgundy (incredible with a wash of gold eyeshadow) to a rebellious forest-green. The wand is slender and the formula predictably sophisticated, offering lift and length without the bulky weight.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
10
Best fibre mascara

Maybelline The Falsies Surreal Mascara

The Falsies Surreal Mascara

Everyday falsies wearers will know that no mascara can match the impact of a faux set of lashes, but this formula comes pretty close. Its helix shaped brush means that no lash is left behind and your eyelashes look thick and voluminous thanks to the lash-extending fibres inside.

11
Best thickening mascara

Fenty Beauty Hella Thicc Volumizing Mascara

Hella Thicc Volumizing Mascara

Thickening formulas can often be tricky; the wrong move and you're left with a smudgy imprint, the wrong formula and you're left with an avant-garde, racoon-resembling eye look by midday. This fluffing formula guarantees neither, only maximally full lashes that are both thick and lengthened all day long.

12
Best natural mascara

Glossier Lash Slick

Lash Slick

The ultimate day time mascara, one application of Glossier's Lash Slick gives satisfyingly fanned out, clump-free, barely-there lashes. What's more. you can layer and layer this au natural formula for a false lash effect without the glue or the effort.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13
Best false-lash effect mascara

Benefit Bad Gal Bang Volumising Mascara

Bad Gal Bang Volumising Mascara

Our history with Benefit's cult mascaras is a lengthy one; first it was the iconic They’re Real, followed by the definition-boosting Rollerlash and now, its ultra-voluminous and maximalist Bad Gal Bang. This deceivingly skinny brush gives you all-in thickness, drama and lift all in one formula, never failing to deliver that faux lash look.

14
Best fluffy mascara

Victoria Beckham Beauty Future Lash Mascara

Future Lash Mascara

Bestowing the gift of 'your lashes but better', we present Victoria Beckham's Future Lash. The uber-thin brush will win over those who favour precision with their mascara, and a couple of coats will leave you with glossy, natural but defined lashes. It's not just called Future Lash for the fun of it either: the formula is enriched VB's C2 complex which conditions your eyelashes and improves them over time for stronger, healthier, future lashes. Geddit?

15
Best curling mascara

Lancôme Lash Idôle Mascara

Lash Idôle Mascara

It's not often you can get the ELLE beauty team to agree on their favourite beauty product, but it turns out this was the mascara to unite us all. Its curved tapered wand allows you to get right into the corners, picking up lash hairs we didn't even know we had, and it's curl-holding ability is truly something to behold.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
16
Best high-street mascara

L'Oreal Paris Telescopic Lift Mascara

L'Oreal Paris Telescopic Lift Mascara

High-street beauty brands often lead the way when it comes to industry innovation, but this is especially true of the mascara category. Easily as good as the most pricy prestige options, L'Oreal's Telescopic Lift mascara has gone viral for good reason: it lifts and lengthens remarkably well, and stays put all day long. Tick!

17
Best brown mascara

Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes

Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes

If fluttery, flirty lashes are what you're after, Charlotte Tilbury's Pillow Talk mascara lengthens lashes to their fullest and defines with a jet black coating. Not a fan of that ultra noir drama? Opt for its newest Pillow Talk shade, a berry-brown hue perfect for auburn hair shades or making blue eyes pop.

18
Best mascara for sensitive eyes

Merit Clean Lash

Clean Lash

When it comes to tubing formulas, this is the everyday mascara we've been reaching for lately. As effective as it is chic, this buildable texture lengthens and defines effortlessly, with a post-wear removal that's just as easy.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19
Best dramatic mascara

NARS Cosmetics Climax Mascara

Climax Mascara

This big bushy wand never fails to deliver super long, separated lashes with a formula that won't flake or smudge onto your eyelids. Think Nars' signature drama for your eyes. Described as a hard core lift with a soft-core feel, it gives your lashes maximum volume without every feeling clumped or heavy.

Lettermark
Katie Withington
Beauty Assistant

Katie Withington (she/her) is the Beauty Assistant, at ELLE UK and Harper’s Bazaar. Working alongside the ELLE UK Beauty Team, she covers all things beauty for both print and digital, from finding backstage make-up trends at London Fashion Week and investigating buzzy skincare ingredients, to unzipping the beauty bags of Julia Garner and Emily Ratajkowski. Prior to joining ELLE UK in 2022, Katie studied (BA) Fashion Journalism at London College of Fashion and has previously contributed to Red, Good Housekeeping and Prima.  
 

Watch Next
 
preview for ELLE UK - Beauty
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Shop Beauty

two models wearing tinted moisturiser

ELLE Edit: 14 Of The Best Tinted Moisturisers

milan, italy february 24 l r ratner and luoyi pose backstage ahead of the ermanno scervino fashion show during the milan fashion week womenswear fallwinter 2024 2025 on february 24, 2024 in milan, italy photo by rosdiana ciaravologetty images

The Best Retinol Serums On The Shelves Now

the best night creams

ELLE Edit: The 17 Best Night Creams

best hair dryer

The 9 Best Hairdryers, Tried And Tested

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below