Fanatics and NHL unveil new 2024-25 uniforms as officials insist THESE threads have been tested and refined after the apparel brand's lackluster MLB jerseys drew player complaints

Fanatics and the NHL have unveiled their new jerseys for the 2024-25 season, and after all the controversy over the brand's MLB uniforms, officials insist that these threads have been tested and refined.

Fanatics, which was criticized for Major League Baseball uniform issues that MLB and the MLB Players Association later said Nike was responsible for and was fixing for next season, is using the same factory that has made hockey sweaters for decades.

'This is a huge moment for our company, our 22,000 employees, really to demonstrate what we can do when we have full control over the end-to-end process,' Fanatics Commerce CEO Andrew Low Ah Kee told The Associated Press. 


'We all take a lot of pride in the work that we do. Ultimately, it´s not about the words that come out. It´s about the actual product and we´re excited to have that on players and equally with fans because the proof is going to be in the actual product.'

It is the first time the company has designed and made in-game uniforms with its own branding for a major North American professional sports league. 

In this handout provided by Fanatics, a Fanatics logo is sewn on the back of a Panthers jersey

In this handout provided by Fanatics, a Fanatics logo is sewn on the back of a Panthers jersey

Additionally, the pants have proven to be see through, as shown by Shohei Ohtani above

Additionally, the pants have proven to be see through, as shown by Shohei Ohtani above

The league said playoff MVP Connor McDavid, Florida Panthers Stanley Cup-winning captain Aleksander Barkov and teammate Matthew Tkachuk, brother Brady Tkachuk and two-time champions Steven Stamkos and Nikita Kucherov were among the players on all 32 teams who got to see, feel and try on the new jerseys.

Keith Leach, Fanatics' NHL VP and general manager, said one of the initial prototypes developed in 2023 showed 'board burn' wear and tear that dissipated sleeves, leading the company to add an extra layer of reinforcement to solve the problem. He said equipment managers reacted positively to the change, which was tested during some summer skates and refined before moving on in the process.

'The players got to see it - not every player but (more than 100) players got to see it - before the playoffs,' Leach told the AP. 'That way there´s no surprise of, `It just showed up in my locker room in training camp and there´s my jersey.´'

That was the reaction, and not in a good way, of many baseball players at spring training, after Nike made changes to MLB uniforms. Fanatics Founder and CEO Michael Rubin said in March that his company made everything to Nike's specifications, and a memo sent to players by the MLBPA in late April called it 'entirely a Nike issue' for 'innovating something that didn´t need to be innovated.'

The jerseys won't appear much different in 2024-25 despite the new maker: Fanatics

The jerseys won't appear much different in 2024-25 despite the new maker: Fanatics 

The jerseys have also been criticized for their inability to absorb sweat, as seen with the Yankees' Carlos Rodon

The jerseys have also been criticized for their inability to absorb sweat, as seen with the Yankees' Carlos Rodon

Fanatics and the NHL, which reached a 10-year agreement in March 2023, wanted to keep the changes to a minimum. Teams were given a moratorium on rebrands, other than Anaheim and Los Angeles already in process and the notable exception of the Arizona Coyotes moving to Salt Lake City in April and recently becoming known as the Utah Hockey Club.

'I'm proud of what the Utah Hockey Club has done under very, very short time frames,' longtime NHL executive VP of marketing Brian Jennings told the AP. 'I think when the uniform comes out, despite all the people that are online and they say what they do - we´ve all experienced that - you´ll see a world-class uniform and an evolving brand structure from the Utah Hockey Club.'

Leach also said part of the process was building a world-class team including experienced designer Dom Fillion and sticking with SP Apparel, which has been churning out jerseys for the league for nearly 50 years. They will still come from SP's factory in Saint-Hyacinthe, Quebec, outside Montreal, which produced them for Adidas since 2017 and Reebok for a decade before that.

In the news release accompanying the jersey reveal, NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman said Fanatics 'preserved the quality, performance and design of our uniforms' and NHLPA executive director Marty Walsh said company officials from very early in the process 'have kept their commitment to partnering with the players in the transition to the new on-ice jersey.'

Jennings said the league and its partners don't take lightly the responsibility of making jerseys in a sport predicated on players' speed and skill. Toronto's Auston Matthews in a quote provided in the news release said the jerseys feel comfortable and look breathable, adding, 'Any little detail that can help us perform at our best makes a difference.'

'What they do on the ice on an eighth of an inch of steel is simply magnificent, and we want to make sure that they continue to do that,' Jennings said. 'You always want to say, `Hold on a second, when you see this being worn under the big lights by professional athletes, it is going to raise the bar.''

MLB will reportedly change its Nike/Fanatics uniforms following widespread complaints over the new jerseys which were introduced in full this spring.

The Nike Vapor Premier uniform, which was first worn at last year's All-Star Game,  has been roundly criticized by players for its smaller lettering, see-through pants and inability to absorb sweat.

Angels OF Taylor Ward described the feel as 'papery' and it 'doesn't look like a $450 jersey'

Angels OF Taylor Ward described the feel as 'papery' and it 'doesn't look like a $450 jersey'

As reported by ESPN's Jeff Passan in April, the league will modify its uniforms, though changes may not take effect until the beginning of next season.

Citing an obtained memo from the MLB Players Association, Passan noted that the league will go back to larger lettering, fix 'mismatched' gray shirts and pants and address the jerseys' problems with sweat.

Interestingly, the MLBPA placed blame on Nike - and not manufacturer Fanatics - for the uniform problems.

Fanatics, which has been making MLB jerseys since 2017, has been heavily blamed for the missteps, but according to the memo, the company, 'recognizes the vital importance of soliciting Player feedback, obtaining Player buy-in and not being afraid to have difficult conversations about jerseys or trading cards. 

Several players made their distaste for the new jerseys public.

One unnamed player on the Baltimore Orioles told the Baltimore Banner that they, 'look... like a knockoff jersey from TJ Maxx.'

And Philadelphia Phillies shortstop Trea Turner said that 'everyone hates' the new uniforms

And Philadelphia Phillies shortstop Trea Turner said that 'everyone hates' the new uniforms

Meanwhile, Phillies shortstop Trea Turner told the AP, 'I know everyone hates them.'

And the Angels' Taylor Ward told The Athletic, 'It looks like a replica. It feels kind of like papery. It could be great when you're out there sweating, it may be breathable. 

'But I haven't had that opportunity yet to try that out. But from the looks of it, it doesn't look like a $450 jersey. So far, thumbs down.'

The memo stated that the MLBPA 'cautioned against' the various changes when they were proposed initially in 2022.

According to Passan, 2025 is 'the latest' possible timeline for the jerseys.