Chris Sutton slams 'show pony' Antony for letting Erik ten Hag down - as he and co-host Ian Ladyman pick their biggest FLOPS of the season on It's All Kicking Off!

  • Chelsea completed the signing of Moises Caicedo for a British record £115m fee
  • Antony managed only one goal in 29 Premier League appearances this season 
  • Have Chelsea offered Manchester United a way out of the Erik ten Hag darkness through Mauricio Pochettino's exit? - Listen to the It's All Kicking Off! Podcast 

Chris Sutton believes that 'show pony' Antony has let Erik ten Hag down with his performances for Manchester United.

The Brazilian, who had joined his old Ajax boss at Old Trafford for a £85.5million fee in 2022, managed only three goals and two assists in a dismal campaign that also saw him lose his place in the starting line-up. 

On Mail Sport's It's All Kicking Off! podcast, Sutton insisted that the Red Devils winger was the biggest underperformer of the 2023-24 season.


'[Antony] actually made me look value for money,' the former Blues striker Sutton joked. 'For the outlay on him, in terms of goals and assists they just simply haven't been there. He is a show pony. That's what he is and I think he's let Erik ten Hag down.' 

However, Sutton's IAKO co-host Ian Ladyman disagreed and instead opted for Chelsea midfielder Moises Caicedo as his flop of the campaign. The 22-year-old was at the centre a high-profile tussle between Liverpool and Chelsea last summer before he eventually completed a move to Stamford Bridge for a British record £115million fee. Additionally, Sutton and Ladyman also revealed their choices for the biggest overachievers - which happened to involve two players with Chelsea connections. 

Listen to the latest episode of It's All Kicking Off in full below or on Mail Podcasts:

Antony managed only five goal contributions in all competitions for Manchester United

Antony managed only five goal contributions in all competitions for Manchester United

Erik ten Hag recruited the Brazilian from his former club Ajax for £85.5million last summer

Erik ten Hag recruited the Brazilian from his former club Ajax for £85.5million last summer

Moises Caicedo struggled to get to grips with life at Stamford  Bridge after his £115m move

Moises Caicedo struggled to get to grips with life at Stamford  Bridge after his £115m move

Chris Sutton labelled Man United winger Antony a 'show pony'
Ian Ladyman disagreed with his co-hosts selection and put forward Moises Caicedo

Chris Sutton (left) and Ian Ladyman (right) revealed their selections for the season's biggest under and overperformers of the campaign

Listen to It's All Kicking Off! on Spotify or Apple Podcasts. New episodes released every Monday and Thursday.