Global governance after the financial crisis: A new multilateralism or the last gasp of the great powers?
N Woods�- Global Policy, 2010 - Wiley Online Library
N Woods
Global Policy, 2010•Wiley Online LibraryIn the wake of the global financial crisis, three G20 Summits have reinvigorated global
cooperation, thrusting the International Monetary Fund centre stage with approximately
1trillionofresources.WithChina,Brazil,India,Russiaandotherpowerfulemergingeconomi…,isanewmoremultilateraleraofgovernanceem…
?Thisarticleexaminestheevidence.Itdetailsthegovernancereformsandnewfinan…–insufficienttopositiontheIMFtoaddresstheglo…
,tosetnewmultilateralrules,tooperateasanalternativetoself‐insuranceorindeedtoprovideamoremultilate…
.TheIMFisshiftingbetween:borrowerdependence(relyingonfee‐payingborrowersforincome);�…
cooperation, thrusting the International Monetary Fund centre stage with approximately
1trillionofresources.WithChina,Brazil,India,Russiaandotherpowerfulemergingeconomi…,isanewmoremultilateraleraofgovernanceem…
?Thisarticleexaminestheevidence.Itdetailsthegovernancereformsandnewfinan…–insufficienttopositiontheIMFtoaddresstheglo…
,tosetnewmultilateralrules,tooperateasanalternativetoself‐insuranceorindeedtoprovideamoremultilate…
.TheIMFisshiftingbetween:borrowerdependence(relyingonfee‐payingborrowersforincome);�…
Abstract
In the wake of the global financial crisis, three G20 Summits have reinvigorated global cooperation, thrusting the International Monetary Fund centre stage with approximately 1trillionofresources.WithChina,Brazil,India,Russiaandotherpowerfulemergingeconomiesnowatthetable,isanewmoremultilateraleraofgovernanceemerging?Thisarticleexaminestheevidence.ItdetailsthegovernancereformsandnewfinancingoftheIMFbutfindsonlyverylimitedshiftsintheengagementofmajoremergingeconomies–insufficienttopositiontheIMFtoaddresstheglobalimbalances,tosetnewmultilateralrules,tooperateasanalternativetoself‐insuranceorindeedtoprovideamoremultilateralresponsetothedevelopmentemergency.TheIMFisshiftingbetween:borrowerdependence(relyingonfee‐payingborrowersforincome);independence(withitsowninvestmentincome);andlenderdependence(relyingonwealthymemberstoextendcreditlinestoit).TheresultisanambiguoussetofforcesrestrainingtheIMFtostayasitis,andonlyweaklydrivingreform.Anewordermayemergeinwhichmultilateralinstitutions–suchastheIMF–endupwithonlyalimitedroletoplayalongsideemergingnationalandregionalstrategies,unlessamoreradicaltransformationbegins.PolicyImplications•IMFgovernance(decision‐makingmajority,location,managementandstaffing)needstotransformfastifitistoaddressthetasksassignedtoitbytheG20.•TheIMF’sdependenceonloansfromitswealthiestmembers(foritsnew 600 billion) restrains the institution from serious reform, only weakly offering a driver for further change.• There has been a failure to mandate and resource the IMF (and its sister institution the World Bank) so as to ensure a multilateral response to the ‘development emergency’that has resulted from the financial crisis.
![](https://cdn.statically.io/img/scholar.google.com/scholar/images/qa_favicons/wiley.com.png)