Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) is characterized by concerns for perceived defects in physical appearance that appear to others as mild or unobservable. Individuals with BDD frequently refer concerns with their physical appearance being ‘not right’ (not just right experiences; NJREs), and BDD‐related behaviours may be performed until their appearance is perceived as ‘right’. The aim of the study was to explore the relationship between BDD and NJREs in cosmetic surgery and aesthetic medicine settings.

Individuals requesting cosmetic procedures with BDD symptoms (BDD‐symptoms group; n = 24), without BDD symptoms (cosmetic intervention [CI] group; n = 45), and individuals that have never required these procedures (no cosmetic intervention [NCI] group; n = 53) entered the study.

Results showed a greater number of past‐month NJREs, higher NJREs severity, higher drive for thinness, and greater general distress in the BDD‐symptoms group. Pertaining to features associated with NJREs (perfectionism and obsessive–compulsive disorder symptoms) and ED core features, the BDD‐symptoms group scored higher only with respect to NCI. Regression analyses showed that BDD symptoms were predicted by age, NJREs severity, and drive for thinness above and beyond general distress, perfectionism, obsessive–compulsive disorder symptoms, bulimia, and body dissatisfaction related to weight and shape in the BDD‐Symptoms group (in comparison with the CI and NCI groups).

NJREs may represent a potential vulnerability factor for BDD symptoms in cosmetic settings.