Name	Known for
Sam Jay Self -Host Self -Host See fewer	You People (2023)
Christina Aloisio A Capella Group A Capella Group See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Jennifer Barnhart Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Between the Lions (1999)
Terrence Cook Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Tornadic Winds: Dodge City (2018)
Carla Denise Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Mike's Apartment (2001)
Ayanna Dookie Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Can't Complain (2009)
David Matthew Feldman Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Oh Noah! (2011)
Zack Fox Party Regular Party Regular See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Franqi French Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Curb Your Enthusiasm (2000)
James Godwin Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Stake Land (2010)
Chris Gould Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Mike Hinkle A Capella Group A Capella Group See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Joyelle Johnson Party Guest (as Joyelle Nicole Johnson) Party Guest (as Joyelle Nicole Johnson) See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Jak Knight Party Regular Party Regular See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
James J Kroupa Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Michael Latini Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Saturday Night Live (1975)
Rick Lyon Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Lara MacLean Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Noel MacNeal Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	Bear in the Big Blue House (1997)
Monroe Martin Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Jimmy Martinez Self Self See fewer	Top Five (2014)
Jimmy Martinez Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Paul McGinnis Puppeteer Puppeteer See fewer	The Muppets (2011)
Gregg Mess Stormtrooper Stormtrooper See fewer	FBI: Most Wanted (2020)
Yanise Monét Party Co -Host Party Co -Host See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Leonard Ouzts Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Set It Up (2018)
Julianna Peacock A Capella Group A Capella Group See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Gary Ryder Mr. Green Mr. Green See fewer	Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance) (2014)
Casey James Salengo Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Intra Quest (2023)
Craig Simonetti A Capella Group A Capella Group See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Sean Switzer A Capella Group A Capella Group See fewer	Pause with Sam Jay (2021)
Ques Williams Party Guest Party Guest See fewer	Tragedy on Taco Tuesday (2022)
James Wojtal Head Puppeteer (as James Wojtal Jr.) Head Puppeteer (as James Wojtal Jr.) See fewer	The Happytime Murders (2018)
Katie Kaufman Miss Scarlett (uncredited) Miss Scarlett (uncredited) See fewer	Simon Says (2024)