Real Estate

Inside Judge Judy’s NYC penthouse that she’s selling for $9.5 million

Judge Judy Sheindlin and her husband, Jerry Sheindlin, are selling their duplex penthouse in New York City for $9.5 million.

“We’ve enjoyed this jewel of an apartment,” Brooklyn native Judy, who has an estimated net worth of $480 million, told the New York Times in May. “Time to simplify.”

The home is located in the affluent Sutton Place neighborhood of Manhattan and features a wraparound terrace with a panoramic view of the East River.

Judge Judy Sheindlin is selling her New York City duplex penthouse for $9.5 million. James Dimmock/Amazon Freevee
The home is located in the affluent Sutton Place neighborhood of Manhattan. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
It has a paneled library with a wood-burning fireplace. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
A 29-foot entrance gallery leads to a spacious living room. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
The living room brings in plenty of sunlight. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph I

Judy, 81, and Jerry, 90, bought the four-bedroom, four-bathroom residence at the top of a 93-unit building in 2013 for $8.5 million.

Monthly maintenance costs $10,130, according to the listing.

Upon entry, the penthouse boasts a 29-foot gallery leading to a sunlit living room with a wood-burning fireplace.

The chef’s kitchen features a wood island and marble countertops. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph I
The master bedroom is located on the lower level. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph I
It has an en suite bathroom. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph I
The formal dining room boasts floor-to-ceiling French casement doors. Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph I

The apartment also has a formal dining room with floor-to-ceiling French casement doors, a paneled library with a second fireplace and a chef’s kitchen with professional-grade appliances, marble countertops and a wood island.

A wrought iron staircase leads to the lower level, which includes the primary bedroom and its en suite bathroom.

“There’s a modernity to the layout and an openness,” Compass broker Mickey Conlon, who listed the abode with Tom Postilio, told the Times. “It’s grand, but not ostentatious in any way.”

Sheindlin starred in “Judge Judy” from 1996 to 2021. Getty Images
She now appears in “Judy Justice.” Michael Becker/IMDb TV

The co-op at 14 Sutton Place South offers a full-time doorman, a gym, a bike room and a private storage unit for its residents to use.

The Sheindlins, who used their NYC penthouse as a pied-à-terre, also own sprawling properties in Greenwich, Conn., Naples, Fla., and Newport, RI.

The couple, both of whom have worked as judges in New York and starred in TV court shows, have been married since 1978.