Amber Riley in 2009 and on March 13
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Chord Overstreet in 2009 and on March 13
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Chris Colfer in 2009 and on March 13
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Darren Criss in 2009 and on March 13
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Dianna Agron in 2009 and on March 12
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Harry Shum Jr. in 2009 and on Dec. 7, 2014
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Heather Morris in 2009 and on March 13
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Jane Lynch in 2009 and on March 13
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Jayma Mays in 2009 and on May 22, 2014
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Jenna Ushkowitz in 2009 and on March 16
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Kevin McHale in 2009 and 2015
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Kristin Chenoweth in 2009 and on March 12
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Lea Michele in 2009 and on Feb. 28
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Mark Salling in 2009 and on March 13
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Matthew Morrison in 2009 and on March 2
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Naya Rivera in 2009 and on Jan. 11
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Neil Patrick Harris on “Glee” in 2010 and hosting the Oscars on Feb. 22
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Alex Newell in 2012 and on Feb. 28
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty
Melissa Benoist in 2012 and on Feb. 21
Fox / Everett Collection / Getty