A dish in a red ornate bowl.
Ugly Baby is Carroll Gardens’s best Thai restaurant.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

The Best Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Old-school Italian bakeries, standout Thai food, and one of New York’s top pizzerias

View as Map
Ugly Baby is Carroll Gardens’s best Thai restaurant.
| Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Carroll Gardens is small and residential, once marked mostly by its Italian restaurants, but its selection of old and brand new restaurants is top-notch: Where else but here can you find Sicilian lard bread, Chicago-style hot dogs, acclaimed thin-crust pizza, and mouth-numbing pad krapow in the same square mile?

Read More
Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process.

Just over the BQE in what’s going by the Columbia Waterfront District resides Popina from James O’Brien, with a menu of pastas, vegetables, and seafood at neighborhood-friendly prices. Don’t miss the recently expanded back patio, now with a bocce court.

A vast back patio with an overhang.
The backyard at Popina.
Popina.

Swoony's

Copy Link

Swoony’s is an American restaurant from the same owner as Cafe Spaghetti: The specialty here: gut-busting grill grub, like creamed spinach, clams casino, short rib au povire, and a double cheeseburger with Thousand Island dressing on an English muffin-style bun. Like the food, the restaurant has an old-fashioned feel; it’s located in a three-story house that was built in 1931.

The short rib au poivre at Swoony’s, an American restaurant in Carroll Gardens.
The short rib au poivre at Swoony’s.
Justin Belmondo/Swoony’s

Cafe Spaghetti

Copy Link

Cafe Spaghetti is a newish Italian restaurant in a neighborhood full of old-school standbys. The restaurant is known for its pasta, but there are other ways to eat here, with dishes like meatballs, baked clams, eggplant Parmesan, and chicken Milanese. Some dishes diverge from staples to reflect the modern age: “breakfast spaghetti” with bacon, and at brunch, ricotta pancakes with orange-blossom honey. Don’t miss the backyard garden.

Awnings, vines, diners at tables, and the setting sun.
The backyard at Cafe Spaghetti.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Court Pastry Shop

Copy Link

Court Pastry Shop was founded by the Zerilli family right after the Second World War in 1948. It emphasizes Neapolitan pastries, butter cookies, and gelati. And you won’t find a better filled-on-the-spot cannolo in town, but take a second look in the glass case for some pastries often served mainly at festivals in the old country, including pastiera, or grain pie, made with ricotta and bits of candied orange peel.

Three types of pastries in a glass case.
A selection of classic Neapolitan pastries at Court Pastry Shop.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Bobbi’s Italian Beef

Copy Link

For whatever reason — The Bear? — restaurants selling foods from Chicago have multiplied in recent years. Bobbi’s, a small restaurant with a retro vibe, specializes in wet, gravy-soaked Italian beef sandwiches served with sweet peppers or hot pickled vegetables. The large menu has all sorts of other dishes, too, like Italian sausages, Chicago-style hot dogs, and personal pan pizzas.

A Chicago-style hot dog appears in a red basket next to a side of tater tots.
A Chicago dog from Bobbi’s.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Untable

Copy Link

Untable opened last fall alums of Thai restaurants, Somtum Der and Ugly Baby. The tagline is “unconventional Thai food” and it largely keeps to the promise with dishes like a super hot “what the hell” fried rice. Check out the specials and Instagram as far as what to order from its often changing menu. The restaurant has recently attracted attention from Michelin.

The exterior of a red restaurant, Untable, in Caroll Gardens, Brooklyn.
Untable, a Thai restaurant in Carroll Gardens.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Mazzola Bakery

Copy Link

Carroll Gardens used to be full of old-school Italian bakeries, but today, there are only a few left. Mazzola, open at this location since 1928, is known for its lard bread — a brown loaf baked with cured prosciutto and provolone. The bakery makes a great slice of Sicilian pizza, too: The sauce is thick and sweet on its crispy crust.

Loaves lined up in a basket.
Mazzola is one of the few bakeries selling classic Neapolitan lard bread.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Gus’s started as an approachable neighborhood steakhouse serving dishes that can border on enthralling, including hash browns with trout roe and chicken a la plancha; it has since transitioned to a menu that includes pasta; Monday through Thursday, the restaurant is running a deal at $56 per person — an appetizer, main, and dessert, served family-style.

A hand dunks a french fry into a white ramekin of sauce next to a burger resting on a plate.
The burger at Gus’s Chop House.
Teddy Wolff/Gus’s Chop House

Lucali starts taking names for dinner at 5 p.m., but fifteen minutes earlier, there’s usually a line down the block. Then there are the rules: It’s cash only. You have a time limit on your table. It’s B.Y.O. wine, but only one bottle is allowed. New Yorkers put up with this because pizza at Lucali is quite special. The dough is thin and chewy, with blistered spots around the perimeter. The only other item on the menu is a calzone: You’ll want to order it.

A thin-crust NYC-style pizza shown from above with red sauce and basil.
A pizza from Lucali.
Lucali

Kittery Seafood of Brooklyn

Copy Link

This very good seafood restaurant, inspired by the lobster pounds of Maine, serves all sorts of oceangoing creatures, running from simple fish and chips, Brooklyn steamers, and raw oysters to more ambitious fare. The outdoor seating area is a perfect place to hang on long summer evenings, and it gives a real feel for the laid-back nature of the neighborhood.

A sign painted on the building with a red lobster.
The outdoor seating at Kittery is a big lure.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Frank's Luncheonette

Copy Link

Not to be confused with all the other restaurants in Brooklyn and Manhattan with a name referring to an Italian named Frank, this small eatery was founded in 1965, making it older than all the others. Basically, you can view everything for sale in glass cases the minute your walk inside: find soups, pizzas, chicken parm sandwiches, and lasagna — a thumbnail of the working class fare of Carroll Gardens going back 60 years. It’s also one of the few actual old-time luncheonettes left in town — and we don’t mean one invented by some canny modern restaurant empire.

A storefront with a red awning.
Frank’s Luncheonette was founded in 1965.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Ugly Baby

Copy Link

When Ugly Baby opened in 2017, it became one of the best places to eat Thai food in all of New York City. The menu changes constantly, but some things have stayed the same: You can count on the food being incredibly spicy, for example, and an unnaturally good list of craft beers to wash it down.

A dining room table with several dishes, two orange beverages with ice cubes, and a few ornamental, palm-sized cacti.
Ugly Baby may be Carroll Gardens’s spiciest restaurant.
Jessie Jacobson/Eater NY

Frankies 457

Copy Link

Here’s the restaurant from olive oil tycoons (along with pasta and other items) known as the Franks — chefs Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo. The longtime neighborhood restaurant is the kind of place to hang and graze: Start with some olives, a little plate of tuna and roasted pepper, an escarole and walnuts salad, and maybe a share plate of Sicilian-style meatballs. Don’t miss the next-door slice shop, F&F, and their wine bar, Frank’s, with a knockout wine list.

A bowl of pasta with a tomato-based sauce.
A plate of pasta from Frankies 457.
Melissa McCart/Eater NY

Cremini’s

Copy Link

This small restaurant way down south in Carroll Gardens, near the Smith and Ninth Street stop on the F, specializes in the food of Italy’s Le Marche, where sandwiches are made on larded flatbreads called crescia. These are delicious sandwiches, akin to the piadini of northern Italy, and imbued with the taste of a smoky oven. Arancini, potatoes, fritters, and pastas from the region are also available.

A flatbread sandwich with the dappled bread folded over meat and cheese on a flowered plate...
A flatbread sandwich from Cremini’s
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Popina

Just over the BQE in what’s going by the Columbia Waterfront District resides Popina from James O’Brien, with a menu of pastas, vegetables, and seafood at neighborhood-friendly prices. Don’t miss the recently expanded back patio, now with a bocce court.

A vast back patio with an overhang.
The backyard at Popina.
Popina.

Swoony's

Swoony’s is an American restaurant from the same owner as Cafe Spaghetti: The specialty here: gut-busting grill grub, like creamed spinach, clams casino, short rib au povire, and a double cheeseburger with Thousand Island dressing on an English muffin-style bun. Like the food, the restaurant has an old-fashioned feel; it’s located in a three-story house that was built in 1931.

The short rib au poivre at Swoony’s, an American restaurant in Carroll Gardens.
The short rib au poivre at Swoony’s.
Justin Belmondo/Swoony’s

Cafe Spaghetti

Cafe Spaghetti is a newish Italian restaurant in a neighborhood full of old-school standbys. The restaurant is known for its pasta, but there are other ways to eat here, with dishes like meatballs, baked clams, eggplant Parmesan, and chicken Milanese. Some dishes diverge from staples to reflect the modern age: “breakfast spaghetti” with bacon, and at brunch, ricotta pancakes with orange-blossom honey. Don’t miss the backyard garden.

Awnings, vines, diners at tables, and the setting sun.
The backyard at Cafe Spaghetti.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Court Pastry Shop

Court Pastry Shop was founded by the Zerilli family right after the Second World War in 1948. It emphasizes Neapolitan pastries, butter cookies, and gelati. And you won’t find a better filled-on-the-spot cannolo in town, but take a second look in the glass case for some pastries often served mainly at festivals in the old country, including pastiera, or grain pie, made with ricotta and bits of candied orange peel.

Three types of pastries in a glass case.
A selection of classic Neapolitan pastries at Court Pastry Shop.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Bobbi’s Italian Beef

For whatever reason — The Bear? — restaurants selling foods from Chicago have multiplied in recent years. Bobbi’s, a small restaurant with a retro vibe, specializes in wet, gravy-soaked Italian beef sandwiches served with sweet peppers or hot pickled vegetables. The large menu has all sorts of other dishes, too, like Italian sausages, Chicago-style hot dogs, and personal pan pizzas.

A Chicago-style hot dog appears in a red basket next to a side of tater tots.
A Chicago dog from Bobbi’s.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Untable

Untable opened last fall alums of Thai restaurants, Somtum Der and Ugly Baby. The tagline is “unconventional Thai food” and it largely keeps to the promise with dishes like a super hot “what the hell” fried rice. Check out the specials and Instagram as far as what to order from its often changing menu. The restaurant has recently attracted attention from Michelin.

The exterior of a red restaurant, Untable, in Caroll Gardens, Brooklyn.
Untable, a Thai restaurant in Carroll Gardens.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Mazzola Bakery

Carroll Gardens used to be full of old-school Italian bakeries, but today, there are only a few left. Mazzola, open at this location since 1928, is known for its lard bread — a brown loaf baked with cured prosciutto and provolone. The bakery makes a great slice of Sicilian pizza, too: The sauce is thick and sweet on its crispy crust.

Loaves lined up in a basket.
Mazzola is one of the few bakeries selling classic Neapolitan lard bread.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Gus's

Gus’s started as an approachable neighborhood steakhouse serving dishes that can border on enthralling, including hash browns with trout roe and chicken a la plancha; it has since transitioned to a menu that includes pasta; Monday through Thursday, the restaurant is running a deal at $56 per person — an appetizer, main, and dessert, served family-style.

A hand dunks a french fry into a white ramekin of sauce next to a burger resting on a plate.
The burger at Gus’s Chop House.
Teddy Wolff/Gus’s Chop House

Lucali

Lucali starts taking names for dinner at 5 p.m., but fifteen minutes earlier, there’s usually a line down the block. Then there are the rules: It’s cash only. You have a time limit on your table. It’s B.Y.O. wine, but only one bottle is allowed. New Yorkers put up with this because pizza at Lucali is quite special. The dough is thin and chewy, with blistered spots around the perimeter. The only other item on the menu is a calzone: You’ll want to order it.

A thin-crust NYC-style pizza shown from above with red sauce and basil.
A pizza from Lucali.
Lucali

Kittery Seafood of Brooklyn

This very good seafood restaurant, inspired by the lobster pounds of Maine, serves all sorts of oceangoing creatures, running from simple fish and chips, Brooklyn steamers, and raw oysters to more ambitious fare. The outdoor seating area is a perfect place to hang on long summer evenings, and it gives a real feel for the laid-back nature of the neighborhood.

A sign painted on the building with a red lobster.
The outdoor seating at Kittery is a big lure.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Frank's Luncheonette

Not to be confused with all the other restaurants in Brooklyn and Manhattan with a name referring to an Italian named Frank, this small eatery was founded in 1965, making it older than all the others. Basically, you can view everything for sale in glass cases the minute your walk inside: find soups, pizzas, chicken parm sandwiches, and lasagna — a thumbnail of the working class fare of Carroll Gardens going back 60 years. It’s also one of the few actual old-time luncheonettes left in town — and we don’t mean one invented by some canny modern restaurant empire.

A storefront with a red awning.
Frank’s Luncheonette was founded in 1965.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Ugly Baby

When Ugly Baby opened in 2017, it became one of the best places to eat Thai food in all of New York City. The menu changes constantly, but some things have stayed the same: You can count on the food being incredibly spicy, for example, and an unnaturally good list of craft beers to wash it down.

A dining room table with several dishes, two orange beverages with ice cubes, and a few ornamental, palm-sized cacti.
Ugly Baby may be Carroll Gardens’s spiciest restaurant.
Jessie Jacobson/Eater NY

Frankies 457

Here’s the restaurant from olive oil tycoons (along with pasta and other items) known as the Franks — chefs Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo. The longtime neighborhood restaurant is the kind of place to hang and graze: Start with some olives, a little plate of tuna and roasted pepper, an escarole and walnuts salad, and maybe a share plate of Sicilian-style meatballs. Don’t miss the next-door slice shop, F&F, and their wine bar, Frank’s, with a knockout wine list.

A bowl of pasta with a tomato-based sauce.
A plate of pasta from Frankies 457.
Melissa McCart/Eater NY

Cremini’s

This small restaurant way down south in Carroll Gardens, near the Smith and Ninth Street stop on the F, specializes in the food of Italy’s Le Marche, where sandwiches are made on larded flatbreads called crescia. These are delicious sandwiches, akin to the piadini of northern Italy, and imbued with the taste of a smoky oven. Arancini, potatoes, fritters, and pastas from the region are also available.

A flatbread sandwich with the dappled bread folded over meat and cheese on a flowered plate...
A flatbread sandwich from Cremini’s
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Related Maps