Felicity: Ben or Noel — did she make the right choice?

With the cast of Felicity reuniting in EW’s annual Reunions issue, it only felt right to talk about the Ben-Felicity-Noel love triangle.

Ben was the reason the show existed. After graduating from high school, Felicity spontanelously decides to drop her Stanford plans, only to follow Ben to the University of New York. Ben constantly proves that he may not be the most thoughtful while the couple date, but Felicity notoriously finds herself going back to him. On the other hand, Noel was the basic guy-next-door who from the start, who proved to be dependable and comforting. They were perfect for each other, almost having too much in common, so of course they couldn’t work.

While Felicity (SPOILER ALERT!) eventually chose Ben, we can’t help but wonder if she truly made the right choice. Are you Team Ben or Team Noel? Cast your vote in EW’s poll of notable TV love triangles, ahead.