A familiar tale: Boy meets girl, boy likes girl, boy visits girl’s hometown and meets the offbeat quartet of ladies she calls her family. He then learns that all five women may actually be the product of a spell placed upon his new lover by her spinster aunt, who split the girl into five separate beings who will not become whole until she finds true love. Curiously, this strange setup seems almost plausible thanks to Gabrielle Zevin’s effectively taut prose. But she employs too many cute tricks that keep the reader at arm’s length (naming her narrator N., blocking out names and years for no apparent reason). By the time you reach the optimistic conclusion of Margarettown, you’ll wonder how a book so romantic can leave you feeling so cold.
Related Articles
![Must List collage of Jeremy Allen-White in The Bear; June Squibb in Thelma; Amaarae;](https://ew.com/thmb/HX94u_Bjlzs0239MMMdvqdI6f30=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Must-List-JUNE-28-79ac266c1b9a4453851550867d33e2ad.jpg)
The Bear, Thelma, Amaarae, and A Quiet Place: Day One top this week's Must List
![Must List collage of Stephen Merchant in Outlaws; Shaboozey; Benedict Cumberbatch in Eric](https://ew.com/thmb/Oh-yZ7V7fsGWXgZpWEUsJPZRWok=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Must-List-MAY31-5c6696b9518849baa7930c886ada42c7.jpg)
The Outlaws, Eric, and Shaboozey top this week's Must List
![Harry-Potter-covers](https://ew.com/thmb/cG0rh0Lw75IQ0jEYmX9HSuJFKRg=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/harry-potter-covers-2000-65e5c82072e94c88af3f6b2b68fecb3a.jpg)
See how Harry Potter book covers have changed through the years
![Michael Richards](https://ew.com/thmb/srnt9zNCVzOT7sq_NVIrJcnTDx0=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/michael-richards-052724-9b620aa45fff4d6a9bab7a938c59335f.jpg)
Michael Richards says his struggles with anger stem from 'unwantedness,' being a result of sexual assault
![The Must List: Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga, Evil, Stop Making Sense](https://ew.com/thmb/43k6XvrDMBzSz8GjtelFljtdGJo=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Must-List-Tout-May24-32ee690ab0dc4330be5e31ac7affe08c.jpg)
Evil, Furiosa, and a killer Talking Heads tribute top this week’s Must List
![Michael Richards attends NDRC Food For Thought Benefit celebrating safe and sustainable eating on May 29, 2014 in Santa Monica, California.](https://ew.com/thmb/tBxRabSG_HKTgdHDyIStPJau8UA=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Michael-Richards-052324-c2e65b8d6c774dc29853fd878ce9a308.jpg)
Seinfeld star Michael Richards reveals cancer battle, 'probably would have been dead' in months without surgery
![SUNNY HOSTIN, MEGHAN MCCAIN - THE VIEW - Monday, January 8, 2018](https://ew.com/thmb/xTlCVgHyeNV0fsmgsvlzil2erKI=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Sunny-Hostin-Meghan-McCain-The-View-052124-22c4113c8c3c4204ba3acce762ab2731.jpg)
Sunny Hostin didn't know ex-View cohost Meghan McCain unfollowed her: 'Maybe she broke up with me'
![Nicola Coughlan and Luke Newton in Bridgerton; Jeff Probst in Survivor; RuPaul in Drag Race](https://ew.com/thmb/hdpf7aRcLEsmj2cPUifQ3EfLONs=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/MUST-LIST-MAY17-5863368456df4b95aa73aee2d4fc7a4f.jpg)
Bridgerton, Drag Race, and a Suvivor podcast top this week’s Must List
![Host Whoopi Goldberg and guest Mike Nichols on "The View" in 2012.](https://ew.com/thmb/PMiJCTRTC5wwrq7j8TI2fN1TuqA=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Whoopi-Goldberg-Mike-Nichols-050624-fa91f817170f40928e6341167e65dcd2.jpg)
Whoopi Goldberg shares why she 'couldn't stop crying' on The View after Mike Nichols died
![Daniel Radcliffe and J.K. Rowling](https://ew.com/thmb/T72FTiNI7xvMr7nHpIuGbTy-bYI=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/daniel-radcliffe-J.K.-Rowling-043024-a5bf5cb043ff46e2aee3953c63fbee05.jpg)
Daniel Radcliffe responds to J.K. Rowling's anti-trans rhetoric: 'It makes me really sad'
![100 Years of Solitude](https://ew.com/thmb/NG9ah8ALD5DbXi4TqAH-SYDB1gQ=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/100-Years-of-Solitude-041724-b5130146440046c8a4cfdde954f384cb.jpg)
New One Hundred Years of Solitude teaser features one of literature's most iconic opening lines
![Daniel Radcliffe, J.K. Rowling and Emma Watson attend the "Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows Part 2" world premiere at Trafalgar Square on July 7, 2011 in London, England](https://ew.com/thmb/r3_1D0hgp2eydmSE0Hxnnp4UZOs=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/JK-Rowling-Daniel-Radcliffe-Emma-Watson-5cc964cc104848ce94ea2bde927a41e3.jpg)
J.K. Rowling says she won't forgive Harry Potter stars Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson for their trans support
![The Must List: X-Men '97, The Jerrod Carmichael Reality Show, Dragon's Dogma 2](https://ew.com/thmb/c5QhD9aIpi9BcJ3l1UXuo24tHjo=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Must-List-3-28-e20411d112104b04bf324e51a6880966.jpg)
Jerrod Carmichael, X-Men '97, and Dragon's Dogma 2 lead this week's Must List
![The Last Thing He Told Me](https://ew.com/thmb/18zAVkaiP5d8fn01v8KXsW0M22w=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/The-Last-Thing-He-Told-Me-041023-f71fdf498ba64e00821b2ec7987c0757.jpg)
The Last Thing He Told Me season 2, based on upcoming book sequel, is a go at Apple TV+
![REACHER, Alan Ritchson](https://ew.com/thmb/UTLTXjXZhEExcRNzifAk4VOaWf8=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/REACHER-Alan-Ritchson-012424-934a42a7f5684f9184f6b9fc674dc2c4.jpg)
Reacher will go undercover in season 3, based on Lee Child book Persuader
![Dominic West says Prince Harry's memoir influenced his performance on The Crown](https://ew.com/thmb/LUrCZPl1DIufY4dYucx2gsImVvI=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/dominic-west-the-crown-prince-harry-121523-8d9d353c41204de8b7a737cba9c77ab5.jpg)
Dominic West says Prince Harry's memoir influenced his performance on The Crown