Without question, the title and the plot — Southern college schoolmates gather 35 years after they’ve last seen each other to scatter a friend’s ashes — are deeply and cloyingly icky. And who, in this day and age, would call a woman in her 50s a girl, without a deep sense of irony? There sure ain’t no irony here (this is about proper Southern women, after all, each quietly unhappy in her own quiet, unhappy way) but Smith redeems herself by painting thoughtful portraits of women who are far more interesting than the chiffon-thin plot.
Related Articles
![Keri Russell attends The Diplomat - DC Special Screening at Motion Picture Association of America on April 19, 2023 in Washington, DC.](https://ew.com/thmb/KItmt4EFXJF-Qzxh69ULIxGsbGg=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/keri-russell-1-070924-2d607694aa634d788ae08b27e49f71dd.jpg)
Keri Russell says cutoff for girls on Mickey Mouse Club was when they looked 'like they were sexually active'
![Jonathan Bennett hosts 'Finding Mr. Christmas' on Hallmark+](https://ew.com/thmb/tUkjQHy79SKxzrQSC25wryFjS1w=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/finding-mr-christmas-071024-1-6a04619abc4947818b4c74a918c15eda.jpg)
Hallmark's Finding Mr. Christmas reality show seeks holiday movie hunk
![Jesse Plemons as Landry Clarke, Zach Gilford as Matt Saracen on Friday Night Lights](https://ew.com/thmb/eAP0g2QK94B2XPlr81G6shsCPJA=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/zach-gilford-071524-99d7630dbeb047f487acc440ca7bea24.jpg)
Zach Gilford says he and Jesse Plemons 'would jump at' opportunity to reunite on screen: ‘He’s such a talented actor'
![tim doyle](https://ew.com/thmb/eQR1WvKsDBhwnI5OO48fOht-Dzk=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/tim-doyle-071124-729eb86e25994cf295b9657436a643e5.jpg)
Last Man Standing showrunner Tim Doyle censured by WGA West for offensive social media post
![Vanessa Williams](https://ew.com/thmb/4G0Yu-8fJJ_j_sksHwD56jtYUTM=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/vanessa-williams-pagent-now-072324-c1a175d21c654992b1ffd1264725e8d4.jpg)
How Vanessa Williams lost the Miss America crown but won over Hollywood
![Chris Hahn, Tolu Ekundare](https://ew.com/thmb/Ilzn6ubvA-kPozO0qtPf8A3Q1TE=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Chris-Hahn-Tolu-Ekundare-perfect-match-070224-ed38590cda184b7f80bf68d06914f242.jpg)
Perfect Match's Tolú slams Chris, says they never hooked up: 'I know this man can't f---'
![Actresses Shannen Doherty adn Jennie Garth attend the Entertainment Weekly and Women in Film pre-Emmy Party presented by Maybelline Colorsensational held at Restaurant at The Sunset Marquis Hotel on September 17, 2009 in West Hollywood, California.](https://ew.com/thmb/e9Q_4k6HEWwXK88Z56befSkF45Y=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Shannen-Doherty-Jennie-Garth-tout-030424-e237984649b042aeba27842c3f152d2a.jpg)
Jennie Garth recalls last words her 90210 costar Shannen Doherty told her before actress' death
![Lauren Graham, Kelly Bishop, Gilmore Girls](https://ew.com/thmb/ROCmx9kqM_oW-ltFBAiXIC6pYJw=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/lauren-graham-kelly-bishop-gilmore-girls-062924-76813a0284414712a8809f18726b5890.jpg)
Lauren Graham and Kelly Bishop have Gilmore Girls reunion: 'Here's to the ladies who lunch'
![Osha Aniseya (Amandla Stenberg) and the Stranger (Manny Jacinto) on 'The Acolyte'](https://ew.com/thmb/kRQdSly9YQKSRH3vr4-_w_tApuc=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/acolyte-3-071624-a9bc265148f442cd8d6717313d3b2e13.jpg)
The Acolyte star Manny Jacinto addresses the Stranger and Osha romance
![Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos on Live with Kelly and Mark](https://ew.com/thmb/kTtIu3pJnkK07tJHwtOk0YUvSZg=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/mark-consuelos-070124-98ad27130b8b461f95d5722764d46b8e.jpg)
Mark Consuelos shaves head, debuts new hairstyle on Live for secret TV role: 'It's like a chinchilla'
![Christina Applegate attends the 28th Annual Critics Choice Awards; Cast of Love Island USA Season 6](https://ew.com/thmb/8cR1SUHMG_LREt3qkVNq1UU8Pjk=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/christina-applegate-love-island-070424-1-c7cc9300e9d548638d356987eefea24a.jpg)
Christina Applegate suggests Love Island cast stop using white deodorant because it resembles a 'yeast infection'
![Still from All American](https://ew.com/thmb/M0vloYHO-iCm7HsPe5shqLBq3As=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/all-american-1-071524-49a8cdb9f86c4c77b31c385a8b057fc2.jpg)
Daniel Ezra opens up about stepping away from All American: 'We’ve accomplished the mission'
![Adult film actress Jesse Jane attends the 2018 Adult Video News Awards at the Hard Rock Hotel & Casino on January 27, 2018 in Las Vegas, Nevada](https://ew.com/thmb/CCeckXV-Bo3a44GI6UfQZeoEC3k=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/jessie-jane-070824-fac4c35100fd4a769e934d5ceebc2b77.jpg)
Adult film star Jesse Jane’s cause of death announced by officials
![Drag Race](https://ew.com/thmb/2YsWBfiSSLSpDhRKygPVKEvyzZg=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Drag-Race-072024-c85d2e0e7d904f17b24d23e9da3db602.jpg)
Drag Race star Kennedy Davenport reveals partner had miscarriage: 'Thank you all for the love'
![Eva Longoria](https://ew.com/thmb/lzKogRJDAo8Q03ZBK7XzVbr3iDA=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/_Eva-Longoria-062024-1f85126a5fbb438f978098020ea02bd6.jpg)
Eva Longoria wants a Desperate Housewives reboot: 'I miss Wisteria Lane'
![Pretty Little Liars Season 2 Episode 7 Tabby](https://ew.com/thmb/-EaxmkoHwTsfFhyroL86CyaUsJs=/282x188/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/pretty-little-liars-1-061824-c50db685c60a4ff0b43c80fd816fea0b.jpg)
Pretty Little Liars: Summer School bosses dish on finale twists, deaths, and alternate endings