Template:Rfc

Please consider joining the feedback request service.

An editor has requested comments from other editors for this discussion. Within 24 hours, this page will be added to the following list:

Unsorted Error: No RfC category specified

When discussion has ended, remove this tag and it will be removed from the list. If this page is on additional lists, they will be noted below.

Template documentation[view] [edit] [history] [purge]

If you plan to make breaking changes to this template, move it, change scope, or nominate it for deletion or deprecation, please notify the Article Alerts project at Wikipedia talk:Article alerts as a courtesy, as this page is used by the AAlertBot bot to detect and report pages. Thank you!

This template is used by one or more bots.

If you intend to change this template in any significant way, move or nominate it for deletion, please inform the bot operators. Thank you. The relevant bots are: User:Legobot operated by User:Legoktm. And User:Cewbot/log/20201008/configuration.

Usage

{{rfc|topic}}

Use this template when making a request for comment. This template should immediately precede the signed (or just dated) text of the request. Do not begin the request with a wikilink; this may cause formatting errors.

Both the template and the request for comment itself should be placed in a discussion page related to the RfC topic; alternately, a new page dedicated to the RfC may be created.

Up to ten topics can be included in the same tag; i.e. {{rfc|topic 1|topic 2}}.

Within an hour or two after the edit has been saved, Legobot (talk · contribs) will add an |rfcid= parameter to the template, and will also add the discussion to the lists of RfCs that are indicated by the topic area parameters, e.g. Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Biographies if the topic area |bio was specified. Do not add |rfcid= without a value; do not choose your own value for the |rfcid= parameter, or re-use a value that is in use (or was previously used) on another RfC – instead, always let Legobot select a value. If you would like to add another topic area to the RfC after Legobot has already processed the {{rfc}} tag, simply add the additional topic(s) to those already within the tag, before the |rfcid= parameter; Legobot will notice the addition and add the discussion to the new RfC topic pages.

Do not include any opening html tags (e.g., <small>) in the initial RfC statement unless its corresponding closing tag (e.g., </small>) also comes before the first timestamp, i.e., don't "straddle" the first timestamp inside html code, otherwise it may corrupt the entry of the RfC on the topic discussion pages.

If Legobot finds two or more {{rfc}} templates on the same page which do not yet have an |rfcid= parameter, it is liable to assign the same |rfcid= to different RfCs (example), with the consequence that only one of them is publicised (example). If it is felt necessary to hold two or more RfCs on the same page, the discussions may be started together but you should add the {{rfc}} template to just one discussion at a time, and wait for Legobot to set an |rfcid= on that one before you add an {{rfc}} template to another discussion.

If you find a page with two or more {{rfc}} templates that have the same value for the |rfcid= parameter, remove that parameter from the {{rfc}} template which occurs first on the page, wait for Legobot to assign a fresh value, and check for further duplication.

Inactive usage: If giving an example of the use of this template, or suspending an ongoing RfC, do not use the constructs <nowiki>{{rfc}}</nowiki> or  because the bot may consider that it is an actual RfC, and will add an RFC ID or remove the template entirely, as it sees fit. Instead, use one of the template-linking templates such as {{tlx}}, as in {{tlx|rfc|bio}} which produces {{rfc|bio}}.

Note: It is a very good idea to let the section heading begin with "RfC" or "Request for comment", as for example "RfC: Past or present tense for television series?"

Expiry

The template does not provide a parameter for an expiry date. The bot will look for the first datestamp that occurs in the page text at any point after the template, and will treat that as the starting time for the RfC, and will remove the template thirty days after that time. If the {{rfc}} template is added at the top of an existing thread where discussion has been going on for some time, it is important to add some text that includes the current timestamp between the {{rfc}} template and the first posting, so that the RfC runs its full thirty days (example).

Definition of topic areas

Issues by topic area (View all)
Article topics (View all)
Biographies	(watch)	`{{rfc\|bio}}`
Economy, trade, and companies	(watch)	`{{rfc\|econ}}`
History and geography	(watch)	`{{rfc\|hist}}`
Language and linguistics	(watch)	`{{rfc\|lang}}`
Maths, science, and technology	(watch)	`{{rfc\|sci}}`
Media, the arts, and architecture	(watch)	`{{rfc\|media}}`
Politics, government, and law	(watch)	`{{rfc\|pol}}`
Religion and philosophy	(watch)	`{{rfc\|reli}}`
Society, sports, and culture	(watch)	`{{rfc\|soc}}`
Project-wide topics (View all)
Wikipedia style and naming	(watch)	`{{rfc\|style}}`
Wikipedia policies and guidelines	(watch)	`{{rfc\|policy}}`
WikiProjects and collaborations	(watch)	`{{rfc\|proj}}`
Wikipedia technical issues and templates	(watch)	`{{rfc\|tech}}`
Wikipedia proposals	(watch)	`{{rfc\|prop}}`
Unsorted
Unsorted RfCs	(watch)	`{{rfc}}`

Note to template editors

It looks to be the case that Legobot will fail to remove RfCs if there are any parameters on the RfC tag other than the categories and the |rfcid= parameter that Legobot sets. Be cautious when adding new parameters, even no-op parameters, as this may cause Legobot to behave unpredictably.

Parameter		Description	Type	Status
RFC category	`1`	The topic of the RFC (Article topics or Project-wide topics) Example tech	String	required
RFC ID	`rfcid` `2`	The ID of the RFC filled by Legobot	Number	suggested

Usage

Expiry

Definition of topic areas

Note to template editors

See also