Abstract
Purpose
(1) To estimate the pooled prevalence of psychological symptoms in Chinese migrant workers (CMWs), as measured using the Symptom Checklist-90-R (SCL-90-R) in observational studies conducted in China, and (2) to explore the potential variables associated with the SCL-90-R Global Severity Index (GSI), the overall mental health indicator of CMWs.
Methods
We performed a comprehensive literature search of the major English and Chinese databases (to June 2012). Cross-sectional surveys and case–control studies of CMWs (and controls where appropriate) that reported at least one subscale score of the SCL-90-R were included. Multilevel meta-analysis was used to pool the symptom scores of cross-sectional surveys and mean differences of symptom scores (“Cohen’s d” values) between CMWs and controls of case–control studies. Multilevel meta-analysis with ecological- or study-level covariates was used to explore the associations between variables and SCL-90-R GSI score.
Results
The search yielded 48 cross-sectional surveys (comprising 42,813 CMWs) and seven surveys that included control samples. The pooled psychological symptom scores (95 % confidence interval) of CMWs were statistically higher than those of norms from Chinese general population on all scales of SCL-90-R, except for obsessive–compulsive subscale in study quality subgroup analysis. CMWs also scored statistically higher than those of urban counterpart controls on all scales of SCL-90-R. Multilevel regression meta-analysis model revealed that four covariates that accounted for 33.9 % of SCL-90-R GSI heterogeneity across all surveys, including: “mean age of study sample,” “geographic area,” “per capita GDP,” and “statutory minimum monthly wage” of study site in implementation year.
Conclusion
CMWs have more severe psychological symptoms than the general population, and thus, appear to experience higher level of psychological distress. Macro-economic factors may have impact on the overall mental health of CMWs, but the factors that contribute to mental health and mental distress among CMWs remain to be explored and understood.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- CMW:
-
Chinese migrant worker
- SCL-90-R:
-
Symptom checklist-90-R
- SOM:
-
Somatization
- O–C:
-
Obsessive–Compulsive
- I–S:
-
Interpersonal sensitivity
- DEP:
-
Depression
- ANX:
-
Anxiety
- HOS:
-
Hostility
- PHOB:
-
Phobic anxiety
- PAR:
-
Paranoid ideation
- PSY:
-
Psychoticism
- AMW:
-
Average monthly wage
- GDP:
-
Per capita gross domestic product
- SMMW:
-
Statutory minimum monthly wage
References
National Bureau of Statistics of China (2011) 2011 China statistical yearbook. China Statistics Press, Beijing
National Bureau of Statistics of China (2010) The 2009 report on the surveillance of China’s rural-to-urban migrants. China Statistics Press, Beijing
Laura M, Sally M, Anne E (2003) Migration and health: a review of the international literature. MRC Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, Glasgow
Lurie I (2009) Psychiatric care in restricted conditions for work migrants, refugees and asylum seekers: experience of the open clinic for work migrants and refugees, Israel 2006. Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci 46(3):172–181
Bhugra D (2004) Migration and mental health. Acta Psychiatr Scand 109(4):243–258
Lou Y, Beaujot R (2005) What happens to the ‘healthy immigrant effect’: the mental health of immigrants to Canada. PSC Discuss Pap Ser 19(15):1–25
Levecque K, Lodewyckx I, Vranken J (2007) Depression and generalised anxiety in the general population in Belgium: a comparison between native and immigrant groups. J Affect Disord 97(1–3):229–239
Cantor-Graae E, Selten J (2005) Schizophrenia and migration: a meta-analysis and review. Am J Psychiatry 162(1):12–24
Glaesmer H, Wittig U, Brhler E, Martin A, Mewes R, Rief W (2009) Are migrants more susceptible to mental disorders? Psychiatr Prax 36(1):16–22
Grant B, Stinson F, Hasin D, Dawson D, Chou S, Anderson K (2004) Immigration and lifetime prevalence of DSM-IV psychiatric disorders among Mexican Americans and non-hispanic whites in the United States: results from the national epidemiologic survey on alcohol and related conditions. Arch Gen Psychiatry 61(12):1226–1233
de Loret MC, Stanojevic S, Ruiz P, Gilman R, Smeeth L, Miranda J (2012) The effect of rural-to-urban migration on social capital and common mental disorders: Peru migrant study. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 47(6):967–973
Wong DFK, Li C, He X (2007) Rural migrant workers in urban China: living a marginalised life. Int J Soc Welf 16(1):32–40
Wong D, He X, Leung G, Lau Y, Chang Y (2008) Mental health of migrant workers in China: prevalence and correlates. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 43(6):483–489
He X, Wong D (2011) A comparison of female migrant workers’ mental health in four cities in China. Int J Soc Psychiatry. doi:10.1177/0020764011423467
Li X, Stanton B, Fang X, Xiong Q, Yu S, Lin D, Hong Y, Zhang L, Chen X, Wang B (2009) Mental health symptoms among rural-to-urban migrants in China: a comparison with their urban and rural counterparts. World Health Popul 11(1):24–38
Li L, Wang H, Ye X, Jiang M, Lou Q, Hesketh T (2007) The mental health status of Chinese rural–urban migrant workers: comparison with permanent urban and rural dwellers. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 42(9):716–722
Qiu PY, Yang Y, Wu F, Cao X, Zhao SN, Ma X (2010) Mental health of floating population in China and worldwide: the advance and future directions. Chin Mental Health J 24(1):64–68
Shen Q, Lu Y, Hu C, Deng X, Gao H, Huang X, Niu E (1998) A preliminary study of the mental health of young migrant workers in Shenzhen. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 52(Suppl):S370–S373
Luo M, Gao Y (2004) Investigation of psychology hygiene of out-of-town temporary workers in construction sites. Mod Prev Med 31(1):24–25
Liu Y, Tian D, Yan L (2009) The mental health status among migrant workers on the labor market in Liaoning. Chin J Health Educ 25(12):894–895
Liu Y, Yin Q, Huang H, Lin C, Zhang Z (2010) Mental health and social support: comparison between male and female migrant workers. Chin Mental Health J 24(8):631–632
Jiang L (2004) Analysis on psychological status of outside workers from industrial enterprise in Shenzhen city. Mod Prev Med 31(1):57–59
Qian S, Wang W, Wang Y (2008) The mental health status of 232 Hennan migrant-workers and its influencing factors. Chin J Health Psych 16(4):459–461
Hesketh T, Ye X, Li L, Wang H (2008) Health status and access to health care of migrant workers in China. Public Health Rep 123(2):189–197
Liu H, Zhang J (2004) Norms of symptoms checklist (SCL-90) in Chinese middle school students. Chin Mental Health J 18(2):88–90
Meng Y, Qiu C, Liu Y, Lai L, Wu J, Huang X, Wen F, Zhang W (2011) Mental health of policemen in juvenile reformatory in Chengdu city. West Chin Med J 26(6):907–911
Zhu S, Dong L, Du R, Yin M (2010) Impact of occupational burnout and mental health on primary and secondary school teachers and mental health of their students. Chin J Sch Educ 31(7):802–805
Fan Y, Wang B, Zhai X, Su Z (2002) A test for the reliability and validity of SCL-90 in the middle school student. Sichuan Mental Health 15(3):133–135
Chen S, Li L (2003) Re-testing reliability, validity and norm applicability of SCL-90. Chin J Nerv Ment Dis 29(5):323–327
Derogatis L, Lipman R, Covi L (1973) SCL-90: an outpatient psychiatric rating scale—preliminary report. Psychopharmacol Bull 9(1):13–28
Chen P (2008) Researches on the mental health of migrant workers. Med Healthc Apparatus 15(8):60–62
Zhan J, Su Z, Jing J (2008) The study situation in mental health of migrant peasant workers. Med Recapitulate 14(1):158–160
Mallen C, Peat G, Croft P (2006) Quality assessment of observational studies is not commonplace in systematic reviews. J Clin Epidemiol 59(8):765–769
Chris O, Diane MMSG (2004) Cross-sectional study design and data analysis. College Entrance Examination Board, Chicago
Wells G, Shea B, O’Connell D, Petersen J, Welch V, Losos M, Tugwell P (2010) The Newcastle–Ottawa scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in meta-analyses. http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.asp. Accessed 25 May 2012
Cohen J (1988) Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences, 2nd edn. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc., Hillsdale
Tong H (2010) A research of twenty years’ vicissitude: SCL-90 and its norm. Psychol Sci 33(4):928–930
Eduard B, Universitt LJK (1999) Confidence intervals as an alternative to significance testing. Methods Psychol Res Online 4(2):33–46
Rashbash J, Steele F, Browne W, Prosser B (2004) MLwiN (version 2.02). Institute of Education, University of London, London
Begg C, Mazumdar M (1994) Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics 50(4):1088–1101
Duval S, Tweedie R (2000) Trim and fill: a simple funnel plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics 56(2):455–463
Zhou L, Wang J (1998) Analysis on the mental health survey of migrant workers in Wuhu city. Chin Ment Health J 12(4):243
Sun J, Li M, Wu L (1999) Mental health among migrant workers in Anhui: a cross-sectional survey. J Health Psychol 7(1):80–81
Chen P, Jiang H, Yang X (2001) Investigating analyses of psychological healthy condition for 81 non-regular labourers working on a public project. Central China Psychiatry J 7(1):19–20
Li X (2004) Investigation of the mental health states of youthful laborer working on a public project. Chin J Health Psych 12(6):468–469
Luo H, Zhang X, Deng X, Xu S, Yang S (2005) Comparison of psychological problems between the male and female workers in the “three form enterprises”. J Chin Phys Suppl: 20–22
Wang L (2005) Stress and mental health of farmer-workers. Chin J Ind Hyg Occup Dis 23(6):6
Li D, Zhang J, Lu J, Chen B (2006) Investigation and analysis of nonnative workers group mental health status in Baotou city. Chin J Health Psych 14(2):152–153
Liu X (2006) Investigation into mental health of home-going peasant-workers during the spring festival. Mod Prev Med 33(10):1926–1927
Tang J, Su S, Zhang Y, Jing J, Wu Y, Xue Y, Yin X, Zou X, Zhuang D, Zhuang D, Huang H, Chen Q (2006) Health status of migrant workers in a community of Zhuhai city. Chin J Health Educ 22(10):731–734
Xu X, Zhu H, Li T, Shi C (2006) Mental health and coping style: data of workers from rural area. Pract Prev Med 13(1):70–72
Jiang S, Zhang L, Wang W (2007) The mental health of migrant workers in Chongqing city. Psychol Sci 30(1):216–218
Liu J, Zhang Q, Xia L, Tang J (2007) Study on the psychological health status of migrant workers in Shenzhen. Chin J Health Psych 15(7):644–646
Gong C, Zheng L, Guo J, Hu R, Zheng L (2008) Mental health mong migrant workers in Wuhan, China: a cross-sectional survey. Consume Guide 18:58
Hu R, Ge G (2008) A survey on the mental health status of 408 rural-to-urban migrant workers in cities. Chin Health Serv Manag 25(3):196–198
Jia F, Wu Y (2008) A study on mental health of rural-to-urban young peasants in Suzhou city and its influencing factors. Med J Chin People’s Health 20(23):2823–2924 (2826)
Li H, Ren L, Sun L, Cheng J, Zhang Z (2008) Research on the psychological health state, life events and coping style of the non-native enterprises workers. Chin J Behav Med Sci 17(9):819–820
Liu X, Luo J, Liu S, Zhou H (2008) Investigation on mental health of peasant-workers on duty and peasants at home. Chin J Public Health 24(8):923–925
Sun C, Liu G, Liu D, Liu H (2008) Survey on the mental health status of migrant workers and its main influence factors. Mod Prev Med 35(14):2693–2694 (2697)
Wei J, Xie Y (2008) Mental and physical symptoms among migrant workers of Ningbo city. Chin Ment Health J 22(3):201
Yuan H (2008) The study of young migrant workers mental health status and education in Shanghai. East China Normal University, Shanghai
Zhan J, Qiu T, Su Z, Wang T, Jing J, Liao R, Lin L (2008) A control study of mental health of female industrial workers migrated from other places. Med Recapitulate 14(12):1907–1909
Guo H, Luo Y, Wen J, Li Q (2009) Analysis on psychological status of LaoWuGong from industrial enterprise in Shenzhen city. Chin J Health Psych 17(2):220–221
Guo L, Cui P (2009) Investigation on mental health status of labor workers in Shenzhen city. Chin J Health Psych 17(11):1315–1316
He X, Fan C, Ma S, Wu X (2009) Psychological state of migrant workers in one of pubs in Guangzhou and analysis of its influencing factors. Pract Prev Med 16(6):1805–1807
Jiang Q, Zhang Z, Yang Z, Fan J, Luo Q, Lei X (2009) A study of the correlations among self-efficacy, coping style and psychological health of immigrant workers. Med Soc 22(4):59–61
Li Y, Huang S, Wang B, Yang H (2009) Mental health survey on young migrant workers. Public Med Forum Mag 13(27):815–816
Su L, Wei B, Ling X (2009) Analysis of the relationship between social support and mental health of rural migrant workers in construction sites. Mod Prev Med 36(6):1096–1097
Wang R, Cui S (2009) Survey on mental health status among peasant workers in Dandong city, Liaoning province. Chin J Health Educ 25(9):701–703
Zhang H (2009) Migrant worker in rural areas of Henan province mental health survey and analysis. Northwest Popul J 30(3):76–79
Zhou L, Jiang L, Li Z, Zhang J, Xin M (2009) Mental health survey on 3188 migrant workers from construction industries. Chin J Behav Med Brain Sci 18(9):833
Cao Y, Niu Z, Zhang L (2010) Mental health, self-esteem and self-efficacy among migrant workers. J Qiqihar Med Coll 31(12):1933–1934
Jiang L (2010) Mental health, social support, and quality of life among young migrant workers. Fujian Normal University, Fuzhou
Liao C (2010) Mental health of young migrant workers and social influence thereof and protective factors. China Youth Study 1:109–113
Liu Y, Lin C, Sun X, Huang H, Yin Q, Zhu B (2010) Analysis on mental health status and effect factors in floating women in Jiangsu. Matern Child Health Care Chin 25(4):460–463
Lu Z, Huang G, Yang Z, He M, Yang Y, Zhang J, He Y (2010) Mental health status of female migrant workers and its influencing factors. Med J Chin People’s Health 22(21):2783–2787
Dai X (2011) The mental health, physical fitness and exercise of the migrant workers in the Pearl river delta. Chin J Sports Med 30(6):564–568
Ding Y, DongFang W, Li Z (2011) Research on the relationship between migrant-workers’ values and mental health in Chongqing city. Guide Sci Educ 10(29):146–148
Hua Y, Huang Y, Liu C, Li Y, Tang H (2011) A research on the psychosocial problems of new-generation migrant workers. Nanchang Hangkong University, Nanchang
Jia X, Liu L, Chen Q, Xiong Y (2011) Investigation on the mental health of construction migrant workers in Haikou. Chin J Health Psych 19(6):686–688
Lin Q, Liu Y, Zhou J, Cao N, Fan Y (2011) Investigation on personality and mental health among the migrant workers in Guangzhou city, 2010. Prev Med Trib 17(10):889–892
Yan F (2011) Investigation on mental health status of peasant workers in Cenzoic era in Qiqihar city. Chin J Health Psych 19(8):937–939
Zhou J, Mei L, Jiang Z, Zou J, Chen W, Zhang X, Xie X, Xu M, Huang H, Yu W (2011) Investigation on psychological health status of female workers in industrial enterprise. Occup Health 27(8):841–843
Zhuo L, Ding W, Hong T, Song H, Zhuo J (2011) A study on the mental health and correlates of migrant workers. China Sch Educ 1:18 (43)
Zheng L, Luo B, Liu D, Tan Q (2011) Mental health situation of migrant workers in Baoan district, Shenzhen city, South China. J Prev Med 37(5):30–33
International Organization for Migration (2010) World migration report 2010—the future of migration: building capacities for change. IOM Publisher, Geneva, Switzerland
Gushulak B (2007) Healthier on arrival? Further insight into the “healthy immigrant effect”. CMAJ 176(10):1439–1440
McDonald J, Kennedy S (2004) Insights into the ‘healthy immigrant effect’: health status and health service use of immigrants to Canada. Soc Sci Med 59(8):1613–1627
Chun P, Organista B, Marín G (2003) Acculturation: advances in theory, measurement, and applied research. American Psychological Association, Washington
Muntaner C, Eaton W, Miech R, O’Campo P (2004) Socioeconomic position and major mental disorders. Epidemiol Rev 26(1):53–62
Lund C, Breen A, Flisher A, Kakuma R, Corrigall J, Joska J, Swartz L, Patel V (2010) Poverty and common mental disorders in low and middle income countries: a systematic review. Soc Sci Med 71(3):517–528
Lund C, Silva MD, Plagerson S, Cooper S, Chisholm D, Das J, Knapp MVP (2011) Poverty and mental disorders: breaking the cycle in low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet 378(9801):1502–1514
Hudson C (2005) Socioeconomic status and mental illness: tests of the social causation and selection hypotheses. Am J Orthopsychiatry 75(1):3–18
Kuruvilla A, Jacob K (2007) Poverty, social stress and mental health. Indian J Med Res 126(4):273–278
Peng Y, Chang W, Zhou H, Hu H, Liang W (2010) Factors associated with health-seeking behavior among migrant workers in Beijing, China. BMC Health Serv Res 10(1):69–79
Wang M (2005) Employment opportunities and wage gaps in the urban labor market: a study of the employment and wages of migrant laborers. Soc Sci China 5:36–46
Simmonds M, Higgins J (2007) Covariate heterogeneity in meta-analysis: criteria for deciding between meta-regression and individual patient data. Stat Med 26(15):2982–2999
Zhong B (2009) How to calculate sample size in randomized controlled trial? J Thorac Dis 1(1):51–54
Lu Y, Hu P, Treiman D (2011) Migration and depressive symptoms in migrant-sending areas: findings from the survey of internal migration and health in China. Int J Public Health. doi:10.1007/s00038-00011-00314-00030
Research Group of the State Council of China (2006) Investigation report on Chinese rural-to-urban migrant workers. Chinese Yanshi Press, Beijing
Zhong B, Zhang J, He M, Huang Y, Chen H (2010) Methodology improvements in China mental disorder epidemiological surveys from 1950 to 2008. Chin J Psychiatry 43(4):235–240
Doi S, Barendregt J, Onitilo A (2012) Methods for the bias adjustment of meta-analyses of published observational studies. J Eval Clin Pract. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2753.2012.01890.x
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by the Direct Grants for Research from the Chinese University of Hong Kong (Grant No.: 2041727, 2041728).
Conflict of interest
None.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
B.-L. Zhong and T.-B. Liu contributed equally to this work.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zhong, BL., Liu, TB., Chiu, H.F.K. et al. Prevalence of psychological symptoms in contemporary Chinese rural-to-urban migrant workers: an exploratory meta-analysis of observational studies using the SCL-90-R. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 48, 1569–1581 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-013-0672-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-013-0672-4